X-Men: Apocalypse – 10 Compelling Casting Rumours Rated

The who's who of Professor X's potential new team.

Arguably the most important casting has already been confirmed with the news that Oscar Isaac - clearly making a play to be crowned the king of geek properties after his turn in Star Wars - is set to go blue for the titular villain. It's good casting, though as a villain he's an unknown quantity Isaac says what his experience of the character so far suggests a suitably fearsome villain: €œI€™ve seen a couple things€ Scary s€“t. Scary s€“t€ I€™m going to bring down to their knees. It€™s amazing, I€™m so excited about everything that€™s going to happen.€ Hopefully he's going to be bulking up for the role. And speaking of physical transformations, James McAvoy says he expects to be bald for the film: the big question is whether they'll address how a man with luxurious hair could go bald in a matter of years. Anyway, what of the new versions of the old favourites; Storm, Cyclops and Jean Grey? The short-lists are apparently in (thought they do keep growing almost daily)...


10. Chloe Moretz Turned Down Jean Grey, Elle Fanning Didn't?

According to reports in November - not long after Bryan Singer announced that casting was underway - both Moretz and Fanning apparently spoke to the director about the possibility of taking on the key role of Jean Grey. At that stage screen tests hadn't been finalised, but a follow up report on the other side of the new year stated quite categorically that Moretz had been offered the part, but had been forced to turn it down because of a shooting clash. Does that then mean that Fanning screen-tested and was over-looked for the Kick-Ass star? Might there be a second chance for the Maleficent star? Would They Have Worked? Moretz has that spark of mischief that could have hinted from an early age that Grey had the capacity to become evil (remember Professor X admitted that he'd worked hard on her as a youngster to help suppress the Phoenix side of her character), and she's proved herself diverse since landing a jarring first body blow with that infamous C-Bomb in Kick-Ass. Fanning meanwhile would appear to be a less edgy choice, though quite how she'd fit filming into her jam-packed schedule is anyone's guess.

9. Taron Egerton Could Play Cyclops

The Kingsman star is going to have a big 2015, and if rumours are to believed, he's on the latest short-list to play Old Laser Eyes. Or Young Laser Eyes more appropriately, since it's going to be the '80s. The actor was inevitably vague when questioned about it:
"I really can€™t comment on the Cyclops thing. I€™m not really sure what€™s going on there or where that came from, but my friend Nicholas Hoult plays Beast and he says that€™s very fun. Of course, everyone would like to play a superhero, but this is by no means me saying I would like to go play Cyclops. So, I don€™t know.€
So that's a definite maybe. Possibly. Would He Work? Well, Matthew Vaughn's other left-field comic book property - Kick-Ass - proved to be the successful launch pad that Aaron Taylor-Johnson needed to become a regular A-Lister (albeit an odd-ball one), so there's obviously value in the director's casting team. But for now the jury is pretty firmly still out on the star, though he's doing his best to impress after his break-out performance on British fire service show The Smoke: he's just been in Testament Of Youth alongside Kit Harrington, and he'll be in the Krays' biopic with Tom Hardy in 2015 too. So by the time Apocalypse comes out, he might well be considered a genuine Hot Youth Thing.

8. Alexandra Shipp Could Play Storm

According to Latino Review, the most likely candidates to play the weather-wielding mutant are also the least remarkable in terms of what they've done so far; but then, that's hardly a concern when Quicksilver proved in Days Of Future Past. Casting unknown at least makes it easier to step into the boots of as big a name actress (at least back when X-Men first launched as a movie franchise) as Halle Berry. The first option is apparently Alexandra Shipp, most known for her performance last year as the lead in TV movie Aaliyah: The Princess of R&B, as well as an unfortunate role in the Chipmunks Squeakwel, which will never not be horribly cringe-worthy. She's also about to play a supporting role in Straight Outta Compton, so you get the sense she's on the verge of more of a break-out. Would She Work? Is a TV biopic really grounds enough to warrant consideration for such a key role? Well, she couldn't possibly do any worse than Halle Berry, who managed to make a fairly impressive character seem boring. But then, the Aaliyah biopic was mercilessly panned (despite being the second highest watched TV movie of the year - which is bit like coming second in a Miss Mediocre pageant).

7. Saoirse Ronan Could Play Jean Grey

With Latino Review suggesting that both Ronan and Game Of Thrones star Sophie Turner are up for the key role of Jean Grey, it would appear that Bryan Singer has a very definitive idea of what he's looking for in his Grey: poise, height and an intangible regal feel that would undoubtedly suit the character's dynamic in the X-Men set up. Clearly having Jena as a shrinking violet alongside the other X-Men characters would be a mistake, so it makes sense that she would have the more recognisable actors linked to playing her. And Hanna would suggest that Ronan has it in her for more physically demanding roles than her recent appearance in Grand Budapest Hotel. Would She Work? There's a good chance, but Ronan is probably the hardest sell in terms of transmitting the darkness of Phoenix that should still be bubbling under the surface of Grey's cooler demeanour. In purely talent terms, she's definitely a good pick though.

6. Jamie Blackley Could Play Cyclops

He might not be as old as Egerton, but Blackley actually looks older, and would be less convincing as a teenage Scott - though that might suit the agenda to start introducing him as a leader in waiting. The Isle Of Man born actor was one of the teen sensations of 2014 thanks to starring in If I Stay alongside Jean Grey candidate Chloe Moretz, and he's no stranger to some fairly sizeable Hollywood projects, having cut his teeth on The Fifth Estate and Snow White And The Huntsman. He might not quite be a household name yet, but he's proved himself diverse enough to tackle Singer's demands for the character. Would He Work? He's certainly got that young leader edge about him, and he's the right sort of physical shape to pull of an athletic younger mutant too. It's just whether he's well-known enough.

5. Zendaya Coleman Could Play Storm

The latest round of rumours has put Coleman alongside Alexandra Shipp as the most likely candidates for Storm, suggesting that Bryan Singer is indeed looking to cast relatively unknown (at least in terms of film projects). Fans of the Disney Channel probably won't consider the Shake It Up star and singer unknown, but they're probably not the key demographic for Singer's epic superhero movie anyway. Ironically, she was first choice to play Aaliyah in the same film that Shipp starred in, so clearly Singer is a fan of terrible Lifetime biopics. Would She Work? Genuinely who knows? Though she's mostly known for her association with Disney projects, she's actually a classically trained actor, and cut her teeth with Shakespearean plays, which might be a good indication that she could pull off the majesty of the queen of the clouds.

4. Hailee Steinfeld Could Play Jean Grey

Around the time that both Elle Fanning and Chloe Moretz were mentioned as in talks to play Grey, True Grit star Steinfeld was also rumoured to be on the shortlist. Since stealing the show in the revivalist Western from the Cohens, Steinfeld has had a busy time, leaping through genres with reckless abandon, and playing the super-powered mutant wouldn't be too much of a stretch after her performance in the upcoming action comedy Barely Lethal (a teenage special ops agent infiltrates a school). Okay, so maybe that's a stretch, but she's a good actress, which is basically all that matters. Would She Work? The key selling point here is that Steinfeld actually somewhat resembles Moretz - not just in physical appearance but in the spirit she brings to her characters. In True Grit she gave her role remarkable - occasionally precocious - intelligence, and she would undoubtedly fit the idea of Grey as a genius.

3. Tye Sheridan Could Play Cyclops

According to The Wrap's Jeff Sneider, the favourite to play leader in waiting Cyclops is Mud's break-out star Sheridan, who subsequently went on to help Nic Cage score an unlikely success with Joe, and has Last Days In The Desert upcoming with Ewan McGregor as well as the god-awful sounding Scouts Vs Zombies. But then, he does have to eat. When it comes down to it, Singer is going to have a tough time choosing his Cyclops if these three names are indeed the fore-runners: all are talented, all are on the up in career terms, and all would seem to fit the aesthetic bill. It will probably boil down to who tests best, and if Sneider is to be believed, it's already Sheridan. Would He Work? Sheridan has done well in all of his major projects so far, holding his own against Brad Pitt, Matthew McConaughey and Nic Cage, and all in all he would seem the most dependable (and the most bankable of the options).

2. An Unknown Child Could Play Nightcrawler

Bryan Singer has been openly flirting with the idea of bringing Nightcrawler back for a while now: he was supposed to be in X-Men: The Last Stand and was considered for Days Of Future Past, so it would seem to be third time's a charm for the teleporter. And don't just dismiss this as a rumour for now, as Singer is still stating his intentions, with his most recent statements on the character suggesting he's going to be redrawn as Mystique's son...
"I'm excited because I want to start introducing familiar characters at different ages and also explore the '80s. Nightcrawler is a familiar character, and if he's born from Mystique in the movie, he'd be quite young (again, a "different ")."
Ignoring for a minute the fact that Nightcrawler isn't a shape shifter (and thus couldn't really be her son), that would at least give Mystique an even more substantial role in proceedings, which was hinted coming out of Days Of Future Past. But how do you handle the kid? Would It Work? It depends really: if the child is used as a plot device, then that might be okay, but if they start introducing plucky little younger side-kicks you start hearing enormous Scrappy Doo klaxons going off at every turn. So maybe it's going to be a case of a silent performance by a very young child being the best approach...

1. Sophie Turner Could Play Jean Grey

By far the most intriguing casting rumour has suggested that Game Of Thrones' put-upon former Queen Sansa is one of the front-runners for Jean Grey, which hopefully has a lot more to do with her acting ability than the fact that she's already got the right colour hair. Quite how she'd cope with an American accent is an unknown element, but she has a lot going for her, even if she'd be a significantly different direction to how Chloe Moretz would have performed the character. Would She Work? Very much the same as Saoirse Ronan, you'd have to say, though Turner's time on Game Of Thrones would be a smart selling point if Singer and Fox want to count on an upsurge in fans from a ready made source. Of everyone listed, she probably has the most "geek credentials," and that's not to mention the fact that she's genuinely blossomed into a very good actress on the HBO show. She even has the pseudo-regal poise you might expect from Grey, who you'd expect to carry an almost maternal spirit even in early age. Who would you like to see Cyclops, Storm and Jean Grey? Share your picks below in the comments thread.

Contributor
Contributor

WhatCulture's former COO, veteran writer and editor.