10 Expensive Video Games Nobody Wanted
All the bells and whistles still can't make people buy them.
Video gaming, on the whole, is big business. Much like movies, there's a billion dollar industry that can put big budget into the production of one. Or, when put to the fans, their love can crowdfund a long awaited sequel or reboot.
And much like movies, there can and have been some absolute flops. Whilst a comic book movie franchise can turn over billions on the silver screen, its video game counterpart can almost sink a long-running publisher on release. Live action movies doesn't mean gamers want live service games.
Or even worse, games that promise either the moon or prison dominance (that'll make sense in a bit) that deliver neither. Games that are hyped up but fall flat on release, much to the ire of the waiting public.
Yet that's not the worst of it, as one game threatened to crash the entire market before we even got out of the decade of big hair and Bananarama. That's no exaggeration, it was a dangerous moment back in the early 80's.
Whatever the reason, here are ten examples of games that were either bankrolled or crowdfunded to astronomical levels, only to sell poorly. Misled intentions, broken games, there's a whole gamut here being explored.
Enjoy, and try not to kick yourself if you fell for one of these when they came out.
10. Tomb Raider: The Angel Of Darkness
Lara Croft's reboot trilogy in recent years is not only well received, but also not her first reboot. Or even her second. Yet whilst this iteration is doing well, it wasn't always looking that peachy for the raider of tombs.
The first reimagining came in 2003 with The Angel of Darkness. Scrapping Lara's more traditional, highly acrobatic gameplay into something more grounded, it was intended to reinvent the character as a more serious explorer. Y'know, because shooting dinosaurs isn't "serious" enough.
A lot of the spectacle was replaced with sneaking about restrictive corridors, and as such, fans didn't really take to Croft's leap to the then-newest generation of consoles.
Neither did critics, citing is as lacking compared to what the PS2 and Xbox could offer in terms of better, similar games. Whilst it did sell better than other examples on this list, it wasn't enough to generate interest in the planned reboot titles.
Thankfully, Crystal Dynamics did restore the faith in 2006's Legend (before bungling another franchise on this list), but for a time, Lara's fate was almost as buried as she's been a few times.
9. Brütal Legend
Poor Tim Schafer. Whilst he makes some oft-considered cult classics, they never seem to find their place in mass-selling legacy. Yet fans still raised three million for Broken Age, so there's clearly some love there.
It's a shame the same can't quite be said for Brütal Legend. On paper, it should have been a multi-platform rock adventure. It had Jack Black, it had a killer soundtrack, not to mention a who's who of rock legends in there too. Ozzy Osbourne, the late Lemmy, Rob Halford... and even Tim Curry!
It could have been great, had Schafer not pulled a bait-and-switch on what kind of game Brütal Legend was going to be. The opening act (and conveniently the demo portion) had players believe it was a Dante's Inferno-style hack and slash.
Which then suddenly turned pseudo-Command & Conquer, hybrid real time strategy game with base management. As you can imagine, people weren't happy with the switcheroo.
Backlash was aimed at marketing hiding this reveal, with critics citing the muddling gameplay not being strong on either component. The only thing that sold well... were the licensed songs used in the game.
8. Conker's Bad Fur Day (N64)
Conker, the furry foul-mouth, is an endearing little bugger. Starting off all twee on the Game Boy Colour, he found his success when Rare went R rated with Bad Fur Day. Or so you'd think, but it's not as rosy at it seems.
Bad Fur Day did find success when it was released on Xbox in 2005, as part of Microsoft's acquisition of Rare. Yet the same can't be said for the original release on the Nintendo 64 some four years prior.
It was predicted to shift big, as R rated games on the N64 were few and far between. The hype was there, with its game website (remember those?) recording a lot of traffic. Hopes were high, Rare had a good track record already, so this should have been a hit.
Except... it wasn't. Nowhere near, in fact. High game cost towards the nearing end of the console's shelf life, among other factors, saw this shift less than six digits upon release.
Weirdly, original still copies still fetch a high price now. But not to Rare, who saw this as a commercial failure.
7. Sonic Boom: Rise Of Lyric/Sonic Boom: Shattered Crystal
As Count Dooku once said, "Twice the pride, double the fall". In Sonic's case, releasing not one but two companion games simultaneously could have gone well... but it didn't.
The blue blur has always had a rocky history with 3D games, so Rise of Lyric was already not off to a promising start. Shattered Crystal, the 3DS accompaniment, should have been a safe bet with its 2D gameplay.
However, not even that could save the series from the disaster of Lyric. Review copies weren't given out, and the end result was an absolute shambles. The only positive was seeing speedrunners tear the game apart with a heinous glitch.
Shattered Crystal didn't exactly fly off the shelves either, resulting in a combined six hundred thousand sold. That's normally a loss on one game, let alone a double whammy.
Whilst the animated show that ran alongside it reviewed well, the follow up game on the 3DS, Fire & Ice, did little to bolster the hedgehog's new look.
As a result, Sonic was left to cool his feet until Mania brought players back to that classic gameplay they love.
6. Daikatana
John Romero co-founded id Software, responsible for groundbreaking titles like Doom, Wolfenstein 3D and Quake. However, that's not what his name is synonymous with.
The absolute spectacle surrounding, and including, the release of Daikatana is his biggest hubris.
Besides the claims about Romero making [players] his bitch in a provocative advert, the behind the scenes was even worse. Initially pitched in 1995, it took a full five years and a rumoured thirty million dollar budget to see Romero's darling brought to life.
Reports of a rockstar lifestyle, a revolving door of staff and other bold claims saw skepticism turn into annoyance over the delays, and the end result did little to quell that.
With a projection of 2.5 million copies expected to be sold, Daikatana saw low-end chart numbers on release. By the end of its release year, it had barely sold fifty thousand, roughly 2% of its intended figure.
Rightfully hailed as "one of the worst video games of all time", the only good thing to come from Ion Storm studios was Deux Ex. Romero had nothing to do with that, thankfully.
5. Kingdoms Of Amalur: Reckoning
It's not very often that you hear a city has bankrolled the production of a video game, but it has happened. Well, to be less hyperbolic, developer 38 Games requested a $75 million dollar from the Rhode Island Economic Development Corporation.
And was granted it.
So, it would be fair to assume that there was a lot riding on the studio and, subsequently, Kingdoms of Amalur: Reckoning. It looked good, with its single player Warcraft/Fable vibe going for it. It was bright, it was entertaining to play, and there was tonnes of life to it.
All it had to do was sell well... which it didn't do. Selling only a third of its intended "break even" target of three million, Reckoning was dubbed a commercial failure despite scoring well.
Consequently, 38 Games couldn't make the repayments on their whopper of a loan, filing for bankruptcy before the game had even been out a year. And who got left with the bill?
The taxpayer, of course. Which marred Reckoning's reputation for some years to come.
It's seen better days since its revival in 2020, with THQ thankfully not bankrupting Austria to re-release it.
4. Shenmue III
As mentioned earlier, fans willing to crowdfund games if the excitement is there. To Shenmue's credit, it has been a long-endearing series with a massive fan base.
Even then, it was surprising to see the kickstarter for the third installment reach six million dollars in just over a month.
Expectations were high, the standard was set, fans wanted to see Shenmue embrace modern conventions and blow the eighth generation of consoles (and PC) competition out of the water. Remember how good it looked on the Dreamcast, etc?
It should have been a sure-fire hit. At least six million in funding, original director Yu Suzuki behind it, and remember how good it was on the Dreamcast?!
Sadly, that sentiment didn't carry eighteen years over to the end result. More importantly, it looked and played just as it did in 2001... much to the disappointment of many who expected more.
Not the diehard fans, they loved it. But that doesn't equate to sales, seeing it sell less than the remasters of the first two games. Deep Silver defended it as a "core niche product", but I doubt we'll ever see a fourth one.
3. Marvel's Avengers
Whilst Square Enix and Crystal Dynamic's take on the Marvel's insanely high grossing movie franchise didn't almost kill the gaming industry, it did threaten to sink the former.
Anything Avengers-wise should have been a shoe-in, had both parties not failed spectacularly on launch. The end result was a middling assortment of gameplay types, broken up with a mess of a currency system and repetition throughout.
As such, critics and fans alike weren't rushing to buy it, with a player base dropping nearly 100% in the game's second month of release in 2020. Sales from the opening weeks were positive, yet Square Enix reported a $63 million loss that financial year.
Square were still confident that live service works as a model, adding a much-derided payment model a year later. Which was quickly removed.
Fortunately for the publisher, the Final Fantasy VII Remake sold well in 2020, which didn't entirely force them out of the market. Better still, the Guardians of the Galaxy game of 2021 was positively received, removing a lot of the negative aspects seen in Avengers.
Suffice to say, it was an expensive lesson for Square Enix.
2. Anthem
If one were to compare the futuristic Javelin spacesuits to the Icarus' flight fable, it almost makes a decent parable. Bioware, hot off the back of the Mass Effect trilogy's success (dodgy ending aside), wanted to break free from the ME/Dragon Age name they'd made for themselves.
And with great ambition and cost behind Anthem, they flew too close to the proverbial sun.
In its defence, it did look good on pre-release. The early demonstrations of zipping around in Iron Man-esque suits, taking on enemies as a team in exotic locations looked awesome.
But looking awesome is not the same as playing awesome, and on release, Anthem did not hold up to its charm. A lacklustre launch did see some net return on the game, including microtransactions in-game (boo).
In EA's eyes though, it massively undersold and was therefore deemed a big, expensive mess. As a result, planned content was dropped, as was an Anthem 2.0 revival and the game was condemned to the bargain bin.
Still, it was more fun to play than Mass Effect: Andromeda at least.
1. E.T The Extra-Terrestrial
Ultimately, you can't do a list like this without the biggest flop of all time. The game so bad that it caused the great video game crash of 1983. The stinker that made Nintendo rethink their console branding, with "video games" being a dirty word in the wake of this debacle.
It can only be... E.T the Extra-Terrestrial for the Atari 2600.
A one-man development time of a few months was never going to be a good sign, but Atari insisted it would be ready for the holiday season. The result: a terrible game that ended up in a landfill in New Mexico.
Whilst the total number of games buried varies, the impact it had not just on Atari but gaming on the whole was massively damaging.
Atari reportedly lost $536 million in 1983, causing a massive blow to "home gaming" and potentially, the fate of future consoles. Nintendo got around this by calling their new machine an "entertainment system", lest it suffer the same fate.
But for a time, that little turd-shaped alien could have brought an early death to one of the biggest earning mediums of all time.