The Dark Knight Rises: How Many Oscars Will It Win?
How will Nolan's epic finale to Batman fare at the Oscars next year?
After The Dark Knight was famously snubbed for major Academy Award consideration outside of the technical field in 2008, the word on everyone's lips has been whether Christopher Nolan's bookending follow-up, The Dark Knight Rises, would manage to amass a larger amount of nominations. After all, it is widely believed that the widening of the Oscar field in the 2010 ceremony was due to the snubbing of Nolan's Joker-starring masterpiece (alongside the omission of excellent films like WALL-E, The Wrestler and Revolutionary Road). Whether you believe Rises is a better film than The Dark Knight or not, there is the possibility that Nolan's efforts in the series as a whole will be rewarded this time around with at least a few additional nominations, especially after his last film, Inception, was nominated for Best Picture. However, after ludicrously failing to score a Best Director nomination for his mind-bending sci-fi, I'm not particularly convinced the Academy will be behind him this time. Here is a projection of the chances that The Dark Knight Rises will be nominated for and win in any categories for which it is eligible. Best Actress has not been included due to the lack of a lead actress (Anne Hathaway would be supporting). Best Actor
Chance of a nomination: 1/10 Chance of a win: 0/10 The solitary Best Actor prospect in The Dark Knight Rises would, of course, be Christian Bale for his superior portrayal of hermetic billionaire Bruce Wayne. It goes without saying that in Nolan's second entry into the franchise, he was entirely overshadowed by Heath Ledger's unforgettable performance, though this time around finds himself facing a more even playing field against Tom Hardy and Anne Hathaway. The more thoughtful and emotional, character-driven trajectory of the plot this time around also gives Bale more dialogue with Michael Caine's Alfred, and superbly acted though these exchanges are, they aren't really substantial enough in of themselves to compete against acting lions the likes of Daniel Day Lewis (Lincoln), Joaquin Phoenix (The Master), Hugh Jackman (Les Miserables) and Leonardo DiCaprio (The Great Gatsby). Of course, all of those films are up to this point sight-unseen, but they would have to disappoint on a major scale for Oscar to make room for Christian Bale, no matter how strong his work was this time around. Best Supporting Actor
Chance of a nomination = 2/10 Chance of a win = 0/10 Though Heath Ledger broke the glass ceiling for comic book films as far as acting plaudits go, one can't help but be a little cynical and suggest that were Ledger still alive, he probably would not have received an Academy Award nomination no matter how excellent - and deserving - the performance was. That discussion is somewhat past the point anyway, as Tom Hardy's portrayal of Bane - though excellent - is highly unlikely to earn Academy Award attention, largely because the character lacks the same iconic stature of The Joker, and is relatively unknown to the majority of viewers - specifically Academy voters - at large. Also, controversy over Hardy's vocal performance and the fact that some audiences have struggled to understand him will also dampen his chances further, in a field that is already likely to boast Philip Seymour Hoffman (The Master), Woody Harrelson (Seven Psychopaths) and Leonardo DiCaprio (Django Unchained).
Best Supporting Actress
Chance of a nomination = 3/10 Chance of a win = 0/10 Anne Hathaway delivered a brilliantly understated portrayal of Selina Kyle aka Catwoman in The Dark Knight Rises, one that hews away from the cheesy Halle Berry performance to something resembling - if tighter and less pulpy than - Michelle Pfeiffer's unforgettable turn. The Academy likes Hathaway, and last year gave a surprise nomination to a strong female character, in Rooney Mara's Lisbeth Salander (The Girl with the Dragon Tattoo) - albeit in the Best Actress category - but Hathaway may end up blocking herself out, as she is hotly tipped in this field already for her turn in Tom Hooper's musical Les Miserables. Furthermore, while her work here is staunchly effective, her screen time is limited and she is at all times a character on the periphery rather than one who gets a wealth of so-called "Oscar-reel" scenes, as Ledger's The Joker was blessed with. Best Art Direction
Chance of a nomination = 5/10 Chance of a win = 3/10 It is a category that is predominantly cluttered up by opulent period pics, and with the likes of The Great Gatsby, Anna Karenina, Django Unchained, Les Miserables and Lincoln stepping up to the plate this year, it would be a fight for Rises to squeeze in there. That said, The Dark Knight did indeed earn an Academy Award nomination for Art Direction, and so it is possible that Nolan's grander, more stylistically diverse follow-up could again please voters, particularly if one of the above films turns out to be a disappointment (and its more superficial credentials are therefore given less regard as a result).
Best Adapted Screenplay
Chance of a nomination = 5/10 Chance of a win = 2/10 One of the toughest nuts to crack in the more rigid award categories is that of the screenplay, and it's one that blockbuster films especially struggle with. Given that this year's most prized contenders are adapted from highly-acclaimed plays (Beasts of the Southern Wild), novels (Life of Pi), amazing life stories (The Sessions) and investigative journalism (Argo), it would be quite a push for Nolan to force his way in here. Though Nolan has indeed been nominated for a screenwriting Academy Award twice, it has been in the original rather than adapted category both times (for Memento and Inception). That said, the political currency of Nolan's narrative - in broaching the battle between the 99% and the 1% - might capture the imagination of voters not expecting such engagement with our times in a superhero film, and the film's overall emotional resonance might also earn it a few plaudits in this regard, so don't count it out entirely. Best Costume Design
Chance of a nomination = 2/10 Chance of a win = 0/10 It isn't a category that any of Nolan's films have even been nominated in, and it's unlikely again that his film will succeed here, especially after the Batsuit, and the Joker's loud, outrageous clothing was not recognised last time. Anne Hathaway's fairly dressed-down catsuit and Bane's militia-style deckings are unlikely to be seen as anything approaching awards worthy, so it's difficult to imagine that a nomination would even be thought about here, especially when you consider the genre's typical domination by period fare, of which there is plenty this year - Anna Karenina, The Great Gatsby, Django Unchained, Les Miserables, Lincoln, Snow White and the Huntsman and Mirror Mirror.
Best Cinematography
Chance of a nomination = 9/10 Chance of a win = 7/10 One the film's safest bets for a nomination is Wally Pfister's glorious cinematography, which has seen him nominated in four of Nolan's previous films (Batman Begins, The Prestige, The Dark Knight and Inception). Given the two previous Batman films got love here, it would seem surprising if Rises were the first film in the series not to. Considering its emphasis on IMAX technology (with 72 minutes of its screen time consisting of IMAX footage, a substantial leap on The Dark Knight), as well as the massive scale and focus on beautifully snow-kissed, chilly locales in the film's later sections, this is almost as sure a bet as the film is likely to get. That said, Pfister will face strong competition in Life of Pi, Django Unchained, The Master and especially Terrence Malick's latest, To the Wonder. Best Makeup and Hairstyling
Chance of a nomination = 2/10 Chance of a win = 0/10 Given that The Dark Knight failed to garner a nomination with its wacky Joker makeup, Rises has virtually no chance of success here, given its makeup largely consists of the previous flourishes - Batman's black eye work - with some very minor touches on the new characters, such as the scarred skin on Bane's body and Catwoman's sexy lipstick. The category has been revised to include hairstyling, but it will do little to enhance the film's chances as, simply, nothing stands out. This category will be crowded by Lincoln, Django Unchained, Les Miserables, and possibly Prometheus and The Hobbit.
Best Film Editing
Chance of a nomination = 6/10 Chance of a win = 5/10 Lee Smith has edited Christopher Nolan's last five films, though has only been nominated in this category once, for The Dark Knight. His snub for Inception remains one of the Academy's most notable recent mistakes, given how well his work ensured the labyrinthine narrative managed to clip along coherently rather than become mired in confusion. Inconsistent editing has nevertheless been a frequent criticism of Nolan's films - specifically Batman Begins, which featured frustratingly choppy action scenes - even if by this point the editing does, for a film running in at 2 hours, 45 minutes, feel tight and considered. That said, its length also opens it up to easy criticisms from its detractors, and so it will depend on the performance of films like Life of Pi, Lincoln, Zero Dark Thirty, The Master and Django Unchained. Best Original Score
Chance of a nomination = 5/10 Chance of a win = 3/10 One of the less predictable categories for the film is the score; after all, neither Batman Begins nor The Dark Knight has been nominated in this category, the latter famously occurring after its score was disqualified because - ludicrously enough - the music cue sheet had too many composers listed on it. It is a category that continues to baffle, yet a branch that is obviously rather fond of Hans Zimmer, nominating him for Inception's score in 2010 (and giving him 8 previous nods, winning the gong for The Lion King). However, they might be motivated to nominate Zimmer here for his overall contributions to the franchise, as well as the fact that this third score takes a divergent trajectory, focusing more on haunting themes as keeping in line with the picture's more sombre, downbeat tone. It is unlikely to win as the Academy has shown notable prejudice towards synth and electronic-based scores, though they did demonstrate surprising open-mindedness in awarding Trent Reznor and Atticus Ross Oscars for their The Social Network score in 2011. The main obstacle is whether the score will be deemed ineligible because it borrows many motifs from the previous films, which I fear is a strong possibility.
Best Sound Editing
Chance of a nomination = 10/10 Chance of a win = 8/10 A sure bet for Rises' Oscar glory, Richard King's previous work for Christopher Nolan has been rewarded twice (The Dark Knight, Inception), and it is always a category that summer blockbusters tend to perform well in. It will face competition from Joss Whedon's The Avengers, but this film's more grounded sound work, combined with memorable sound effects - especially from Batman's various vehicles - are likely to make it the victor in this category. Best Sound Mixing
Chance of a nomination = 9/10 Chance of a win = 6/10 Though The Dark Knight scooped the Sound Editing Oscar, it missed out on Sound Mixing, quite possibly caused by complaints that the theatrical exhibition of the film resulted in dialogue often being drowned out by Hans Zimmer's bombastic score, a problem that has also plagued Rises (even if this owes more to incorrect sound levels of each individual cinema rather than the mix itself). Furthermore, the controversy surrounding Bane's voice will likely reflect unfavourably upon the quality of the final mix. Again it will face competition from the year's other spectacular superhero film, but will additionally face off against Les Miserables with its combination of singing, music and dialogue.
Best Visual Effects
Chance of a nomination = 8/10 Chance of a win = 6/10 The money shot of The Dark Knight Rises is unquestionably the football field explosion sequence, but largely the film is a triumph of subtle visual effects applied to organic stuntwork, particularly during The Bat's flight scenes, which combined mounted and suspended vehicles with impressively photorealistic renderings of the Caped Crusader's airborne means of transport. The Batpod's visual effects, meanwhile, are admittedly a little spotty in places, but the overall success with which these effects are melded into the stunt-based action, and the fact that The Dark Knight was nominated for similar successes, makes it a fairly safe bet in this category, and something The Avengers will likely not be able to compete with. However, The Hobbit and Life of Pi are considered to be major threats, and their bombast might edge out the subtlety of TDKR's effects. Best Director
Chance of a nomination = 5/10 Chance of a win = 0/10 This is the one that so-called "Nolanites" everywhere will be following very closely; whether Christopher Nolan, who has to this point only been nominated for his writing, will finally scoop up a directing nomination after having been nominated by the prestigious Director's Guild of America three times to date, for Memento, The Dark Knight and Inception. In many ways it might feel like a summation of his career thus far, yet a sizeable opinion that the film might not be quite up to the standard of The Dark Knight might work against him. However, steering a blockbuster of such an epic length towards an emotionally satisfying conclusion, as well as the mix of bravura action with strong themes and character development might finally net him that nomination he so desperately deserves. However, he will be facing extraordinarily stiff competition, with Paul Thomas Anderson (The Master), Ang Lee (Life of Pi), Steven Speilberg (Lincoln), Tom Hooper (Les Miserables), Quentin Tarantino (Django Unchained), Baz Luhrmann (The Great Gatsby), Terrence Malick (To The Wonder) and Ben Affleck (Argo) all touting new releases this year. While a win is virtually impossible, a nomination would be a relieving feather in the director's cap after so many previous snubs.
Best Picture
Chance of a nomination = 8/10 Chance of a win = 0/10 The widening of the Best Picture field has, in many eyes, devalued the stature of a "Best Picture nominee" marquee on posters and home video advertising, but it has allowed for some pleasantly diverse films, such as A Serious Man, The Tree of Life, District 9, Inglourious Basterds and Toy Story 3 to receive nominations. The flipside is that it has also allowed laughably undeserving fare, such as The Blind Side, Extremely Loud and Incredibly Close and The Help to become nominees, such that if Nolan's Rises is not nominated, the new system is likely to endure a new bout of criticism. After all, with these films sitting at 67%, 47% and 76% on the Tomatometer respectively, while Rises perches on 87% with a much higher 8.0 average - as well as a 9.0 on IMDB - the feeling is that their nomination, and Rises' omission, would not reflect the popular sentiment. However, this would invite questions about who the Academy Awards are supposed to represent, and of course, the answer to that is the view of AMPAS, largely consisting of over-60s, white men, rather than the predominantly under-35 male crowd that have been travelling in their droves to see Nolan's opus. That said, it is abundantly clear that, with a wider nominee range, The Dark Knight would have secured a Best Picture nomination, and after Nolan's Inception picked up a nod, it is also very likely that Rises will find a space for itself, even if this year is absolutely packed with strong prestige and populist possibilities. Winning, however, is virtually impossible, more owing to the fact that the Academy is only ready to recognise a superhero film's place alongside high-minded arthouse fare, but not necessarily reward it in the major categories. That said, films such as Paul Thomas Anderson's The Master are likely to offer a legitimate challenge to Nolan that would extend beyond Academy prejudices, and I doubt few would argue with that. And now it's time to tally up the nominations and wins...
Oscar Tally: 7 Nominations, 3 Wins
Nominations (wins are in bold): Best Picture Best Art Direction Best Cinematography Best Film Editing Best Sound EditingBest Sound Mixing Best Visual Effects It's a pessimistic list, perhaps, but then that'll make it all the more exciting if, in fact, I am wrong, and the film can rack up additional nominations for Nolan's direction and Zimmer's score in particular. Still, a Best Picture nomination would itself be a leap forward for the superhero film. Academy Award nominations will be announced on Tuesday, January 15th, 2013, and the ceremony itself takes place on Sunday, February 24th, 2013.