World War Z: 5 Pros & Cons
It wasn't that long ago when Paramount's $190 million investment, a loose adaptation of Max Brooks' novel World War Z was thought to be the next high-profile Hollywood bomb. The behind-the-scenes drama that plagued the troubled production seemed to be more interesting than the actual movie, especially when the studio announced last fall that they were reshooting the entire third act. Blockbusters are typically subject to short reshoot periods, but this was something unheard of. People were writing the obituary long before the project hit theaters. And yet, reports of World War Z's demise were greatly exaggerated. Securing mostly positive reviews from critics (68% on Rotten Tomatoes), the zombie thriller has become a big hit with audiences. Grossing a surprising $66 million here in the States over its opening weekend, Brad Pitt's latest made enough to finish second at the box office, knocking Man of Steel off of its perch. It still has a long way to go to make back its budget, but the film is more successful than anyone could have imagined. Turns out casual moviegoers don't care about production woes. When I named this one of the 15 Films You Need To See In 2013, I wrote: "Most of the films on this list Im expecting to be of high quality and end up earning a spot in my home video collection. Others are here more out of curiosity than anything else. Brad Pitts zombie adventure World War Z is one of those films."It's true. I wasn't expecting World War Z to be any good at all. The turmoil surrounding the film made me interesting in seeing how the final product came out, but that was it. Now that I've seen it, I have to say the movie is actually solid entertainment. It's not great and it won't be remembered as one of the year's best, but I was pleasantly surprised with World War Z's quality. Still, there were some things that they could have done better. Here are the pros and cons of World War Z. WARNING: THIS ARTICLE CONTAINS SPOILERS FOR WORLD WAR Z
Pro: Gerry Lane
There was a lot of outrage from fans of the source material when it was revealed that the movie World War Z would deviate greatly from the original book. Instead of telling the "oral history of the zombie war," Marc Forster's adaptation would focus on U.N. employee Gerry Lane (played by Pitt) who is forced to leave his family behind as he goes on a globetrotting adventure searching for a cure to the zombie outbreak. I'm guessing the filmmakers made this decision in order to make World War Z more cinematic and the Gerry Lane character is one of the biggest bright spots in the whole film. It's not the role moviegoers will always associate with Pitt (a certain Mr. Durden claimed that title long ago), but the actor gives a very nice performance as an everyman thrown into an extraordinary situation. Gerry is an easy character to relate to and root for. He possesses all the qualities you would want to see in a movie hero. He's selfless (he's always concerned about what's best for his family). He's resourceful (he quickly picks up on strategies to gain the upper hand against the zombies) and he's willing to sacrifice himself for the greater good (the nail-biting climax in the tense third act). When he completes his goal and is reunited with his family at the end of the movie, you feel happy. While a faux documentary featuring "interviews" with "survivors" of a war could have been an interesting route to take, reworking the narrative and creating Gerry Lane was a wise choice both from a business (this type of film is easier to market) and artistic (Gerry Lane makes it easier for the viewers to experience to film's events) perspective.
Con: Uninteresting Supporting Characters
There's a scene in JJ Abrams's Super 8 where Charles explains to Joe why he wrote a love interest for the hero in his short film. Charles says that giving the main character a wife makes it easier for the audience to care about what happens because you want to see the two of them get back together. That's all I could think of whenever Gerry's family was on-screen (coincidentally, World War Z and Charles's short film in Super 8 revolve around a man investigating a zombie outbreak. Go figure). They seemed to exist for the sole purpose of making the movie more emotionally engaging. Outside of that, they didn't so much of anything. They weren't critical to the overall story. But World War Z has a bigger problem that goes beyond Gerry's family. There isn't a single interesting supporting character in the entire movie. It's a pity because a lot of films feature side characters that steal the show and become just as memorable as the main character (see: Joker, The; Candie, Calvin; Eklund, Dickie; DeVito, Tommy; Landa, Hans; Kyle, Selina). Populating your movie with a whole cast of great characters - and not just one main one - helps elevate your film and make it special. Pitt's supporting players are essentially walking plot devices. Gerry's friend Thierry is there to set the plot in motion. The soldier Segen is there to help Gerry discover the cure. Other characters Gerry meets throughout the film spout exposition-heavy dialogue and then leave. Outside of Gerry, nobody is given anything interesting to do, which is disappointing. He's the only character with anything resembling an arc. Since they threw the source material out the window, maybe they could have given Gerry a sidekick character that teams up with him and goes through his own changes. Maybe his wife could have been a doctor and helped people in a lab develop a cure (weak example, I know...). I just wish Gerry wasn't the only memorable character from World War Z. There won't be any Best Supporting Actor nominations here.
Pro: The Zombies
Considering Foster is the same guy who nearly derailed the Daniel Craig James Bond era with the incoherent Quantum of Solace, it's a minor miracle the set pieces of World War Z are great. All of them are tense, action-packed, and exciting (especially that scene in the plane...). Part of what makes them so successful is the fact that the zombies are very fast. I liked this because it helped add to the drama and made the infected more of a threat. When you see hordes of zombies stacking on top of each other to scale walls and chase people through streets, you hold your breath and hope for the best because these guys are tough to beat. It was a smart story choice to make the zombies sprint towards their prey as opposed to having them plod along. From a technical standpoint, the special effects were terrific. There was a lot of doubt expressed when some CGI-heavy clips were featured in trailers, but the post-production team did a great job at making everything look realistic. It was the right call to combine practical zombie makeup with computer graphics in order to avoid any I Am Legend type disasters during the creature design. That decision helped make the outbreak and the zombies feel more real and added something to the movie. It didn't just look like one big video game. I knew when CGI was used, but it was difficult to tell the difference at some points. But not EVERYTHING about the zombies was great...
Con: Where's The Gore?
Being a PG-13 zombie flick, World War Z got a lot of flack for going after the more family-friendly rating from fans of the genre. To paraphrase YouTube legend ItsJustSomeRandomGuy in this video, when parents have the choice to take their children to see the latest Pixar film or a movie about the zombie apocalypse, I'm sure they'll appreciate having options. In all seriousness, I do understand the decision to make it PG-13. What I don't understand is how bloodless the whole affair was. I'm not saying they should be emulating the Candyland Shootout from Django Unchained, but I swear there was more blood in the scene where Carl Fredricksen hits the construction worker over the head with his cane in Up than there was in whole movie of World War Z. This should not happen. I'm not well-versed in the zombie and horror genres, but I do know that gore and bloody violence are big parts of what make them a favorite among moviegoers. While the zombie sequences were thrilling to watch, I think they would have been augmented somewhat with the inclusion of some more brutality. I don't know if the filmmakers should have just gone all in and targeted an R rating (and we all know that there's a market for R-rated horror films), but if they wanted to keep it PG-13, there's ways to push boundaries and still get away with it. For the most part, the action bits were pretty clean and sterile, even when Gerry hacked off a soldier's hand to prevent an infection. Part of me just thought this was odd. The lack of gore didn't hurt the film that much, but more blood and violence would have made World War Z better. Fans of the genre expect this stuff and they're no doubt disappointed by this decision.
Pro: The Filmmakers Amending Their Mistakes
World War Z seriously seemed doomed when it was announced that Paramount hired Damon Lindelof and Drew Goddard to rewrite the film's climactic act once it was determined what was originally shot wasn't any good. An expensive, seven-week reshoot schedule was set and all our fears about the product struggling were put to rest once we finally got to see the finale. Shifting the action from a battle in Russia to the interior of a W.H.O. building, the scaled-back, more dramatic third act is one of the most tense ends to a film I've seen in recent memory. In order to get supplies needed to develop a vaccine of sorts (Gerry discovers that people with terminal illnesses are invisible to the zombies, so his plan is to get samples of diseases and inject people with curable sicknesses in order for humanity to survive), Gerry and the doctors must get from one end of the building to the other as quietly as possible so they don't attract the attention of the infected (the zombies are stimulated by sound). Did it seem like something out of a video game level? Maybe. But I was on the edge of my seat the whole time. It was a wild ride the whole way through. It was a well-constructed sequence that felt like something out of a horror film. The revised third act also gives the filmmakers an opportunity to provide Gerry with a standout character moment that defines his personality. When a zombie is blocking the exit from the sample vault, Gerry decides to test his hypothesis on himself and injects a terminal virus in his veins (the stakes are raised even more when the doctors say certain ones Gerry has will kill him immediately). He writes a note reading "tell my family I love them" and shows it to a security camera where the doctors can see and rolls the dice. It was a heartfelt, emotional scene and I applaud the filmmakers for this. I was certainly not expecting a big-budget film like this to end in such a tender, touching fashion. Of course, Gerry lives and the humans develop the vaccine and start to fight back, but the biggest thing here is the fact that everyone involved with World War Z knew they were wrong and admitted their mistake. This kind of honesty is rare in Hollywood. Paramount had already spent a lot of money making this movie before the third act rewrite was sanctioned and they very easily could have released the original movie and put out an inferior product. By remaking the third act, it raised the budget and they face an uphill climb to turn a profit, but at least Forster, Pitt, and the execs at Paramount can say they made a film they were proud of. It was a triumph of art over money. You don't see this stuff happen every day (and thankfully, not every blockbuster undergoes the same troubles World War Z did), but it was nice to see them amend their mistakes and fix what was wrong. Let's just hope they learned their lesson and when World War Z: Part Two is being written, they get it right the first time around. What did you think of World War Z? Let us know in the comments below!