The Wolverine: 5 Big Blunders (But 5 Ways It Still Kicks Ass)
The day has finally come! Yes, James Mangold's The Wolverine is out in cinemas the world over, and while you can read my review here, you can more importantly make up your own mind on Logan's latest claw-slashing adventure, this time taking him to Japan. Reviews have tended towards the mixed - the Rotten Tomatoes score is 67% with a 6.2 average - though the consensus is that it still delivers a worthy installment in the character's mythology, and is likely to leave you even more excited heading towards X-Men: Days of Future Past. The film is nothing if not a mixed bag; it makes several unmistakably big blunders despite its overall intention to pay suitable tribute to the source material it draws from. In some aspects, it deviates from basic logic, and in others it just doesn't do the comic book characters justice, but it still boasts enough kick-ass moments to make it worth a watch. Let's take a look... Take note that SPOILERS DO FOLLOW. 5 Big Blunders...
5. Yashida Is Unaffected By Radiation
The opening scene of The Wolverine shows Logan saving a young Yashida from the atomic bomb explosion at Nagasaki at the end of World War II, by hurling him into a well and then using the cover of the well as a shield against the force of the explosion. We see the effect that this has on Logan, stripping layers of his skin away and burning him to a cinder, seconds before his regenerative abilities kick in and return him to his regular state, much to Yashida's amazement. The problem is that this doesn't really do much for the radiation that would be waiting to greet Yashida the second he stepped outside the well. Given how close they were to the explosion, there's pretty much no way he could avoid being irradiated upon exiting the well (even if he waited days), or even catching some fallout while being down there, yet the film totally skirts around this.
4. Jean Grey Is Almost Totally Pointless
The trailers showing off Jean Grey made us hope that that a revealing flashback would give us another glimpse into Logan's psyche leading up to what happened at the end of The Last Stand. Instead, Jean appears through a number of dreams and visions to Logan, cementing the fact that death follows him around like a specter, and despite his attempts to lie low, it is always going to be a part of his existence as long as he is breathing. Though it's a fine idea in principle, it's just kinda cheesy to have Jean ladelling out character psychology in this manner. This reaches its apex at the end of the film, when Jean tempts Logan with simply giving in to his mortality and "crossing over" with her when he seems to be dying, before he accepts that he had to kill Jean, and gets on with the rest of his life, having seemingly conquered his demons. The point is that this could have been done without her needing to spell it out in visions; a smarter film would have found a way to convey this through tangible, living characters.
3. Wolverine Losing His Powers Was Boring
Wolverine losing his powers should have made the game that much more dangerous, as now Logan would be vulnerable and have to watch his back, but Mangold oddly doesn't give Wolverine much of a chance to shine without his powers, instead shoving him into verbose dialogues with Mariko Yashida and not really making the mutant's plight particularly interesting. I want to see Logan struggling to kill the bad guys, and having to actually look out for himself, but that isn't really adequately conveyed during the set-pieces in the first act, even after Viper's potion has been administered. What's worse, though, is the means through which Logan gets his powers back. He discovers that a bug implant is constricting his heart and preventing him from regenerating, so what does Logan do? He cuts into his own stomach with his claws and removes the bug, which, given his near-mortal status at this point, is totally freaking ridiculous.
2. Viper Was Wasted
Viper was built up in the movie's advertising as being a menacing, tenacious adversary for Wolverine to face down, but in execution, she's actually a pretty disappointing baddie, largely because we don't really learn much about her. She introduces herself in much the same manner as in the trailer - "A chemist, capitalist..." - though doesn't really elaborate much, serving primarily as fodder for the plot, which eventually has her revealing the Silver Samurai, because otherwise, there would be nobody to segue viewers into the final battle. She's presented as a murderous badass from the outset, and then meets a curiously muted end when facing off against Yukio, where we never get to see the full extent of her powers, or the admittedly enticing nature of her skin shedding (even if the bald head looks super silly).
1. Yashida Being In The Silver Samurai Suit Made No Sense
The lamest and most disappointing reveal of all, though, is that when the Silver Samurai begins attacking Wolverine, we find out that Yashida has been piloting it all along. It's a stupid twist because we saw Yashida "die" from his illness earlier in the film, and so it just seems like a lazy attempt to pull the wool over our eyes and deliver a knockout twist. Instead, it's just stupid, and will invalidate much of the film's otherwise rock-solid first act. Why go to such pains to pretend that he's dead? Or were his cronies just rushing him to the Silver Samurai suit? It just doesn't make a lot of sense. Plus, it's kinda hard to take the romantic angle seriously when Logan has just murdered both Mariko's father and grandfather. Sure, they were complete jackasses who totally deserved, it, but still, family's family... However, it's not all bad (obviously). Let's look at 5 ways The Wolverine delivered on its promises...
...But 5 Ways It Still Kicks Ass
5. Wolverine's Characterisation
Though the means through which it is conveyed isn't always top notch, it's refreshing to see Logan in such a destitute mode, kitted out in a big beard and long hair after the events of The Last Stand. The credit is really to Jackman rather than anyone else, who makes us feel his guilt and his frustration at being unable to simply live a quiet life, being constantly pulled back into one of fighting. The parallels between the Japanese Ronin - a samurai without a master - and Logan, who walks the Earth on his own, is palpable and well-drawn, even if the screenplay piles on the visions of Jean Grey like there's no tomorrow. The character would have been better served by simply showing Wolverine interacting with his real, physical environment and the people within it, but still, the film adequately made sense of the character's existential issues, and resolves them in a suitable enough way.
4. The Action (Mostly)
Though there's not exactly a lot of it, the film does deliver some scintillating action, especially in its first act, as Wolverine fends off assailants at Yashida's funeral, and then ends up battling several of them both in and atop a train. Both of these sequences in particular remind us of how adept James Mangold is at staging action; we can feel the impact of every hit even in spite of the PG-13 rating, and more to the point, he doesn't indulge in the fashionable shaky cam that ruins so many films like this. The stand-off atop a train, in which Wolverine takes on multiple assailants, is pure comic book action; yes, it's thoroughly ridiculous, but that's sort of the point. Though many critics thought the film was too "dark", this scene's riotous outlandishness proved if nothing else that Mangold wasn't taking himself too seriously. As for the third act's action, that's less great, as mentioned above...
3. Yukio
One of the consistent areas of praise for The Wolverine is the introduction of a sidekick of sorts for Logan, in Rila Fukushima's Yukio (who was also a supporting character in the comics). Here she ends up first bringing Logan to see Yashida, and then has a future vision of him dying with his heart in his hand. Over the course of the film, they go from uneasy cohorts to dedicated protectors of one another; when Logan is vulnerable, she tries to keep him out of danger, while Logan does the same when he gets his powers back. It's a fun, interesting dynamic because the two are so starkly different, yet because Yukio proves herself as kick-ass in her own right, it manages to be fish-out-of-water fare without getting too silly. At the end of the film, we feel that the two have actually bonded, and it would be a shame if she didn't appear in some of Logan's future adventures.
2. It's Leaps Ahead Of X-Men: Origins
It might sound like a backhanded compliment, but man, wasn't this film just miles ahead of the decrepit mess that was X-Men Origins: Wolverine? Gavin Hood's wonky failure made a joke out of Wolverine, and though Jackman still did a fine job with what he had, it just showed no respect at all for the comic books, especially with how they basically turned Deadpool into Baraka from Mortal Kombat. Liev Schreiber was game for a workout as Sabretooth, but there was absolutely nothing there for comic book fans (or really, fans of good cinema at all...) The Wolverine, though far from perfect, rectifies many of the key problems from Origins, as far as the tone goes, the level of the action goes, and the chicanery of the narrative goes. With a character as popular and entertaining to watch as Logan, he certainly deserves a standalone film that reflects that awesomeness.
1. Mid-Credits Scene
Everyone's been talking about the mid-credits scene at the end of the film, and with good reason. Set two years after Logan's Japan episode, Logan is walking through an airport, when he is approached by both Magneto and Professor Xavier, who explain that something catastrophic has happened, and his help is required to fix it. Obviously, this is the lead-in to next year's X-Men: Days of Future Past, in which it has been confirmed that Wolverine will be the one travelling through time in order to stop the Sentinels from taking over and subjugating the mutants. After having not seen McKellan and Stewart in their respective roles for years, this was a great, shocking way to introduce us to them once again, and after the terrible post-credit scenes pumped into the last Wolverine movie, a fine way to erase the memories of that horrendous venture. Have you seen The Wolverine yet? Disagree with our reasoning? Sound off in the comments below.