Us: 7 Ways Jordan Peele Defies Modern Horror Conventions

Jordan Peele's excellent sophomore horror film doesn't lean too hard on genre conventions.

Us Jason Pluto Closet
Universal

Jordan Peele's Us achieved great success this past weekend, raking in $70 million across North America. This more than doubles the opening weekend box office results for Peele's last cinematic undertaking, Get Out. While Variety reports that Us has now surpassed John Krasinski's A Quiet Place to claim the largest opening weekend box office for an original horror film, these numbers are far from the film's only crowning achievement.

With 94% on Rotten Tomatoes, Us shows that Jordan Peele's sophomore effort still has what it takes to dazzle critics. True, the film scores lower with casual viewers. Its 70% audience rating, compared with the 86% audience rating earned by Get Out, is indicative of the many viewers who felt that Us failed to deliver an experience as uniquely genre-bending as Peele's last outing.

Us may not blow viewers away with the same intensity as Get Out, but the ups certainly outweigh the downs. Us demonstrates that Peele can attempt a more straightforward horror film without entirely succumbing to genre conventions. The following 7 attributes of Jordan Peele's Us may not amount to the sum of a film like Get Out, but they definitely allow Us to shine in comparison to most other modern horror films.

Warning: Some of the following entries are intensely spoiler-laden. If you've not seen the film, proceed with caution.

7. The Silent Opening

Us Little Adelaide Jordan Peele
Universal

While plenty of modern horror films understand the concept of "less is more" as it applies to gore and monsters, Us applies this maxim to the sound design in its opening scenes. The first sequence does not lean heavily on high-pitched string music to signify an oncoming jump scare or to let audiences know that they're supposed to feel uneasy.

Instead, the first sequence practically does away with non-diegetic music altogether. Just about the only music heard prior to the opening credits comes from Adelaide's TV, the automated sound system in the hall of mirrors, or the sound of Adelaide and Red whistling to one another. When Us finally reaches the first true horror beat of the film, it occurs in absolute silence.

This doesn't mean that audiences won't feel any sense of unease prior to the first scare. As Adelaide follows her parents around the Santa Cruz Boardwalk, the camera depicts the scene from a child's perspective. Her parents look like giants, standing at twice her size. A carnie running games nearby looks strangely obscured to the viewer, as Adelaide is not tall enough to completely see over his booth.

Without any music whatsoever, this simple visual tool causes the familiar to appear imposing. If Us succeeds in putting any of Jordan Peele's abilities on full display, it's his ability to draw discomfort from the mundane. The choice to do this while forgoing traditional audio cues is what makes the opening particularly strong.


6. The Audio-Visual Dissonance

Us Jordan Peele Bunnies Rabbits
Universal

After forgoing musical cues in its opening sequence, Us flips its approach as soon as the opening credits begin. An imposing chorus of Latin vocals hits the audience's ears, as their eyes take in row after row of bunny cages. There is nothing threatening about these bunnies, but they remain with the viewer throughout the entirety of the opening credits.

This lingering shot serves the obvious purpose of giving viewers time to ask questions. Why bunnies? Where are these cages? Is it important that there are so many more white bunnies than brown ones?

The questions don't stop at the bunnies. For the rest of the film, Us keeps viewers alert by providing musical cues where they don't seem to belong. Why are creepy strings accompanying a shot of seagulls flying over the beach? Why do the bouncy string beats over the Tethered family's first appearance feel like something out of a comedy rather than a horror? Why does Winston Duke continue to play the scene comedically long after the strings have begun their eerie crescendo?

None of this is done without purpose. The decision to place discomforting auditory cues over images that our eyes deem innocuous (or bouncy music over images that we deem unsettling) is enough to spark curiosity. Since Us sometimes likes to plant relevant details and thematic elements in the background, this is a brilliant way of training audiences to pay attention.

In many modern horror films, any auditory cue not signifying an actual creepy moment is usually just leading to a false jump scare. In the context of Us, it's something of a reverse-Pavlovian method of teaching audiences the value of remaining observant. The reward? Audiences who listen will learn the purpose of the bunnies long before their third-act reveal.


5. The Symmetry

Us Jordan Peele Frisbee
Universal

Typically speaking, horror films want audiences to experience fear at the same time as the protagonists. This is why characters in horror movies tend to be afraid of sharks and masked murderers rather than, say, frisbees.

Us, on the other hand, manages to create tension with simple moments such as a frisbee landing so that it perfectly aligns with one of the giant polka dots on Adelaide's beach blanket. Her friend Kitty remarks that such coincidences seem to be occurring frequently as of late.

Surely enough, we see odd moments of symmetry multiple times throughout the film's early scenes. A toy spider with a real spider crawling next to it. A pair of jaded twins who speak in unison several times in a row (unintentionally, although it still feels like something of an offbeat tribute to The Shining).

Even the film's resident Bible verse - a horror convention Peele decided not to forgo - acts as an example of perfect symmetry. Plenty of scripture makes reference to evil, but Peele specifically chose Jeremiah 11:11 with its mirrored chapter and verse numbers. This does not scare Adelaide when she first sees it, but the same numbers unnerve her later when Jason notices the time on his digital clock.

These are important moments in Us. While the film contains no shortage of bizarre images, it's the little coincidences and moments of symmetry that cause Adelaide distress. In a film where that which looks most familiar is to be feared, the most unnerving images are those which appear too perfect.


4. The Villain Design

The Family Us Fireplace
Universal Pictures

Some directors try hard to justify their villain designs through backstory, but many horror movies present villains that seem to be designed primarily from an aesthetic perspective rather than a story-based one. There's no reason to bring a hockey mask to a woodland campsite other than so Jason Voorhees can steal it and develop his signature look. Pre-immolation Freddy Krueger was presumably hoping to get away with his murders, yet he crafted the least subtle weapon imaginable.

The Tethered, while clearly designed with aesthetics in mind, tell a cohesive story through their design. While we may not know where they got the red jumpsuits, we can easily identify their inspiration as the red silhouettes on Adelaide's Hands Across America t-shirt. We can identify scissors as a sensible weapon choice for an event referred to as "The Untethering," as well as an easy weapon to carry in a jumpsuit pocket. Even Red's blonde eyebrows hint at a backstory, one that adds depth to her character not exposited through dialogue.

As explained in an interview with makeup head Scott Wheeler, Red's eyebrows were bleached by exposure to Pluto's fires. She is not the only one to get burned - a close look at Umbrae reveals her eyebrows to be almost entirely missing. Despite the disdain that Red expresses for her family when introducing them to the Wilsons, they are as bonded to each other as they are to their surface-dwelling counterparts. Evidently, this bond is not without consequences.

This adds an interesting layer to the film's themes of being burdened by the familiar, an impressive feat for a simple makeup choice. The Tethered do not appear to love each other, yet they are stuck together nonetheless. This mirrors the Wilsons, who sometimes feel stuck together yet clearly share an undeniable love.

Such an interpretation might be possible without Wheeler's makeup decisions, but characterization through visual design is an important element of filmmaking that Us adeptly incorporates.


3. The Dual Scopes

Us Pluto Fire
Universal

In the beginning, Us appears set to deliver a home invasion plot similar to other horror films such as The Strangers or The Purge. Midway through, the scope broadens with the reveal that the Wilsons are not by far the only family with Tethered counterparts. The story shifts gears into something almost reminiscent of a zombie film when the Wilsons hop in their car to flee Santa Cruz in search of safety.

Even when the scope broadens, the intimate nature of the story never quite dissipates. The Tethered may be joining hands across America, but the Wilson family is still primarily concerned with fighting their own shadows. A notable scene involving the Wilsons' friends, a well-chosen NWA song and a boat named B-Yacht'ch stands as the only significant diversion from this central conflict.

The choice to retain this intimate focus despite the wide scope of the story serves to enhance the central theme of the film. Jordan Peele confirmed in an interview with Yahoo that Us acts as both a social commentary and a personal one, and the central conflict reveals that the latter commentary is perhaps the most urgent. One may lament the state of their nation, but their own shadow side is a far more immediate threat. The Wilsons cannot take on all of the Tethered, but they can at least slay their own dark reflections.

Attempts at meaningful commentary are not uncommon in the world of horror. Both of the home invasion films referenced above use their stories to carry deeper themes. Us, however, manages to attack its message - that we are our own worst enemies - from two entirely different angles at once. This allows for greater variety of interpretation, and a group of friends may easily walk out of the theatre together having each heard an entirely different part of the message.


2. The Final Showdown

Us Adelaide Ending Jordan Peele
Universal

Paradoxically, one of the biggest genre conventions defied in Us is that it actually stays true to the genre during the final showdown. Horror films with clearly defined villains often struggle to pull this off. Whether its Jessica Biel running from Leatherface or a car-throwing demon being forced to fellate a chainsaw in the Evil Dead remake, modern horror films tend to devolve into borderline action flicks during their climax.

This isn't necessarily due to incompetence on the part of the filmmakers. A creature lurking in the shadows may cause one's hairs to stand on end, but an adrenaline-fueled physical struggle will feel like any other fight scene. Jordan Peele employs a unique solution to this problem by ending his movie with what could essentially be called a dance fight.

The final showdown in Us is choreographed in a very literal sense of the word, and it helps to maintain the unnerving atmosphere of the final setting. As Adelaide's fitful attacks are countered by Red's fluid movements, shots from a childhood ballet recital are interspersed throughout the scene. This is not a fight, but merely another macabre display of Red's cunning precision.

Red's dance maintains not only tension, but also theme. If not for Adelaide, Red never would have danced as a child. Now, Red has forced Adelaide into a dance that will leave her changed. The music cuts out as Adelaide savagely strangles her graceful opponent, and the two are finally untethered. Depending on the viewer's interpretation of the Tethered, Adelaide has now either joined the two parts of her soul or entirely destroyed the only version of it that truly existed. Either way, the curtain has fallen on the dance without cause for ovation.

Ballet's importance to the story may strike some viewers as odd, abruptly exposited in what feels like a late addition to the script. Nonetheless, it makes for one of the more memorable climaxes in recent horror films.


1. The Obvious Twist

Us Poster Adelaide Jordan Peele
Universal

Plenty of viewers will likely predict the final moments of Us within the first few minutes of the film. Twists may have worked in older films such as Psycho, but a generation of moviegoers trained by M. Night Shyamalan to look for twists in every ending can be difficult to take by surprise. The genius of Us, however, is that the film itself seems to be aware that its twist is obvious.

A lesser horror film might try to hide its twist through deception and plot holes, or simply tack on a twist that doesn't make sense in light of the preceding events. Instead, Us practically beats its viewers over the head with foreshadowing. From the moment Adelaide and Red meet in the hall of mirrors, it becomes clear that the little girl who returned to her parents was not the same one who wandered off at the boardwalk.

This actually works to the film's advantage. Audiences don't need to feign surprise at the final reveal, because the film's twist serves an entirely different purpose than to shock the viewer. Knowing Adelaide's past, we're left to decipher whether her past misdeeds truly define her in light of her clear dedication to the family she's protected throughout the film.

Clearly, the Tethered are capable of humanity, and Adelaide's past evils have not kept her from feeling love and developing a maternal instinct. At the same time, Adelaide achieved that humanity at the expense of an innocent life. If her goodness arose from evil, is she truly good? If Red's evil arose from being banished to a lesser caste, is she truly a villain or merely a victim of the most demented large-scale class segregation ever conceived?

Questions such as these are far more important to the film's ending than the mere element of surprise. Us is not a two-bit horror film that blows its final moments on cheap shock value. Us is the Nietzschean abyss of modern horror, asking viewers to look deeper into its message and staring back at them all the while.


In this post: 
Jordan Peele
 
Posted On: 
Contributor

Kieran enjoys overanalyzing and arguing about pop culture, believing that heated debates can (and should) be had in good fun. He currently lives in Fort Worth, TX, where he spends his time chatting with strangers on the bus and forcing them to look at pictures of his dog.