10 GENIUS Concepts Wasted On Buggy Video Games

Sometimes, just having a great idea isn’t enough to save a busted game...

Friday the 13th the Game
Gun Media

A colleague of mine once said “game ideas don’t have any value [until they’re proven in-engine]”. Though I don’t agree with the sentiment (I think creativity extends just beyond farting out the mere seed of a potential game), I do agree that you need quite a bit more than just a great idea to make a game stellar. After all, dreaming big is only the first step - making them come true is the tough bit.

Come on, the first guy who put chicken and tarragon together was an absolute genius, but if he couldn’t bake to save himself, his half-cooked, sludge-like pastry on his chicken and tarragon pie wouldn’t win him the Great British Bakeoff, would it?

In an industry increasingly happy to play it safe and release one bland, homogenous game after the next, it can be extremely frustrating to see an exciting and unique concept wasted on a so-so (or worse, a terrible) game.

But, in some ways, I’m still happy that these games exist - risks taken, properties revived - even if they missed the mark. But if you’re anything like me, you still curse what could have been...

10. Gigantic

Gigantic game
Motiga

I don’t think anyone could hear “a game where a 100ft-tall Griffin fights a Hell Serpent controlled by AI, and players fight as satyr archers, angry minotaurs and owl swordsmen to harvest power to give them strength to win the ongoing Kaiju battle” and think “ugh, seen it all before, mate. NEXT.”

This “next big MOBA/hero battler hybrid” was to suffer a painful fate, though - the PC/Xbox One free-to-play title was plagued with financial issues, with Motiga and Perfect World (developer and publisher, respectively) struggling to get enough of an initial playerbase to consider it financially viable, and it was live for only a single year.

With an exquisite art style and character designs (as well as a roster well-balanced across the board), the multi-stage battles in Gigantic would increase in intensity until reaching a dramatic crescendo where your humongous master beasts would scrap in the central arena. The only problem, though? Due to Motiga/Perfect World’s limited resources, the game would often be laggy, buggy, or crash out entirely.

As a...er... gigantic Gigantic fan on Xbox One, it was painful to see it a victim of its release window - one oversaturated with hero shooters - despite it being genuinely unique.


9. Hellgate: London

Hellgate: London
Namco Bandai Games

Hellgate: London’s sales pitch could be summarised as “if Diablo existed in an apocalyptic, modern-day London, with the option to switch between third and first-person perspective”. If that didn’t get your juices flowing, you’re more dead than the atrophied muscles in my sedentary quarantine gamer legs.

Created by a team of former Blizzard Entertainment employees, Hellgate: London wears its inspiration quite clearly on its viscera-coated berserker sleeves, with swathes of demonic enemies baying for your blood (with the stakes being high - Hellgate uses roguelike elements to keep you on your toes).

Sometimes referred to as “Doom Diablo” (having the pace and the grotesque intimacy of first-person murderin’ whilst retaining the micromanagement of picking up a hundred bits of loot a minute), Hellgate would befall a terrible fate, however - with decreasing funds the servers became nightmarishly poor, and in 2008 the team filed for bankruptcy, with all of its intellectual property - including Hellgate - seized by debt collectors.

However, don’t despair - if you still want to play it, HanbitSoft now owns the rights and re-released it as Hellgate London: Resurrection, and you can play it right this second... if you live in South Korea.

What hellish luck.


8. Evolve

Wraith Evolve
Turtle Rock Studios

I adore asymmetric multiplayer titles. There’s something about the sense of skewed odds that really interests me - I love playing as the underdog, as it makes victory so much sweeter.

Evolve, then, is something of a bittersweet course to me - like sugar-dipped earwax, consuming it gave me the uneasy sense that the enjoyment wasn’t worth the diarrhoea.

As a team of four hunters, you and three pals must track down and defeat the beast, which can evolve as it eats, making it stronger over time. As a result, you and your mates ideally want to find it fast - but this is where the core gameplay loop faltered. The vast majority of the match is spent tracking the beast - a bit of a King Kong treasure hunt - before an explosive, brief and unsatisfying bit of action, and it’s over - like making love with me.

With an imbalanced cast and bizarre glitches like killing the beast in a single hit, though, all the money was instead spent on paid DLC and a big marketing push to re-release the game as free-to-play.

Neither solution worked, and those involved with Evolve resolved to have it dissolved.


7. Two Worlds

Gandohar Two Worlds
TopWare Interactive

Eager to get to the sweet, delicious, money-saturated underbelly exposed by The Elder Scrolls Oblivion (and later, Skyrim), Two Worlds attempted to join the pantheon of outrageously-popular fantasy open-world WRPGs, and failed pretty miserably.

Whilst on paper it shares a lot with its Bethesda cousins, in practice it’s far more noticeable why the game suffered. Despite its unique concept of having no traditional linear narrative (with the tagline “write your own story”), Two Worlds’ cracks all start to appear when you realise how enormously broken the entire experience is (with some experience-wreckers being intentional, others not so much).

On my first ever play through, I completed a late-level quest without fulfilling the objective criteria. I also, inexplicably, went invisible and didn’t become visible again until I reloaded my earlier save. And, though I didn’t do it myself, you can actually kill the end boss within minutes of starting the game.

Though it’s a neat idea to keep your narrative and connected gameplay non-linear, this means the flaws become fractal - a duplication bug becomes a damage-stacking bug, which then becomes a permanent stats-boosting bug.

Ironically... the bugs, unlike the story... can never end.


6. Too Human

Too Human
Silicon Knights

By this point, Too Human is an example on par with Duke Nukem Forever for its sheer persistence, refusing to die in development hell after being worked on for a whole decade.

Unfortunately for Silicon Knights and Microsoft, the game’s turbulent past had proven simply too rough for the game to be much good, and a myriad of design choices and quite prevalent bugs made sure the good ideas the game had would never make up for its shortcomings.

The idea was top-notch - a futuristic, sci-fi take on Norse mythology where cybernetic beasts take the place of the usual Draugrs, Jotnars and Fenrirs and cyborg Valkyries descend from the sky to administer electroshock therapy to fallen heroes.

However, even if you could get past some truly baffling design choices (like using the right stick as your primary attack input and no default camera control), the game suffered from all manner of bugs - falling through the game world, toggled HUD refusing to reappear, runes (the game’s mod items) sometimes having no effect whatsoever, and my personal favourite - enemies continuing to attack you, even whilst you’re in an unskippable cutscene.

Too Human? More like... Poo Spewman.*

*Original joke, do not steal


5. Perception

perception game
The Deep End Games

There are some items on this list where I’m sad at the wasted potential of premise, of setting, of licence - but with this one, it’s the uniqueness of the high concept pitch and the subsequent failing to follow through with it which gives me sadness in my duodenum.

In Perception, your character, Cassie, is blind. However, using echolocation (via the sound of her tapping cane or footsteps) she can send resonating ripples of noise through the environment, creating a picture on-screen. However, being a horror game, noise also attracts a malevolent presence to you, effectively making sound a limited resource.

However, though some of the bugs in the game are uncommon-if-gamebreaking (such as falling through the floor, or a command prompt not appearing, stopping progress), the undeniable worst part is that, due to the core premise and mechanics of the game (with environment only appearing when tapping your cane) it’s nigh on impossible to tell if your personal environmental hiccup is by design, or if it’s a glitch...

Which, now that I think of it, is really kind of ironic, considering the game is all about determining/navigating your environment as a blind person.

Cassie? More like... Assie.*

*Seriously, do not steal


4. Ghost Recon: Breakpoint

Ghost Recon Breakpoint Team
Ubisoft

Ubisoft have perfected the “doing a whole bunch of plain, ready salted objectives in a huge open-world environment” template, now, and though their games seem content with being pretty samey every time, this does translate to a macaroni cheese-with-cut-up-hot-dogs-level of comfort food predictability. Basically, we buy a Ubisoft open-world game, and we get what we expect.

Except when we don’t.

Ghost Recon Wildlands didn’t aim too high, hoping to use its ubiquitous formula again - only this time, it’d be as the basis for the triumphant return of the Ghost Recon franchise. That game was regarded well, if... very Ubisofty, though it had its share of bugs, busted multiplayer and enemy AI.

It wasn’t until Breakpoint, the follow-up title to Wildlands, that the stability issues and bugs reached... er... breaking point, with absolutely insane things like failing a mission whilst in cutscenes, vehicles spawning out of nowhere to explode, and even seemingly-trivial things like attempting to climb a wall and getting stuck inside it.

Interesting sidenote - the one time I tried playing Breakpoint with a friend, I accepted a side-mission which I instantly failed, due to the mission-giver disappearing, then the game crashed.

Macaroni cheese with cut-up iron filings-tier comfort food.


3. Friday The 13th

Friday the 13th The Game
Illfonic

Jason Vorhees is not a laddie who does things by halves (unless we’re talking about literally bisecting people).

He’s killed in cabins, killed in the wilderness, killed in space and... killed in his own game!

The idea behind Friday the 13th is a solid one - instead of screaming at the TV for the gormless sods to “run, don’t hide in the cupboard you goober”, you and a team of other human players actually get to control the hapless Camp Crystal Lake holidaymakers... whilst another, more stabby person controls Jason. In order to win, the teenaged knife-dodgers must complete preparatory tasks in order to escape, whilst Jason has to make them a pot of tea and Viennese whirls (and/or murder them).

So far, so good - except, the game has more bugs than a lakeside barbecue, with some of the most egregious being Jason just... walking through closed doors intended to slow him down, and magically teleporting victims back to him to deliver a final blow (affectionately referred to by players as “his rubber band”).

In addition, the game stopped receiving updates years ago, so unless they pull a “Jason X”, looks like Friday the 13th is gubbed... for good.


2. Aliens: Colonial Marines

Aliens Colonial Marines Xenomorph
SEGA

Seeing a developer pick up the Alien licence should evoke feelings of excitement, but after Colonial Marines, my reaction is now a kneejerk “get away from her, you BITCH!”.

Though the later Alien Isolation would do a fantastic job of recreating the authentic Alien survival horror, Colonial Marines didn’t do even close to the same for that the authentic Aliens action-horror (Alien and Aliens, any fan will tell you, are part of completely different genres which deserve totally different game treatments).

The tumultuous development and shocking handling of marketing (with Gearbox’s Randy Pitchford even flat-out lying about features and levels of detail which would never be in the game) sadly transferred to the gameplay, which was less scary than a Labrador puppy eating trifle - the much-touted “hive AI” of the xenomorphs seemed to amount to little more than several of them spinning rapidly on the spot, waiting to be shot, and the occasional “straight-jacket Alien” awkwardly fidgeting around with a clenched backside like it was attempting to get to the toilet before the aubergine jalfrezi bested it.

Throw in some utterly abysmal set-pieces which occasionally just flat-out crashed the game, and you have a Giger-inspired monstrosity revolting for all the wrong reasons.


1. Extinction

Extinction Game
Iron Galaxy

Oh, Extinction. You sure do know how to disappoint a middle-aged man who enjoys stylised anime violence his mum says “looks like it’s for bairns”.

At the height of my Attack on Titan excitement, I bought the official game and found it... not all that bad, but I needed more. I turned my attention towards this amazing-looking giant-slaying game by the guys who worked on the new Killer Instinct, and bought Extinction on day one.

I did not manage to play it for a whole day.

Extinction is enraging to play. You must remove the attacking giants’ limbs before going for their heads, but movement is bizarrely simultaneously jerky and unresponsive. You leap onto a giant and the camera gets stuck in their crotch. You kill a giant, then inexplicably die without cause moments later.

During one mission, I had to protect the city from giant onslaught/kill them all, and I did so with time to spare. However, the city’s health meter kept depleting for no reason, and I failed. Same thing happened a second time. It wasn’t until I changed the order I killed the giants in that the meter stopped.

Another... giant disappointment. I guess you could say I...

...oh, you’ve already left.


Watch Next


Friday the 13th Quiz: How Well Do You Know Jason Voorhees?

Friday the 13th Part 6 Jason Lives Jason Voorhees
Paramount

1. In Which Movie Did Jason's Trademark Hockey Mask Make Its First Appearance?

Contributor
Contributor

Hiya, you lot! I'm Tommy, a 39-year-old game developer from Scotland - I live on the East coast in an adorable beachside village. I've worked on Need for Speed, Cake Bash, Tom Clancy's The Division, Driver San Francisco, Viva Pinata: Trouble in Paradise, Kameo 2 and much more. I enjoy a pun and, of course, suffer fools gladly! Join me on Twitter at @TotoMimoTweets for more opinion diarrhoea.