The Batman Review: 7 Ups & 2 Downs
1. Alfred Is Slightly Undercooked
Firstly, Andy Serkis is a brilliant actor who nails his role as Alfred. Sadly, even his performance wasn't enough to keep the butler's head above water in this Batman retelling. That's not on Serkis - it's just clear that Matt Reeves plans to flesh the character out in subsequent sequels, and that never really gives him enough to do here.
Pennyworth isn't akin to Jared Leto's Joker in Suicide Squad (it's nowhere near that level of missed opportunity), but Alfred should surely feel like a central figure in Bruce Wayne's ongoing battle with mental fragility. He's literally the closest human being to Batman, and yet that never truly comes across.
He's background noise.
One gets the feeling they could've done loads more with Alfred. Why cast someone with the skills of Serkis and then reduce them to being one of the least-engaging characters in a story focused on exploring Wayne's crippling self-doubt and rage?