The Blair Witch Project: 7 Most Compelling Fan Theories

Because a murderous, spectral witch is just too straightforward, right?

Blair Witch Secret
Artisan Entertainment

Is there any film that divides horror fans more than The Blair Witch Project?

None are simply lukewarm when it comes to discussing this film, having either been deeply effected by its unsettling, minimalist approach, or left thoroughly disappointed because "nothing happens!". You'll have surely heard the word "overrated" thrown around in regards to how deserving this film is of its 'classic' status; angry comment sections everywhere are brimming with people who cannot comprehend why The Blair Witch Project is so often cited as one of the most frightening films ever made.

These people argue that the film's creative, early viral marketing strategy was solely responsible for the impact on original audiences, not the strengths of the film itself. To this I say "bo****ks". Even today, The Blair Witch Project still holds up as a terrifying experience for first-time viewers (if seen under the right conditions).

Once the question of "is it real, or not?" had completely worn off, people started to ponder the important question: what actually happened to Heather, Josh and Mike? Is what we're seeing really as straightforward as a vengeful, unseen witch playing cat and mouse with the people who stray into her domain?

To ultimately leave The Blair Witch Project so open-ended and uncertain was a stroke of genius (ambiguity wasn't the original intention), inviting some fascinating debate into what is already a brilliant horror landmark.

7. Mary Brown Is The Blair Witch

Mary Brown Blair Witch
Artisan Entertainment

Early on in the documentary footage, when the trio are compiling interviews with the Burkitsville locals, they visit an eccentric old recluse named Mary Brown who recounts a supernatural encounter from her childhood. Of course, they instantly dismiss Mary as a "lunatic", as Heather later describes her.

This is the most superficial of the popular theories out there about The Blair Witch Project, and in truth there is very little to back this assumption up. On first viewing, a significant number of people likely assume from Mary Brown's fleeting minute of screen time that she will ultimately be revealed as the titular entity, based entirely on the fact that she bears a likeness to the stereotype of the decrepit old hag (frail; old-fashioned attire; pointed nose and chin). Honestly, that's probably why Myrick and Sanchez put her in the film.

However, as supporters of this theory correctly point out, Heather remembers that Mary Brown had warned them of "something about a pile of rocks" when they discover that such formations have mysteriously appeared around their tent. It is also frequently noted that the string binding Mary's gate is similar to that used to tie the stick figure symbols that also crop up in the woods.

Even if she isn't actually Elly Kedward herself, rather an unhinged fanatic unhealthily obsessed with the local legend, it's not too much of a stretch to believe that she is responsible for the rocks and sticks. It's the human teeth and severed tongue that are a touch more concerning.


6. Heather Was Secretly An Occultist Obsessed With The Witch Legend

Blair Witch Project
Artisan

This online theory is an interesting one: it works on the suggestion that Heather, utterly obsessed and consumed by the Elly Kedward legend, essentially summoned a dark presence in the woods, without the knowledge of Josh and Mike.

Funnily enough, this interpretation is backed up more by the elaborate marketing of the film than by what we see in the film itself. Myrick and Sanchez not only expanded on the lore of the Blair Witch legend (entirely invented for the purposes of the film) with their fictionalised companion documentary, but they also provided additional 'evidence' which was supposedly discovered alongside the footage, in the form of diary pages.

The film's official website features excerpts from this journal, which recount the project's production from Heather's perspective. She writes: "I can't explain the kinship I feel to her [...] I cannot see how she could avoid perceiving the energy I am sending her way, and have been for 2 years now."

This suggestion also provides us with a whole new way of interpreting that iconic, and rather snotty, message to home. Bearing this theory in mind, this scene can be read as a confessional from an occult fanatic who is in over her head, and only now realising what she's done. Addressing their families, she says "it is my fault": could this admission be more literal that we first assume?

To take things one step further, perhaps Heather knowingly took Josh and Mike with her under the guise of filming a documentary, with the intent of using them as some sort of sacrificial offering. Spooky stuff.


5. The Townsfolk Were In On It

The Blair Witch Project
Haxan Films

Nothing conclusively supernatural actually happens on camera in The Blair Witch Project, or at least nothing that cannot be just as easily explained by a flesh-and-blood killer (or killers). As one interviewee states at the beginning of the film, Heather's documentary isn't the first to be made about the Rustin Parr murders, Coffin Rock, Robin Weaver, or the Elly Kedward legend. One popular theory suggests that the Burkitsville locals were sick and tired of having their town's history exploited by ignorant outsiders, and they conspired to stalk and murder the three young filmmakers.

Or more likely the opposite could be true: for a town that probably relies heavily on macabre tourism, the townspeople may have seen this new documentary project as a way of adding more meat to the existing legend, thereby encouraging more tourists to flock to the area upon discovery of the footage. In fact, this turned out to be the result of the film's convincing marketing in real life, too; many people actually travelled to the filming locations of The Blair Witch Project having seen the fictionalised companion documentary, not realising that the lore had been entirely invented.

The fact that the locals are so cooperative with Heather, Josh and Mike, as well as the fact that whoever responsible clearly made the effort to frighten them before luring them to their deaths, suggests that the latter theory is more likely. Some fans online have also suggested something along the lines of a mass cover-up, or even a supernatural influence affecting the whole town, but that seems a bit too far-fetched.


4. Josh And Mike Plotted To Murder Heather

Blair Witch Project
Artisan Entertainment

The most widely accepted theory on the internet is that Josh and Mike took advantage of the opportunity to have Heather isolated and vulnerable in the woods, so that they could murder her and cover their tracks with the carefully orchestrated, ambiguous footage. There is actually a great deal of evidence in the film to back this theory up.

Supporters of this theory are quick to point out that the boys are almost always walking ahead of Heather, and often insist that they are in possession of the map and compass. This is admittedly very odd, considering that this is Heather's passion project that neither Josh nor Mike seem to care that much about, and that Heather is the one who had carefully planned their routes and itinerary.

It all plays out as if the boys are deliberately disorienting Heather, manipulating the route and perhaps even damaging the compass. It's certainly confirmed that they discarded the map, which in itself makes no sense whatsoever. Heather even wisely insists that they walk in a single direction to find their way back to civilisation, but Josh and Mike overrule her. Why would they reject the most logical course of action, unless they wanted to keep Heather weakened and vulnerable in the middle of nowhere?

Also, the most compelling piece of evidence in favour of a supernatural explanation is the mysterious cackling at night, which incidentally would have been easy for Mike to pull off as the project's sound technician. Heather's journal pages frequently state her mistrust of the pair. After the map goes missing, Heather even remarks: "you two are having just a little too much fun for my taste."

Some fans go a step further, speculating that Josh and Mike's motivations may have had something to do with their involvement in a cult of some sort. This would explain Mike's willingness to participate, as he only met Heather for the first time on the morning of their trip to Burkitsville. If Mike does not have the history with Heather that Josh does, and therefore cannot possibly have any personal reason to want her dead, the pair being cult members provides a motive.


3. The Culprit Is The Spirit Of Rustin Parr, NOT The Blair Witch

Blair Witch Project
Haxan Films

The children who were murdered in the 1940s were not victims of the Blair Witch, but of a recluse who claimed to have been forced to act on her behalf. The locals tell of how Parr would kidnap children in pairs and take them back to the basement of his woodland home, making one face the corner while he killed the other - much like Heather and Mike are implied to have been killed at the end of the film.

This theory suggests that the correct explanation is indeed a supernatural one, but that the entity responsible for the filmmakers' disappearance is wrongly assumed to be the Blair Witch. The manner in which the filmmakers are killed (the basement; Mike facing the corner) hints more towards the culprit being the murderous ghost of Rustin Parr.

Although Parr had claimed to be doing the Blair Witch's bidding until she was satisfied enough to release him from her service, who is to say that he was not just a schizophrenic who was familiar with local legend? Or perhaps he was perfectly sane and simply an evil bastard using the supernatural as a cover for his own sick urges?

Either way, many fans believe that the Burkitsville woods are haunted, not by Elly Kedward, but by the spirit of the madman who in life had been obsessively devoted to her legend, and continues to be just as devoted in death.


2. Josh Lured Heather And Mike

Blair Witch Project Josh
Artisan Entertainment

Assuming that there really is something supernatural stalking the trio, it is made clear quite early on that Josh has been singled out. It's Josh's belongings that are strewn across the campsite and covered in the mysterious slime. It's also worth noting that despite being the peace-keeper and the most level-headed, laid back member of the group initially, he's the one who uncharacteristically snaps as their situation gets more desperate.

Though the other two gradually become more hostile towards each other in a way that is understandable, believable and in keeping with their established personalities, Josh almost seems to transform into a completely different person. His aggression towards Heather, in particular, feels a lot more sinister than simply the frustrations of someone frightened, tired and hungry. In other words, he appears possessed.

Is he under the Blair Witch's influence like Rustin Parr before him? Or instead, expanding on the previous theory, is Josh possessed by the murderous spirit of Parr himself?

The acting all-round is phenomenal in this film, but Joshua Leonard's performance might just be the strongest of the three leads, mainly because of how he handles the tensions leading up to his character's disappearance. Is Josh possessed by something supernatural? Or is he handling their situation worse than his companions and has simply reached breaking point? He plays it perfectly in such a way that either is equally believable.


1. The Blair Witch Can Manipulate Time

Blair Witch Project Rustin Parr
Artisan Entertainment

Why were Heather, Josh and Mike unable to locate their car? Why was no search party able to locate Heather, Josh and Mike? And why is the infamous murder house of Rustin Parr still standing when the young filmmakers stumble upon it in the final minutes of the film, despite it supposedly having been burned down many years previously? The only theory that seems to provide an answer to these questions is this: the group were somehow transported back to the 1940s at the time of Rustin Parr's serial killings.

Movie explanations involving time travel do feel like massive cop-outs, particularly in horror films. Time manipulation was more or less confirmed to be an ability of the Blair Witch in the naff 2016 update (and yes, that film also confirmed that there is indeed a witch - entirely missing the point of the original). Although many people agree that this theory makes the most sense, they felt insulted by having it spelled out to them in Adam Wingard's sequel. It was the ambiguity that made the original so terrifying.

Of course, this theory offers no explanation of why the filmmakers find themselves walking in circles, despite travelling in one direction for an entire day. Can she manipulate space as well as time?

Some fans go a step further, and argue that the whiny Lane fellow from the sequel travelled back in time to murder Heather, Josh and Mike. Personally, I refuse to view any aspect of the original mystery in relation to that abomination of a reboot.


Contributor

Olivia Bradbury hasn't written a bio just yet, but if they had... it would appear here.