The Marvels Review: 5 Ups & 5 Downs

Another middling offering from the MCU.

The Marvels
Marvel Studios

Some four and a half years after her last major appearance in the Marvel Cinematic Universe, Carol Danvers (Brie Larson) is finally back for a sequel the Internet just can't stop talking about - for better or worse.

The Marvels is out now, and so following months of hand-wringing over both dubious test screenings and concerning box office projections, critics and fans alike can actually assess for themselves.

The wildly mixed early reviews certainly haven't painted the most encouraging picture for an MCU that's struggled majorly with quality in recent times, and no, the critics aren't being harsh - The Marvels is every bit the aggressively uneven bag you've heard.

Nia DaCosta's fizzy superhero sequel is packed with interesting ideas but stumbles repeatedly on the execution front, while also leaning back far too complacently on the series' well-trod formula.

This is a tough movie to get excited about in retrospect, and even its more tantalising teases for the future leave one wondering whether Kevin Feige and company can actually pay them off long-term.

So before we get to what The Marvels actually gets right, here's where it unfortunately falls down...


Downs...

5. The Script Is A Mess

The Marvels
Marvel Studios

First and foremost, the script for this thing is just all over the place.

If you're looking for a nuanced, well-crafted story here, you're bound to be sorely disappointed. But even those expecting standard fare for the MCU may be left surprised at just how barebones The Marvels' narrative truly is.

What passes for a plot here is propelled forward by only the most tedious of expository dialogue.

Genuine intrigue and detailed character development are in shockingly short supply across the board, with the chit-chat more or less feeling like perfunctory waypoints from one action sequence to the next.

The dialogue throughout also generally lacks the pep and energy expected of the MCU, despite the game efforts of the three leads to bring it to life.

Just like the scripts for recent MCU mediocrities like Thor: Love and Thunder and Ant-Man and the Wasp: Quantumania, this plays like a first draft which accidentally got the greenlight for shooting.

It feels at least a few drafts away from being ready for production, ensuring that the end result is just a bit feeble and unremarkable.


4. The Body-Swapping Gimmick Is A Huge Letdown

The Marvels
Marvel Studios

In an era where it's so tough for superhero movies to stand apart, The Marvels' body-swapping gimmick - whereby Carol, Monica (Teyonah Parris), and Kamala (Iman Vellani) switch places whenever they use their powers - was certainly an enticingly fun hook.

The MCU's version of Freaky Friday - well, sort of (they don't actually swap bodies).

Yet despite wasting no time at all in setting this up, it affords desperately few opportunities for uproarious character comedy or memorably creative action, and so ultimately ends up seeming like a bit of an afterthought.

Even if you can accept how laughably inconsistent the internal logic to the body-swapping mechanics are, conceptually it feels like a rough sketch of what was surely a killer idea on paper.

With this being the movie's most distinctive, standout feature, it's extremely disappointing how little of interest is done with it. What a waste.


3. Dar-Benn Is One Of The MCU's Worst Villains

The Marvels Dar-Benn
Marvel Studios

It probably won't surprise anyone who's noticed how little attention The Marvels' trailers have paid its central villain that she's one of the MCU's most forgettable antagonists to date.

Kree revolutionary Dar-Benn (Zawe Ashton) actually has some innately compelling motivations for her beef with Carol, yet execution counts for a lot, and as a character there's barely any meat on her bones at all.

Despite a decent attempt by the talented Zawe Ashton to breathe meaningful life into the character, she's given scarcely little to do beyond look menacing while chewing through the generic Villain Monologues.

If perhaps not quite as bland as, say, Thor: The Dark World's Malekith (Christopher Eccleston), Dar-Benn absolutely ranks among the lousiest and least memorable of all the MCU baddies so far.

If it felt like the franchise had basically conquered its infamous Villain Problem years ago, The Marvels confirms that it's far from stamped out.


2. The Editing Is ROUGH

The Marvels Brie Larson
Marvel Studios

Though there's a lot to be said for The Marvels being snappy and to-the-point at just 105 minutes, this is also a film that feels at times edited to within an inch of its life.

Especially in the early going, there's a frantic choppiness with which the film fleets from one character or scene to another, rather than letting moments and beats breathe.

This feels less like a pure pacing issue - because the short runtime remains one of the movie's best assets - but rather that The Marvels' final cut was likely frankensteined together during a tough post-production process.

Numerous online reports have noted the film's underwhelming test screenings and extensive reshoots, and to that end the version of the movie now in cinemas has a strangely bolted-together feel to it.

The more expository dialogues in particular sticks out like a sore thumb next to genuine character moments, as though they were hurriedly added during reshoots to clarify plot points.

Characters also regularly feel like they change mood on the turn of a dime in the middle of a scene - especially Carol and Nick Fury (Samuel L. Jackson), the latter more-or-less turned into a comedy sidekick here.


1. The Tone Is All Over The Place

The Marvels
Marvel Studios

Nobody's expecting something super-serious from a Captain Marvel movie, but the first film had a much firmer handle on its tone in terms of juggling earnest and comedic moments.

The Marvels is by comparison an off-kilter farce that's likely to produce some severe tonal whiplash in audiences.

Two scenes in particular - one involving a planet with a... unique mode of communication, the other involving cats - are so jarringly goofy that they almost threaten to derail the movie's entire established tone.

When you consider that some of the film's sillier scenes are placed directly next to some of its grimmest, it's easy to look at The Marvels as a bit of a mood car crash and a film that just didn't get the fundamentals nailed down enough during pre-production.

Yet even accepting these notable gripes, The Marvels is far from a disaster. And so, here's where it actually succeeds...


Ups...

5. Kamala Khan Steals The Show

The Marvels
Marvel Studios

Unquestionably The Marvels' MVP is also the character general audiences are least likely to be familiar with - Kamala Khan aka Ms. Marvel.

If both the writing and direction for Carol feel a little shaky and Monica is basically just... there, it's Kamala who ends up the best-realised hero of the three.

This is in large part due to Iman Vellani's infectious, enthusiastic energy, for though Kamala's very extra vibe could threaten to render her irritating, Vellani keeps her on the right side of personable.

Beyond Kamala's regularly amusing fangirling out, seeing her evolve into a more steadfast and confident hero under Carol and Monica's tutelage is easily one of the movie's bright spots.

It's just a shame that between Ms. Marvel being one of the MCU's least-watched Disney+ shows and this movie inevitably tanking at the box office, Disney might feel less inclined to give Kamala a focal role in the future.


4. The Entertaining Action Sequences

The Marvels Monica
Marvel Studios

Even accepting that the movie doesn't do nearly enough with its neato body-swapping gimmick and its VFX are dead-average, Nia DaCosta does at least deliver a number of entertainingly chaotic and spritely action sequences.

The set-pieces, though hardly standout for the franchise as a whole, make the most of the three leads' physicality and emphasise their growing bond as their synergy increases.

These superpowered throwdowns provide much-needed relief from the barrage of wooden expository dialogue throughout, and help the film tear through its short runtime in relatively inoffensive fashion.

It's just a shame that the action staging didn't make a little more effort to really have fun with the body-swapping shtick.


3. The Short, Snappy Runtime

The Marvels
Marvel Studios

Much as it might sound like a back-handed compliment to praise a movie for being short, in an era where it feels like blockbusters just keep getting longer, a disciplined 105-minute runtime is a damn oasis.

The Marvels may have plenty of problems which may or may not pertain to its post-production woes, but in the very least it moves fast, maintains a pacy clip throughout, and never sticks around in one place for too long.

Whether this being the shortest MCU movie is more a symptom or cause of its problems will certainly be debated in the days to come, but with so many tentpoles being so tiresomely bloated these days, one that just gets to the point feels like something to applaud.

It's a shame the movie as a whole isn't more persuasive, but in the very least it's efficient and sprints from beat to beat in a manner sure to leave few checking their watches.


2. The Solid Chemistry Between The Three Leads

The Marvels
Marvel Studios

If there's one thing above all else that The Marvels absolutely, positively needed to get right, it was nailing the chemistry between Carol, Monica, and Kamala, and in that sense it largely succeeds.

Most of the movie's strongest moments involve the trio getting acquainted with and riffing off one another - sharing their experiences as superheroes and rather speedily dropping their defenses.

Or in Kamala's case, just freaking out that she's teaming up with two bonafide superheroes.

Sure, the three actors are doing much of the heavy lifting here through their sheer charms given the rather inconsistent writing on offer, but simply hanging out with The Marvels ensures the film is anything but a chore to get through.


1. It Teases Some Interesting Future Possibilities

The Marvels
Marvel Studios

No spoilers here, but in the very least The Marvels manages to avoid feeling like a totally inessential MCU film because it teases some genuinely tantalising possibilities for the future.

The film's final scenes - and particularly a genuinely startling mid-credits scene - make a motivated effort to start laying the track for future attractions.

And though things may naturally be subject to change given the MCU's rather rickety standing at present, these teases should excite those who've felt that the last two phases were majorly lacking in direction.

But of course, two enticing teases can't really compensate for a movie's many deficiencies, and it remains to be seen whether their payoff will actually live up to the potential. Here's hoping.


Contributor
Contributor

Stay at home dad who spends as much time teaching his kids the merits of Martin Scorsese as possible (against the missus' wishes). General video game, TV and film nut. Occasional sports fan. Full time loon.