Why Halloween (2018) Is Scarier Than You Think
Michael Myers is back, and this time, stalking isn't on the agenda.
Halloween 2018, set 40 years after Michael Myers' infamous return to Haddonfield, is a brilliant return to form for the franchise, and perhaps the only other genuinely great entry in the series. It isn't without its flaws of course, and it's not nearly half as scary as the original, but it does tell a truly intelligent story and features one of the most gripping finales the slasher genre has ever seen.
David Gordon Green's film has only been in the spotlight for just under a month now, but it understands what many other Halloween films haven't: the nature of Michael Myers, and what makes him such a terrifying and enduring horror villain. It does this by providing clever commentary on the series' history, rooted directly in previous depictions of the character, but also by paying homage to and by depicting a totally new version of Michael. He's still The Shape, and he still boasts that slow, methodical walk, but he's not the same - not quite.
This is a new kind of Halloween. Myers doesn't stalk, he doesn't stare, and he doesn't pause - three elements that made John Carpenter's original Halloween so suspenseful. Instead, he moves along at a terrifying pace, ghosting from house to house like a literal bogeyman - one who, in 2018, doesn't have the time to indulge in his own voyeuristic tendencies.
For fans of the original Halloween, such a change may even make the character of Michael less terrifying, less unique, and perhaps even less interesting, but there's a genuinely unnerving reason for this change in Michael's MO, and one that makes Halloween (2018) every bit the bone-chilling watch it was originally touted to be.
5. The Night HE Came Home...
In order to understand Michael as he is today, we must first understand the character as he was forty years ago - an institutionalised 20-something who returned to the town of his birth to relive his most impactful childhood memory, and terrorise Middle America in the process.
There are plenty of reasons for why Michael Myers is the horror genre's most terrifying figure - the fact he kills without rhyme or reason, his ghostly movement and that iconic mask - but one of the biggest stems from the fact this horrifying journey all began at the tender age of six. The murder of Judith Myers is so unnerving because it stems from the most sterile image of America that can be conjured - a young child, raised in a suburban town in the middle of the country, dressing up for a cherished holiday. Carpenter himself conceived of Halloween's story by drawing from the idea that every town has its secret - "there's always a house down the lane that somebody was killed in, or that somebody went crazy in" - and that's what makes it such an effective piece of cinema; Haddonfield, in essence, could be anyone's town. All that's missing is a freshly baked pie cooling on an open windowsill.
But there's another side of the coin with Halloween, and it lies in the genesis of Michael Myers. According to Carpenter, the idea for the character stemmed from a visit he'd undertaken to a Kentucky Institution, where he witnessed a young boy with a blank, expressionless stare. This would later inform Doctor Loomis' iconic description of the character during the second half of the film, although there's something just as important that should be noted.
Myers is institutionalised at a young age, and when he breaks out, he retains an almost childlike persona. The first thing on his agenda once he breaks out is to break into a halloween store and steal a mask, before he travels to the home of his parents. He literally retraces his steps, and then cruelly, methodically, stalks the first person he happens upon. He toys with his victims in a ruthless game of hide and seek, just as he did in 1963 with his sister, because it's all he knows, and all he's been waiting for.
It's also the chief reason for why Halloween is so terrifying, and though it may not seem that way at first, it too informs the new sequel in a pretty significant way.
4. Halloween's (1978) Most Terrifying Moments Happen During The Day
Many point towards Carpenter and Debra Hill's Halloween as the birthplace of the slasher genre, and they'd be correct. The film pioneered so many of the genre's tropes, but it's also a slasher unlike any other. For starters, it's nowhere near as violent as its later relatives would become, and most of the suspense is actually derived during the day, building tension to an almost unbearable level as night descends on Haddonfield, and the inevitable follows.
In a great many ways, it's Halloween's earliest moments that are its most terrifying. From the moment Michael emerges into view from behind the door of the Myers house and begins breathing heavily, to the moment where Laurie Strode (Jamie Lee Curtis) looks out of the classroom window and sees The Shape fixated on her, Halloween revels in making the audience feel both helpless and uncomfortable, as daylight itself falls victim to Myers' campaign of terror.
How does this relate to the new Halloween? Well, Michael spends no time at all stalking, biding his time, or toying with his victims. Once he arrives in Haddonfield, he starts killing instantly. It's almost second nature, and though it could be argued that the film loses a key component of Michael's horror in not having him observe his victims the way he used to, the shift in approach actually begets a terrifying revelation - one that lies directly in Myers' institutionalisation, and in previous depictions of the character onscreen.
3. 40 Years, Dwelling On Only One Thing...

Which brings us (perhaps belatedly) to David Gordon Green's Halloween. Taking place 40 years after the Babysitter Murders (a clever callback to Halloween's original working title), the film sees Michael Myers return to Haddonfield for one more night, with a now traumatised Laurie Strode determined to do what Loomis couldn't, and kill The Shape for good.
Halloween borrows plenty of different elements from the franchise's sequels, but most comparisons seem to reference Halloween: H20, the first of the franchise's sequels that decided to do away with previous continuity and start afresh. The difference now, however, is that this new Halloween has dropped the familicide angle entirely, restoring Michael to his true, terrifying and motive-less self. This places 'the night he came home' in a completely different context, and positions Laurie as a victim of happenstance, rather than as the intended target of Michael's sibling bloodlust.
The most fascinating thing about the new movie, however, is that it appears as though the murder of Judith Myers no longer takes primacy in Michael's memories. Whereas before he was acting on childhood instinct, now he's reliving the memory of 1978. Of course he reacts to Doctor Sartain's utterance of Judith, but the interaction Michael has with Oscar (Drew Scheid) underneath the motion-sensor lights clues us in on where the character currently is - at least tacitly.
Oscar, in a drunken stupor - and believing that Michael is actually just an upset neighbour - asks him one question: "have you ever known one girl you couldn't have?" This is a pretty blatant reference to Laurie, the sole survivor of the 1978 murders, and though this is about as close to a motive as we can ascribe to Michael's return, all his victims - bar perhaps the journalists in possession of his ghostly mask - are also victims of happenstance, just as Laurie and her friends were 40 years earlier.
That's what makes this new film so terrifying. Michael's no longer reliving a childhood memory, but instead the murders of 1978. The senseless nature of his violence is exemplified through that opening tracking shot, where he moves from building to building, and the lack of pause - whether to stalk or observe - is thoroughly disquieting.
2. Trying To Explain The Inexplainable

Halloween makes an effort of proving that Michael Myers cannot be explained, and goes so far as to kill those who dare try. Not only does this appear to be some sort of meta commentary on the previous evolution of the franchise, where various motives were ascribed to the character, from Druid cults to broken homes, it also serves a purpose in restoring The Shape to true bogeyman status.
Early on in the film we are introduced to the character of Dr. Ranbir Sartain, dubbed contemptuously as "the new Loomis" by Laurie. Unlike Loomis, Sartain is completely and utterly fascinated by Myers, to the point of obsession. It's heavily implied that he manufactured Michael's escape, and he does it all in a vein attempt to understand his personality. The issue here, of course, it that Michael is pure evil - the kind that no one could ever hope to rationalise, explain, or explicate.
Any attempt to understand Myers in this film is met with aggressive violence, and that cuts to the very core of the character. He does what he does not because of any particular drive - he is just evil given human form. That's far more terrifying than anything an origin or convoluted backstory could convey, and it's partially why the new film is so unnerving.
1. How Ruthless Brutality Became Michael's Defining Trait
There's a striking moment that occurs midway through the new Halloween, where Michael first arrives in Haddonfield. The film has recently wrapped up its terrifying truck stop sequence (what many would consider its scariest moment), and Myers has returned home once again. He walks along the street, until he bumps into a couple of trick-or-treaters, and then slowly turns a corner. He finds a hammer, enters the closest home to him, and brutally murders the only adult occupant inside. Immediately after, he picks up a kitchen knife resting on a table, and moves onto the house next door, repeating the process as a young woman begins to settle down for the evening.
First of all, there are many similarities between this sequence and the opening shot in the Carpenter movie. It's all accomplished in one take, there are two moments where perspective switches to the killer's point of view, and it even mirrors certain sound effects from the original film. It's a textbook homage to Carpenter and Hill's classic (with a brief nod to Halloween II's opening as well), but it also illustrates how cold, brutal, and ruthless Myers is.
Sure, there's an argument to be made that this devolves the film into 'more splatter, less slasher', but it's just as effective. It's also done in a way that retains The Shape's signature spookiness, while at the same time elevating the character to new levels of brutality in a brand new context - one that places the Babysitter Murders, and not the murder of Judith, as Myers' defining event.