The Predator Review: 5 Ups & 6 Downs
The Fast & Furious of Predator movies...
After a marketing campaign that started with an uninspiring fizzle, despite the excellent cast and the presence of Shane Black in the driving seat, The Predator is about to roar its way into cinemas. It's as confident and as swaggering as you'd expect from something that features both an 11-foot monster with dreadlocks and a joke calling said monster "alien Whoopi Goldberg" and your reaction to it will depend heavily on your reaction to that sentence.
It's probably fair to say that Black's sequel is going to be an acquired taste, but there's absolutely no denying the entertainment factor. That just comes with the almighty caveat that you really, really need to tune your expectations into the right frequency to get a lot out of it.
That's not to say there aren't some great elements though - it's just that they're balanced a little unfortunately by some bad ones.
First the positives...
Ups
5. The Nostalgia Is Strong
As everyone should have expected when Shane Black was announced as the director and writer of The Predator, his sequel is a portrait of nostalgia, not only for the Predator franchise but also for a bygone era of action movies. At times it feels a little like Black is insisting that that golden era is still very much relevant despite the evidence, but his eye for nostalgia is pretty infectious.
There are tongue-in-cheek Easter Eggs, whole characters based on the tropes established in Predator and a general agenda to take us all back to the time before action movies were so grim and po-faced. There's something admirable in that and Black should be commended for making what amounts to a living exhibition of those olden, golden days. When it works, at least.
At times, you will fully expect Arnold Schwarzenegger himself to pop up in full camouflage make-up to wink at the camera, it's that knowing. And the reuse of the "get to the chopper" line will genuinely leave people falling about the place. It's gloriously silly.
4. The Violence
If you're looking for a bloodbath, you've got it. Shane Black has clearly decided that the way to make up for the lack of nuance and subtlety is just to rip people in half every few minutes. There are whole armies of side characters who exist solely to be victims of the Predators, almost like they're on a conveyor belt and Black is determined to out-gross the Saw franchise for the way they're dispatched.
This is absolutely not a comment on the futility of war and the human condition or an allegory for the pillage of foreign lands by American military presence: it's just a film that really likes pulling various bones out of people while they're still alive. And there's definitely an audience for that kind of thing.
Sure, the attempt to get in as many gags as possible jars slightly when people's actual entrails are on show, but that does fit the self-conscious B-movie vibe that hums along under the expensive effects.
3. It's Mostly Better Than The Other Sequels
Predators was actually a pretty good film that really doesn't get the love that it deserves and The Predator is certainly as entertaining as that film. It's not as clever or as complex, but it makes up for that by throwing all caution to the wind and being as silly as possible.
It's streets ahead of the weirdly glum Predator 2 and neither of the awful AVP movies can compete with it, mostly because it's having so much fun with itself. If you're a fan of the franchise, there's a lot in here for you, but that might limit the appeal a little for more mainstream fans.
It's not the best Shane Black film by any means, but it should help tickle the fancies of established fans of the brand, which is pretty much what Black is aiming for.
2. Trevante Rhodes
Trevante Rhodes - who was exceptional in Moonlight and will have a hell of a career going on from here - is the best thing about The Predator by a country mile. Sure, he feels like he's been dropped in from another film entirely and perhaps even an entirely different ERA of film (he wouldn't be out of place in the original Predator actually), but he's a joy to watch.
There might be some complaints about how heavily he smokes (if it wasn't 2018, you'd suspect some big tobacco firm was paying a premium for him to advertise, given how many times he lights up), but he seems to be the only one in the entire film who's in on the joke.
And it wouldn't be unfair to say that a Predator film that had HIM as the real star would have been a superior thing all round. It's genuinely exciting to wonder what he'll do next.
1. It Knows EXACTLY What It Is
The best assessment of The Predator comes in the form of an analogy. It's like that one friend everyone has. He's the first to suggest shots, will often want to climb scaffolding or buildings while drunk, he probably ate a Tide pod. He does things "for the likes," has a general hatred for "boring people" and you worry about him. To outsiders, his appeal is limited, but you dearly love him despite it all. That's The Predator in a nutshell.
The film is pretty much the Fast & Furious of the Predator franchise. It is muscle-bound, not too bright and absolutely, self-consciously ridiculous. And it's clearly having an absolute whale of a time with it while sticking a middle finger up at everyone who curls a lip up at it in disdain. It's provocative, confident and ridiculous and it revels in the fact.
If you like the brand of high-octane, glossy nonsense that Fast & Furious provides, this is absolutely the film for you. But you should probably have guessed that already.
And now to the negatives...
Downs
6. The Hero We Don't Entirely Deserve
Somewhat unfortunately, Boyd Holbrook is not Arnold Schwarzenegger. He's not Danny Glover even. Hell, he can't even compete with Adrien Brody. He's not quite the kind of hero you hang this sort of franchise movie on, because he's not charismatic enough and not knowing enough to be the in-point for all the silliness.
Perhaps it's because one of the film's big narrative tricks essentially undermines him on purpose, he's just not really all that memorable. He does try his best, spitting out some dialogue that could do well as t-shirt slogans, but he feels somewhat lost in a movie that really wants a hero from the 1980s but ends up stuck with someone more modern and less exciting.
It's an unfortunate reality that he's also upstaged entirely by the excellent Trevante Rhodes too, because you'll spend most of the time wishing he was the hero.
5. Some Of The Effects Are Under-Cooked
Some of the effect work in The Predator is brilliant, with the traditional Predator powers shown off wonderfully and Shane Black's penchant for action set-pieces really pushing his effects team. That said, the film is missing one truly memorable set-piece and one of those heroic last stands we've all come to expect from this franchise.
And there's a real problem with some of the other effects. The chief problems come courtesy of the Hell Hounds, which at times look on par with Zuul and Vinz Clotho from the original Ghostbusters movie. They don't really look finished.
The worst part of that is that the hounds are completely superfluous too. One of them sets up something in-story that doesn't happen and you end up with a sort of weird Scooby Doo vibe by the time the third act comes around that isn't entirely embraced either.
4. The Complete Lack Of Sense At Times
Having said that the film knows what it is and gleefully messes with all expectations in that respect, the writing occasionally leaves a lot to be desired. When the name on the script is Shane Black, that's a problem.
There are ideas - like the idea of hybridization - that seem tacked on, while the entire motivation of the "rogue" Predator who kicks the entire thing off is completely absent. You're initially introduced to it as a prototypical Predator, only for the plot twist to change everything, but the twist contradicts everything that happens in the opening sequence. And then when the twist is escalated, it's an absolute ass-pull that has no grounding in the rest of the story whatsoever.
It just about gets by because it's so incredibly silly, but there was a requirement here for better writing that simply wasn't there. There are too many whys and when they start to creep in, it's way too easy to notice when the dialogue misses its target too.
3. Some Of The Characters Are A Little Under-Nourished
It may be because Shane Black was so closely involved in the original Predator and knew that the crew behind Arnold Schwarzenegger were essentially just cannon-fodder, but The Predator has a bit of an issue with character balance. Sure, the dynamic between some of them is infectious at times, but you'll struggle to remember a single thing Alfie Allen does and unfortunately, Olivia Munn's Casey Bracket could be removed without any sort of problems to the plot.
When she's held up as a sort of paragon for girl power (though her idea of that seems to be telling people to "grow a dick" and get in the fight), that's somewhat fatal. And the idea that a biologist could do some of the things she does is ludicrous to the point of groaning.
Elsewhere there are problems with Sterling K. Brown's one-dimensional Corporation Guy and the other walking caricatures, but once you realise that they're probably SUPPOSED to be cliches, it's more forgivable.
2. It's Essentially A Parody (And Reductively So)
When the film works, it's great fun, but when it doesn't, it genuinely feels a little like Shane Black has stepped aside to allow Robert K. Weiss and David Zucker to make Predator Movie.
Because the film loses its identity in trying (and failing at times) to balance the humour with ultra-violence and nostalgia, it definitely feels like you're watching a spoof that isn't quite as well-observed as it thinks it is. When the writing really dips in quality, that feeling is even more pertinent.
In that context, Keegan-Michael Key's Coyle becomes a little too close to a Marlon Wayans creation and Boyd Holbrook's lack of charm begins to feel like a joke in itself. Considering the agenda here was to make us fall back in love with Predator (which is made clear by the very conscious sequel set-up), tearing it down so much is a little baffling.
1. The Garbled Mental Health Message Doesn't Quite Land
To get this out of the way first, what Shane Black has TRIED to do with his Aspergers/Autism message embedded in Jacob Tremblay's subplot is really quite admirable. For anyone with children on the spectrum, he's essentially made a superhero just for them (and a positive message about the bullsh*t idea of there being inherent limits to what they can do). But that aside, the rest of the film's portrait of mental health issues is plainly repugnant.
The members of the team that Holbrook's hero ends up a part of are veterans all suffering from some form of mental trauma and unfortunately, that's used as fuel to mock them. Thomas Jane's Tourettes sufferer is roundly and distastefully mocked, Trevante Rhodes' failed suicide attempt is a punchline and PTSD is used as a stand-in for "slightly cookie". There's also a line about the use of the word "retarded" and a gag about Jane unwittingly saying something sexual to Olivia Munn that is WAY too close to the bone.
This is not clever writing and it's not something that anyone should have to see in a film in 2018. Not least when the film tries at other times to be "progressive."
What did you think of The Predator? Share your thoughts below in the comments thread.