10 Best Sequels From Terrible Video Games
Looking at the sequels that redeemed the franchise.
No matter how powerful a gaming franchise is, it's bound to pump out a bad entry or two at some point. Luckily, the occasional dud isn't the end of the world, so long as the developers get back on track.
However, it's a different matter if the first entry in a potential series falls short of expectations. If a new IP is shredded by the critics, the chances of it receiving a sequel are slim.
Even if a follow-up gets green-lit, hopes aren't high, especially if the project is developed by the same team as the disappointing original.
Fortunately, some game franchises successfully moved onto greener pastures, despite dropping the ball at the beginning. By avoiding the pitfalls of the first instalment or by tackling the sequel from a new direction, things can work out better the second time around.
When Just Cause, Shadowrun, and Killzone underperformed, not many were pining for more. As such, it's astonishing how these unwanted continuations pulled out all the stops, offering players the jaw-dropping experience they should've got the first time around.
If you saw how badly this sorry bunch started, you'd never believe they had any potential. Luckily, each of these games managed to spawn an absolutely killer follow-up.
10. Yooka-Laylee & The Impossible Lair
In 2015, Platonic announced a Kickstarter campaign for Yooka-Laylee, a love letter to Rare's beloved platformer, Banjo-Kazooie. Amazingly, the team hit their target of £175,000 in 40 minutes. By the end, they raised £2 million, proving Banjo-lovers had a firm belief in the project.
Despite all the buzz, Yooka-Laylee failed to deliver. Even though this spiritual successor nails Banjo-Kazooie's aesthetic and humour, this outdated clone didn't match the creativity and fluidity of the bear-and-bird's adventure saga.
Though expectations were significantly lower for the sequel, Yooka-Laylee and The Impossible Lair turned out far better. With its smooth gameplay, beautiful level designs, clever puzzles, and catchy tunes, this cutesy collectathon did Rare proud.
But what makes this follow-up stand out is its unconventional set-up and structure. Unlike most platformers, our titular heroes can enter the final stage immediately. However, they don't stand a chance due to the level's extensive length and brutal difficulty. For this reason, Yooka and Laylee must navigate through various levels and collect dozens of bees, each of which will increase our heroes' defences.
Similar to Shovel Knight, The Impossible Lair scratches that nostalgic itch without relying on it, since it has plenty of unique mechanics to satiate die-hard platforming fans.
9. Destiny 2
Destiny's relentless promotions and ludicrous budget indicated that Bungie's cosmic loot-shooter would be the next big thing.
Though Destiny wasn't a complete disaster, it didn't come close to meeting expectations. Critics used words like "cobbled" and "plundered" in their reviews, since its was clear as day that Destiny unabashedly stole elements from superior shooters rather than relying on its own innovations. Due to the excessive grinding, disjointed plot, and Peter Dinklage's monotonous performance, it's hard to believe Destiny was ever intended to be a showstopper.
Even though Destiny 2 was considered more of the same (and pejoratively labelled "Destiny 1.5",) it was a big step in the right direction. Thanks to the expansive story, well-crafted maps, tight gunplay, and focus on exploration, the gameplay felt far less like laborious.
The endless ways to synergise armour mods and perks with weapons encourages players to lose countless hours in the PvP mode. The free annual updates constantly improved on the gameplay and offered a staggering amount of content. (Also, not asking Dinklage to reprise his role was a good idea.)
It had a rocky start, but Destiny's future is looking very bright than ever.
8. New Pokemon Snap
Back in 1999, Nintendo collaborated with Hal Laboratory for a photography-based game called Pokemon Snap. The on-rails title has the protagonist navigate through a set path while taking pictures of approaching creatures. New rewards and paths are unlocked by taking striking photos, encouraging players to stay alert.
Despite the solid pitch, Pokemon Snap was very bare-bones. With only seven levels and 63 Pokemon to find, this spin-off could be completed in under two hours. Also, the photography mechanic wasn't consistent, so players sometimes received minimal points for incredible photos and vice versa.
Fortunately, the sequel knocked it out of the park. Even though recent Pokemon games have been criticised for their poor graphics, New Pokemon Snap looks fittingly picturesque. Thanks to the smooth photography mechanics and balanced reward system, the gameplay is more enjoyable than ever.
Although the gameplay in the original quickly became tiresome, that's not the case here. Since certain critters only come out during certain periods or by diverting from the path, players are encouraged to replay levels and try new things. As a result, revisiting areas rarely feels like a chore.
And with 200+ Pokemon to discover, New Pokemon Snap will keep fans enthralled for a long time.
7. Saints Row: The Third
Due to Grand Theft Auto III's overwhelming influence on the gaming industry, open-world copycats were inevitable. And one of the many doppelgängers that GTA spawned was Volition's crime sandbox, Saints Row.
Unfortunately, this street shooter did little to distinguish itself as anything but a poor imitation of Rockstar's powerhouse IP. When Saints Row 2 received the same criticism, Volition realised their brand wouldn't last unless they did something drastic.
Thankfully, the threequel gave Saints Row a second wind. Rather than grounding the game in reality, Saints Row: The Third focused more on meta gags, cartoony characters, and blasting enemies with octopus guns.
Even though this type of juvenile humour could become grating, that's rarely the case since missions are so inventive and fun. One minute, you're taking part in a Japanese gameshow, the next you're dropped in a zombie apocalypse or battling luchadore wrestlers.
However, none of this would matter if the gameplay wasn't up to scratch. Fortunately, the third entry is a dream to play. The controls are on point, the customisation options are accessible and diverse, and the characters are surprisingly well-developed.
Not only is Saints Row: The Third one of the most enjoyable open-world titles out there, it's excels over GTA in certain departments.
6. Shadowrun: Dragonfall
The Shadowrun tabletop game was hugely popular upon its release, encouraging the creators to franchise the hell out it. Within a few years, the cyberpunk fantasy saga inspired books, collectible cards, and of course, video games.
Although the first video game adaptation was ok, it didn't set the world on fire. Sadly, the second entry wasn't much better. Or the third. Or the fourth.
In fact, it wasn't until the release of the sixth entry, Dragonfall, before the tabletop RPG was done justice. Weirdly, Dragonfall started off as DLC for the fifth instalment, Shadowrun Legends. When the add-on received better reviews than the game itself, the isometric role-player was released as a separate title.
Dragonfall captures the literal magic of the source material while still remaining accessible to those unfamiliar with it. Each party member is thoroughly fleshed out, to the point where players should be pushed to learn more about them. Though the turn-based combat was solid in the last entry, new techniques have been tossed into the mix this time around, refining it to perfection.
The series may not have improved since Dragonfall, but at least Shadowrun purists finally got the gaming experience they always wanted.
5. Just Cause 2
With nearly 400 square miles to explore, 20+ missions, and 300 side-quests, Just Cause seemed like a mega-hit in the making.
Even though Avalanche Studio's shooter took three years to make, the project had "rushed development" written all over it. It had a barrage of game-killing glitches, making certain missions impossible. Worst of all, some ports never received a patch to remedy these glaring issues.
Luckily, Avalanche set things right with the sequel. Boasting over-the-top action from beginning to end, every mission feels like a middle finger to the laws of physics (especially while surfing missiles or turning windmills into rudimentary catapults).
Also, the mechanics of the grappling hook are so flawlessly designed, it puts Batman's gizmo to shame. With this gadget, our hero can crash enemy automobiles into each other, swing onto a vehicle from the air, or attach a car to a helicopter, using the automobile like a wrecking ball.
Due to the glut of creative side-quests, players should be coming back to Just Cause 2 again and again, long after beating the main campaign.
It may not be perfect (especially the voice acting) but this sequel is lightyears ahead of its predecessor.
4. NieR: Automata
As the title suggests, Platinum Games' robot-bashing title is a follow-up to Nier, which was released in 2010.
However, the series' origins go back earlier than that. In 2003, Cavia released a hack-and-slash title called Drakengard. Though the first two instalments were panned, they made enough cash to warrant the Nier spin-off, set a millennium in the future.
This instalment was also heavily criticised, due to its mediocre graphics, bland environments, and janky animations. After receiving three strikes, the franchise could've been abandoned then and there.
Instead, PlatinumGames released a follow-up seven years later, blowing its competition out of the water. Even though NieR Automata follows a similar structure to its predecessor, every aspect is more cohesive and balanced. The gameplay blends genres beautifully, including hack-and-slash, RPG, shoot 'em up, and even text adventure.
The immense size of the enemies makes the simplest battles feel epic. More impressively, the framerate rarely lags, no matter how many screen-filling foes our heroes face.
NieR Automata also requires multiple playthroughs to unlock new areas and story elements. Although playing the main campaign repeatedly can be tedious for certain games, players are encouraged to replay Automata to comprehend the inner complexities of the heroes and the overall story.
3. Killzone 2
When a shooter is sold as a "Halo-killer," the developers are expected to deliver a genre-defining FPS. Sadly, Killzone was anything but, due to its technical issues, fumbling controls, framerate drops, and woeful AI. Though the PSP's Killzone Liberation made improvements, it was still nowhere near as big as was promised.
As a result, the gaming community weren't optimistic when Killzone 2 was being advertised like crazy, believing the developers would deliver more of the same.
But after playing Killzone 2 for a matter of minutes, it's clear the creators spared no expense. The single-player campaign is beautifully structured and well-placed. The graphics look magnificent, even by today's standards. The focus on gritty realism makes players feel like they're controlling living-and-breathing soldiers rather than a bunch of NPCs. Not only that, Joris de Man's exquisite soundtrack was awarded the Ivor Novello, making Killzone 2 the first video game to receive the prize.
Instead of getting a generic sequel, Guerrilla Games gave the world one of the best games of the year and arguably the greatest shooter on the PS3. Even though Halo 2 was released the same year, Killzone 2 got far more attention and praise.
2. Street Fighter II
Street Fighter II didn't just revolutionise the fighting genre, but the arcade industry and competitive gaming. Capcom's prized sequel was so influential, it's easy to forget about the one that started it all.
The reason why 1987's Street Fighter slips our collective minds is simple - it's not very good. Although Street Fighter's core concept is the same as the iconic sequel, it was let down by its clunky combat and unresponsive controls. The simplest moves require an unrealistic level of precision, making the gameplay quite frustrating. With only two characters to choose from, limited moves, and a forgettable soundtrack, the first Street Fighter had none of the hallmarks the series is known for.
Fortunately, Capcom believed the property had untapped potential, inspiring them to give it another shot.
And the rest is history. Street Fighter II has inspired countless copycats, umpteen ports, crossovers, comics, animated shows, an awesome animated movie, a crappy live-action movie, spin-offs, and remakes. 30 years later, the beloved saga has continued to thrive. Even though the sequels also received heavy praise (except SFV,) there's no question Street Fighter II is the franchise's defining entry.
1. Red Dead Redemption
On the surface, Red Dead Revolver felt like it was bending over backwards to give players a true Wild West experience. Since players could take control of half a dozen characters, ride horses, duel on trains, and challenge gunslingers to a quick-draw shootout, the spaghetti-western title could've been a classic.
Too bad Revolver failed in the most basic departments, including visuals, controls, and gaming mechanics. After receiving mediocre reviews, nobody would've blamed Rockstar if they put Red Dead out of its misery.
Instead, the developers created a sequel that is, without an ounce of exaggeration, one of the greatest video games ever made. Due to its nuanced characters, glorious narrative, impeccable world-building, and teeming visuals, it's impossible to criticise Red Dead Redemption negatively without nitpicking. The fact that the developers programmed the horses' testicles to shrink in cold water just goes to show how the attention to detail is second-to-none.
Even though Redemption seemed perfect, its follow-up is considered by many to be even better. RDR II wasn't just a beautiful game, but a true work of art.
Looking back on the three games as a whole, Rockstar's tenacity and determination needs to be commended. After Revolver failed, the development team could've abandoned the franchise and moved onto other projects. Instead, they learned from their mistakes and tried again, creating two masterpieces in the process.