10 Amazing Games You Didn't Realise Aged HORRIBLY

These awesome games aged like milk left out in the summer sun.

Red dead redemption: Undead Nightmare
Rockstar

It's probably fair to say that video games age inherently worse than all other art forms, in large part because games are still an incredibly young type of media, whose technological innovation moves at a geometric rate compared to, say, movies, music, or books.

And so, while some games do manage to age gracefully - say, the original Sonic the Hedgehog - not all masterpieces can be quite so lucky. 

Sometimes games end up succumbing to the ravages of time, and we're forced to admit that they don't really hold up to modern scrutiny.

Now, we all know that certain beloved games have aged like milk - say, the original Grand Theft Auto or GoldenEye 007 - but what about those less-obvious titles which are a genuine chore to play nowadays?

And so, we come to these 10 video games, each of them beloved by millions of players who, more likely than not, haven't revisited them in recent years. 

If you do, you'll likely be taken aback by just how awkward their gameplay mechanics are and how stiff they feel to play.

It does nothing to diminish their overall legacy, but it's worth being aware of if you're planning on revisiting any of these classic games...

10. Hitman 2: Silent Assassin

Hitman 2 Silent Assassin
IO Interactive

It's often said that Hitman 2: Silent Assassin marks the point at which the stealth franchise really found its footing - that it was a vastly superior evolution of the series' messy-but-promising first game, Hitman: Codename 47.

And while that's basically true, it doesn't mean that Hitman 2 is still easy to play with a smile on your face today.

The excessively linear level design just doesn't hold up compared to subsequent titles, the AI is infuriatingly aggressive, and the disguise system lacks the nuance of later games.

The result is a title that's much slower and far more challenging than any other in the series' 25-year history, and typically not for the better. 

It is the definition of a game that outstays its welcome - something even huge fans of the Hitman games might bring themselves to admit.

The next two games in the franchise, Hitman: Contracts and Blood Money, have however aged considerably better with their more balanced difficulty and streamlined mechanics. 


9. Halo: Combat Evolved

Halo combat evolved
Bungie

There's an entire generation of gamers who have overpowering nostalgia for Halo: Combat Evolved - the game which not only put the original Xbox on the map and launched the beloved first-person shooter franchise, but also helped popularise the console FPS.

For its time, the original Halo is a sublime achievement, but played today? It's pretty tough going.

Even when playing the 10th anniversary remaster, the supped-up visuals can't disguise how incredibly dated Combat Evolved's level design fundamentally is. 

The campaign is, for the most part, a repetitive assemblage of hallway shooting galleries, the same dull environments being recycled ad nauseum, as is of course no more apparent than in the infamous Library level.

Though there's nothing inherently wrong with asset reuse - just look at the Like a Dragon franchise - it feels especially uninspired here, with little-to-no attempt made to vary up the seemingly never-ending carousel of seen-it-before hallways and rooms.

None of this stops Halo being a benchmark for the genre, - again, for its time - even if it's nasically a stamina-depleting bore to play today.


8. Ico

Ico
Team Ico

For the great many wondering why Ico hasn't received the same glossy remake treatment that its successor Shadow of the Colossus has, it's most likely because Sony is acutely aware just how much work would be needed to bring Ico up to modern gameplay expectations.

Though Ico is absolutely a vital piece of gaming history - namely, one of the strongest early arguments for games as art in an era where they commanded much less respect - its gameplay just doesn't hold up at all.

Escort missions are divisive at the best of times, but Ico is basically one long six-hour escort mission, and one that's harangued by clunky, floaty controls, an infuriating camera, stiff animations, slack pacing, and a general lack of forward momentum compared to Shadow of the Colossus.

Ico is definitely a game to admire, but if someone played an hour of it today and then just decided to watch the rest on YouTube instead of suffer through the wading-through-treacle gameplay, it'd be tough to blame them.


7. The Elder Scrolls III: Morrowind

Elder Scrolls Morrowind
Bethesda

Much as The Elder Scrolls III: Morrowind is continually held up as one of the greatest RPGs - nay, video games - ever made, going back to it these days sure isn't easy.

Even accepting the jank expected from just about every single Bethesda-developed RPG, Morrowind is a far clunkier experience than anything the studio has developed since.

From the slow movement speed to the awkward, RNG-infused combat, vague quests, and woeful user interface, Morrowind feels positively ancient compared to, say, Oblivion, to say nothing of the wonky animations, unappealing visuals, and ill-aged sound effects.

Even though the series' passionate modding community has released a ton of quality-of-life mods to make the experience more frictionless, Morrowind is at its core a masterpiece of world-building and atmosphere that just doesn't hold up almost a quarter-century later.

We can only hope that the Oblivion remaster does well enough that Bethesda considers giving Morrowind an update too - though it'd clearly need more than a fresh lick of paint to vibe with modern players.


6. Devil May Cry

Devil May Cry
Capcom

Devil May Cry is one of the most celebrated character action franchises of all time, and all paths trace back to the original 2001 PS2 game, which to this very day is often ranked among the greatest games of all time.

But hoo boy, just try playing it today.

Even when experienced as part of 2012's DMC HD Collection, the original Devil May Cry has aged like mayo left out in the hot summer sun.

As fun as the combat is in theory, it's easy to forget that the earlier games in the series had fixed camera angles, not unlike those in Capcom's Resident Evil franchise.

Being at the mercy of bespoke cameras angles, which often change in the middle of combat and therefore prove massively disorientating, seems completely unhinged in the modern gaming era, and it makes going back to play those earlier DmC titles - especially the first - a real chore.

A full-fat remake, which updates the camera and controls to the standards of Devil May Cry 5, would be a huge treat for fans who can't quite stomach going back to the O.G. title in its current state.


5. Metroid

Metroid
Nintendo

The original 1986 NES version of Metroid is undeniably one of the most influential and important games of all time, yet if you haven't revisited it in years or even decades, you might be in for a shock.

The lack of a map, repetitive locations, and general level of challenge make Metroid a gruelling, unforgiving experience today, especially compared to every other entry in the franchise.

Its freedom of exploration and atmosphere are undeniable, but this franchise-birthing entry is enough of a chore to play that you're better off just skipping it and playing the generally excellent Zero Mission remake instead.

Zero Mission strips away much of the original's frustration and makes for a smoother, more enjoyable time on the whole, enough that the only folk who still stick with the original are purists or masochists.

While many genre-defining retro games are still eminently playable decades on, Metroid sadly just isn't one of them unless you've got the patience of a saint.


4. Alan Wake

Alan Wake
Remedy

The recent release of Alan Wake 2 naturally stirred up fan interest in revisiting the original 2010 action-adventure game that started it all. 

But while Alan Wake has a well-earned place as a cult classic largely thanks to its mind-bending narrative, aesthetics, and fantastic atmosphere, the gameplay doesn't really hold water - especially not compared to its sublime successor.

Combat simply doesn't feel good moment-to-moment, the enemy types are woefully limited, and the samey environments wear out their welcome after just a few short hours.

It is a game whose reputation is almost entirely earned by its story and its mood, with the creaky gameplay simply being something players accept for the sake of the overall experience. 

All the same, it was decidedly easier to tolerate in 2010, yet 15 years later when game design has moved so far forward? It's tough to stick with Alan Wake all the way to the end, honestly. Nobody could blame you for dipping after a while.


3. Kingdom Hearts

Kingdom Hearts
Square Enix

Kingdom Hearts remains fondly beloved by millions, because who doesn't love the idea of a Disney-themed RPG developed by Square Enix? But as genius an exercise in intertextuality as it is, the O.G. game is rough as sandpaper.

Even ignoring the scarcely comprehensible word-salad of a plot, the original game's clunky camera and controls ensure both combat and platforming - that is, the two key tenets of gameplay - are frustrating to modern hands.

Elsewhere the user interface is a mess, the level design is infuriatingly obtuse at times, and worst of all, the deathly dull, mandatory gummi levels will ensure players have to actively force themselves to continue.

This is to say, if you've got dew-eyed memories of playing the first Kingdom Hearts as a young whippersnapper, you're probably better off leaving those memories untarnished rather than tainting them with a new playthrough.

Thankfully Kingdom Hearts II holds up considerably better, even though it certainly has its own issues to speak of.


2. Red Dead Redemption: Undead Nightmare

Red Dea Redemption Undead Nightmare
Rockstar

Some 15 years after its release, Red Dead Redemption: Undead Nightmare remains one of the most celebrated DLCs of all time, many lauding its cinematic story, brilliant voice acting, and novel zombie-infused take on the core Western action gameplay.

The overall perception is that Undead Nightmare is a rare DLC that's as polished as the original game, but played today, it's honestly a bit of a slog to get through.

For sure, the cutscenes are still great fun, but the gameplay? Not so much. It doesn't help that the early missions in particular are absolutely chores, from wiping out repetitive waves of zombies to going on a wildly convoluted, maddeningly overlong fetch quest for flowers.

In 2010 these dishwater-dull tasks perhaps didn't seem quite so tedious, but in 2025, where open world games are a dime a dozen and players have decidedly less patience for this sort of generic, even "lazy" quest design, it's harder to accept.

Much as Undead Nightmare was a brilliant DLC for its time, from a gameplay perspective it doesn't really hold up - the moment-to-moment missions are so bereft of character that you'll likely want to race from one cutscene to the next as fast as possible.


1. Uncharted: Drake's Fortune

Unchartered Drake's Fortune
Sony

The legacy of the Uncharted franchise is so storied that it's easy to forget just how far things have moved on since the original game. 

While the Uncharted series is largely credited with finding its cinematic groove in Uncharted 2: Among Thieves, the original game is still the action-packed, Indiana Jones-aping extravaganza that made Nathan Drake a Sony icon.

But if you go back and revisit the original Uncharted today, even in its remastered form, it's a rickety experience.

Sure, it still looks good, but Uncharted's gameplay feels a whole world away from basically everything Naughty Dog has made since. The biggest culprit is the mind-numbingly repetitive combat, which too often devolves into a relentless shooting gallery.

Throw in roughshod controls and awkward cover mechanics, and the first Uncharted is a genuine struggle to get through. And that's without even bringing up those dreadful jet-ski sequences.

While the other Uncharted games have all aged impressively well for the most part, the original feels like a thin sketch - an extremely bristly draft of the greatness the series would later achieve.


Watch Next


Contributor
Contributor

Stay at home dad who spends as much time teaching his kids the merits of Martin Scorsese as possible (against the missus' wishes). General video game, TV and film nut. Occasional sports fan. Full time loon.