The Hobbit Trilogy: 10 Dumbest Moments

Really, Peter Jackson? REALLY?

When Guillermo Del Toro stepped down from the The Hobbit in 2010, there was incredible pressure from fans for the return of Peter Jackson. Having Peter Jackson direct the (at the time) two films would assuage all fears of them being anything less than brilliant. How could the man who directed The Lord Of The Rings Trilogy mess up? He couldn't - it was impossible. Flash forward five years and all three films (Jackson managed to pack in an extra film along the way) have been released. Described by prominent film critic Mark Kermode as €œHobbity Tosh€, it's no secret that The Hobbit Trilogy failed to live up to the mastery of The Lord Of The Rings, not just in the eyes of critics but for a huge number of fans. So what happened? There's a myriad of significant issues, like the fact that the films are unable to establish a consistent tone, are too self-consciously connected to The Lord Of The Rings, and that three films is simply too much screen time for such a slim novel. But while the problems with The Hobbit are many, there are a few scenes in particular that stand out as being just notably stupid...

10. The Bilbo/Frodo Opening

On paper this sounds fantastic - a chance for Ian Holm and Elijah Wood to reprise their The Lord Of The Rings roles in order to ease the audience into a brand new adventure. In reality, however, the scene didn't quite work out like fans had hoped.

The truth is, it just felt off, Frodo and Bilbo's interactions so stilted. Sure, Ian Holm looked a lot older - and so did Elijah Wood, too - but that's not what made the scene bad. Ian McKellen was also older, and he managed to slip back into the role of Gandalf the Grey almost perfectly. No, for whatever reason the chemistry between Holm and Wood was just... gone. References to Sackville Bagginses and Bilbo's €œoddness€ felt cheap and forced - a kind of foreshadowing for the rest of the trilogy. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HaVQJn3Ljio

9. The Rabbit Sled Chase

This one is stupid - really stupid. One of the problems The Hobbit faced was trying to establish a clear tone. Would it be light-hearted and humorous like a children's book? Or would it attempt to recapture the darkness and severity of the Rings trilogy? In the end, Jackson attempted both - to questionable effect.

The films seemed to flip back and forth whenever they needed to, flinging around slapstick gags and sombre moments within minutes of each other. One of the worst products of this was undoubtedly Radagast the Brown's rabbit sled. During a particularly tense moment in which the company finds itself surrounded by Wargs, Radagast appears from nowhere and instigates a chase of Benny Hill proportions. No, seriously - someone actually added Benny Hill music to it, and it doesn't feel out of place... https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3AZlmVNjEjQ

8. The Entire Goblin-Town Battle

The biggest sin an adventure film can commit is to remove all sense of peril €“ but that's exactly what The Hobbit does during the Goblin-Town chase. The Goblin King himself, while silly, was well-animated and well-voiced, lending to an interesting, memorable encounter. It's the subsequent battle when Gandalf shows up that's the real problem. Watching our heroes mow down wave after wave of flimsy CGI goblins in utterly ludicrous ways completely eradicates any danger.

The goblins were no longer weighty foes that proposed a massive threat like in Moria - they were merely special effects programmed to die. And to top it all off, at the end of the scene the company falls hundreds of feet down a cliff while surfing on a piece of rickety bridge. Can you imagine seeing something so ridiculous in The Lord of the Rings? Of course not - every character would be dead. But it's not even about comparisons to LOTR - it was at this point that audiences knew the world of The Hobbit no longer had a clear sense of its own reality. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7kIhKCH8q4E

7. Every Scene Featuring Alfrid

Or €œGrima Wormtongue Lite€ as he has come to be known. The Master of Laketown's lackey Alfrid is quite possibly the most one-dimensional, yet oddly prominent character across the entire Middle-Earth saga. With an overly contrived appearance (monobrow = evil) and cliché motivations (nothing but money) there is literally nothing interesting about him.

What's particularly egregious about Alfrid is that in The Battle Of The Five Armies he has considerably more screen time than many of the dwarves - he probably even begins to rival Bilbo's! And all so audiences can watch him skulk around trying to steal money and cringe when he dresses up as a woman. What was his purpose? https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=i7B3DfL_7ak

6. Legolas Chats To Gloin About Gimli

This scene is just one of many in which Peter Jackson is unable to measure subtetly. When Gloin flips open his locket and exclams €œthat's my wee lad, Gimli€ you can practically see Jackson standing off-camera smiling and winking.

This might not even be that bad if it wasn't yet another example of an overly hammy The Lord Of The Rings reference amongst so many. From direct lines (the eagles are coming!) to ripped off scenes (Gandalf's room-darkening shout at Bag End) there are countless occasions on which The Hobbit goes way too far. What makes it all the worse is how Jackson actually displays the ability to nod towards The Lord Of The Rings using visual clues - in certain scenes Gloin is seen wearing a helmet extremely similar to Gimli's, and wielding a familiar axe. Why couldn't this reference have been something fun for the audience to discover for themselves? https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uHWJJ4BsHQw

5. Kili And Tauriel Flirt Through Prison Bars

It's understandable that Jackson would want to create more female roles for The Hobbit - without Galadriel and Tauriel present there are practically none at all. But creating Tauriel just for the purpose of facilitating a cross-species love triangle isn't just bad - it's insulting, and backwards, and negates whatever Jackson was trying to achieve. It might at the very least be palatable if the relationship between Kili and Tauriel was in any way convincing - but it really isn't. Having two people stare lovingly at each other while soppy music plays in the background isn't how you construct a meaningful relationship. This is the scene when fan's concerns were confirmed - Jackson really had nothing meaningful to offer by splitting The Hobbit into three films. Sure, there was some interesting Sauron stuff, but was it really worth the likes of this? https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DN_mjj7ru5E

4. Thorin Surfs On Molten Gold (Using A Piece Of Metal)

This ridiculous scene is an extension of the lack of reality established in An Unexpected Journey during the Goblin-Town chase scene. The entire furnace sequence is pretty stupid - from Smaug's sudden lack of intelligence to the company's resistance to intense heat - but it's when Thorin surfs across molten gold on a wheelbarrow that things are elevated to new levels of dumb. Mistakes and little logical fallacies in films are generally excusable when they don't have much bearing on the plot or the outcome of the story - but when they ride the line between a main character living or dying they're slightly more problematic. There has been much fan debate about whether or not the molten lava would have melted the iron wheelbarrow - in the end, it doesn't really matter. What is agreed on is that Thorin should have at the very least been so severely burned by the hot iron that his skin would have melted. Ouch. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hXAVsOSAuwk

3. Legolas Vs Bolg

The entire Legolas/Bolg sequence at the end of The Battle Of The Five Armies is one of the most ridiculously overblown action sequences in film, created purely to give Legolas something to do other than sulk over Tauriel.

It's clear just how pieced together and rushed this whole rivalry is. At the end of The Desolation Of Smaug, we watch Legolas chase Bolg out of Laketown - in The Battle Of The Five Armies this entire scene has been disregarded. Did Legolas just randomly stop chasing him? What happened? It's yet another symptom of Jackson attempting to find enough story to fill out his films, rather than filling his films with story.

From the knocking over of the stone tower using a legless beast (seriously?) to the structure somehow supporting a heated battle to Legola's now infamous ability to run up falling stones, the entire sequence is a weightless CGI-fest that's rendered pointless by the fact we know he's going to survive anyway. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CgQSm0uSUtk

2. Smaug's One-Hit KO

This one was always going to be a problem. There are some things that just don't translate very well dramatically from the page to the screen. Throughout the first two films Smaug is bigged up immensely to be a force immeasurable, a flying, flaming furnace who can incinerate anything in an instant. While much of this is true, and well established, it's difficult not to be disappointed when he's downed by a single arrow.

But that's not what's dumb - what's dumb is how the extension of The Hobbit into three films changes the context of Smaug's death. Had the last half an hour of The Desolation Of Smaug been an epic and ferocious battle against Smaug, ultimately culminating in his death, audiences may actually have been satisfied. Instead, we witness an extremely brief battle at the beginning of Five Armies, sweeping Smaug aside before the film has barely begun, and leaving countless audience members asking each other €œIs Smaug actually dead? Is he coming back?€ https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=p5MyNFfh7Ns

1. Thranduil Telling Legolas To Find Aragorn

This scene is unforgivably dumb - from the stilted, melodramatic refusal to actually use the word €œAragorn€ (his true name you must discover for yourself) to the ham-fisted The Fellowship Of The Ring overture, it reeks of self-congratulation.

This is the magnum opus of terrible The Lord Of The Rings references in The Hobbit, serving utterly no purpose other than to try and please fans. Is it supposed to be clever? Is it supposed to be exciting? It's lowest common denominator and barely makes sense at all - if The Hobbit takes place sixty years before The Fellowship Of The Ring, and Aragorn is in his eighties during The Two Towers, did Legolas find him when he was in his twenties? Did they hang out for fifty years? If that's the case, why is none of this mentioned in LOTR? It's a reference that costs more than it was worth including. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uikIIiAdrMI What do you find the dumbest moment in The Hobbit Trilogy? Have a good laugh and share it down below.

Contributor
Contributor

Commonly found reading, sitting firmly in a seat at the cinema (bottle of water and a Freddo bar, please) or listening to the Mountain Goats.