10 Great Video Games That Are Ugly On Purpose

Minecraft being purposefully butt-ugly hasn't stopped it from selling over 200 million copies.

Kane & Lynch 2
Square Enix

Though visuals certainly aren't the be-all and end-all of any video game, it's fair to say that few things will turn players off faster than disappointingly low-fi graphics or an art style that looks like cat vomit.

But every so often a developer will get daring enough to release a game that looks intentionally revolting to the gaming mainstream, whether deliberately offering up nauseating imagery, attempting to ape the dated style of classic games, or building an ugly aesthetic that reflects the game's own thematic ugliness.

At first glance these 10 games were all immediately offputing to masses of potential customers, despite the fact that beneath their willfully gross veneer was a genuinely fantastic piece of work.

Some of these games are even ranked among the very best examples of their respective genres, and while their obtuse, unconventional approaches to art design certainly took some getting used to, it was ultimately well worth sticking with in each case.

The lesson here? Don't judge a game from a single screenshot or short gameplay video: sometimes ugliness can be a virtue, believe it or not. If any of these 10 games looked conventionally "pretty", they just wouldn't hit quite the same way...

10. Undertale

undertale omega flowey
Toby Fox

While Undertale is a ridiculously impressive achievement in being largely developed by a single person, it's also fair to say that it's not exactly a looker in the graphics department.

As with many games produced by small teams - or in this case, one guy - Undertale touts an unassuming, retro pixel art style, with sprite-based, low-detail environments and characters that are regularly offensive to the eyes.

Undertale just so happens to be such a clever and inventive spin on RPG tropes that it's tremendously enjoyable regardless. Plus, just when you think you've seen everything the game has to offer, Photoshop Flowey happens.

Depending on your play-style, you might end up facing off against this truly hideous abomination at game's end - the Neutral Route's monstrous, Kaiju-like final boss which is rendered in a markedly more grotesque, "realistic" style compared to everything else before it.

The jarring nature of Photoshop Flowey's design only makes his appearance that much more shocking and disgusting, ensuring that Undertale's rough-hewn visuals represent far more than just another attempt to cash in on 8-bit nostalgia.


9. The Binding Of Isaac

The Binding Of Isaac
Nicalis

This won't be the only time that a game created by Edmund McMillen appears on this list - that dude sure does know how to create something that makes players feel visceral, primordial disgust.

One such game is his legendary 2011 roguelike The Binding of Isaac, which is filled to the brim with deeply offputting imagery, from penile and feces-based enemies to a dominant aesthetic defined by only the most soul-crushingly dreary browns and reds.

While it's fair to say that the original Flash version of the game was basically ugly out of necessity, the slicker 2014 remake, The Binding of Isaac: Rebirth, nevertheless retains that holistic original art style, which is 100% consistent with the game's darkly transgressive themes and ideas.

The Binding of Isaac's wilful desire to disgust won't be for everyone, and that's fine, but beneath its deeply grotty visage is one of the greatest roguelikes ever made.


8. Kane & Lynch 2: Dog Days

Kane and Lynch 2
Square Enix

While the original Kane & Lynch wasn't exactly a paragon of aesthetically appealing craftsmanship, sequel Dog Days saw developers IO Interactive make a concerted effort to ugly-up basically every aspect of the series' visual style.

Kane & Lynch 2 is designed to resemble the aesthetic of carnage captured on a '90s camcorder, complete with potentially nauseating shaky camerawork and intentionally garish colour contrast, where the darks are crushed into oblivion and the lights are blindingly bright.

The game's image also regularly pixelates and distorts as though we're watching an illicit streaming video we shouldn't be, all of this working in stark opposition to the original's more conventional style.

And yet, it totally works in accentuating the oppressive, nihilistic vibe the developers were shooting for, transcending mere visual scuzziness to become basically experimental.

The game's art director, Rasmus Poulsen, even took a camcorder to Shanghai to capture reference materials for the desired aesthetic, and went on to dub Kane & Lynch 2 an "anti-game" - a rebuke to all the flippantly violent shooters on the market.

While it's far from perfect mechanically, Kane & Lynch 2 dares to go to uncomfortable places that most games wouldn't dare, shoving the grossness of wanton violence in the player's face and asking them if they're still having fun.


7. Hotline Miami

Hotline miami
Devolver Digital

Ultra-violent top-down shooter Hotline Miami is a game that few are playing for the visuals.

Sure, its pixel art throwback style emerged at just the right time in the indie game boom, before players had again become tired of it, but there's still little escaping the fact that this is not a pleasant game to look at. At all.

For starters, the environments are largely incredibly bland and thrown-together, the animations are rudimentary, and the fleeting glimpses of people's actual faces look like they were drawn by somebody's kid brother. And yet, it's all entirely in step with the '80s throwback vibe the game is going for.

Most importantly, though, the moment-to-moment combat is so brilliantly done, and so fiendishly tense, that the aggressively rough-edged visuals can't hurt it. Hell, you might even end up charmed by those horrid, detail-devoid textures.


6. Psychonauts

Psychonauts Raz
Majesco Entertainment

Though Psychonauts 2 was largely well received by fans and critics alike, believe it or not there were those who complained that it didn't look ugly enough, that the original's disconcerting nightmare fuel aesthetic had been given an overly slick makeover.

Psychonauts' commercial failure upon original release has been often blamed on the game's willfully offputting visual style, especially its aggressively grotesque character designs, namely protagonist Raz, whose ill-proportioned facial features are enough to give anyone the heebie-jeebies.

Similarly, given that the game predominantly takes place in surreal mindscapes, the level design is fittingly unconventional, employing unsettling imagery to keep the player uncomfortable at almost all times.

This manifests most infamously in the game's climactic Meat Circus level, taking place in a literal carnival of dead animals as is sure to revolt not only vegetarians but, well, basically everybody.

But Psychonauts' ingenuity nevertheless made it a cult classic despite failing to strike a chord with the mainstream, as legendary director Tim Schafer - who, having previously directed Grim Fandango, knows a thing or two - committed wholeheartedly to the game's twisted, uncanny style.


5. Cruelty Squad

Cruelty Squad
Consumer Softproducts

Cruelty Squad is, more than most games on this list, a title that absolutely won't be for everyone, and that's primarily because its visual style is so unabashedly repulsive. This isn't a game you'd ever want to play hungover, that's for sure.

An acid-dipped riff on classic stealth-action games like Hitman, Cruelty Squad casts players in the role of an assassin tasked with carrying out various assignments.

The big difference? You're a biologically augmented assassin residing in what the developer describes as a "sewage infused garbage world." No lies detected.

The various sandbox levels and all the UI elements are willfully hideous in what's both a throwback to underground FPS games of decades past, and something of a response to the "realism" sought by modern military shooters.

The blocky, low-polygon graphics and nauseatingly garish textures are tailor-made to induce as much discomfort in the player as possible, evoking the vibe that this is something you probably shouldn't be playing.

Yet underneath its purposefully gross aesthetic is a genuinely riveting, refreshingly straight-forward tactical shooter unencumbered by the excessive, overbaked mechanics of modern FPS games.


4. Manhunt

Manhunt Game
Rockstar

For all the flak it received for its brutal violence - to the extent it was even accused, and later cleared, of inspiring a murder in the UK - there's no denying that Rockstar weren't trying to deceive anyone with Manhunt's makes-you-want-to-shower aesthetic.

Given that Manhunt tasks the player with participating in a series of snuff films in order to earn their freedom, it's fitting that the developer decided to style their game in the vein of a grungy, grotty VHS tape that's spent years festering in a police evidence lockup.

The various executions you're able to mete out to your victims are typically displayed through a rough VHS filter, complete with video tracking lines and artifacting suggesting a tape that's been watched a few times too many.

While not pleasant to the eye, this style is absolutely effective in keeping the player on an uneven keel, ensuring they're always unnerved and anxious about what's coming next.

Throw in the fairly bland texture work and lack of colours and this is a game that bleeds violent miserable atmosphere from every pore.

If certainly not as refined as most of Rockstar's beloved AAA efforts, Manhunt nevertheless remains a cult classic for a reason: it pushed the bounds of taste and decency while mostly making good on its Running Man-inspired concept.


3. Papers, Please

Papers Please
Lucas Pope

Sometimes a repellent art style is entirely appropriate for a game examining the wider-reaching, mostly unseen horrors in society.

That's certainly true of 2013's puzzle-simulation game Papers, Please, where players assume the role of a border-crossing immigration officer in a fictional dystopian nation.

Throughout the game you're tasked with inspecting immigrants' documentation to determine the legitimacy of their case, or whether they might be a political dissident seeking to undermine the state.

Ethical dilemmas naturally run rife throughout the masterful game, if you're able to vault the considerable hurdle that is the game's flat, unappealing visual style.

If somebody showed you a screengrab of Papers, Please sight unseen, you'd be forgiven for assuming it was a good 30 years old.

However, the muddy textures and general lack of visual detail only further underline the drudgery of the player's miserable job throughout the game.

Meanwhile the immigrant characters you're tasked with examining are rendered in such uncanny, unappealing pixel art form as to accentuate the dehumanising manner in which the state machine regards them. Genius.


2. Minecraft

Minecraft Game Image
Mojang / Microsoft

Now, anybody who knows anything about Minecraft will appreciate that its blocky 3D aesthetic is one of its most identifiable elements, and certainly hasn't prevented it from selling 238 million copies and becoming the single best-selling video game of all time.

Though there's absolutely a quaint charm to Minecraft's low-fi visuals, make no mistake - it is ugly.

While players have created their own stunning texture modifications over the years, and the game does now support ray tracing, that blocky, ill-aged style still prevails to this very day.

Though developer Mojang announced an aesthetic overhaul with a planned 4K "Super Duper Graphics Pack" in 2017, it was ultimately cancelled in 2019 due to technical issues with getting the pack working across platforms.

Yet this really only reinforces that Minecraft's low-rent visual presentation is one of the reasons for its success - it's simple, clean, and easy for kids and adults alike to understand, while technically undemanding enough to work on basically every gaming device known to man.

Minecraft's complex crafting system likely wouldn't be so popular if the game opted for a more detailed, even "realistic" style, and so this more pared-down aesthetic fits the game's design philosophy like a glove.


1. Super Meat Boy

Super Meat Boy
Team Meat

Edmund McMillen's Super Meat Boy is one of the most important and influential platformers of the last 15 years, no matter that its dominant aesthetic is absolutely revolting.

At first glance you could be forgiven for assuming that the game was just one of the thousands of low-rent Flash games released in the early 2000s, so hideous is its overall style.

For the bulk of the game, the art design is defined by drab, colourless industrial environments, seemingly designed to further demoralise players through this oppressively challenging, yet compulsively addictive, piece of work.

It's a testament to the fluidity of the platforming itself that Super Meat Boy is still such a blast to play, no matter how much of an eyesore its environments tend to be.

Ironically the long-awaited sequel, Super Meat Boy Forever, was widely criticised by fans for its slicker, more polished, and more colourful aesthetic, which many felt ran counter to the first game's grimy ethos.


Watch Next


Contributor
Contributor

Stay at home dad who spends as much time teaching his kids the merits of Martin Scorsese as possible (against the missus' wishes). General video game, TV and film nut. Occasional sports fan. Full time loon.