Vacation: 10 Ill-Advised Comedy Movie Comebacks
Enter a World of Walleys...
Get a comedy right on the big screen and you're headed for Big Money City on a diamond-encrusted chariot pulled by golden geese. You'll be the guy/girl who made the world blow hideously-priced popcorn and soda out their nose. And more importantly you can make several movies under the same banner and never be troubled by originality again.
Vacation was such a franchise, lasting so long it actually spanned the centuries between 1983 and 2003. Fuelled by the catchy theme song of Holiday Road by Lindsey Buckingham, the first instalment featured Clark and Ellen Griswold (Chevy Chase and Beverly D'Angelo), just your average, confused, horny American couple looking to give their family the break of a lifetime at a Disney-inspired theme park. National Lampoon provided the source of the original series and now Warner Bros fancies another roll of the dice with a modern take on the concept. Ed Helms and Christina Applegate play Rusty (Clark's supposedly grown up son) and his better half Debbie, who attempt to get their little angels to the legendary Walley World, a destination Chase was comedically determined to reach way back when.
Does the world need a continuation of this over-egged saga? Definitely not, though it won't stop the studio trying. The process of getting an audience to laugh can be the grimmest of businesses as you're about to discover here. Vacation 2015 is only the latest in a string of movie resurrections that seek to renovate some beloved, chuckle-inducing properties...
10. Kindergarten Cop 2
Nowadays the word "belated" means very little in the entertainment industry. Movies and shows are brought back with mind-boggling regularity. Every so often however a project is announced and the world sits up and goes "Whaaa?" We all knew Arnold Schwarzenegger was excavating his old characters, via Terminator: Genisys and the upcoming Conan The Barbarian: The Hip Replacement Years. But a Kindergarten Cop sequel? And without the Austrian Oak? That was a surprise.
Scary-looking Dolph Lundgren steps into the big fella's shoes. Strangely Lundgren is the actor who probably would have gotten the part in 1991, had Schwarzenegger and a couple of other people turned the movie down. This is certainly a rare foray into comedy to say the least.
A quarter of a century will have elapsed by the time the film is released, so producing this second chapter with a new lead character is a proper puzzle. I guess putting a number two in there (no sniggering please) may trick more people into renting the title. Judgment Day can be reserved for when KC2 is finished, though talk of an Indian sidekick suggests it could be a throwback in more ways than one.
9. Get Smart
Steve Carell is respected throughout the industry as a consummate comedy professional, further cementing his credentials recently by taking over from Bruce Willis on Woody Allen's latest project. Even so, he has signed on the dotted line for a variety of duds, including this big screen reboot of the 1960s spoof TV spy series.
The idea was simple - drop Carell into a wacky espionage scenario and watch the sparks fly. Unfortunately it became one of those movies where everyone showed up and had a good time, but forgot to make a decent film along the way. Even Anne Hathaway in a succession of fetching outfits couldn't electro-shock the comedic corpse back to life.
Carell's supporting cast were top drawer - as well as Hathaway, there was Alan Arkin and Dwayne Johnson. But they fought a losing battle, and their licence to thrill got swiftly revoked. The film's title should perhaps have given them some idea of the time they were going to waste in the first place!
8. The Three Stooges
As the original Stooges had long since departed to the great madhouse in the ether, it fell on the Farrellys to recast the line up. A foolhardy task to begin with it could be said, for characters embedded in the cultural make up of the nation, but eventually (after a decade or so of production wrangling) the roles were taken by Sean Hayes, Will Sasso and Chris Diamantopoulos.
In reverence to the established formula the action got split into three episodic chunks, packed with such sights as Larry David dressed as a nun and Sofia Vergara in scheming femme fatale mode. The head-slapping and "Nyuk Nyuk Nyuk"ing was in full effect, though the hilarious shadow of the original could never be escaped. A sequel is somewhat worryingly headed our way soon apparently.
7. Sgt Bilko
If one man sums up the spirit of American sitcom in the twentieth century it's Phil Silvers, aka Sgt Ernie Bilko. Fast-talking, slippery as an eel but oddly loveable throughout, his schemes at Fort Baxter soon passed into the TV Hall of Fame. With a grinning anti-hero in their living rooms ever week, viewers took Bilko straight to their hearts. Translating the format into a movie was never going to succeed without the late Mr Silvers.
Brit satirical supremo and Sgt. Bilko director Jonathan Lynn acknowledged the folly in a sense by casting Steve Martin in the title role, a much-admired talent who didn't physically resemble his predecessor. Dan Aykroyd, Phil Hartman, Glenne Headly (who'd made an excellent collaborator with Martin on Dirty Rotten Scoundrels) and Chris Rock filled out the cast, but they were essentially trying to climb a comedic Everest.
Silvers' presence was so unmistakeable, and so interwoven into the lives of potential cinema attendees, that the film became a stark lesson in treading on another man's territory. Martin should have taken the hint perhaps. Unfortunately he didn't, as a later entry on the list will demonstrate...
6. Dad's Army
It ended production in 1977, but the bumbling adventures of the Walmington-on-Sea Home Guard still play a big part on the BBC schedule on Saturday night. These aren't just characters who show up on DVD shelves and retrospective documentaries. They have the country rolling on the floor week on week, and in many ways it's like they never left. The cast were made up of a raft of elderly heavyweights, led by the chalk 'n cheese double header of Arthur Lowe and John Le Mesurier.
Looking at the cast for the upcoming 2016 movie, you can see that director Oliver Parker is taking his responsibilities seriously. Toby Jones, Bill Nighy, Michael Gambon and Tom Courtenay are just some of the stellar names hoping to breathe fresh life into the comic franchise. This is clearly seen as more than just another sitcom adaptation.
The question is, after all that effort, will it be worth it? It's a winning format but one that's been owned by other people for decades. The in-demand principals probably won't be clamouring to make lots of instalments, and even if they did the schedule-juggling would be a nightmare. Trying to replace the Rolls Royce of TV comedy for the sake of a film or two? Doesn't sound good to me.
5. St Trinians
Despite the decidedly old-fashioned approach the first entry proved a hit for Ealing Studios. The Legend Of Fritton's Gold followed, featuring David Tennant in one of the various agent-sacking roles he got after leaving Doctor Who. The madness seemed to end with part two, though a third adventure is still being talked about.
Yes the revived studio got some mileage out of their classic brand, and things were modernized a bit. Overall however this became a retrograde step. The original was never going to win any awards, but the new version saddled a decent cast with a poor script and an outdated Carry On-style sensibility.
4. Bewitched
844043Another mainstay of the US TV schedules was this supernatural sitcom, which starred Elizabeth Montgomery as Samantha Stephens, a witch trying to keep a low profile as a happy homemaker. It was brought back in territories around the world (including a weird attempt at a pilot by the BBC featuring Sheridan Smith) but it was decades after the original series when Hollywood decided to create a movie.
The relatively simple premise got jettisoned pretty quick, as writer/director Nora Ephron went high concept, fashioning the idea around Will Ferrell as an actor doing a remake of Bewitched. He casts Nicole Kidman as his perfect Samantha only to discover she is an actual purveyor of black cats and cauldrons.
This needlessly convoluted approach ensured critics and audiences placed a curse on the film, which underperformed at the box office. Not even support veterans Michael Caine and Shirley MacLaine could work the voodoo required to get the broomstick off the ground.
3. The Pink Panther
With the prize turkey of Sgt. Bilko stinking up his CV, you'd've thought Steve Martin would have given properties associated with another actor a wide berth. Sadly he didn't and distinct spinning noises were heard emanating from Peter Sellers' grave when The Pink Panther franchise returned in 2006.
Other players had taken on the role of walking disaster area Inspector Clouseau, from Alan Arkin to Roger Moore, but Sellers made that insane Frenchman his own. Martin is as good a performer as his forebear in many ways, and if he'd done this movie differently he may well have gotten away with it, even as the voice of reason was bellowing at him to stop.
The reboot led to two films, but the star went for some bizarre choices. The white hair + black moustache combination. The accent that was about as funny as garlic breath. Not to mention the downright baffling sequence where Clouseau was tied to a pole in the rain for no apparent reason whilst shouting "I would like to buy a hamburger!" Sellers' reputation as a master surrealist remained utterly untouched.
2. Vacation
National Lampoon's Vacation had a good run. The first film combined lowbrow antics with genuine heart. Chevy Chase played an incompetent guy who in the face of overwhelming odds wanted the best for his family. The Griswolds were about as far from perfect as you could get, and that was the point. European Vacation took the gang away from their native soil for a patchy sequel.
The years went by and the occasional return visit would be made - we spent Christmas with the Griswolds and watched Chase grow older. His kids underwent more facelifts than Doctor Who. It was reasonable to assume everything that could possibly be done had been done. However, as we know, very little in Tinseltown is reasonable.
You can argue the basic idea is straightforward and can be resurrected easily. Comedy road movies are after all a dime a dozen. And it makes sense that the little boy from the original instalment (Ed Helms as Rusty) would grow up and want to do the same thing as his Dad. Tying it to a series that burned itself out over a long number of years though? Not the greatest indicator of freshness. The critics, as you might expect, weren't in the holiday spirit. It may depress you to know the new movie has been a box office success so far.
1. Laurel & Hardy
Talk abounded across the century of a post-grave reunion between the most iconic film slapstick team of them all. John Goodman and Rowan Atkinson were in the frame at one point, but it came to nothing. The pair may well have thought the challenge too great. Fans across the world of all generations would agree they'd be right.
Nevertheless, a fine mess was gotten into with The All-New Adventures of Laurel & Hardy: For Love or Mummy, that saw the descendants of the pair caught up in Egyptian-themed mischief. Bronson Pinchot was Stan, Gailard Sartain was Olly. Producers had the confidence to add to the legend but balked at replacing the immortal double act. Instead they gave us great-nephews with exactly the same names and behaviour, which they didn't seem to understand would be equally disrespectful to aficionados.
Bypassing cinemas, this sorry chapter does the rounds on satellite TV - I only became aware of it by sheer chance during a channel hop - but has rightfully been consigned to the almighty wrong pile in the sky. Definitely one for the "I can't believe they made it!" file.
Do you agree with this list? Are there any misguided remakes you think we've left out? Be sure to let us know in the comments section.