The Biggest Problem With Star Wars: The Last Jedi Is J.J. Abrams

Let the hate flow through you.

JJ Abrams Palpatine
Lucasfilm/WC

With The Last Jedi's home release imminent, it has once again become the hot topic for Star Wars fans as deleted scenes get revealed, interviews are given, and battle lines are drawn once more.

In fairness, people haven't really stopped talking about the movie since it hit cinemas back in December, and to say it's proved divisive is a bit of an understatement. It's been declared both the best and worst Star Wars movie ever made, and petitions have been created to have it struck from canon or force Rian Johnson into apologising.

There are a plenty of criticisms for the movie, but a lot of them stem from the way Episode VIII does - or doesn't - follow on from The Force Awakens. Johnson forges his own path in a lot of ways, and after two years of speculation and build-up, not everyone was happy with what he came up with.

Rather than directing ire at Johnson, though, perhaps it would be better aimed at Episode VII helmer J.J. Abrams. It was his threads that Johnson decided to either drop or take in different directions to those expected, but a large portion of the blame lies with Abrams as a storyteller because, we've seen in his other work, he's great at ideas and concepts, but not so much with the answers.


3. Mystery Boxes And Plot Twists

Star Wars The Force Awakens Snoke Kylo Ren General Hux
Lucasfilm

"What are stories, but mystery boxes? ...[Kept closed] it represents infinite possibility. It represents hope. It represents potential."

J.J. Abrams' TED Talk on his approach to storytelling is now infamous, and it's the biggest and best indicator of his methodology - one that's on full display in The Force Awakens.

While the movie's narrative structure closely follows A New Hope, its bigger ideas are the new ones: the mysterious Supreme Leader Snoke, the parentless Rey, the Knights of Ren. Abrams may or may not have had answers to who these people are but, since he knew in advance that he'd be leaving the trilogy behind, it didn't matter. Like with Lost, he never needed to open the mystery box; he could, as he prefers, keep it firmly shut.

Johnson, then, took possession of these boxes he'd never created, and had a peak inside. With Snoke, he'd have found a powerful figure but one who, despite the theories, there was nothing known about. He was nothing, really, but a hologram who could use the Force. Johnson made him even more powerful, and then cut him down, sensing that he could serve the story better dead than alive.

It's not just a huge shock, but one that pushes Kylo Ren into becoming the new leader of the First Order and the unrivalled Big Bad. We'd already had one Palpatine, so it makes sense that we didn't need another and, after all, Palpatine got no backstory in the Original Trilogy either. What matters most in Snoke's story is that he lured Kylo Ren over to the Dark Side, that he led the First Order, and then that he was killed by his own apprentice. All of which we get on screen. The rest is superfluous and, if there were anything TRULY important, it should've been in The Force Awakens, while the decision to kill him off means he avoids simply being a Palpatine redux.

Likewise, Rey was revealed in The Last Jedi to be a 'nobody', which came after two years of speculation that she was a Skywalker or a Kenobi or a Palpatine or a Jinn or an Erso or product of any other family line in Star Wars. She's left alone on Jakku, and that's all we know about her past. It makes complete sense, then, that she'd be a nobody: for starters, anything else would be too convenient - and Lord knows there were already enough Skywalkers in this saga - and yet also feel shoehorned in. Being from nothing is not only what hurts the Rey the most, but given the pieces Johnson was left to play with, is the best fit, and one that allows the saga to move forward with a new hero that breaks free from that one special family, and instead shows you can rise from nothing to save the day.

The Knights of Ren are largely left out of things in The Last Jedi due to time constraints, but even that is just one line of dialogue from Snoke in The Force Awakens, and one that Johnson gives us an answer to by confirming they were among the pupils at Luke's Jedi Academy.

All of these things are used to drag down Johnson and The Last Jedi, but the problems originate from Abrams' focus on creating mystery boxes rather than actual characters.


2. Luke Skywalker Has Vanished

Luke Skywalker
Disney

Luke Skywalker has vanished. After the title - and, of course, 'a long time ago...' - that is the first thing we see at the start of Episode VII. J.J. Abrams sets out his stall early with the disappearance of Luke, and - while Han gives us a clue - we don't get any sort of definitive answer of where he is until the very end of the movie.

And then the credits roll.

What we know going into The Last Jedi is that Luke has clearly exiled himself from the galaxy, including those closest to him, but why? And that leads to a further question: What could've happened to Luke that, when Han Solo is in such grave danger, he doesn't come to the rescue? It's exactly what the old Luke did, after all.

Since Luke DIDN'T return to save or avenge Han, nor to comfort his sister Leia, nor join the fight against the First Order, there had to have been something drastically different. Luke had to have changed into the weary, cynical version we meet in The Last Jedi, who has cut himself off from the Force, because if he were still similar to the hero of the galaxy then his absence from The Force Awakens would be much harder to swallow. It's precisely because of what we know of Old Luke that we needed this New Luke, which becomes one of the strongest arcs in the film and gives us Mark Hamill's finest performance in the saga. Hamill himself might've voiced concerns, but Abrams is the one who left him standing at the top of an island, cut off from the galaxy. Johnson gave us a genuine reason why.

Of course, there are other issues people have with this: the tossing of the saber, and even more so his non-return to face Kylo Ren. The saber is crucial in that it immediately let's the audience know that this isn't your dad's Luke Skywalker; he's a different person now, setting up his arc across the movie. As for the end, it means Luke Skywalker can once again save the day, having realised the importance of his legend to the galaxy, and makes it a victory: Luke dies as a result of the astral projection, rather than being killed by Kylo Ren, which likely would've happened had he physically gone to Crait. Abrams put the legend of Luke Skywalker into a box, and Johnson is the one who brought it back.


1. What About Episode IX?

Star Wars JJ Abrams
Lucasfilm

As we've seen, a lot of the biggest problems with The Last Jedi stem from decisions J.J. Abrams did (or didn't) make, from making Snoke such a blank canvas that you could project just about anything on to him, to leaving Rey's parentage as vague as possible, and various other kernels of ideas without much substance to them. It would've been easy for Johnson to take this template and simply mirror The Empire Strikes Back, have Snoke be Palpatine, have Rey be Luke's daughter and so on. Instead, he took those kernels of ideas, those mystery boxes, kept the most interesting ones and turned them into actual character arcs: Rey becomes a hero despite not being from a special family, Kylo Ren becomes so much more than a Darth Vader wannabe, Snoke becomes one of the most stunning twists in recent blockbuster history.

But where this gets really interesting is the fact that, unexpectedly, J.J. Abrams is returning to the saga. It's not a position he ever expected, but after Colin Trevorrow's firing and Lucasfilm's issues with directors, he's back in the hot-seat, and will find himself needing to actually deliver answers himself. He is a good filmmaker, and with Chris Terrio co-writing the script there should be a decent balance there, but the jury is nonetheless out.

The Last Jedi means there are numerous possibilities for Abrams with the trilogy closer, because - with Episode VIII containing elements of both Empire and Return of the Jedi along with lots of its own new ideas - there's a chance to continue to do things differently. Johnson started it, but now Abrams needs to let the past die, stop with the mystery boxes, and give us some proper resolution.

What do you think about The Last Jedi and J.J. Abrams? Share your thoughts down in the comments.


Contributor
Contributor

NCTJ-qualified journalist. Most definitely not a racing driver. Drink too much tea; eat too much peanut butter; watch too much TV. Sadly only the latter paying off so far. A mix of wise-old man in a young man's body with a child-like wonder about him and a great otherworldly sensibility.