Tomb Raider Review: 4 Ups & 5 Downs
Well...it wasn't awful. Yay?
The latest attempt to break the "video game movie curse" is in cinemas now: the Alicia Vikander-starring Tomb Raider reboot.
Is it any good? Well, not really: it's scoring wildly mixed reviews so far, but to its fair credit, it does currently sit as the best-reviewed video game movie of all time, something of a backhanded compliment considering its most aggressive competition was The Angry Birds Movie. Oof.
The new Tomb Raider movie is the perfect example of a "save it for Netflix" film: it's rather dull but occasionally engaging, with some pretty visuals and prettier faces, but far from the thoroughly persuasive hit adaptation fans will be hoping for.
If you're a huge fan of the franchise, check it out for sure just to see the 2013 game somewhat convincingly recreated on screen, but otherwise, this is generic, hungover streaming fodder at best. The wait continues for the first truly good video game movie, sadly...
Downs...
5. It's Way Too Long
Tomb Raider clocks in at 118 minutes in length, and makes you feel just about every minute of that run-time due to some painfully poor pacing.
For starters, the first act is a wildly bloated, distended affair, bombarding the viewer with heaps of stodgy "character development" (but it's really just aggressive exposition), and a peculiar sequence where Lara (Vikander) takes part in a "foxhunt", where she rides a bike through the streets of London in the hope of earning some cash.
It's a whole 40 minutes before Lara even reaches the remote island on which her father disappeared, and even then, the remaining hour-plus of the movie rarely manages to hit an energetic groove. Clearly, there was no need for this film to run longer than around 100 minutes, but instead the end result feels needlessly drawn-out and exhaustingly overlong.
4. The Dull, Exposition-Heavy Script
Clearly, the film's biggest overall weakness is the script, which strands the viewer in an avalanche of exposition from the outset and never really lets up.
There are literally countless sequences in this film where a character dispassionately reels off information about the nonsense supernatural narrative, and it's basically the equivalent of playing a Tomb Raider video game and being stuck in an overlong, overly verbose cut-scene...but you can't skip it.
Even outside of the exposition, it's a lifeless, joyless script, lacking any sort of palpable humanity or enjoyable comic relief: it's a purely mechanical concoction that further cements the film's overall dullness.
3. It Wastes A Great Supporting Cast
There are so many great actors in this movie, and most of them sadly don't get remotely close to their due. Aside from lead Vikander, Dominic West gets a surprisingly substantial role as Lara's father Lord Richard Croft, showing up in plentiful flashbacks but largely just spouting that creaky aforementioned dialogue.
Elsewhere, the brilliant Kristin Scott Thomas shows up for a glorified, totally forgettable cameo as Croft Holdings associate Ana Miller, Walton Goggins is never able to rise above being a generic baddie, Daniel Wu is thoroughly wasted as Lara's new pal Lu Ren (being kept out of the action for huge parts of the movie), and even Nick Frost and Jaime Winstone are just here to play two wacky, out-of-place comic relief pawn shop owners.
It's a paycheck movie for most of the actors involved, clearly, but it's a shame the script didn't give them just a little more to work with.
2. The Emotional Beats Don't Work
The emotional core of Tomb Raider is the relationship between Lara and her father Richard, which is largely explored through flashbacks interspersed throughout the film, where Richard bonds with Lara both as a young child and as a teenager.
Unfortunately this father-daughter set-up never rises above feeling laughably cliched, an earnest but generically lazy attempt to imbue a dull story with some added emotional pull.
The fact it even tries to be emotional puts it above most video game movies, in fairness, but it's totally hollow, and every time the movie randomly cuts back to a washed-out flashback for a few seconds, it's more likely to draw chuckles rather than tears from you.
1. The Ridiculous Sequel-Bait Ending
It's not really a spoiler to state the obvious, that the movie ends on the sequence shown in the trailers, where a ponytail-clad Lara picks out two HK pistols for her next adventure.
However, what the trailers didn't spoil is the hilarious, out-of-nowhere plot twist that's thrown in right at the end of the movie, a sudden reveal about a seemingly minor supporting character which has a huge impact on the plot. Before we're able to soak it in, though, the movie quickly ends, betting all its chips on a sequel to explore the issue further.
It of course remains to be seen whether or not the movie will do well enough to get a follow-up, but this last-minute revelation was sequel bait at its most absurd.
So, the film's not great, but for the standards of video game movies, it's certainly not awful either. Here's what it got right...
Ups...
4. Alicia Vikander Is A Totally Convincing Lara Croft
The one major thing the movie gets right is casting Alicia Vikander as Lara Croft. It's clear she put herself through an intense training regimen to convincingly resemble the video game heroine, and also to believably survive the ordeal she's put through on the island.
Vikander doesn't get great material to work with, but as a physical performance, it's probably the most faithful of any video game movie to date. There's still the overall feeling that the Oscar winner's talents are squandered on a project like this, but she helps elevate a thoroughly mediocre film that would be far tougher to watch with a lesser actress in the lead.
She does a fine job making Lara a bada** protagonist while still being vulnerable and far away from a superhero. She's not as charming as Angelina Jolie's portrayal, but that's kinda the point.
3. It Nails The Tone Of The Video Games
This film is of course based on the 2013 Crystal Dynamics reboot of the video game franchise, which stripped away the rather hokey, over-the-top tone of the earlier games and reimagined Lara Croft as a more down-to-Earth, realistically-proportioned female action hero.
To that end, this movie does nail the style and tone of the new games pretty perfectly. There are scripting issues at every turn, but the look and feel of the film should please those who enjoyed the last two games, and at least shows the filmmakers were taking the material seriously.
There's a lengthy sequence in the middle of the film where Lara's just trying to survive against the elements: there's virtually no dialogue (and therefore no boring exposition), and it's probably one of the best set-pieces from any video game movie to date. It feels ripped from the games in a way so few video game adaptations have ever managed.
2. The Action Sequences Are...Not Bad
Norwegian director Roar Uthaug (The Wave) does a solid job with the film's visuals, helping create stylish set-pieces out of even two fairly pointless sequences in the first act - the aforementioned foxhunt bike chase and Lara fending off a group of thieves in Hong Kong - not to mention all the action on the island.
It's a shame these moments aren't backed by a more interesting narrative and characters, and there's way too much talking in-between the running, shooting and tomb raiding, but from the cinematography to the surprisingly decent CGI, the action never drops below fine in the very least. For a video game movie, that's practically a miracle.
1. It's One Of The Best Video Game Movies
All things considered, Tomb Raider is one of the best video game movies. In terms of "serious" adaptations, it might be the best - and it's currently the best-reviewed - though its self-regarding nature also means it's ultimately nowhere near as fun as, say, Mortal Kombat or Resident Evil (both Paul W.S. Anderson movies, horrifyingly enough).
Still, the acting and visuals are leagues ahead of most other video game films, so it's just a shame the boring script and rather self-serious approach stop it from being a truly enjoyable romp.
It's something of a step forward for these kinds of movies, even if there are clearly still a lot of lessons to be learned when crafting a big-budget movie out of a beloved video game.
What did you think of Tomb Raider? Shout it out in the comments!