The Little Mermaid Review: 5 Ups & 5 Downs

Another middling live-action Disney remake.

The Little Mermaid Ariel
Disney

Disney's industrious effort to remake their most beloved animated films continues with The Little Mermaid - an undeniable gemstone of Disney's animated canon which now finds itself remade in "live-action" form courtesy of director Rob Marshall (Chicago).

Despite their general commercial success, Disney's spate of remakes have been all over the map quality-wise, and to that end, the new version of The Little Mermaid is itself a wildly mixed affair.

Broadly well-received by critics so far, this is a competent enough yet mostly unremarkable retelling which saddles the classic original with almost a full hour of extra material that it really doesn't need.

Some heroic central performances and the sheer power of the original songs provide plenty of nostalgic relief, but ultimately The Little Mermaid 2023 still feels like a relatively pale facsimile of the 1989 film.

While thankfully ranking far from the bottom of Disney's many remakes, it doesn't make a particularly encouraging artistic argument for the Mouse House's ongoing quest to rehash their finest works for a new generation.

And with that in mind, here's what doesn't work about The Little Mermaid...


Downs...

5. The Underwhelming Visuals

The Little Mermaid Ariel
Disney

Given that Disney spent $250 million on this thing, you'd at least expect it to look great, right?

Well, not quite.

The Little Mermaid has its moments, sure, but for the most part it's such a disappointingly murky, stylistically anonymous piece of work, lacking the necessary artistic flair to match the colourful vibrancy of the original animation.

In the misguided pursuit of a more "realistic" aesthetic, the colours are often muted into a bland sludge, especially when on land, and even the underwater scenes lack the eye-watering visual pep you'd expect. Avatar: The Way of Water this ain't.

The VFX never quite persuade that we're actually being transported to an underwater kingdom, and beyond all this, director Marshall doesn't offer much in the way of creative or even basically memorable camerawork.

It is a film that, stylistically at least, feels like it was slung together by a committee, and in turn falls far short of the original's more spritely, inspired palette.


4. The New Songs... Aren't Good

The Little Mermaid Ariel
Disney

Because Disney wants to win Oscars, of course The Little Mermaid isn't merely content to perform the classic songs we all know. Three new songs have been written for this new film and, uh, they aren't great.

First up we have "Wild Uncharted Waters," a toe-curlingly corny power ballad performed by Prince Eric (Jonah Hauer-King), which will likely leave audiences trying to figure out whether it's an intentional parody or not.

Less offensive yet not particularly memorable is Ariel's new tune, "For the First Time," which is sung within Ariel's head shortly after she is transformed into a human.

And most egregiously, there's "The Scuttlebutt," a grating rap performed primarily by Scuttle (Awkwafina) with some interjections from Sebastian (Daveed Diggs). Even if you're a fan of Awkwafina, this migraine-inducing song will put your patience to the test.

Ultimately nothing would be lost were these songs cut from the movie entirely - beyond some minutes from the film's overegged runtime of course. Speaking of which...


3. It's Too Damn Long

The Little Mermaid Ariel Eric
Disney

The film clocks in at a relatively beefy 135 minutes, making it both the longest of all the live-action Disney remakes so far - a whole minute longer than Cruella - and a stonking 52 minutes longer than the animated original.

No good film is too long, but this movie doesn't remotely persuade that it needed to be this over-extended. Even if you accept the mandatory existence of the new songs and some welcome added character development for Eric, does that really warrant almost an extra hour of a movie?

Right from the film's opening scenes, there's a leaden, meandering pace which prevails throughout. It's a full hour before Ariel is even transformed into a human, and the middle of the movie sags something fierce.

It's easy to see how this could've been improved by trimming 20-30 minutes of fat, because as it stands it's dangerously close to being an outright slog.


2. Flounder Gets Done Dirty

The Little Mermaid Flounder
Disney

Oh, Flounder, how they massacred you so.

There's been much pre-release hand-wringing about how this movie has redesigned the animal characters to look more "realistic," and while Sebastian and Scuttle at least still have plenty of personality to compensate for the changes, there's no excusing what they've done to Flounder (Jacob Tremblay).

The chubby-cheeked tropical fish of the animated film has been given a more grounded "makeover," his more expressive features planed away to the extent that he basically just looks like a real fish who happens to speak.

It's offputting to say the least, but beyond that, Flounder's role is heavily minimised in this remake to the extent that he largely ends up fading into the periphery. As a result, Jacob Tremblay isn't given much of an opportunity to bring life or personality to the part, sadly.


1. It Lacks The Charm Of The Original

The Little Mermaid Ariel
Disney

All in all, The Little Mermaid is by no means a sacrilegious remake - its Flounder slander aside - yet it also fails to fully recapture the magic and charm of its predecessor.

Much as it tries to exploit the audience's nostalgia for what came before, it's only sometimes successful, and ultimately this feels like far more of a mechanised, corporate Product than the film that inspired it.

That's not terribly surprising, but it is disappointing all the same. That younger generations may grow up knowing these remakes as the "definitive" versions of these stories is undeniably bleak - at least until Disney starts remaking them again in another couple of decades.

These notable gripes aside, though, this isn't a terrible movie by any means, and actually gets plenty right. Here's what works...


Ups...

5. Halle Bailey Is A Fantastic Ariel

The Little Mermaid Ariel
Disney

One thing that most will come away from this movie agreeing upon is that Halle Bailey makes for one hell of a great Ariel. For all of the groan-worthy "controversy" about her casting, Bailey is more than qualified to play the role if only for one reason: she's got one hell of an incredible voice.

Bailey absolutely crushes "Part of Your World" early on and gives beautiful vocal renditions throughout the film, periodically breaking up the otherwise relatively snoozy script and direction.

Sure, some might argue that Bailey could've given us a feistier Ariel for contemporary audiences, but she nevertheless acquits herself exceptionally well throughout, and in turn basically carries the entire movie on her back. To call it a star-making performance is probably an understatement.


4. The Original Songs Are Done Firm Justice

The Little Mermaid Ariel
Disney

In the very least, fans are sure to be left satisfied by the lively, emotional performances of the animated film's most beloved songs, from Part of Your World to "Under the Sea," a wonderfully hammy turn from Melissa McCarthy as she belts out "Poor Unfortunate Souls," and of course "Kiss the Girl."

Sure, it would be unrealistic to expect these new renditions to match or even exceed the originals, but it's clear that the cast and crew cared about getting these songs right and capturing their iconic essence.

For as mediocre as long stretches of this movie are, at least they're periodically punctuated by some truly spirited performances of certified Disney bangers.


3. Melissa McCarthy Kills It As Ursula

The Little Mermaid Ursula Melissa McCarthy
Disney

Though many rolled their eyes when Melissa McCarthy was cast as Ursula given her rather lackluster filmography in recent years, McCarthy turned out to be a sublime casting choice, because she knocks the part out of the damn park.

It's honestly tough to consider an actress who might be better suited to playing this riotously over-the-top, boorish villain. McCarthy is clearly having an absolute blast in the role, aiming for the rafters with her hilariously scenery-chewing turn, ensuring her Ursula is an antagonist you'll love to hate.

She steals every scene she's in, enough that some of the longer stretches without her on-screen are not-so-coincidentally also some of the movie's most tedious.

Ursula is a tough part to nail given how extra she was in animated form, but McCarthy makes it look effortless in the most entertaining way.


2. Eric's More Nuanced Characterisation

The Little Mermaid Ariel Eric
Disney

Though many of the creative additions to the remake don't actually add much of interest at all, Oscar nominee David Magee's script does at least bring some worthwhile extra dimension to the character of Eric.

In the animated film Eric felt less like a person than he did a prop - a symbol of what Ariel wanted to achieve - but in this remake he's given substantially more shade, and mostly for the better.

Here Eric is reimagined as a young man ambivalent about his own station as the heir to an unnamed Mediterranean kingdom, who clashes with his mother, the Queen, over his desire to open channels of communication with the outside world.

It's an improvement for sure, and in turn actually makes his whirlwind romance with Ariel feel more believable. It's a shame the rest of the film isn't up to this level of shrewd reinvention, though.


1. Daveed Diggs Is A Solid Sebastian

The Little Mermaid Sebastian
Disney

Though many fans have expressed their understandable disapproval of Sebastian's more down-to-Earth redesign, he's at least still a relatively expressive character, in large part due to a fun vocal performance from the great Daveed Diggs.

Diggs has a tall order living up to the brilliance of Samuel E. Wright from the original, but he delivers a performance that makes Sebastian feel very much his own.

Sebastian's deadpan one-liners, especially when exasperated with King Triton (a largely wasted Javier Bardem), rouse some solid laughs, and of the three focal animal characters, he's by far the one who feels most worthy of his animated predecessor.

Again, you'll need to deal with a character design that's not great, but Diggs does enough with the part to offset Sebastian's divisive look.


Contributor
Contributor

Stay at home dad who spends as much time teaching his kids the merits of Martin Scorsese as possible (against the missus' wishes). General video game, TV and film nut. Occasional sports fan. Full time loon.