What Critics HATED About Venom
And why you're going to love Tom Hardy's Spider-Man spin-off...
A Venom movie without Spider-Man was always going to be somewhat divisive, but let's get this straight right away: by hiring Tom Hardy, Riz Ahmed and Michelle Williams, Sony did serious work to convince us all that it wouldn't be a problem. There was SURELY no way those talents would sign on for a bad movie, let alone making one to completion.
But it seems that something went wrong, at least in terms of the critical response to the movie. Currently, Ruben Fleischer's spin-off sits on 30% on RottenTomatoes, which is disastrous, considering Justice League sits on 40%, The Amazing Spider-Man on 52% and on X-Men: The Last Stand 58%. All of those were effectively franchise killers (or at least required serious rethinking) and Sony apparently have big plans for their Spider-Verse.
Luckily for the studio, there's some hope that fans will react better to the movie (and they should because it has some seriously great moments and lots of promise for a sequel). If that's going to happen though, they're going to have to address why critics hated it...
6. The First Half Is Pretty Dull
Venom has an identity crisis, ironically, and the biggest problem comes in the first half before we get to see the symbiote and Brock bond. It all feels like an outdated, dull attempt to set up a conventional horror movie that is never coming. The major story beats are derivative at best and cliched at worst but the really fatal issue is that it's just so damn boring.
In actual fact, everything that isn't directly tied up in Tom Hardy as Eddie Brock or Venom or both is pretty dull. Which should hopefully mean the sequel will pull focus onto them more.
5. The Writing Is TERRIBLE At Times
This is not a very well written movie at all. Sure, there's lots of pleasure to be had in the dynamic and dialogue between Venom and Brock (both in his head and out loud) but most of the characters are poorly written, most of the rest of the dialogue is rote or mind-numbing dumb and most of the motivations are entirely absent.
Brock is painted as an idiot for most of the movie, Michelle Williams' Annie floats in and out only as the plot requires and Riz Ahmed's sub-Elon Musk villain is a mess. Nothing any of them says to each other really rings true and it's only when Brock becomes completely self-aware and unhinged that his dialogue gets a logical context.
Whole plot elements are dropped or unexplored as something else becomes important and the over-riding feeling is that the script needed a lot more work.
4. The Action Is Sloppy
As several of the more scathing reviews have pointed out, the action in Venom leaves a lot to be desired. The effects are mostly brilliant, so that's not where the problem lies, though. The real issue is in the way the action is choreographed.
Aside from the first time we see Venom really taking hold of Eddie for a fight, the choreography is uninspired and lacks any sort of real directing flair that isn't obliterated by the necessary framing of heavy duty effects work. There's no personality and even being able to focus on Venom in them is rather difficult at times.
Worst of all, the climax that we're sold as a major sequence ends up lasting a surprisingly short amount of time. Riot is not the major threat he's billed as, the fight does not have insurmountable odds and even the emotional weight in there is undone by the speed with which any real danger is dealt with.
3. The Supporting Characters
Tom Hardy is a phenomenal actor and he's watchable in just about everything. In truth, if you make a bad movie with Tom Hardy in, there's something wrong with your ability as a film-maker. It's just science.
Unfortunately, the same cannot now be said of Michelle Williams or Riz Ahmed who are lumbered with a bad script and too little character development or focus to really matter. If you remove them both from the film, it's hard to even argue that it wouldn't be a worse movie.
Nobody else even comes close to mattering either and it all feels a little like Deadpool again, only with a slightly less compelling central character to rescue the film from the poor points. It's a shame, but hopefully there's a lesson here for sequels if they come.
2. They Didn't Understand The Comedy
Bafflingly, a lot of the reviews that came out earliest before the release (you may not have noticed them, given how tightly Sony squished the embargo to the release) seemed to suggest that their writers didn't know whether they were supposed to be laughing. They absolutely were, because the script has very obvious gags in that are designed to laugh, but it suggests a pretty big problem.
Perhaps it's because of the tonal issues early on or the identity crisis that smashes jokes against po-faced series portions, but it seems to have been a real thing for some critics that the comic thrust of the writing isn't obvious. They missed out, so it's difficult to suggest that there's any sort of wilful ignorance going on. Clearly, it's a problem with how the film transmits its own identiy.
And do you know WHY so many critics hated it? Well, there's a bit theory about what was to blame...
1. The Marketing SUCKED
There's a pretty big problem with Venom that has destabilised expectations of it and which undoubtedly has had some impact on the critical reception. The trailers suggest it's an R-Rated body shock horror movie that sees Venom arriving fully-formed. It is not that. It's not even close to that.
Instead, Venom is a pitch black comedy wrapped up in something else that SHOULD have been marketed more inline with Deadpool. That would have served the film well and made it a FAR easier sell, but you get the sense that Sony consciously did that in other to avoid direct, unfavourable comparisons. That's a shame too, because more confidence would have served this film hugely well.
The best thing you can do as a fan is to reject all expectations based on the marketing and go in with as clear a mind as possible. Don't think of it as a horror, don't think about it as a competitor to the MCU, don't even listen to what the cast and crew are saying about it.
Know this only: Venom is great when it's great and really does deserve your attention. Particularly for Tom Hardy's excellent, odd performance. If nothing else, that's worth the ticket price.