Toy Story 4 Review: 8 Ups & 2 Downs
A triumphant third sequel for Woody and co.
Toy Story 4 is now in cinemas worldwide, and despite understandable scepticism from fans about Pixar delivering another sequel almost a decade after Toy Story 3 gave these character such a satisfying conclusion, the belated follow-up has received near-universal critical acclaim.
And indeed, whether you're a hardcore fan of the franchise or a more casual observer, Toy Story 4 improbably extends the series' winning streak, ensuring Toy Story is by default the best and most consistent cinematic "quadrilogy" ever made.
Though not quite reaching the endlessly imaginative highs of its predecessors, this is far from the cynical cash-grab many expected, and a more-than-worthy addition to one of the most creative, emotional and downright entertaining movie franchises of all time.
Fingers crossed that Pixar sees sense enough to quit while they're ahead by ending things here, but as ever, we'll have to wait and see whether or not Toy Story 5 ever materialises.
For the time being, though, the series' long-standing integrity is held firmly in tact with another heart-swelling dose of fun and feels for all ages...
Downs...
2. The Original Toys Feel (Mostly) Sidelined
One of Toy Story 4's biggest strengths is training a far greater focus on Woody's (Tom Hanks) own individual story, lending the film an unexpectedly intimate feel compared to its predecessors.
The one big negative of, this, however, is that most of the toys introduced in the first two movies in particular are given a lot less to do, and their frequent absence is definitely felt throughout.
Buzz (Tim Allen) spends most of the story relegated to a fairly perfunctory subplot, while the likes of Rex (Wallace Shawn), Hamm (John Ratzenberger), Jessie (Joan Cusack) and Bullseye just aren't given much at all to do beyond a few scant standout moments.
We'll let them off when it comes to Mr. Potato Head, though, given that voice actor Don Rickles sadly passed away before the movie's recording sessions started.
Still, if the script could've found a neater balance between all its characters, it certainly would've been for the better.
1. Yes, It's The Worst Of The Series (But Still Great)
To the surprise of few, Toy Story 4 is absolutely the worst of the four films to date, but there's perhaps no movie franchise in existence where the bar has been set this impossibly high and maintained as such across all prior instalments.
So, while this third sequel can't quite match the pathos, intelligence or sheer inventiveness of what came before, it takes a damn hard swing at trying.
To that end, if you're (somehow) hoping for a movie as strong as the first three, you'll probably find yourself slightly underwhelmed.
Yes, those who felt the film didn't need to happen will probably still feel the same when it's all said and done, but despite being on the lowest rung of the series' ladder, it's still very much a film that delivers on basically everything the series is loved for.
And with that in mind, here's everything Toy Story 4 knocks out of the park...
Ups...
8. Forky Is One Of The Series' Best Characters
Toy Story 4 introduces a host of new characters, by far the most intriguing and memorable of whom is Forky (Tony Hale), a spork brought to life by Bonnie (Madeleine McGraw) at the start of the film, and who struggles to come to terms with the fact that he's a toy rather than a utensil.
Forky ultimately comes to represent some of Toy Story 4's most compelling themes, with his insistence that he's "trash" reflecting self-esteem issues, anxiety and depression, but also one's struggle to embrace their own identity, whatever it may be.
On a broader level, Forky begs the audience to consider, "What is a toy?", a tantalising question enlivened by Tony Hale's fantastically nervy performance, walking a delicate line where his existential quandaries are genuinely empathetic without ever proving irritating.
Forky's already become an icon for millennials online, and the film itself absolutely cements why. With his easy relatability in an often grim and confusing world, Forky is an easy all-timer character for the series.
7. The Animation Is INCREDIBLE
Watching this movie after revisiting the three prior instalments over the last few days, it's staggering just how far Pixar's animation has come in the last 25 years.
Toy Story 4 is without question one of the most visually stunning animations of all time, exemplified no better than by a jaw-droppingly photo-realistic, rain-soaked opening sequence.
Director Josh Cooley does a fantastic job milking the film's dynamic environments for every drop of vibrancy, and it goes without saying that the toys both new and old look absolutely marvellous.
Needless to say, this movie will be an absolute must-have for 4K TV owners once it hits home video.
6. The Emotional, Mature Storytelling
The film's thoughtful script doesn't simply retread the series' prior themes but also introduces some provocative new ones.
In addition to Forky's aforementioned identity issues, it asks audiences both young and old to consider the mystery of existence, and the sheer miracle of being alive.
Elsewhere, the series' exploration of the heartbreaking relationship between toys and their owners heads in fascinating new directions, largely thanks to the presence of the movie's foil, Gabby Gabby (Christina Hendricks), indicating to the audience that Woody's time with Andy was one of immense privilege so rarely afforded to most toys.
The real beauty of the Toy Story franchise has always been its ability to operate on multiple levels and mean many things to different people, and that's brilliantly, perceptively in tact here once again.
By engaging with both age-old issues of existential dread and more current social concerns of self-identification, Toy Story 4 feels remarkably fresh and even ahead-of-its-time for family-friendly animated escapism.
5. Bo Beep Gets A Brilliant Reinvention
There was no omission in Toy Story 3 more glaring or upsetting than the absence of Bo Peep (Annie Potts), and so it's massively satisfying seeing her disappearance not only explained, but her character also being brought back into the fold with Woody.
Best of all, Bo Peep's pink garb and damsel-in-distress shtick is all gone: she's now an assertive, self-assured bada** who challenges Woody's worldview in a number of ways.
Between Annie Potts' terrific vocal performance and the strong writing, it's great to see Pixar offer up another compelling heroine for young girls. That merch is gonna fly off the shelves.
4. The Hilarious, Witty Script
Though the Toy Story series has never quite managed to match the firecracker wit of the original movie, where almost every line of dialogue was solid gold, this fourth film nevertheless nails the series' signature balance of heart-rending emotion and uproarious hilarity.
There's one particular recurring gag in the film involving Ducky (Keegan-Michael Key) and Bunny (Jordan Peele) that ranks as one of the series' funniest to date, while the script generally keeps the sharply observant one-liners coming thick and fast.
If you were worried that Toy Story 4's well-noted production issues, such as a change in screenwriters mid-development, would hamper the end product, that thankfully isn't the case at all.
3. The Terrific New Characters
Each new Toy Story has done a fantastic job of introducing a new cast of toys alongside the classic ones, and Toy Story 4 once again knocks it for six in this department.
In addition to Forky, both Ducky and Bunny are decidedly funnier than the fairly broad-skewing marketing suggested, Gabby Gabby proves to be shockingly nuanced (and brilliantly voiced by Christina Hendricks), and surely best of all, Keanu Reeves is absolutely hilarious as Canadian stuntman toy Duke Caboom.
These characters are all written with depth and great humour, adding another charming cabal of characters to the series' huge toy chest.
2. It Delivers Another Incredibly Satisfying Ending
No spoilers here, of course, but if you were worried that a fourth Toy Story movie might struggle to arrive at an ending even remotely as satisfying as the third, fear not.
One of this film's biggest strengths is that it doesn't try to one-up Toy Story 3's almost unbearably beautiful ending, and instead expands upon it in a way that's meaningful and stays true to all the central characters.
To that end, you probably won't be left quite the inconsolable, sobbing wreck you were at the end of the previous film, but there will be most certainly be tears regardless.
That it manages to give these characters a satisfying send-off (again) without simply recycling or invalidating what came before is not simply impressive - it's practically miraculous.
1. It Might Be The Best "Unnecessary" Sequel Ever
And finally, though Toy Story 4 is absolutely not a movie that needed to exist, it certainly succeeds in justifying itself, and in that stead just might be the best blatantly "unnecessary" sequel ever made.
Pixar seemed like they were tempting fate with a third Toy Story and that turned out spectacular, and yet again here, they've proven just how much they care about doing right by these characters.
That doesn't mean anyone "needs" a Toy Story 5, though, and even if it does happen, it really feels like it's time to move on from Woody, Buzz and co. and tell a new story for the next generation.
This is a great way to leave things, as much as the film didn't need to happen at all.