Why Dolittle Just Disastrously Flopped

Is it enough of a bomb for Downey Jr. to come back to playing Iron Man?

Dolittle poster
Universal

Dr. Dolittle is a beloved English character from a series of children's books written in the first half of the 20th century, and it's easy to see how a high budget star-studded movie adaptation seemed like a good idea on paper. After all, it's not like this is the first time Hollywood has tried with this property: there's just something about the idea of a man gifted with the magical ability to speak to animals. It's one of those essential "what if" stories that drives Hollywood and that's probably what attracted Robert Downey Jr to it.

Sadly, for everyone involved in the latest adaptation, the reality was quite different. The charm of the now retired Avengers star alone should have made the movie a success but it didn't. It bombed and it bombed hard. When the closest comparison everyone's looking at is whether it's worse than the abomination that was Cats or not, you know something bad is up.

And while he might be the one who takes the greatest portion of flack - because his name's above the door - ex-Iron Man isn't the one to blame. The reality of Dolittle is that the whole production and release of this film was troubled and riddled with the kind of problems you don't just shrug off.

That said, no-one ever intentionally sets out to make a bad movie. So the question here is what exactly went wrong. And while it's tempting to just say everything, there are some very specific issues that led to the film becoming the first big disaster movie of 2020.

3. The First Disastrous Decisions

Dolittle Robert Downey Jr
Universal Pictures

While it might look like something of an odd choice for Downey Jr to from Tony Stark to the flamboyant English doctor, you can see why the actor would pick up this kind of project. Not only does the property come with the promise of a captive audience (Hollywood seeks money where it's already found it before, no matter how long ago) but it also represented an opportunity for the actor to distance himself from the role that has defined his career for the past decade.

So his reasoning was sound and the studio's reasoning for making another Dolittle movie is BASICALLY sound. It's just a dangerous game to follow the same logic that led to studios making new takes on Robin Hood and King Arthur recently - i.e. the fact that they are established characters - and assuming that star power is enough to make context and ACTUAL audience interest not matter.

And on top of that rocky starting point, the production made some pretty catastrophic errors.

It all starts with a weird choice for a director and screenwriter. He may have proved himself a great film-maker working on award-winning crime dramas and geopolitical thrillers, but Stephen Gaghan wouldn't be many people's first choice when it comes to creating a fun family comedy. So the fact that he was the one the studio turned to is a little odd at very best.

In broad terms, Gaghan does look like the kind of professional that could produce a sure-fire film regardless of the theme - because class is permanent - but something was very wrong from the get-go. Set reports leaked from apparently disgruntled employees calling the director "batsh*t" and lambasting his methods ahead of him being fired in all but official name and replaced by Chris McKay as the writer and Jonathan Liebesman as director.

Here's what one whistleblower allegedly said:

“It was deep in production hell last year, they started filming scenes before they had even planned where the animated animals would be standing, it was nuts. And then the batshit director went and got fired, which was a little too late after his insane outbursts and subsequent banning from stepping foot into both the lead concept department AND the lead Pre-visual animation department.”

If the rumours are to be believed, the issue came down to Gaghan simply not having the experience to make a heavily CGI-led movie. Which meant his approach to shooting such a film was just completely wrong:

“Then he demanded that the previsual department be fired because ‘We can figure it out on the day”, yeah Stephan, you can figure out where 5+ animated characters and Robert.D.Jr are standing when you have 30 individual camera shots to film on a Monday morning, you f*cking moron.”

Technically speaking, the film does look well-shot, even despite those alleged issues, which shouldn't come as a surprise given the director's pedigree, but it was so lacking in the necessary family fun department that reshoots were inevitable. Because smushing the badly fitting jigsaw pieces of the wrong director and a movie he's entirely unsuited to was never going to make a satisfying end product on the first go.

[Continued: Page 1 of 3]


2. The Wrong Tone

Dr Dolittle
Disney

Way back in fall of 2018, according to THR, Universal Studios executives saw the first cut of and immediately identified the issues. Primarily, it wasn't funny and far stranger, it didn't include anything like the amount of CGI they had expected it to. It also came with a downer ending, because everyone knows that's what the family audience wants to see.

Flash forward a couple of years, after the reshoots and presumably, the studio were happy to accept that adding a constipated dragon to punch-up "a morose father-son story" was a good idea.

It could actually have been different, because Seth Rogen was lined up to be the man to fix things and he consulted on the reshoots before a scheduling conflict meant he and Neighbors co-writer Brendan O’Brien had to drop out. Their almost-hiring suggests that Universal had a very clear idea of what they wanted the film to be in tone and then they asked Chris McKay - who was then replaced by screenwriter John Whittington - and Jonathan Liebesman to put it together. They did not succeed.

Reshoots are a wholly normal thing for a movie this size, and Marvel proved time and again that it can actually make the end results better but Dolittle just became a bad case of "too many cooks in one kitchen" with the lack of one clear vision. That wasn't helped at all by the appalling script or the strange approach to story that seemed to suggest that the film never quite nails down what it thinks it's supposed to be.

Combine that with a huge level of creative control RDJ and his wife allegedly sought on set and you'll have a mess with neither adults nor their kids getting anything out of. It was Downey Jr who came up with the now-notorious dragon enema scene, having ripped up John Whittington's suggested rewrites. Apparently, the actor thought that was just the cherry the film needed.

And that's the problem with RDJ having had so much success in the MCU: he's now got to accept the fact that he cannot be the primary creative influence on his characters.

Tony Stark was lightning in a bottle and the circumstances of the actor coming to that role - when Marvel needed him to be the perfect candidate and he needed the role to revive his career - and then becoming such a founding stone of an entire shared universe will never happen again. Not ever. They bred certain very specific conditions for Downey Jr on set that meant he COULD control what he did in those movies, just as he basically had carte blanche to ask for however much money he required to do it.

In the end, the movie's horrible box office performance isn't helped by the fact that it could never have been cheap to make. The CGI was one thing, but amassing a cast of such huge talent doesn't come cheap either and an estimated budget of $175m and about the same thrown as good money after bad on the marketing campaign means you're looking at around $350m before it could break even. Again, the Cats comparison is pertinent, because that film cost around $90m before marketing and now looks like an absolute bargain.

An MCU movie with Robert Downey Jr in could make that with its eyes closed. A Dr Dolittle movie would always struggle.

[Continued: Page 2 of 3]


1. The Final Nails

Dolittle Robert Downey Jr
Universal Pictures

This is, after all, a franchise that only worked relatively recently on the big screen because of the transgressive nature of Eddie Murphy's version. His Dr Dolittle was a completely new creation with the old character's powers but little else linking the pair. It was a revisionist rather than a nostalgic approach and it worked for that very reason.

For Universal to then believe that going back to the source for a more pure adaptation would work is just numb-headed. The franchise's last book was released 70 years ago and the source material simply has not aged well. There is no nostalgia factor here other than recognition of the character and the vain hope that the central acting performance and the starry cast could make it relevant for a new audience. That never goes well.

It's not even fair to say that RDJ does well with the movie's material. He struggles manfully with a poor script and a ridiculous premise, but his acting decisions should definitely raise an eyebrow too. His accent is horrific and there's more of Johnny Depp hamming it up here than any of the understated brilliance of his Tony Stark.

And it's almost as if Universal knew how big of a disappointment it was going to be since they pushed the release date for Dolittle to January, a month for films studios have no faith in. For it to then have to compete with the surprisingly popular Bad Boys threequel and Sam Mendes' stunning 1917 was just an added blow. Will Smith and Martin Lawrence dominated the box office, Dolitle brought in just over $125m and the turkey status was confirmed.

There is some hope to be had in the fact that there are other markets yet to open, including the UK, but whether the film manages to claw back any of its projected $100m or so loss on those screens remains to be seen. It's rare when it happens at the best of times.

Now the question is this, how will that affect Robert Downey Jr.'s career and what will be his next move? He is no stranger to starring in awful movies (just look at The Shaggy Dog), and the last Avengers paycheck is still putting food on the table to put it lightly so he doesn't need to worry about that either, but it's hard not to think that the way he's perceived in Hollywood have almost certainly have changed.

Hell, who knows, maybe this might make him rethink never playing Tony Stark again...?


Watch Next


We love teamwork! Who doesn't? This article is a collaborative effort between Alexander Kiryushkin and Simon Gallagher.
In this post: 
Dolittle
 
Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

Designer by day - musician and writer by night.

Contributor
Contributor

WhatCulture's former COO, veteran writer and editor.