The Nun Review: 2 Ups & 7 Downs

A disappointing snoozer.

The Nun
Warner Bros.

After The Conjuring 2 embedded itself in horror fans' psyches everywhere with the terrifying visage of the demon nun Valak, it was practically inevitable that Warner Bros. would move ahead with a spin-off centred on the instant genre icon.

Well, The Nun is out now in cinemas, and despite the surprisingly solid output from the Conjuring franchise so far - the first Annabelle excluded - it's a shame to report that this latest effort isn't really up to much.

Scoring squarely mixed reviews from critics, The Nun might do the bare minimum for the most undemanding horror crowds, but if you're hoping for a compelling expansion of the series' mythology or a basically scary horror flick, you're best off looking elsewhere.

It's a disappointment considering the clear talent assembled for the movie, but with a bare-bones script and utter lack of ambition to do anything but the most simplistic genre outing, The Nun is best saved for a home viewing where you can pick your phone up whenever your interest wavers.

Or maybe just don't bother with it at all...


Downs

7. The Lame, Obnoxious Jump Scares

The Nun
New Line Cinema

This shouldn't be surprising to anyone who's seen the trailer, but The Nun sadly gives in to perhaps The Conjuring franchise's basest instinct: littering the movie with lazy, predictable jump scares.

If you've seen more than a few horror films in your life, you'll likely see every single jump scare coming, because director Corin Hardy telegraphs them comically far in advance. Making plentiful use of irritatingly loud tension chords, the jumps aren't even effective or in any way unique.

While a few well-placed, creative jumps certainly would've been acceptable, sadly too many of the scares here feel thrown together without much imagination or effort at all.


6. Valak's Barely In It

The Nun
Warner Bros.

The main attraction of this movie is, of course, the demon nun Valak, who proved so intensely terrifying in The Conjuring 2.

Perhaps appreciating that the antagonist's terror would be diluted if featured extensively over a single movie, Hardy actually keeps Valak in the shadows for the most part until the third act.

Despite the movie being called The Nun, Valak mostly pulls the strings from behind the scenes, and if you're hoping for a 95-minute thrill-ride of a demon nun terrorising people, you're probably going to leave the cinema disappointed.

We only see the demon nun visage from The Conjuring 2 for a few scattered minutes throughout the film, which sucks.

Also, the attempt to explain Valak's backstory commits a cardinal sin of horror lore: over-explaining a supernatural entity's origins to the point that ie demystifies them and makes them less scary. More than anything, Valak's origins on Earth are just howlingly generic and unoriginal.


5. The Exposition-Heavy Script

The Nun Taissa Farmiga
Warner Bros.

Though the film was promisingly written by It screenwriter Gary Dauberman, it is important to remember that Dauberman also wrote Annabelle prior to hitting big with last year's horror smash.

The Nun is far closer to the quality of Annabelle than it is It, sadly, propping itself up between set-pieces with an embarrassing amount of exposition regarding the movie's characters and the central investigative scenario.

Horror movies of all film types need to show rather than tell, and so the film having audiences sit through relentless, robotic chatter time and time again does it no favours at all.

The amount of lore vomit is so excessive at times it might induce laughter rather than intrigue, if you're not left ready to doze, that is. Speaking of which...


4. It's Incredibly Dull

The Nun Demian Bichir
Warner Bros.

Though "boring" can often be a descriptor used by critics for a movie they just didn't like, The Nun truly is a dull, tiresome film that's an utter chore to watch.

Accepting all other criticisms, the killer one is that neither the characters nor the story are at all interesting, with the entire movie feeling like a generic, perfunctory exercise.

Where's the propulsive, nervous energy? Where are the crisp, ominous visuals? Instead we get molasses-slow pacing and wretched, washed-out cinematography far away from the evocative work on the main Conjuring movies.

By the time the end credits rolled, I felt legitimately exhausted by this movie. All 96 minutes of it.


3. The Wildly Unnecessary Comic Relief

The Nun Maurice
Warner Bros.

The character of Maurice (Jonas Bloquet) aka "Frenchie" has been mysteriously kept out of most of The Nun's marketing, despite him having a significant amount of screen time and effectively being the third protagonist.

Though Bloquet does fine enough with what he has, Frenchie is mostly written to be mild comic relief, dropping not-so-witty quips just when things might actually be getting, you know, scary.

The one-liners often diffuse the tension and steer the movie closer to being straight-up schlock rather than the "classy" horror flick it clearly thinks it is otherwise.

Bloquet plays well during his more serious moments fending off the supernatural entities haunting the Cârța Monastery, but the tone-derailing nature of his comedic quips are a major scripting fail.


2. It's Just Not Scary

The Nun Demian Bichir
Warner Bros.

Perhaps even a greater failure than the movie's dullness is that it's not remotely scary. Most of the mildly tense moments are quickly upended by either an annoying jump scare or a needless joke, ensuring the film never establishes the mood and atmosphere it needs to.

Unless you're a teenager new to horror movies, there's likely precious little here that'll have your heart rate rising above resting: it's all old-hat, generic, garden variety genre stock nonsense.

When a horror movie has you frequently yawning even during its more action-packed third act, you know it's really screwed things up.


1. The Extremely Lazy Ending

Conjuring 2 Nun
Warner Bros.

No spoilers here, but the ending to this movie is pretty much the laziest, most cynical and perfunctory thing they could've possibly done. If you think you know how The Nun ends already, you're probably right.

There's a very obvious direction and a very obvious corporate interest the end of the film needs to satisfy, so of course, The Nun never forgets that it's part of a franchise, and pays half-hearted tribute to The Conjuring movies with an arbitrary closing tag.

It remains to be seen whether or not the film will perform well enough to merit a sequel - one suspects yes - and though it doesn't directly set the table for The Nun 2, it wouldn't take much of a leap from this movie's ending to get it going.

So, The Nun is not a good movie, then. If you can stay awake throughout, though, there are a couple of meritorious elements worth noting...


Ups

2. The Rock Solid Cast

The Nun
New Line Cinema

The main reason this movie was so promising in the first place was the presence of great actors like Taissa Farmiga and Demián Bichir.

Farmiga, whose older sister Vera of course plays Lorraine Warren in the Conjuring films, is giving it her all as the petrified yet determined Sister Irene, and clearly deserved a far better movie to lend her talents.

Oscar nominee Bichir, meanwhile, is typically solid as her companion, Father Burke. His distinctive vocal tenor makes the most of the largely sloppy dialogue, and at times he just barely prevents ennui from setting in.

As already mentioned, Jonas Bloquet does good work but is saddled with some bone-headed comic relief, while Bonnie Aarons is again appropriately horrifying as The Nun.

Brilliant Northern Irish actor Michael Smiley also shows up for literally a few seconds near the start of the movie, in what's nothing if not a colossal waste of his splendid talents.


1. The Eerie Central Locale

The Nun
New Line Cinema

As dull and uninteresting as the film ultimately is, the production designers at least deserve some credit for lovingly recreating the Cârța Monastery with total and utter conviction.

From the exterior glimpses of the towering monastery to the ornate interiors, claustrophobic walls, passage-ways and so on, it is most certainly a fitting location to set a movie such as this.

A shame it is, then, that the script does little interesting with it, and Maxime Alexandre's lifeless cinematography fails to make the most of what the production has put together.

Given that the monastery was recreated primarily through location doubling and shooting on a sound stage, it's impressive how totally seamless the results are, especially on a fairly modest $22 million budget.

What did you think of The Nun? Shout it out in the comments!


Contributor
Contributor

Stay at home dad who spends as much time teaching his kids the merits of Martin Scorsese as possible (against the missus' wishes). General video game, TV and film nut. Occasional sports fan. Full time loon.