X-Men: 7 Best & 7 Worst Casting Decisions In The Franchise So Far

For every Hugh Jackman, there's a Halle Berry.

Thanks to the head-turning success of X-Men: Days Of Future Past, the franchise that Bryan Singer built and then arguably rebuilt is once again a big topic. Though it might not have quite the irresistible traction of the Avengers universe, fans still pour into cinemas in their millions to see X-Men movies, with even the worst two films in the series pulling in relatively major chunks of money, and it's remarkably good to see the quality of the product match the expectations and excitement of the fan-base. Some will still queue up to stick the knife in on the franchise, exaggerating issues on Singer's new sequel, or wilfully ignoring the value in his agenda, because for all of its successes, and its moments of excellence, the franchise has made some serious missteps - not only in hiring directors unworthy of the task, but also in story execution and directing decisions. And one area of the series that has been somewhat notoriously hit and miss is the casting: for every perfectly pitched choice, there has been a Halle Berry - and there's nothing can leave quite as bad a taste in the mouth as the presence of a Halle Berry. With that in mind, we're looking at the very best and the disappointingly worst casting decisions in the franchise so far. First up, the best casting decisions...

7. Kelsey Grammer - Beast (X-Men: The Last Stand)

Though some of the special effects in the climactic battle of The Last Stand were questionable at best (apparently suggesting that Beast could somehow fly at one stage), there's not a lot wrong with The Last Stand's iteration of the second most famous blue character in the X-Men movie universe. The script might not be quite there, and he's not on screen long enough - especially when you consider the Thanks to the combination of his imposing physique and his notorious loquaciousness, Kelsey Grammer was always the most likely to play Beast as an older, wiser head, and his characterisation of the tamed beast working with the government fit his on screen persona well, without compromising the physical threat of the character. Though the majority of The Last Stand was jettisoned in Bryan Singer's franchise fixer, it felt like a fitting nod to how well Grammer was suited to the role that he was invited back (though ultimately he could only commit to a cameo thanks to Transformers 4).

6. Ryan Reynolds - Wade Wilson (X-Men Origins: Wolverine)

It may seem somewhat at odds with the general acceptance of Origins as the worst ever X-Men movie to have an actor who was a major part of what was worst about the film included in a run down of the best casting decisions in the franchise, but there are few actors who would ever be as perfect for the role of Wade Wilson than Reynolds. Though the film completely ruined the good work done in casting Reynolds by turning Deadpool into a joke with the spectacularly stupid Weapon XI arc, and robbed the world of a chance to see him under the iconic hood, Reynolds' diamond-sharp tongue and facetious charisma was the perfect answer to the requirements of the character. If anything, everything that made Reynolds so perfect for the role should have been pushed further: Deadpool is designed to be obnoxious, frustrating and comical, and in Reynolds' hands he could have been, if he wasn't saddled with such a poor script and direction. We can only hope the mooted stand-alone movie actually happens.

5. Alan Cumming - Nightcrawler (X2)

Despite how pleasant it might be to think of Neil Patrick Harris under lots of dark blue make-up using his theatrical skills to give the circus mutant a flamboyant edge, X-Men fans really have to be thankful he never made it past the audition stage, since the man who got the job was so pitch perfect. Cumming's casting was at least partly helped by his fluency in German - an essential element of the character - but it was his ability to segue between ferocious exoticness and brilliantly intelligent vulnerability that made Nightcrawler such a key figure in X2, even despite a limited amount of screen time. Sadly, Cumming wasn't invited back for the sequel, as the production team and the actor himself decided that it simply wasn't worth the preparation time, but in that decision we were robbed of one of the best supporting characters in the franchise who would have added a lot more to Days Of Future Past than some of the other surviving future mutants.

4. Michael Fassbender - Erik Lensherr/Magneto

Though he was accused of allowing his natural Irish brogue to creep in to the second half of First Class, Michael Fassbender owns Matthew Vaughn's reboot from top to bottom. He is given easily the best moments, from the Tarantino like assassination of two hiding Nazi officers through to his role in the Cuban missile crisis sequence, and it is no accident that the film deems him important enough to welcome him to screen with a Vader-like ominous theme tune. Fassbender does emotionally wounded intensity like few other actors, and there is a rawness in his performance as Lensherr that doesn't always rely on strong outbursts, thanks to the depth he adds to the character. While Sir Ian McKellen is the definitive Magneto, Fassbender is the definitive Erik, on a dark journey of self-discovery that translates his personal anger into a grand, Machiavellian scheme in a relatable way. He is charismatic, irresistibly watchable and the perfect counter-point to James McAvoy's clipped, reasoned Xavier.

3. Sir Ian McKellen - Magneto

As previously noted, Sir Ian McKellen is the definitive Magneto, and it's impossible to think of anyone else in the role, just as it is to think of anyone else playing Gandalf in the Lord Of The Rings and Hobbits movies. In the end, both roles are completely owned by the classically trained actor, and it comes down to the majesty he brings to his performances. McKellen's presence is enough to command the attention entirely, and it is performances like his Magneto, particularly in the first X-Men that proves just why Hollywood was always so fascinated with the idea of casting classically trained European actors in villainous roles. In The Last Stand, Professor X's death depends entirely on McKellen's reaction, and there are relatively rare notes of vulnerability in his performance - particularly in that film - that hint at the complexities of the character. And in Days Of Future Past we see that come into full bloom: Magneto is still the powerful force, but he is jaded and scarred, and though it would have been nice to see how he got to that point, McKellen sells it so well that it isn't so much a hole as a missed opportunity to see more of him.

2. Sir Patrick Stewart - Professor Charles Xavier

Watching Star Trek: The Next Generation now, it's hard not to see why Sir Patrick Stewart was always the most likely choice to play the X-Men's leader and guide, and it's not simply because Picard and Professor X are two of the three most famous bald characters in geekdom (Lex Luthor in at number 3). But aesthetics are only half of the story here: like McKellen, Stewart is classically trained with a particular slant on Shakespearean roles, and the disciplines learned in those roles adds a wonderfully successful regality to is Xavier. He is a picture of poise and power, even when the rest of the characters on screen tower above him, and that is chiefly because of the kingly, familiar notes Stewart brings to the role. Stewart is a grounding influence in the cast: patriarchal and welcoming, which works perfectly for both Captain Picard and Xavier, and though it is rarely required of him, his ability to change to something more dramatic and more powerful proves precisely why he was chosen in the first place.

1. Hugh Jackman - Wolverine

Had Fox had their way, it could have been an awful lot different for the mutant with the metal claws, and who's to say that Dougray Scott (who was initially cast) or one of the many other actors linked to the role would have been able get so perfectly under the character's skin as relative new-comer Jackman. Despite having only a couple of notable TV and movie credits to his name (including the unlikeliest reference for Wolverine in Oklahoma), Jackman was cast, coming to the role too late to go through the kind of extreme preparation that have subsequently turned his Wolverine into the most vascular character in all of cinema history. And it's worth considering the performance in terms of that lack of preparation: in X-Men, Jackman's Wolverine is not the blunt object with the snarky quips he would become - he is far more human and far more lost, and the actor sells that inherent vulnerability in such a way that it offered the perfect antidote to the more cartoonish aspects of the characterisation. His relationship with Rogue is the emotional heart of the film's story, and without his charm and the chemistry he builds with Anna Paquin, it simply would not have worked as successfully. And now on to the worst casting decisions...

7. Danny Huston - William Stryker (X-Men Origins: Wolverine)

Danny Huston is by no means a terrible actor - he has proved otherwise in other projects - but he is just miscast as Stryker, and it doesn't help that he is utterly undermined by the ominous shadow of Bryan Cox's superior, definitive version of the character from X2. Huston's Stryker is too obviously slimey, and too serpentine, and when he is faced with the threat of impending violence from his creations, he crumples like a pantomime villain, instead of facing it down as X2's older, wiser Stryker does during the attack on Xavier's school. Huston doesn't feel like a military man in Origins - more a cynical corporate stooge, who should have a bigger bad to answer to, and there's not enough of the mad scientist about him to fully sell the version of the character they were clearly going for. Fundamentally, there isn't enough of a distinction between Stryker when he's pretending to be good and when he's dropped the facade entirely to really sell both sides of the character, and only part of that can be blamed on the script problems.

6. Tyler Mane - Sabretooth (X-Men)

Now admittedly, Bryan Singer's vision for Sabretooth was not as complex nor as taxing as Gavin Hood's Victor Creed, and thus probably didn't require Oscar Wilde to play him, but it would have been better to have someone with some actual charm to match the exceptional character design. It might have been different if Singer had got his way and been able to cast Kevin Nash - the initial target to play Sabretooth - but instead we ended up with a bargain basement alternative in the shape of his former WCW tag team-mate, Tyler "Nitro" Mane. Perhaps it's a little unfair to say he was awful, but he doesn't offer anything to the role that a stunt man in heavy make-up wouldn't: there is no actual acting behind Sabretooth in that first film, and though there is the suggestion that he is a genuine threat to Wolverine, that is very much despite the performance beneath the sideburns and fangs.

5. Omahyra - Arclight (X-Men: The Last Stand)

You could be forgiven for thinking that the part of Arclight, who has the suspiciously helpful and even more suspiciously specific mutation of being able to make plastic guns explode was actually played by Prince in a string vest in The Last Stand, but you'd be wrong. Instead the mutant who forms part of the secondary, and largely superfluous (apart from a handy knack of having the perfect mutations needed to advance the plot) was played by a model with a look of Rihanna and similar acting skills, and she justifiably disappeared into the background - yet another casualty of bad casting and improper character balance. That casting wouldn't have been out of place though, considering Omahyra seems to have been cast simply because she looks a bit odd - which seems to be the same basis that her modelling career was based on as well - and could thus sell the idea of mutation easily.

4. Will.I.Am - (X-Men Origins: Wolverine)

There are lots of things The Black Eyed Peas' rapping front-man and producer extraordinaire can do: he can turn his chair around on "talent" shows, he can "invent" gadgets, he can sing and dance, and he can sculpt his hair into improbable geometric shapes. But one thing he plainly cannot do is act, and even in the quagmire of mostly awfulness that is Gavin Hood's X-Men Origins: Wolverine, the man with plainly too much punctuation in his first name was the worst player. He might have looked the part of Kestrel, but that does not a good performance make, and he manages to turn a charismatic character into a dead-eyed dullard whose death at the hands of the far more appealing Victor Creed comes more as a welcome relief to remove him from Wolverine's inner circle than the tragedy it is supposed to be. In failing to give his character life, Will.I.Am treads the already well-travelled path of pop stars trying and failing to break into Hollywood, and it's hard not to wish he didn't leave the character in the far more capable hands of a more accomplished, more able actor, who might have made him an engaging sidekick.

3. Daniel Cudmore - Colossus (X2 Onwards)

It is perhaps a little unfair to suggest that Daniel Cudmore's presence in the X-Men film universe is as toxic as some of the others on this list, but it is probably the most baffling of all the casting decisions. For X2, he was clearly brought in to play the supporting character of Piotr Rasputin because he had the right look, with precisely zero expectations that he would be required to do much acting, which was fine. He was mostly just there for muscle, so his low impact beyond his aesthetics was entirely justifiable in the interest of making a statement; but then as the franchise continued and Colossus became part of the actual X-Men team in The Last Stand and Days of Future Past, his casting began to look increasingly ropey. Despite his suitability to play the character in physical terms, Cudmore is not exactly an actor, and his necessarily one-dimensional performance as Colossus throughout the series has added very little at all. He is no more than good-looking furniture, to be carried by the rest of the cast, all of whom have grown in stature and comfort with their characters. But as a mark of his lack of progression, Colossus - who should have been a great character - ended up feeling like a tertiary player, even behind the new villains Blink and Warpath

2. Vinnie Jones - Juggernaut/Cain Marko (X-Men: The Last Stand)

X-Men: The Last Stand is not as terrible as you remember it; it's just that the enduring moments are so horrible that memories of anything else tend to evaporate in their wake, so the film is reduced down to an endless montage of Omahyra and her string vest, the silly stunt-work and more than anything, of Vinnie Jones showing precisely why his "renaissance" as an action actor after his football career ended was so misguided. For reasons known only to himself, Brett Ratner clearly took Juggernaut's familial link to Charles Xavier in the comics as justification to cast a British actor, but seems to have gone looking for a suitable candidate when everyone was busy doing something else, and was forced to cast from the dregs. So instead of CGI enhancing a good, or at least charismatic actor (like the woefully under-used Eric Dane, who had little to do other than look pretty multiple times), we got a C-Movie actor/sportsman, wrongly imbued with the direction that he should be the funniest character in the film. And it turned out as horribly as that sounds.

1. Halle Berry - Storm (Everything)

If this article was a true reflection of how awful some of these worst casting decisions turned out to be, Halle Berry would appear in this list three or four times (to be fair, she didn't exactly do a great deal in Days Of Future Past, and we at least got to see her shish-kebabed). But taken as a whole, Berry's Storm is stunted, boring and can't seem to decide from which country she's supposed to hail. The script might not be overly kind to her in the sequels, or in Days Of Future Past - which saw her role diminish thanks to pregnancy - but there is nothing in her first appearance in the character that offers hints of why she should have been given more responsibility. Despite having one of the most intriguing mutants to play, Berry's performance is simply not interesting or engaging, and her painful delivery of the infamous Toads In Lightning line is the crown on top of her awfulness. Which are your favourite and least favourite casting decisions in the X-Men movie franchise? Share your picks below in the comments thread.

Contributor
Contributor

WhatCulture's former COO, veteran writer and editor.