The Old Guard Review: 5 Ups & 5 Downs
An intriguing if messy Netflix superhero flick.

Netflix's quest to bring blockbuster-caliber thrills to their streaming platform continues with the release of The Old Guard, their Charlize Theron-starring adaptation of Greg Rucka's comic book of the same name.
Theron stars as Andy, the leader of an elite group of mercenaries who are actually centuries-old immortals capable of recovering from practically any injury dealt to them. They're superheroes, basically.
As Andy and her squad connect with a young new immortal in their midst, Nile (KiKi Layne), they find themselves fighting for their freedom against a corporation with designs on their abilities.
Like most of the streamer's blockbuster-sized movies to date, The Old Guard is a mixed bag of entertaining performances, enticing action, and underwhelming writing, resulting in a watchable tentpole that's just not quite good enough to be truly memorable.
In these tough times it'll certainly provide adequate popcorn-gobbling comfort, even if a more unique spin on this material surely would've been possible with just a few screenplay tweaks...
Downs...
5. It's Trying WAY Too Hard To Build A Franchise

Like so many blockbuster movies these days, The Old Guard unfortunately puts the cart before the horse in terms of trying to sell audiences on a multi-movie franchise before even delivering a single truly good movie.
So much of the film's mythology is tied up in teases for future installments and building a "brand" that it's hard not to view the overall result as a little too cynical for its own good.
The success of the Marvel Cinematic Universe has obviously encouraged studios to try and milk lucrative IP for every drop they're worth, and while the prospect of a sequel to this movie is hardly horrendous, the table-setting for the second film often comes at the expense of this one.
It wouldn't surprise anyone if The Old Guard is a huge ratings hit for Netflix and gets at least a couple of sequels, yet the film's frequent franchise-baiting - especially with its predictable, sequel-teasing final scene - feels both unearned and unnecessary.
4. Not Enough Action

Though the marketing for The Old Guard was focused extensively on the film's array of slick action sequences, it's a mild disappointment that lengthy carnage is actually in relatively short supply across its two-hour runtime.
While most of the set-pieces we do get are tightly shot and relatively entertaining - but more on that in a moment - there are several frustratingly long stretches of time where audiences may get restless waiting for the next burst of combat.
Considering the project's evidently substantial budget and glossy trailers promising myriad gory shootouts and punch-ups, it's surprising how often the movie instead forces viewers to sit through tiresome, elongated dialogues. Speaking of which...
3. The Exposition-Heavy Script

The Old Guard is perfect proof that it doesn't always pay to have the creator of an IP adapt their own work, as Greg Rucka's script for this movie is an excessively talkative, exposition-heavy mess.
It certainly has a firm handle on its characters and its world, but continuously betrays the "show, don't tell" principle by having so much crucial information unveiled in boring, shot-reverse-shot dialogues.
Rucka understandably has a lot to establish in the early going, but rather than find a creative way to organically convey this information to the viewer, he settles for having characters unnaturally rip through verbose, stilted monologues about their histories.
Though the talented ensemble certainly does their best to mitigate this, there's no denying that most of the movie's problems are a result of its mediocre script.
2. Chiwetel Ejiofor Is Totally Wasted

Chiwetel Ejiofor will class-up practically any movie you put him in, so it was certainly neat to see him show up here as former CIA agent Copley, at least until it quickly becomes clear that there's desperately little for him to actually do.
Though there are some initially neat teases for his arc throughout the movie, ultimately he never graduates beyond being a stock middleman archetype, and for an actor of his incredible versatility, that's a criminal waste.
Ejiofor certainly seems game for something meatier to sink his teeth into it, but it just isn't there in the script, and most of his scenes in the movie are, honestly, lifeless and forgettable. At least he got paid, right?
1. The Villain SUCKS

A major issue with The Old Guard is that, once the central squad is established, it fails to give them a compelling antagonist to rally against.
The movie's primary villain is Merrick (Harry Melling), a Big Pharma CEO who wishes to capture the immortals and experiment upon them for his own gain - under the guise of helping humanity, of course.
Even if you can accept how absurdly generic and unimaginative Merrick's motives are, Melling plays the part like an absolute cartoon character, all bug-eyed and over-the-top, which doesn't really fit with the movie's broader tone.
Worse than that, he's just not interesting in any way. As is such a common problem with superhero films, the movie banks so much on its heroes that it leaves little behind for their foe.
If a sequel does indeed happen, it's in desperate need of a more persuasive foil for the team.
But with these flaws out of the way, The Old Guard does still get enough right to deliver a moderately entertaining ride...
Ups...
5. It's A Unique Spin On The Superhero Formula (Sort Of)

Though much of its creativity is admittedly stifled by the run-of-the-mill script, The Old Guard nevertheless deserves credit for offering up a unique(ish) spin on the superhero movie formula.
It's most obviously indebted to the X-Men franchise, with its focus on a Wolverine-esque set of heroes who can "die" and return to life shortly thereafter, yet deviates just enough from the well-worn genre tropes we're all over-familiar with.
It could certainly have done far more to carve out a niche for itself, but despite its cynical efforts to lay the groundwork for a franchise of films, there is a clear desire here to be more than just another ensemble fantasy-action film.
Between its diverse cast of characters, their intriguing backstories, and the refreshing lack of mega-budget, CGI-heavy action sequences, it almost feels like a new breed of superhero movie - almost.
If the potential sequel can further distinguish itself from genre typicality, it could easily be a major improvement.
4. Charlize Theron's Thrilling Performance

It won't shock anyone to learn that Charlize Theron is far and away the best thing about this movie, turning in exactly the sort of committed, physical performance you'd expect from the Mad Max: Fury Road show-stealer.
Even when the script is at its most transparently lazy and the story grinds to a halt, Charlize plays her part with absolute conviction, in both the physically demanding action sequences and the more emotional, character-driven scenes.
Much like Chiwetel Ejiofor, she's a credit to practically any movie she appears in, and much of the reason that The Old Guard remains so consistently watchable is her electrifying presence.
3. The Compelling Character Development & World-Building

Theron's fine work aside, what really provides hope that The Old Guard could sustain a couple of sequels is its enticing approach to both its characters and the world they reside within.
Even if it often gets too expository for its own good, Rucka's script is clearly invested in its central team, ensuring the most of the key players have intriguingly dark, tortured backstories.
Flashbacks are employed liberally to explain how the heroes made it to this point, succinctly suggesting that being immortal isn't all it's cracked up to be, but instead simply another terrifying tier of existence with its own set of drawbacks.
It is this commitment to the human element - a facet so often lost in the chaos of superhero films - which provides the most promise for any future installments. In the very least, the film ends with some compelling plates left spinning.
2. The Solid Ensemble Cast

Though The Old Guard is certainly The Charlize Theron Show, she's nevertheless aided by the efforts of a strong supporting cast.
KiKi Layne, as the team's newcomer Nile, is an especially alluring addition, getting to not only trade blows with Theron in the early going but also share with her some of the movie's more affecting dramatic scenes.
Elsewhere the ever-great Matthias Schoenaerts is a hoot as former Napoleonic soldier Booker, while the group is rounded out by Aladdin's Marwan Kenzari and Luca Marinelli as Joe and Nicky, a charming gay couple whose love has spanned centuries.
Together, these performers bring plenty of added value to the table, and like Theron, try to make the most of the inconsistent material they're working with.
1. The Well-Crafted Fight Scenes

And finally, though there's certainly not enough action throughout the film, what we do get is ably delivered by rising filmmaker Gina Prince-Bythewood (Beyond the Lights).
Despite her lack of experience in the action arena, the director smartly covers most of the action in expansive wide shots, allowing sharply-choreographed fights to play out without excessive cuts or frustrating close-ups.
Theron in particular is given the floor to carry out some satisfyingly balletic mayhem with weapons and fists alike, such that while this is hardly on the level of, say, John Wick, the action nevertheless feels decidedly more visceral and real than your average superhero movie.