The Cloverfield Paradox: What Does The Ending Really Mean?
It's all just a matter of matter.
If you tuned into Super Bowl 52, you would have seen a great game of football, some typically exciting trailers for the likes of Solo: A Star Wars Story and Avengers: Infinity War and another devastatingly clever marketing ploy by Bad Robot that turned a movie that had found difficulty getting distributed previously into one of the must-see movies of the year.
Midway through the game's first half, Bad Robot and Netflix's planned advert aired, revealing the title of the third Cloverfield film (previously known by its production title God Particle and the frankly made-up Cloverfield Station) to be The Cloverfield Paradox and even more stunningly, revealing that it's now available to watch on Netflix. Now that's how you build marketing intrigue.
The trailer's big hook - particularly for Cloverfield franchise fans - was the promise to reveal the "meaning" of Cloverfield, a shared universe thus far defined by its lack of meaning. After two movies purporting to be a shared universe but not in the conventional manner, explanation was needed, and The Cloverfield Paradox offered up a satisfying answer that opens up the possibility of even more movies where pretty much anything goes. That's the joy of establishing your own vague rules.
So what does it all mean, then? Read on for a frank discussion of what happens and the meaning...
7. What Happens
As Earth faces an energy crisis, a team of scientists are sent into space to test a radical solution - using a Shepard particle accelerator to ignite a new super energy source that could solve the crisis in one fell swoop - but a malfunction leads to the station travelling to an alternate dimension where other alternate dimensions bleed into it, causing all sorts of issues (all of which have a distinctly Event Horizon vibe to them).
The crew learn of their mistake as the alternate dimensions bleeding together conspire to kill them all off, like some sort of intangible slasher movie monster and seek to resolve it by using the Shephard to return to their own dimension, because apparently simply doing the same thing again is the correct way to undo the first mistake.
With all of the crew killed - either through accidents, heroic sacrifices or straight murder - Hamilton (who is conflicted by the idea of staying in the alternate universe where her children weren't killed) and Schmidt manage to return home and use the Shephard correctly to gain Earth it's power supply.
Unfortunately, as they return home, it turns out that there are gigantic monsters (the same as from Cloverfield, only bigger) rampaging across the Earth and Hamilton's husband can't warn her quick enough not to return to the surface. Fade to black.
6. The Multiverse Theory
The multiverse malfunction doesn't come without a prescient warning. Before the crew successfully fire the Shephard, they're publicly warned not to by Doctor Mark Stambler - the pre-eminent exponent of the Cloverfield Paradox. His theory suggests that the experiment could cause a rift that would open up the possibility of the universe being invaded by forces from other dimensions - monsters from the deep or other monstrous invaders.
(Why do alternate dimensions never just have puppies and chocolate?)
Stambler's theory confirms the existence of multiple other dimensions that wouldn't otherwise mangle together without something messing with their boundaries. But when those are screwed with, issues can arise not just across space but also - crucially - time. In effect, even if your messing happens in the near future (where Cloverfield Station is), it could open up rifts anywhere on the timeline (which is why the fourth Cloverfield movie will be set in World War II).
It seems that some of the alternate dimensions are weirder than others. For instance, one of them features killer tiny worms that make people explode, one includes the odd revelation that a key component of the Shepard particle accelerator is inside a crewman and one includes people being trapped inside walls with electrical wires running through them.
That's just what happens when you meddle with the fabric of the universe.
5. How It Reflects Real Theoretical Concerns
Stambler's theory/warning isn't without real-world precedent and The Cloverfield Paradox is essentially a Large Hadron Collider anxiety horror.
As the scientists at CERN try to understand the universe more by using the LHC, critics have vocally challenged their assumptions and suggested that the experiments could open up portals to other dimensions or Hell.
There isn't quite the same sci-fi suggestions as Stambler posits concerning monsters crossing over and alternate dimensions fighting for dominance, but the film definitely dials into existing anxiety.
4. How Many Dimensions Are There?
So how many different dimensions are at play in The Cloverfield Paradox
It isn't enough to say that two universes are working against one another to compete for the same space: there are far more to consider. Both of the "main" dimensions are fundamentally presented as fairly normal, with the only differences being to trivialities in the grand scheme of things. In one Hamilton is Earth-based, in the other she's on the Station; in one Tam is the Shephard engineer, in the other she's not; in one Mundy has an arm, in the other he doesn't.
These realities do bleed together, but they go through another mangle. For instance, there's no way Mundy's animated arm reflects either of those normal realities. That's from somewhere else entirely - probably one of the more supernatural dimensions. And there's also no way Mena's reality features monsters, exploding worms or somehow being threaded with electrical wires for no reason as normal occurrences either.
The reality is probably that there are many multiple dimensions all fighting, rather than just two, which is precisely why the crew's attempt to "undo" their mistakes don't reset everything as they believe.
3. What It Means To Cloverfield And 10 Cloverfield Lane
Here's the real killer question: how does the rift created in The Cloverfield Paradox impact the first two movies?
The simple answer is that rather than the monster from the first movie being a product of deep-sea oil drilling waking it, the rift opened in the near future of the Cloverfield Paradox dimension opened a portal between the Cloverfield dimension and the realm that is the home to those monsters.
The same goes for 10 Cloverfield Lane - again, a different dimension to the Cloverfield universe - into which a portal is opened from wherever the aliens who terrorise Earth hail. They're essentially different dimensions tied together by the rifts created in the future, and potentially linked to many other dimensions with endless possibilities for storylines.
That would seemingly include more supernatural elements, though what they will translate to in Overlord remains to be seen.
2. Implications For The Future
The most interesting part of Stambler's Paradox theory is that the dimensional rifts can affect anywhere on the timeline. We already have Overlord coming, whose action is set during World War II where American paratroopers land in France ahead of D Day and discover that the Nazis are using mysterious supernatural forces to help them try and win the war.
Presumably, that's an alternate reality to our own (in which the Nazis could possibly win the war through these supernatural means), but there's no guarantee that it isn't the same dimension as The Cloverfield Paradox is set in, given the seemingly volatile frictions between Germany and Russian, who remain world super-powers.
It's entirely possible that that reality saw the Nazis win the war and a Cold War between the two powers fester for years until the energy crisis kicked it off again.
The strangest and most exciting implication of Overlord is that the Nazis have learned to actually harness the supernatural forces that crossed over into their dimension, which changes the ideas introduced in The Cloverfield Paradox quite markedly and opens up lots of creative possibilities for JJ Abrams and his film-makers to potentially explore.
1. So What Does "Cloverfield" Mean?
So is the naming convention that runs through all of the movies merely a coincidence?
You could understand the case of the Cloverfield monster being designated as such if there was some awareness of the Station being the epicentre of the dimensional rifts, but there's no saying that's the case, and the fact that 10 Cloverfield Lane is the address of the second film's setting definitely seems to be a coincidence.
But what if it's a rule, rather than an accident?
What if Cloverfield is a cross-over junction - a sort of stationary point in the multiverse where the rifts are drawn to open? Effectively like the idea of a Hell Mouth, but with inter-dimensional portals where the crossing point always relates to Cloverfield.
The genius of The Cloverfield Paradox is that while it offers a solution for why the monsters and aliens exist in its movie universes, it doesn't fully explain anything, and the Cloverfield conundrum remains only partially solved. And to be honest, it probably doesn't require explanation down to the most minute detail. There's appeal in its magic.