Warcraft: 10 Reasons It's A Huge Disappointment

Prepare to cringe.

Warcraft Paula Patton
Universal

Duncan Jones' long-awaited Warcraft movie is finally rolling out internationally (ahead of its U.S. release on June 10th), and it's fair to say that critics aren't exactly in love with it so far.

Though fan response has been a little more forgiving, that most audiences not in total denial will at least appreciate that the film hasn't lived up to the potential of the iconic video game, even if they did ultimately enjoy it as a slice of big-budget fan service.

Whether or not it does well enough at the box office to get a sequel, Warcraft is unfortunately another underwhelming video game adaptation to add to the pile. Time to keep our collective fingers crossed that Assassin's Creed finally breaks the curse in December, then...

For now, here are 10 reasons Warcraft is a huge disappointment...

10. Awful Editing & Pacing

Warcraft Orgrim
Universal Pictures

One thing that's clear early on in the movie is that not even Oscar-winning editor Paul Hirsch could make much sense of what's going on.

Director Duncan Jones claimed this week that 40-or-so minutes were cut from the movie as mandated by Universal, resulting in an incredibly choppy, rushed final product, where Jones cuts hastily between various scenes and locations without allowing the audience to soak this wonderful world in.

That's not all, though: the fight scene editing is confusing and occasionally incomprehensible, and scene transitions often employ a crude cross-fade that makes the whole thing look laughably cheap and amateur.

Though Universal can only be blamed for some of these issues, it does suggest that their interference has severely compromised the end result.


9. Boring & Witless Dialogue

Warcraft Paula Patton
Legendary Pictures / Blizzard Entertainment

Alright, so a Warcraft movie doesn't need the wittiest or most insightful dialogue, but it would be nice if it were more than merely functional.

Jones and Charles Leavitt's script sadly takes the dullest, least imaginative route possible, saddling characters with heaps and heaps of expository dialogue that may have even the more lore-hungry audiences feeling a little exhausted.

The dialogue is almost entirely in the service of pushing the trite and generic plotting, so even attentive viewers may feel confused, bored and irritated.

And this is without even mentioning the film's woeful attempt to shove comedy into the mix (but more about that in a moment).

In short, the script may make you cringe more than you would hope for. Not good.


8. Practical & CGI Elements Clash Horribly

Warcraft Eagle
Universal

While there's no arguing that the CGI Orcs are the movie's easy highlight, the rest of the movie's visual effects palette simply isn't as refined or impressive.

Sadly, scenes featuring a mixture of live-action humans and CGI suffer in particular as a result of poor compositing, meaning that the practical sets and props end up looking rather cheap, like they belong in a low-budget BBC fantasy series.

Jones also doesn't help this by constantly cross-cutting between the gorgeously-rendered Orc scenes and the more awkward-looking human ones, highlighting the massive gulf of aesthetic quality between the two.

For a $160 million movie, is this level of visual inconsistency really acceptable? Parts of it look like a movie produced for about $100 million less than that.


7. The Tone Is All Over The Place

Warcraft Baby
Universal

Considering how utterly goofy Warcraft as a property is, it's stunning that Jones decided to go the almost totally earnest, self-serious route, treating the lore like it's Shakespeare and rendering it tiresome and dull as a result.

It's offputting as a viewer when something so blatantly daft is given such a joyless treatment, and yet the film's occasional divergences into humour also fall pathetically flat. One minute it's deathly serious, and the next...someone's getting turned into a sheep.

In what feels like it was mandated by a nervous studio, the script is occasionally obliged to include some cringe-worthy moments of "humour" and "comic relief", usually a quip from the mouth of protagonist Anduin.

The vast majority of these moments clash harshly with the more stern, gritty tone of almost everything else, and it doesn't help at all that they're mostly not funny at all.

Perhaps the most hardcore Warcraft fans might be able to put up with the film being so invested in its own being taken seriously, but for most others, it makes it all add up to a lot less fun.


6. Mostly Terrible Perfomances

Warcraft Ben Foster
Universal

Though Toby Kebbell's Orc Durotan steals just about every scene he's in, for the most part the human characters just can't measure up to the same level.

It doesn't help that the cast are saddled with a ropey script for the most part, but not a single human performance stands out as particularly compelling, with several proving downright bad.

The usually reliable Ben Foster is howlingly hammy as Medivh, mumbling his way through his placeholder dialogue while clearly thinking about what he'll spend his paycheck on.

Then there's Dominic Cooper, who looks tired and apparently wishes he was literally anywhere else, and Paula Patton, who as Garona Halforcen, has caught most of the flak online so far for her fairly wooden performance.

It takes an impressive kind of awful to wring such uninspired, even actively awful work in some cases, out of such a talented cast.


5. Generic & Dull Action

Warcraft Guldan
Universal

If there's one area where Warcraft would unquestionably succeed, it's the action, right? Well, aside from the fact that there's nowhere near as much of it as you would expect, the action that is there is for the most part overly familiar and just pretty...boring.

It's all hack-and-slash nonsense you've probably seen in about a dozen fantasy films before, and none of it feels particularly fresh or unique. It's serviceable at best, and ennui-inducing at worst.

There's just very little to distinguish it from other movies in the genre, and Jones doesn't manage to make it feel especially epic or exciting.

It also doesn't help that most of the action is broken up into chunks rather than sustained: Jones cuts to talkier scenes in-between all the fighting rather than just let us savour it.


4. It Never Makes You Care About The Characters

Warcraft Dominic Cooper
Universal

Warcraft is severely handicapped by needing to introduce such an absurdly large cast of characters that it never really has time to develop any of them in much depth at all.

Just remembering their names is tough enough, but this is complicated by the fact that many of them are killed off before we're able to form bonds with them or really give a damn about them dying.

Rather than feeling sad or angry, audiences will more likely shrug at the host of big characters who don't survive the film, because rarely are any of the characters (alive or dead) anything more than archetypes: the King, the eye candy, the family man, the villain, the second-in-command and so on. They're defined more by their job in terms of moving the plot forward rather than by who they are as a person or Orc.


3. Duncan Jones' Direction Is A Total Mess

Warcraft Duncan Jones
Universal

As brilliant as Duncan Jones' first two movies were (Moon and Source Code), Warcraft reeks of a director wholly out of his depth, tackling a budget that's almost $130 million more than either of his prior movies.

While Universal's meddling may be somewhat to blame, Jones' general direction is totally all over the place: as mentioned, the editing, visual effects and performances are a hot mess, and even Jones' shot selection just feels frequently uninspired, like we're watching a cheap costume drama from a no-name filmmaker.

The scene that best exemplifies how off-the-mark Jones' direction seems occurs late in the movie when a main character is killed off, but what should seem like an epic moment is curiously downplayed, draining the scene of almost all of its pathos and emotional potential. It's so bizarre considering how much we're asked to buy into said character throughout the film.

Then he's killed out of the blue and discarded for the remainder of the film with only one brief reference made to his death. How utterly bizarre and tone-deaf.


2. It Will Confuse Non-Fans

warcraft orc
Universal Pictures

While it's a given that the film will be infinitely more appealing to Warcraft fans, if Universal truly want the project to succeed, then it also has to have a broader appeal to the masses. After all, nobody green-lights a $160 million movie made solely for a fanbase, even one as large as Warcraft's.

Still, the film assumes you're fully swotted-up on your Warcraft lore and makes little attempt to include the uninitiated: the script flies through reams of names and places that are sure to throw non-fans or casuals, making it hard to get invested in the world or the people in it.

Sadly, they can't even just sit back and "enjoy the ride", because as mentioned, the action isn't very good either.


1. It Sets Up A Franchise...That May Never Happen

Warcraft Durotan
Universal

The most depressing truth of all is that, for all of the movie's faults, it sets up a huge, sprawling world with so much promise.

However, the fact that the film is tracking to have a soft opening at the U.S. box office may doom the potential franchise from the outset, and though international grosses could bail it out, there's no guarantee that we'll get another movie.

As bad as the film is, it would be disappointing if there's no second chance to remedy this, given the richness of the lore and the possibility of a vastly superior sequel. The next few weeks will be crucial in terms of finding out whether Warcraft is a viable cinematic brand or another curious failure.

What did you think of Warcraft? What do you make of the reviews so far? Shout it out in the comments!


In this post: 
Warcraft
 
Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

Stay at home dad who spends as much time teaching his kids the merits of Martin Scorsese as possible (against the missus' wishes). General video game, TV and film nut. Occasional sports fan. Full time loon.