Titanic: How It Should Be Re-Cast In 2021

Which actors deserve their tickets aboard the "unsinkable ship"?

Titanic Recast
Fox

Who would have thought that a movie about one of the biggest tragedies in recorded history would have made such a beautiful and heartwarming story, albeit with a fair few tears mixed in?

Titanic truly was (for lack of a better word) a titanic success and has become one of the most famous must-see-before-you-die movies. Thanks to this legacy, the idea of retouching the film is likely to get many people up in arms, but that doesn't mean there's no benefit to looking back and thinking, what if?

Part of what made the story of Titanic engaging were the characters. Putting names and faces to the victims of the disaster made the truth of the matter all the more devastating, and the actors who took those roles played a big part in the film's success.

However, despite how iconic these performances are, it is still exciting to ponder who would take the roles in this day and age. As the movie comes close to celebrating its 25th anniversary, let's take a look at what those different faces could/should look like.

10. Thomas Andrews - Adrian Dunbar

Thomas Andrews Adrian Dunbar
20th Century Fox/BBC Two

Although this character spent most of his time in the background, there's no denying that he has one of the most tragic parts in the film.

As the master-builder of the ship itself, it's easy to see how responsible he felt for it, and watching as he tried his best to warn people about the sinking before going down with it was poetic and sad. So, you'd need to find an actor who could convey this sense of severity whilst still being likeable enough to make you feel bad for him, and Adrian Dunbar would be a perfect fit.

Dunbar already ticks one major box, and that's being Irish. But more than that, he is a talented actor who always makes his characters likeable and complex, meaning he'd no doubt nail this part.

Plus, it has to be said that Dunbar and Victor Garber (the original actor behind the role) are the spitting image of each other, meaning it's already clear the Line of Duty star would look and feel at home on board the Titanic.


9. Old Rose - Vanessa Redgrave

Old Rose Vanessa Redgrave
Fox/Wikimedia Commons

Ah, Rose, the hero of the story and the heart/soul of the film.

It's easy to look past her older counterpart, as the intensity of the sinking scenes make you forget that you already know Rose survives. Still, the interludes back in the modern-day remind you that what you're seeing is just a distant memory told by a character you've fallen in love with. Her narration is the crux of the movie, so why not go with someone tried and tested?

Vanessa Redgrave needs no introduction, as she's one of the most respected actors in the business. Her long-spanning career has been littered with beautiful roles and performances, even grabbing her an Oscar for the 1977 flick Julia, so she'd have the right level of prestige for this part.

Redgrave would need a little help ageing up, as passing for a 101-year-old would be tough. However, with the right make-up and performance, Redgrave could easily convince you that she's the long-lasting survivor of this horrible event.


8. Captain Smith - Liam Cunningham

Captain Smith Liam Cunningham
Fox/HBO

It's a well-known fact that Titanic holds the record for being one of the joint-three movies to have won the most amount of Academy Awards, that being 11. So, when you step back and think about it, Bernard Hill, who played Captain Smith here and Théoden in Lord of the Rings: The Return of the King (one of the other three movies), is one of the most highly acclaimed actors in Oscar history. Thus, he does leave some big shoes to fill.

When it comes to recasting the confident turned, heartbroken captain, it's easy to lean towards someone who has already proven his worth at sea, that being Liam Cunningham.

This actor is great at playing authority and boasts enough vulnerability to make his performances nuanced and three-dimensional. Watching as his version of Captain Smith loses control of the ship and makes the brave decision to go down with it would be a recipe for success, as he's likeable, confident, and already has the fluffy beard to pull it off.


7. Molly Brown - Margo Martindale

Molly Brown Margo Martindale
Fox/Amazon Prime Video

While the Titanic movie has a grounding in reality, it's not news to reveal that most of the events on board were fabricated for dramatic tension. There was no Rose, no Jack, and most of the characters who did exist probably didn't behave the way you've seen in the film, save for maybe Molly Brown.

Known as "The Unsinkable Molly Brown", this figure was one of the biggest heroes of the tragedy, attempting (unsuccessfully) to get the lifeboats turned around and even leading a survivors committee to help lower class passengers after the disaster.

The character needs someone who can convey strength and compassion in a short amount of time, and legendary character actress Margo Martindale would be an ideal candidate. She can fit into any part she's given, going from dramatic and profound roles in projects like American Crime Story to hilarious and self-aware bits in the likes of BoJack Horseman.

Martindale would also nail Molly's unconventional placement in the upper class, which helps her bond with Jack and show support for the lower classes. She would, no doubt, do Molly Brown proud.


6. Spicer Lovejoy - Alistair Petrie

Spicer Lovejoy Alistair Petrie
Fox/Netflix

Spicer Lovejoy might not seem like the most vital piece of this film's puzzle at first glance. But, as the secondary antagonist and muscle for Cal Hockley, he's a big part of adding conflict for Jack and Rose's romance. Without him, a lot of the tension would be gone.

The character is quite a simple role, as he comes along to intimidate Jack and establish order for his boss. But that makes it all the more important to find someone compelling and convincing even in more stoic performances. Thanks to that, all roads point to Sex Education's Alistair Petrie.

Petrie has a naturally commanding presence that makes him frightening and filled with authority. His solid and still face paints the picture of someone willing to get their hands dirty, emitting the right amount of danger.

To add here, Petrie also thrives at adding depth to his characters, as even when he's taking on smaller, less significant roles, he still brings a sense of history to them. You can see this from his parts in Rogue One, Rush and more.


5. Brock Lovett - Jovan Adepo

Brock Lovett And Jovan Adepo
Fox/CBS

Many people look at the flash forward sequences of Titanic as surplus to requirement.

It's true that the modern day segments bring the pacing to a halt and set the film off to a slow start, but they're also critical, as they paint the idea that what you're watching is grounded in reality. Brock Lovett is at the centre of all that.

These segments really need to be carried by Brock, as he delivers a vital message about empathy in the movie. He starts as someone who is extremely passionate about the disaster but seems naïve to the human suffering of the event. Towards the end, however, he learns his lesson. So, you'd need someone reliable who isn't a distractingly well-known name.

Jovan Adepo would be a fantastic choice, as he could bring a sense of passion and quirkiness to the character. Plus, while Adepo has appeared in some great projects like Watchmen, The Stand, Fences and more, he's not a household name, meaning he could sink right into the role.


4. Ruth DeWitt Bukater - Gillian Anderson

Ruth Dewitt Bukater Gillian Anderson
Fox/BBC One

Ruth was a character who - despite the film's bloated runtime - didn't get too much of a chance to shine.

She played the typical role of the overbearing and strict mother to the repressed protagonist and did it well. But, just when things got interesting after you learned about her dire financial situation, the ship began to sink, and she was shuffled off to a lifeboat, essentially disappearing from the film.

It's safe to say that whoever gets cast in this role would need to convey a lot in the little time they have, so why not go for the well-respected and constantly engaging Gillian Anderson? This actor has proven time and time again that she can knock it out of the park, and seeing her take this role would make perfect sense.

She would effortlessly establish the character as a cold-hearted woman looking out for her own interests. Still, she could also season Ruth with a sense of desperation and sadness, making her all the more interesting.


3. Cal Hockley - Adam Driver

Cal Hockley Adam Driver
Fox/Netflix

If you were to ask anyone who the most hated movie villain from the 90s was, then you'd find a lot of them pointing to this tall glass of scumbag.

Cal Hockley is almost cartoonish in his villainy, as there seem to be no redeemable traits about him. He's abusive towards Rose, stubborn to a fault, elitist, and even tries his best to be a murderer in the latter part of the film. The man is, simply put, a despicable person, which is why he's perfect in this movie.

Catching lightning in a bottle twice with this character would require a great actor, and Adam Driver is a good pick. He could tick plenty of boxes in this part, with some of the most important being his authority, intimidation, and lack of empathy.

However, this role would also challenge the typically stoic actor, as Cal was hateable primarily thanks to his arrogance and dastardly smile. Breaking out into something more expressive wouldn't just be good for Driver; it would also make this performance memorable for audiences.


2. Jack Dawson - Timothee Chalamet

Jack Dawson Timothee Chalamet
Fox/Sony

Titanic wasn't just a story about a ship; it was the tale of a pair of young people falling in love and fighting their social standing, all in the face of disaster. As one half of that romance, Jack became iconic, and his final moments would make him one of the most memorable characters in movie history. That's a lot of pressure, but Chalamet could handle it.

Many would call Timothee Chalamet the modern reincarnation of Leonardo DiCaprio, so that's not a bad start. Besides that comparison, he's also a genuinely phenomenal actor who can deliver on likeable characters and fits the unconventional romantic lead to a T.

The actor has shown in movies like Little Women, Call Me By My Name, Lady Bird, The King and more that he's got an emotional range bigger than a toddler at playtime. He can bring nuance and depth to the role of Jack while still capturing the charm which made the original performance so iconic.


1. Rose DeWitt Bukater - Saoirse Ronan

Titanic Recast
Fox

Rose is one of the most formidable characters to play in this movie. While Jack can get by just being likeable and charming, Rose needs to capture a whole smorgasbord of emotions. She needs to feel vulnerable yet rebellious, high-class yet down to Earth, desperate to find a way out yet willing to keep her family alive. Then, to top it all off, she has to add terrified and fighting for survival to that list. It's no easy feat.

However, Saoirse Ronan has made it very clear throughout her career that she can handle such characters. She shot to prominence thanks to her roles in movies like Atonement and The Lovely Bones, then had another career boost after appearing in Brooklyn, Lady Bird and Little Women. The latter two even saw her share the screen with Chalamet, proving they've got the chemistry for this leading pair.

Ronan has a great mastery of combining bravery with vulnerability, infusing her characters with a sense of strength but also a weakness that makes things challenging for them. She captures everything Rose needs to make her work.


In this post: 
Titanic
 
Posted On: 
Contributor

Michael is my name, overanalysing comedy is my game! Anime, wrestling, TV, movies and video games all live in my head rent free!