The Hobbit: 10 Times Peter Jackson Ruined A Character
A rabbit sledge... , really?
When the Lord of the Rings trilogy was released in the 2000s, it generated a sense of frantic excitement and wild enthusiasm, unknown in the world of fantasy cinema. Now, cast your mind back to when the first trailer for The Hobbit dropped sometime in 2011. The child inside awoke and your imagination ran wild with the prospect of revisiting Middle-earth.
With that first trailer came hope that this would be a cinematic experience to match the original trilogy. Even with all the rumours of a troubled production, directors dropping out and studio interference, the initial images of the Hobbit looked incredible.
But as the first movie began to unfold, the unease started to set in. There was a feeling that Jackson had forgone all the things that made the Lord of the Rings great: prosthetic make-up and set design was replaced with CGI; the gritty realism gave way for comic spectacle; and cheap thrills had taken precedent over plot. The next two instalments only compounded these issues.
But put aside the crappy animation, the over-bloated action sequences and the forced love triangle, the most egregious insult was the miss-handling of almost every major character.
10. Bolg's Entire Story
Bolg was certainly imposing, but in terms of his character there wasn't much going on...
In the book, Bolg was the leader of the orcs at the Battle of Five Armies (Azog was long dead by this point). The fact Jackson adapted this significantly is not the issue, he just went about it in a piss poor way.
The character certainly required some fleshing out, Tolkien only mentioned him briefly in the book, ascribing his demise to the furious skin-changer, Beorn during the final battle. The character design indicated that Jackson was aware of this plot point, though. Bolg certainly looked like he'd had a history with the skin-changers; he wore bear claw trophies on his shoulders, and that head wound looked like it was inflicted by something big... With Beorn mentioning the orcs were responsible for the death of his people, it seemed Jackson was setting up some big showdown between the two.
Sadly, that didn't happen, Bolg merely served as punching bag for Legolas to practice his combat acrobatics on. He had almost no significant impact on the plot... There's that prolonged boxing match with Legolas in the second movie, and he took part in a version of Middle-earth: Total Wipeout in the third, but apart from that what other point did he serve?
9. Radagast's !*$%ing Rabbit Sledge
Radagast didn't appear in Tolkien's the Hobbit, instead he was a character who briefly appeared in the Fellowship of the Ring. Nevertheless Peter Jackson's choice to include him wasn't necessarily a bad one. Tolkien described him as a Wizard who'd become overly distracted with nature, to the point of forgetting his task in defeating Sauron. The fairy-tale nature of the Hobbit made him a fitting character to include, and Sylvester McCoy played the mushroomed addled, forrest-hippie brilliantly.
Having said all that, Jackson introduced him with an overly long chase sequence, that become indicative of the entire trilogies lacklustre momentum.
If there's one thing that doesn't lend itself to Middle-earth, it's a Hollywood chase sequence; Jackson substituted fast cars for wargs and, wait for it... , a rabbit sledge. It was one of those early moments in the trilogy that made your stomach drop. It was indication that Jackson had succumbed to favouring wild spectacle over plot-driven narrative.
Not only was the sequence utterly dull, but it served to make both Tolkien's world and Radagast feel ridiculous.
8. Tauriel's Unexplained Interest In Kili
When the news hit that Jackson was introducing a non-cannon character into the Hobbit, the internet almost imploded. One half was praising the addition of a bow wielding elf-maiden, who brought some balance to a sausage-heavy cast. The other half was ready to riot - with incels losing their sh*t about the inclusion of a female character. Whether you agreed with the inclusion of Tauriel or not, it can be agreed that Jackson dropped the ball when it came to the execution of her story arc.
Initially, Tauriel looked like she might pose an interesting question in the world of Middle-earth: Were some elves racists towards other elves? Early on it is implied that Legolas has the hots for Tauriel. His father is less than keen about this notion, however. Due to his son being a Sindar elf, Thranduil deems Tauriel unworthy of his affection given her lowly Silvan status.
It had the potential to be a complex Romeo and Juliet style romance, causing some real tension for the characters... , but like many setups in this trilogy, the payoff was almost non existent. Tauriel just ended up becoming besotted with a dwarf she's met once... , and Legolas' only reaction was to deliver some of his signature, mournful stares into the distance.
7. Bard The Bowman's Non-ending
Although Bard has a major part to play in Tolkien's The Hobbit, he actually has very few scenes and fairly limited dialogue. He's portrayed as a gruff and sullen man, who commands the archers of Lake Town. After slaying the dragon he leads the survivors to the Mountain and takes part in the Battle of the Five Armies, before becoming King of Dale.
Jackson invented the whole rebellious, bargeman backstory, and fleshed out his family background to drive up the tension. These were all great character development opportunities. The Bard in the books is a little one-dimensional but Jackson gave him some motivation - namely his need to protect his children and his sense of duty towards his beleaguered, fellow townsfolk.
But sadly the director underutilised this wealth of new material. The third Hobbit movie, was so inundated with swinging swords, that there was no possible room to develop or resolve any of these plot points. After slaying the Dragon all we see of Bard is a a few hero shots, fighting in the streets of Dale... Does anybody even remember what happened to him after the battle?
6. Kili's Efforts At Romance
Kili and most of the other dwarves don't receive a huge amount of character development in the books. We know Kili and Fili are the youngest and most naive, but they're also two of the bravest of Thorin's company. Their most defining moment comes in the final chapters when they die trying to defend the wounded body of their uncle Thorin - a great opportunity for a scene, that Jackson didn't take advantage of.
It was clear Jackson changed his mind about what role Kili would play in the movies, mid-production. If you look at his early prosthetic design, Kili was far more dwarfish, and far more... , ugly. You can even spot him with a larger noes and a more pronounce forehead in several shots in Bag End. But when the ill-advised romance with Tauriel got the green light, Jackson decided he needed a 'handsome dwarf', and Aidan Turner fit the bill.
From the second movie onwards Kili became a wise cracking ladies-dwarf, spewing out pick up lines as cheesy as: "I could have anything down my trousers" and as clichéd as: "You make me feel alive". It was a total drag.
5. Azog's Prolonged Death Sequence
By the time Thorin got around to defeating Azog did anyone even care?
Peter Jackson was smart when filming the Lord of the Rings, he avoided one on one duels at all costs, and when he did include them, they were punchy and affective. Remember when Aragorn took on Lurtz in the Fellowship? That all happened in under a minute (and that was the extended edition), there was no cutting away to other characters, it was quick and brutal, and it worked.
But the Thorin/Azog fight dragged on for what felt like an age. The entire run up was intercut with footage of Legolas doing something ridiculous, or Bard looking sad, or Gandalf waving his wand. When the showdown actually happened, it was was over five minutes of ice skating and forced dramatic pauses.
Jackson seemed to forgo character driven plot in his final film, in the hope that flashy action sequences would do the heavy lifting for him. Sadly it just served to make the final showdown feel like a cheap imitation of a Marvel climax.
4. Smaug's Chase Sequence
Although the Hobbit was criticised for its over reliance on CGI, it did include two incredibly well done digital characters. Andy Serkis gave the world another memorable performance as Gollum. But we were also given Benedict Cumberbatch's interoperation of Smaug. Although digitally enhanced, his vocal performances was mesmerising. He managed to capture both Smaug's sly mind and his imposing character perfectly.
And that's not to mention how detailed and stunning the character was visually. The design for Smaug took months, the team went through a long, painful process, pinning down exactly how to bring Tolkien's most famed antagonist to life.
So it was a shame that Jackson wasted the character on another ill advised and poorly executed chase sequence. The last 20 minutes of the Desolation of Smaug was a tedious romp through the Lonely Mountain - with dwarves swinging on chains, and surfing on rivers of gold. That's not to mention the ridiculous moment Smaug squared up to a giant, golden Christmas chocolate.
3. Beorn's Non-existing Payoff
There's a running theme in this article. So far we've attempted to highlight just how inept Peter Jackson was at giving any of his characters a satisfactory story arc. To give Jackson his due, the decision to hire Swedish actor Mikael Persbrandt was inspired. Complete with Middle-earth mohawk, Persbrandt was able to portray the imposing, impressive and uneasy nature of Beorn effortlessly. Which makes it even more of an injustice that he never got a proper ending.
Our introduction to Beorn was exciting, snappy and over before we knew it. But Jackson did a fine job of setting him up as a character to have a significant role further down the line. We find out he has a particular grudge against the orcs pursuing Thorin's company, for their part in wiping out his entire race. Beorn's wrist-shackles even hinted at the probability he had been held captive and tortured by them, himself.
Surely this meant he'd come back to exact revenge and assist in the final battle in some significant way. NOPE. After all that clever foreshadowing all we got was a brief clip of Beorn sky jumping from the back of an eagle and briefly flailing around in a crowd of nondescript orcs. Considering he rescues Thorin and then kills Bolg in the books, Jackson missed a trick.
2. Sauron Made The Plot To Convoluted
Peter Jackson was faced with an interesting task when it came to adapting the Hobbit into a three part movie. In the book, Tolkien drummed up some tension by having Gandalf disappear for a significant section of the narrative, forcing the Dwarves and Bilbo to face a few challenges without his aid.
Gandalf's brief mention of the Necromancer was originally nothing more than a vague nod to the wider world of Middle-earth, and an excuse to have Gandalf leave. Tolkien only decided this would be Sauron when he wrote the Lord of the Rings years later.
Jackson felt this would be a good opportunity to tie his new trilogy back to his original. It had all the ingredients for a tasty sub-plot, but Jackson over cooked it. Rather than giving a few sinister winks to the Dark Lord, Jackson decided to make him an integral part of the story. It's easy to see why he did this, but it took up so much screen time that it sapped momentum from the narrative established in movie one.
The Hobbit was supposed to tell the tale of Bilbo and the Dwarves retaking the Misty Mountain. Instead it became embroiled with a wider plot line, shabbily dovetailed into Bilbo's story in the most unsatisfying way possible.
1. Legolas' Over Expanded Role
The combination of bad writing and Orlando Bloom's wooden acting, resulted in one of the worst character executions in the entire trilogy. Early on there was speculation that several characters from the Lord of the Rings would make appearances in the Hobbit. Elijah Wood would make a brief comeback as Frodo, and Orlando Bloom was rumoured to show up as the Elf-prince Legolas.
The prospect of having his arrow-slinging hero back onscreen clearly ran away with Peter Jackson, as it became clear Bloom's role was anything but a cameo. By now it's widely known that Legolas did not appear in the book, Tolkien didn't conceive of the character until he wrote the Lord of the Rings, years later. His inclusion is not altogether unwarranted, however, given the expanded life of elves and his relationship to Thranduil. It even made sense for him to have a significant role in the story given his status in Mirkwood.
But his time spent leap frogging over dwarves and performing wildly elaborate acrobatics just became tedious. Even the cursed Kili/Tauriel romance sub-plot, might have been saved, if Jackson actually had Legolas react to it in some kind of significant way. The Legolas character was indicative of these movies - he was the jazz hands distracting us from the lack of substance.