The Biggest Mistake Each DCEU Film Has Made
One of cinema's most hit-or-miss franchises...
Few franchises have had a more fascinating journey than the DC Extended Universe.
It might've been inconsistent and had its share of duds, but this is still a deeply interesting film series with a ludicrous amount of highs and lows, successes and failures. It may not be nearly as successful as the Marvel Cinematic Universe, but it's a franchise that has rarely left the public consciousness since first making waves in 2013 with Man of Steel. In particular, the Snyder Cut of Justice League coming to HBO next year is huge news.
In spite of the disappointing box office performance of its most recent movie, Harley Quinn and the Birds of Prey, it's safe to say that things are getting better for the DCEU. In fact, it hasn't released a terrible film since 2016's Suicide Squad and in order to continue on this upward stride, Warner Bros. should do everything they can to learn from the mistakes of the previous DCEU films.
Being the inconsistent franchise that this is, there are plenty; misjudged performances, awful villains, poor writing and heavy studio interference leap immediately to mind. So, what is the biggest mistake in each DCEU film so far?
8. Man Of Steel: The AWFUL Action Sequences
Man of Steel is a frustrating one.
It starts off well, with some nice quiet scenes and some very economical non-linear storytelling that gives the movie a touching, gently soulful vibe at first. Impressively, this first half makes Superman, who is not an interesting superhero since he can basically do everything, genuinely compelling for once.
Unfortunately, all of the good work laid out by these earlier scenes comes crashing down whenever the film does one of its abysmal action sequences, which sadly make up most of the film's second half.
These fight scenes are nothing but over-powered characters throwing each other through walls and are devoid of even the slightest bit of tension or excitement, while the disturbing amount of collateral damage the fight scenes cause undermines Superman as a hero. The Metropolis-set finale is particularly awful.
Man of Steel's final scenes after this climax are rock-solid, but unfortunately it's too little, too late. With better action, Man of Steel would definitely be looked back on with more fondness than it currently is.
7. Batman V. Superman: Dawn Of Justice - The Desperate Attempts To Launch A Cinematic Universe
Batman Vs Superman: Dawn of Justice was an undeniable dud. It's well-acted (aside from Jesse Eisenberg's painfully bad turn as Lex Luthor), visually stunning and starts with promise, but quickly devolves into a complete and utter mess.
The reason for this is that it does too much to try and set up a cinematic universe and is hopelessly overstuffed with plot-lines that either feel shoe-horned in or go nowhere. For example, there's a bizarre scene in which Bruce Wayne has a dream about an unidentified man shouting at him through a portal, but this is never explained or even mentioned again.
As for Gal Gadot's Wonder Woman, she is delightful but she does still feel like she should've been saved for a later movie. There's also that bizarre scene in which Wonder Woman looks at a slideshow of clips of The Flash, Aquaman and Cyborg, which is jarring sequel-bait to say the least.
The ending is also an example of setting up too much too soon. Superman's death came far too early in the franchise and the Justice League movie was set up too quickly as well.
Thanks to how over-stuffed the movie is, it's narratively weak and filled with plot-holes, preventing it from ever taking off. Warner Bros. definitely got ahead of themselves here.
6. Suicide Squad: The Fantastically Dire Screenplay
Suicide Squad is probably the worst DCEU film to date. It's surprisingly well-acted (aside from Jared Leto's mediocre Joker and Cara Delevingne's embarrassingly awful villain) and this keeps it at the two-star level, but for the most part it is a truly terrible film.
Aside from the godawful editing, messy directing and over-use of pop music, the main mistake of Suicide Squad was the ghastly script. It has a couple of nice moments and flashes of potential - for example, a scene with the squad in the bar is actually rather good - but these parts only make how bad the rest of the script is even more frustrating.
There's no tension or character development here, while there's also little in the way of substance or logic. Most of the plot doesn't make any sense at all and the entire thing is a shallow, empty and stunningly ugly train-wreck. It's also a bit of mystery as to why David Ayer was hired to do the film given that he's been involved in so many terrible movies at this point.
All in all, Suicide Squad proves once again that without a good-enough script, a film really is dead on arrival.
5. Wonder Woman: The Weak Villains
Thanks to dazzling action, one of the best hero arcs in superhero movie history and the Greatest superhero movie love story ever, Wonder Woman is the best DCEU film so far.
Still, although it's a superb film which blows the MCU's Captain Marvel out of the water, Wonder Woman still has a few issues. The most glaring problem, aside from too much slow-motion, dodgy CGI and occasionally jarring tonal shifts, are the villains.
In contrast to Wonder Woman (a surprisingly strong Gal Gadot) herself, who is one of the most lovable and heart-warming on-screen heroes of recent times, the antagonists suck.
The two German villains (Danny Huston and Elena Anaya) in the movie are largely uninteresting and although Ares, the big bad, is better, this is mainly thanks to David Thewlis' solid performance. He is still just another ludicrous OTT CGI bad guy in the end.
It was surprising to see such weak elements in what is otherwise such a well-rounded movie. Speaking of villains, it's arguable that the DCEU has had a bigger villain problem than Marvel ever did. It wasn't until Birds of Prey, the franchise's eighth film, that the DCEU finally delivered a genuinely awesome antagonist.
4. Justice League: Being Made Too Soon
Justice League is a very underrated superhero film. In no way, shape or form is it a standout, memorable work but despite the messy story, atrocious villain and overall lack of weight, it is still well-acted, visually stunning, consistently fun and, considering the infamously troubled production, surprisingly coherent.
The writing is a definite issue, but in all honesty there was a very simple fix for Justice League: push it back.
It really was too early for the DCEU's Avengers-type movie. The franchise hadn't figured out its artistic identity or where it was really going yet and, with all of the shaky character arcs and uncertain, ultra-safe story that Justice League presents, it really shows.
It would've been a lot better to, at the very least, give Aquaman and the Flash solo movies before this for, even though Justice League introduced these characters very well, it would've been better to have known them a bit more first.
Had Warner Bros. really had a firm grasp on where this franchise was going, it's likely the production would've been far less hellish. Still, after this the franchise did (rightly) focus on solo movies and just building up the universe patiently, so clearly Warner Bros. are learning from past mistakes. Good on them.
3. Aquaman: The Safe Story
If there's one word to sum up Aquaman, it would be... nice.
It's a nice, uplifting story of an under-confident hero believing in himself and it's elevated further by James Wan's outstanding direction and a strong cast who give it their all, especially Jason Momoa as the titular character.
Nevertheless, it's an example of an average screenplay being elevated by an excellent cast and crew. Aquaman is, unfortunately, a very by-the-numbers superhero origin story that follows all the story beats you'd expect to see from this type of movie. It is most certainly a good film, but because it plays everything so safe it never becomes great.
Still, it does deviate from the origin story formula in one way in that the central love story, for once, actually works, so that definitely counts for something.
2. Shazam: The Lame Villain
Shazam! is a very fun superhero movie and the second-best DCEU film. It isn't necessarily a great film but it's certainly a very good one that has a lovely, heart-warming tone and an infectious glee that's hard to resist. Considering how dark many of this franchise's other films are, it's a remarkable breath of fresh air.
The cast are great, the script is sharp, the emotional drama works and the jokes land beautifully, but Shazam has its issues, just like any other film. Aside from its overlong runtime, the biggest issue is the weak villain; yes, the superhero movie villain problem rears its ugly head once again.
Dr Thaddeus Sivana is yet another totally bland and forgettable villain who never leaves any sort of impact. The character was also a criminal waste of the brilliant Mark Strong. Normally, Strong is a goldmine when it comes to playing villains but even he's far worse than normal here, indicating that (understandably) he couldn't find a way to make this bad guy very interesting.
1. Harley Quinn - Birds Of Prey: The Hit-And-Miss Writing
It's a shame Birds of Prey bombed at the box office, as it is actually pretty good. The cast is great, it finally delivers the franchise's first truly awesome villain (a brilliant Ewan McGregor, in what genuinely might be his best performance since Trainspotting) and the action sequences and stylish direction are genuinely insane.
Unfortunately, Birds of Prey faltered somewhat with the writing. The dialogue, gags and non-linear storytelling work very well, but the plot is totally forgettable and doesn't offer an awful lot in the way of substance.
Additionally, the movie is full of jarring tonal shifts. It has a goofy, Deadpool-esque vibe but the way it cuts between light-hearted gags and gruesome violence does give it a rather disjointed feel. It sometimes feels overly mean-spirited as well.
Still, in spite of these flaws, this is a rock-solid superhero film and it's nice to see that the DCEU is carrying on its successful course-correct. Hopefully they'll keep it up.
Watch Next
You'll Never Get 100% On This DCEU Quiz