The Suicide Squad Cast Reveal - Predicting EVERY Character

14. David Dastmalchian - Polka-Dot Man

Batman Polka Dot Man
DC Comics

Batman fans may recall David Dastmalchian for his brief performance as one of Joker's underlings in 2008's The Dark Knight, where he's interrogated by Harvey Dent after a daylight attack on the GCPD. He's returning to the DCU with The Suicide Squad, and according to reports will be playing Polka-Dot Man, a Silver Age Batman villain who somehow keeps on coming back.

When he first appeared in 1962, Polka-Dot Man's spots actually had their own unique properties. He could magic up weapons and vehicles on a whim, but when he returned to face a darker, less colourful Gotham, he did so with just a baseball bat, and found himself getting beaten by Harvey Bullock for his troubles.

It's hard to see which approach Gunn will take in the upcoming film, but expect it to play up on the 'will he, won't he' potential of Polka-Dot Man's powers. Either that or he rushes into a situation with a bat and winds up dead for his troubles. Take your pick.

[EP]


13. Joel Kinnaman - Rick Flag

Suicide Squad Rick Flag Joel Kinnaman
Warner Bros. Pictures

Joel Kinnaman's turn as Rick Flag in the first Suicide Squad was neither here nor there in that it was also probably the most inoffensive thing about the film itself; a bland male establishment figure to anchor the movie against the colourful (and much more entertaining weirdos) moviegoers came to see.

However, Flag is still an essential component of Task Force X, and one who needs to stay for the sequel. He'll still be the same, gruff by-the-numbers military type and that's because he has to be. There really isn't that much else to him.

That isn't to say that the film can't expand upon the character further, though. Flag, while a military stalwart, has a unique relationship with the Squad and one that fundamentally alters how he perceives his own service. There's clear potential to extract a more nuanced portrayal in the sequel in that sense, and one Gunn will be eager to pursue once filming commences.

[EP]


12. Taika Waititi - Copperhead

Copperhead batman
DC Comics

There are so many roles Taika Waititi could perform in The Suicide Squad, but how best do you deploy the actor/director in a film already chockfull of frankly bizarre figures? The answer is simple - make him Copperhead.

Waititi could probably turn even the most forgettable Squad member into a hilarious foil for the others to play off against, but could anyone honestly pass up the opportunity to see him dressed up in the original Copperhead's snake suit, venomous fangs and all?

Copperhead has gone through a whole host of changes in the comics, even being reimagined as an actual man-snake hybrid in the New 52, but there's just something about seeing a man dress up in a frankly ridiculous reptilian get-up that's so much more appealing. Factor in Waititi's dry sense of wit, and you're left with a character so absurd that the thought of them not being in The Suicide Squad is somehow even more ridiculous.

[EP]


11. Jennifer Holland - Karin Grace

Karin Grace DC Comics
DC Comics

If we were fantasy booking how to make The Suicide Squad, this is the point where we'd suggest that the first iteration of the Suicide Squad, as led by Joel Kinnaman's Rick Flag would end up killed off, with Flag either also killed or imprisoned by a powerful villain. That would draw out Amanda Waller again as she sought to cover her tracks (while pretending she cared about Flag's fate).

If that was the case, you'd want someone who cared about Flag leading the retrieval Squad, which makes the idea of Jennifer Holland playing original Squad member Karin Grace all the more compelling. She's not a villain - which suits Holland far more - and her links to Flag could be used to invert the usual damsel in distress storyline rather beautifully.

The other possibilities are that Holland could be playing someone like Killer Frost, who is a compelling enough character that you'd suspect she'd have entered Gunn's thinking at some point. Or, slightly more left-field is the possibility of her playing Hawkgirl. In the original Suicide Squad, Task Force X obviously end up in Midway City - the original home of Hawkman and Hawkgirl - and the idea of having some heroes involved trying to get in the way of the Squad is really great.

[SG]


10. Peter Capaldi - Hugo Strange

Hugo Strange
DC Comics

While we don't know who he's playing for certain, yet, we do know one key thing about Peter Capaldi's character in The Suicide Squad: he's bald.

The former Doctor Who actor turned up at a fan convention with his newly shorn look and apparently told guests in attendance that he had to shave his head because of the use of prosthetics. Now, that could be true, which means we could be looking at someone like Doctor Light, but Capaldi releasing such key information also feels a little TOO convenient.

More likely is that he's simply playing a conventionally bald character, which has drawn rumours of him playing Multiple Man and The Thinker. Perhaps it's wishful thinking, but he's got a great look - and great screen presence - for someone like Hugo Strange rather than an active Squad member.

Having him overseeing the Arkham prisoners would be great and if it led into him being revealed as a villain in his own right, Capaldi would be more than capable of pulling it off.

[SG]


9. Viola Davis - Amanda Waller

Suicide Squad Amanda Waller
Warner Bros. Pictures

Viola Davis was perfectly cast as Amanda Waller in the first Suicide Squad film, and given the character's synonymy with the group, it makes sense as to why she's coming back.

Although it'll be slightly disappointing to not see her bounce off of Ben Affleck's Batman in the sequel, as was teased at the end of the first film, Waller is still compelling on her own. Expect her to still be just as ruthless as before, but hopefully a little smarter in how she uses the Squad this time around.

One of the strangest things about the first film was how it assembled this off the books, deeply unethical group to get up to missions the public can't know about. They're then sent off to fight a giant supervillain sky portal, whereas in the comics, the team were used far more frequently as a typical black ops unit, infiltrating different countries and getting up to some genuinely immoral wetwork.

Should Waller deploy them properly this time around, expect further tension.

[EP]


8. Tinashe Kajese - Vixen

Vixen DC Rebirth
DC Comics

We might have already seen TWO versions of Vixen in the Arrowverse, but there's no way that will impact the possibility of us seeing her in James Gunn's Squad line-up.

Vixen's association with the Suicide Squad in the comics makes her one of the more complex characters here because she actually volunteers to work with them after her superpowers - being able to mimick animals - leads to her losing control to her animal side. And her skillset of being able to draw on the abilities of ANY animal that has ever lived on the planet is beautifully cinematic.

She was also born in Zambesi, a country in the comics modelled on Zimbabwe, which is where Tinashe Kajese - who is mostly known for bit parts in TV shows like Valor and The Inspectors - was born. Perhaps don't expect her to be a major character, but the casting certainly fits.

[SG]


7. Sean Gunn - Rag Doll

Rag Doll Secret Six
DC Comics

While it's doubtful Sean Gunn possesses the contortionist skills necessary to make Rag Doll work on screen, he's no stranger to motion capture and could certainly make the role work given a little movie magic.

In the comics, there have actually been three versions of Rag Doll. One was a Golden Age villain who fought against the Flash, the second emerged during the Silver Age to fight Starman, while the third was the son of the first and is more commonly associated with the Secret Six than the government approved counterparts.

Still, while Ragdoll hasn't joined the Squad in the comics, there's scope to make him a member now. He has a great set of abilities to pool from and while Gunn himself might be a left-field choice for the mask-clad figure, he'd also have the benefit of being the first to portray him in live action.

[EP]


6. John Cena - Sportsmaster

Sportsmaster Comics
DC Comics

John Cena's name being on the castlist here is obviously a huge deal for WWE fans, but he's also proved himself to be a pretty gifted actor too - particularly in comic roles recently. If this comes off, he could genuinely be set for a similar trajectory to The Rock in Hollywood, it's that astute a career move.

Lots of talk has suggested that Cena would be great for Peacemaker, but it would make a whole world more sense for him to be playing Sportsmaster. The character is actually one of the names linked with Idris Elba too, but the idea of a frustrated sports star turning to crime fits Cena's look. He's a pretty goofy character, but you could definitely see Cena playing him...

Hold up, what are we thinking? There's surely only one character Cena can possibly be playing - Gentleman Ghost. Because you can't see HIM either.

[SG]


5. Flula Borg - A Random Love Interest (Of Harley?)

Flula Borg Pitch Perfect 2
Universal Pictures

Not everyone can play a Suicide Squad member and when Flula Borg's name was first mentioned for The Suicide Squad, he was linked to the role of a romantic interest for one of the main characters.

This might not be accurate, of course, but how good would it be to cast off the shadow of Jared Leto's Joker even more (and to confirm that Harley is bisexual, because it's not been something any comic book movie has really even considered looking at) by giving her a romantic interest.

Borg is most well-known for his role in Pitch Perfect 2 but he's done voice work elsewhere (including on Ferdinand with John Cena and in the Boss Baby show). He generally plays German characters, because he's German, and there's obviously a possibility he's playing a German villain of some sort, but the idea of Harley having a normie boyfriend is rather wonderful.

[SG]


Contributor
Contributor

WhatCulture's former COO, veteran writer and editor.

Content Producer/Presenter

WhatCulture's very own resident movie guy, Ewan has been working in the content creation biz for over 10 years now, having started as a freelance contributor to WhatCulture Gaming all the way back in 2015. After graduating with a First-Class Honours in History from Northumbria University in 2017 (where he won a prize for a totally killer dissertation on the Watergate years), Ewan took on the role of Comics Editor at WhatCulture and quickly developed WhatCulture Comics into one of the biggest superhero-focused channels on YouTube. He followed this with a brief hiatus at Screen Rant in 2021, where he worked across the Gaming and Film sections as a writer and editor, before returning to WhatCulture as a Senior Content Producer / Presenter in 2023. He started his own podcast, We Love Dad Movies, in 2022, and has contributed several written pieces to the Eisner-nominated comics website Shelfdust as well. In his current role, Ewan incorporates his love of cinema, comic books, and history into written pieces and video essays for WhatCulture's Film & TV channel, as well as WhatCulture Gaming and WhatCulture Horror, with a particular focus on nineties-era Dad Movies, old school Westerns, and Golden Age Hollywood Noir. John Carpenter is his fave, and he thinks Batman Beyond should never have been cancelled. If that's your vibe, you'll probably like his stuff.