The Batman Review: 7 Ups & 2 Downs

Matt Reeves has crafted a unique Batman origin story to be proud of, but...

The Batman Catwoman 2022
YouTube/Warner Bros Pictures

It's genuinely difficult to break new ground with the Batman universe.

Bruce Wayne, the crime-fighting superhero himself, supporting characters like Catwoman, The Penguin and more - everything has been done to death in print, gaming and film over the years. Shows like Gotham have even examined a different side to the Bat's world, but uniqueness is...hard to come by.

That's why director Matt Reeves should be proud of what he's achieved with 2022's The Batman. Hardcore Bat-fans were split when Robert Pattinson was unveiled as the next millionaire playboy with the tortured past, but this reboot does a nifty job of making the 'Caped Crusader' feel like something fresh.

That's a minor miracle, but not everything is perfect.

Stumbles come in the form of undercooked supporting cast members (or one in particular, at least), and there is a danger of The Batman dropping into Spider-Man 3 territory at some points. Maybe that's harsh, but some aspects of the film might be jarring for those going in with balls-to-the-wall action movie expectations.

Here's all the good and the bad from a reborn Batman adventure.


Downs...

2. Batman: The Emo Years?

The Batman Bruce Wayne 2022
YouTube/Warner Bros Pictures

Let's get these nasty negatives out of the way ASAP.

Bruce Wayne and the Batman franchise in general has always worn tragedy well. Unhappiness kinda comes with the territory, especially when one considers what a young Brucey went through as a child; nobody has ever hidden this depressed side to him in comics, cartoons, video games, TV or film.

However, the opening 30 minutes or so of The Batman could be jarring for some. There's a distinct lack of "F*CK YEAH" action and more emphasis on Wayne moping around speaking to his private journal. If he could star in a My Chemical Romance video, he would. This is as emo as the Bat gets.

Granted, these scenes act as a clear nod to some of the classic graphic novels that shaped Gotham, but things will develop a little too slowly for those craving action movie thrills and spills. There's no real opening salvo to get pulses racing. This is introspective, and definitely emo-tinged.

It's nowhere near as cringeworthy as the emo splashes found in Spider-Man 3 (which was mentioned during the intro), to be fair.


1. Alfred Is Slightly Undercooked

The Batman Alfred 2022
YouTube/Warner Bros Pictures

Firstly, Andy Serkis is a brilliant actor who nails his role as Alfred. Sadly, even his performance wasn't enough to keep the butler's head above water in this Batman retelling. That's not on Serkis - it's just clear that Matt Reeves plans to flesh the character out in subsequent sequels, and that never really gives him enough to do here.

Pennyworth isn't akin to Jared Leto's Joker in Suicide Squad (it's nowhere near that level of missed opportunity), but Alfred should surely feel like a central figure in Bruce Wayne's ongoing battle with mental fragility. He's literally the closest human being to Batman, and yet that never truly comes across.

He's background noise.

One gets the feeling they could've done loads more with Alfred. Why cast someone with the skills of Serkis and then reduce them to being one of the least-engaging characters in a story focused on exploring Wayne's crippling self-doubt and rage?


Ups...

7. You’ll Want To Rewatch It ASAP

The Batman 2022
YouTube/Warner Bros Pictures

One of the biggest compliments you could give the film is that it's so re-watchable.

It's a testament to how well Reeves lays the table for Bruce's moody characterisation and motivations that you'll want to fire it up again immediately and watch those earlier set-up scenes all over again. The similarities and interplay between the main hero and villain (The Riddler) are also incredible engaging and worth revisiting.

This isn't one of those black and white 'good vs. evil' tales at all. Yes, Batman is obviously the "goodie" of the piece, but even he has a darkness to him that haunts certain parts of the story. That's escalated whenever Riddler, or any of the other "baddies" leap into view. It's all multi-layered and so well executed.

The near three-hour run time isn't even exhausting. It's true that certain movie-goers will wonder why the opening third is slower, and yet everything is well-paced enough to make repeat viewings worth your while. The Batman isn't a 'one and done' experience.


6. Batman’s Evolution Is A Trip

The Batman Robert Pattinson
Warner Bros.

Remember that, "I'm vengeance" line from the trailers? That gave the impression that this would be Batman gone Rambo due to his traumatic childhood - that's not strictly the case. The character goes from striking fear into Gotham's criminal underbelly to being a much more well-rounded, justice-seeking machine.

The film doesn't reinvent the wheel, so to speak, but it does take film buffs on a fun ride. Besides, everyone knows what they're getting from this character by now, so experiencing Batman's evolution and Wayne's journey together is a fascinating trip.

Although it featured in the 'Downs', stick with the opening 30 minutes or so. You'll be rewarded for that.

There's more on the fleshed-out origin story later in this piece. For now, just know that seeing everyone's favourite caped crime-fighter evolve from a moping figure who struggles to relate with Gotham's population into a powerful force for good is great.


5. The Riddler’s Darkness

The Batman Riddler 2022
YouTube/Warner Bros Pictures

Ooft! Paul Dano = tour de force.

Reeves doesn't pull any punches with the direction for his combined Edward Nashton/Riddler character either. The very first thing you see Dano's villain do will make you squirm, and the flick does a cracking job of escalating his importance in each follow-up scene.

Jim Carrey from Batman Forever, this isn't. Nobody's slagging off the great man's over-the-top work back in the mid-90s, but Dano takes The Riddler in an altogether different direction. There's an intense bleakness to his appearance, behaviour and the messages he leaves for Bruce Wayne, and it's all...a riot.

Serial killer vibes are nothing new to the Batman universe. Somehow though, Dano's intelligent portrayal of someone who enjoys toying with Wayne elevates his character to Jack Nicholson as The Joker comparisons. That's high praise indeed, albeit deserved praise.


4. Catwoman Generally

The Batman Catwoman 2022
YouTube/Warner Bros Pictures

Then, there's Zoë Kravitz and her sterling portrayal of Selina Kyle/Catwoman - she's another highlight of The Batman. Whereas others, like Serkis as Alfred, seem a little half-baked and like they won't be developed until the sequel, Kravitz commands attention and could easily star in her own film.

If DC and Warner Bros want to, they could easily make up for that terrible 2004 Catwoman garbage starring Halle Berry. Y'know, just saying. Zoë is the ideal candidate to make a standalone origins story for Kyle work. She's that comfortable in the role throughout Reeves' retelling of Batman.

This Catwoman sits snugly between the early "good" and "bad" of Bruce Wayne and Edward Nashton with absolute ease. Some hardcore fans of the Batman world don't like when the superhero shows weakness for Selina, but even those doubters will tip a cap towards what's presented here.

A spin-off awaits.


3. Other Supporting Characters Soar

The Batman Penguin 2022
YouTube/Warner Bros Pictures

It's another compliment to The Batman that this article has gone so deep without mentioning Colin Farrell as The Penguin or Jeffrey Wright's role as Jim Gordon once. Both star in notable scenes throughout the run time, but it's especially amazing that characters as important as Penguin don't actually dominate.

Think about that for a second!

Reeves could've framed the entire movie around just one villain, and had Farrell steal the show. The fact he didn't puts Batman in even more danger (there's a 'Bruce Wayne vs. The World' element to proceedings that rocks) and helps sell the idea that everyone in Gotham doubts the Bat.

Special mention for Wright. His skills raise the typically-curmudgeonly Gordon up a notch, and make him more than a sideshow irritant in Batman's personal fight against crime. Unlike Alfred, these characters are fleshed out enough to make them valuable to the plot whilst still keeping enough in reserve for inevitable sequels.


2. A Unique Origin Story?!

batman 2022 mask face
Warner Bros.

Take a bow, Matt Reeves and writer Peter Craig.

In fact, take a bow everybody who story-boarded The Batman from start to finish. This fan certainly didn't think there was any fresh ground to tread in this universe, but Matt Reeves and his team managed to find it. There's a uniqueness to the way they spin Bruce Wayne's yarn here that's so admirable.

Christopher Nolan received huge acclaim for the way he handled things with Batman Begins way back in 2005. Is this better? The temptation is to say yes, but there's some recency bias involved there too. That's hard to get away from, because Reeves' version is obviously the one swirling around this reviewer's head.

Anyone who expects a 'crash boom bang' action flick from beginning to end will be slightly disappointed. Those who stick with The Batman and demand a new nugget or two of inspiration from a well-told story will be anything but. How the hell did they manage to make "unique" and "Batman" go together in 2022?!


1. That Final Action Scene

The Batman 2022
YouTube/Warner Bros Pictures

Again, this isn't some fast-paced action romp by any means. However, The Batman does have action scenes. It's a bloody superhero movie - of course there's gonna be some chaos. Reeves is smart enough to hold back on most of it until a show-closing series of events that will leave every fanboy/girl buzzing.

The final action set piece makes that earlier introspection worth ploughing through.

The movie finally lets loose and turns Pattinson into the Bat everyone knows and loves when it counts. Gamers will recall those "predator" moments in games like Arkham Asylum and Arkham City; this is that in film form, and it's glorious to witness. The 'Dark Knight' unleashed is still one of the best sights in cinema.

Being honest, almost everything beforehand comes across as a tease for moments like it. Credit must go to Pattinson for defying expectations to play Batman properly too. He's gritty, tense, angry and majestic all at once.

Are you looking forward to seeing The Batman? For more content, check out WWE 2K22: 10 Hands On First Impressions You Need To Know and GTA 6: Everything We Know So Far!


In this post: 
The Batman
 
Posted On: 
Contributor

Lifelong wrestling, video game, music and sports obsessive who has been writing about his passions since childhood. Jamie started writing for WhatCulture in 2013, and has contributed thousands of articles and YouTube videos since then. He cut his teeth penning published pieces for top UK and European wrestling read Fighting Spirit Magazine (FSM), and also has extensive experience working within the wrestling biz as a manager and commentator for promotions like ICW on WWE Network and WCPW/Defiant since 2010. Further, Jamie also hosted the old Ministry Of Slam podcast, and has interviewed everyone from Steve Austin and Shawn Michaels to Bret Hart and Trish Stratus.