The Hobbit vs The Lord of the Rings

9. The Shire

In a land seemingly engulfed in a state of constant battle, there is something oddly comforting about the quiet existence of the Shire. Though it is by no means the venue for which the masses flock to the screens - imagine, a three hour picture of Farmer Maggot tending to his crops - its inclusion is still important.

In both An Unexpected Journey and The Fellowship of the Ring, the opening scenes depict the very best of the Shire. Whilst the well-kept larders and the neatly furnished decorum of Bilbo's home offer an insight into the quaint housing arrangements of a hobbit, the lush meadows and well-meaning smiles of the community show what the life of a hobbit is like on a much wider scale; a humble life, a life of comfort and contentment.

Undoubtedly aided by its extensive coverage, it is An Unexpected Journey that truly offers a more rounded feel for the Shire. The comical contrast of Bilbo - a well to do hobbit - and the company of dwarves - a more boisterous bunch - encourages the audience to fall in love with the unassuming nature of the Shire in a way The Fellowship of the Ring didn't quite manage. Though the audience are no doubt eager to depart the home of the hobbits, there is a sadness when this eventually occurs - especially with the knowledge of what is to come.

Winner - An Unexpected Journey