10 Incredible Video Games That Never Existed
Cancelled before their time.
Often, a smaller company will struggle to convince a larger publisher into taking a chance on an unproven concept. Publishers are cautious, especially when it comes to spending money; they expect immediate returns on their investments, and their expectations are often unrealistic, or downright implausible.
In some cases, the cost of actually producing a game will exceed initial predictions, and in these instances, a publisher might choose to axe an upcoming title, rather than allow for it to come to fruition.
Ultimately, the decision to cancel a video game is about cutting losses, or at least, potential losses. Sometimes, the game in question is much anticipated, and would likely achieve a degree of commercial success, but that alone isn’t enough to guarantee its survival. In some instances, a game is cancelled for seemingly no reason whatsoever, or because of something utterly arbitrary, like a disagreement over artistic direction.
Whatever the reason, the following titles were all cancelled before their time, and will remain incomplete forever - or at least the foreseeable future. Some of them had trailers, and some even had playable demos, but none made it onto store shelves. They were abandoned in an unfinished state, and while many of them might have turned out excellently, we’ll simply never know what could have been.
With that said, here are 10 incredible video games that never existed, but certainly should have…
10. Silent Hills
Announced in 2014, Silent Hills was heavily
anticipated, and was planned to be the ninth instalment in the Silent Hill
franchise. Directed by Hideo Kojima and Guillermo Del Toro, the game was unveiled
via a playable teaser, entitled P.T., which tasked players with navigating
their way through a haunted house, which functioned as though a cyclical
labyrinth, growing steadily more eerie over time.
Solving the final puzzle of the teaser (which was downright impossible) revealed the title for the upcoming project, as well as several other crucial details. However, following the completion of Metal Gear Solid V: The Phantom Pain, Silent Hills was cancelled due to a dispute between Konami and Kojima, and though the details of that dispute are unconfirmed, it resulted in Kojima leaving the company altogether for pastures new.
In some alternate reality somewhere, Silent Hills was finished and released, and in all likelihood, it’s one of my favourite games. P.T. alone won multiple awards, and was downloaded over a million times prior to its removal from PSN.
Can you even imagine how successful it would have been? Representing a dream collaboration between several prominent creators including legendary manga artist, Junji Ito, Silent Hills was all set to take the world by storm. Alas, we’ll never know... but we can dream.
9. Mega Man Legends 3
A staple of videogames, Mega Man has been around since
1987, and has since produced well over fifty unique titles, spanning multiple
console generations. In 1997, a decade after Mega Man first premiered on the
Nintendo Entertainment System, Capcom released Mega Man Legends, a spin-off
series which aimed to take the franchise in an all new direction, emphasising a
more versatile exploration over linear platforming.
After three successful instalments in the series, Mega Man Legends went into hibernation until 2010, at which point it was announced during a Nintendo press conference that Mega Man Legends 3 was finally entering production, and would debut on the 3DS.
In July 2011, Mega Man Legends 3 was suddenly cancelled, a mere year after it was first announced. Unsurprisingly, fans took to the news with disappointment; however, that disappointment quickly transformed into resentment after Capcom essentially blamed the cancellation of the project on a lack of public interest.
In reality, the cancellation of Mega
Man Legends 3 had little to do with the fans, and was more likely caused the departure of series co-creator, Keiji
Inafune, who left Capcom in November 2010.
8. Shadow Realms
First announced in 2014, Shadow Realms was an action-oriented RPG with a competitive multiplayer focus. At the time, the game was
being developed by Bioware Austin, and was scheduled for release in 2015. Prior
to its eventual cancellation in February, Shadow Realms was planned as an
episodic title, and would have featured co-operative style gameplay, pitting four players against the Shadowlord, who would have been controlled by a fifth
player.
Initially delayed due to poor player
feedback, Shadow Realms was later cancelled entirely. All references to the game were
removed from EA’s official website, and the team assigned to the project were
redistributed throughout the company, and reassigned to other projects,
including Star Wars: The Old Republic. To this day, little is known about the
game’s cancellation, although it seems to have been the result of a large scale shift in
focus.
Strangely enough, Shadow Realms seems to have made it quite a ways into production. Gameplay footage is extensive, and looks fairly promising. It may not have set the world on fire, but it could have been a huge amount of fun. In the end, we’ll never know.
7. Thrill Kill
Due for release in 1998, Thrill Kill was a fighting game designed around several mature themes, and was planned to be the first entry in a new franchise.
In the game, players would have chosen from a selection of
playable characters, pitting those character against one another in a multitude
of different environments. The objective was to decimate your opponents in the
bloodiest, most creative ways conceivable, gradually increasing your ‘bloodlust’
until you could to perform special, gruesome fatalities, known as 'thrill kills'.
The game was being developed by Paradox Entertainment, and was planned to be published by Virgin Interactive, who were later purchased in their entirety by Electronic Arts. EA, concerned by the violence inherent in the game, decided to cancel the project, fearing that its release would tarnish their public reputation. In fairness, Thrill Kill was an exceptionally violent game; however, it was also entirely finished project, ready to go.
The game featured moves with suggestive titles, such as ‘Bitch Slap’ and ‘Swallow This’, and was actually the first game to receive the AO (Adults Only) rating from the E.S.R.B. As a result, EA decided to axe the project in order to avoid potential outrage. The game itself was highly anticipated, and its cancellation disappointed a great many fans.
Ultimately, it was ahead of its time, and if were released today, no one would have batted an eye.
6. Fallout 3
The original version of Fallout 3 was in development for a long time prior to its eventual cancellation in 2003. Codenamed Van Buren, the game was being developed by Black Isles Studios, and had been delayed on multiple occasions in favour of other projects.
Tasked with surviving the perils of the wastelandsIn the game, players would have taken control of an unnamed prisoner, and like the two previous instalments in the series, Fallout 3 featured a top-down perspective and turn-based combat, emphasising strategy and exploration more than ever before.
Sadly, in 1998, Interplay Entertainment very nearly filed for bankruptcy, and were forced to disband Black Isles Studios. Fallout 3, as well as several other projects were cancelled in the process.
In 2008, Bethesda's revamped Fallout 3 was released an entire decade after the last instalment in the series and was praised almost unanimously by critics. To date, the game has been awarded countless honours, and is considered one of the finest games of the previous generation.
With that said, Bethesda’s version was a significant departure for the series, and while many people approved of this departure, others lamented the cancellation of Van Buren, which was considered to be the true sequel to Fallout 1 & 2.
5. Prey 2
Officially announced in 2011, Prey 2 was the sequel to
2006’s Prey, a first-person shooter developed by Human Head Studios that emphasised
nonlinear exploration, environmental puzzles and gravity manipulation. The
planned sequel would have seen players take on the role of Killian Samuels, an
amnesiac bounty-hunter tasked with apprehending dangerous fugitives on a futuristic
alien planet, Exodus.
A preview of the game was showcased at E3 2011, and was positively received. Shortly after, Prey 2 was delayed by Bethesda, and rumours began to circulate that the game had actually been cancelled. In reality, development had been shifted away from Human Head Studios in favour of Arkane, the creators of Dishonored. It was later revealed that development on the game would begin from scratch, which was surprisingly considering how much progress Human Head Studios had reportedly made on their version of the game.
Infuriated by the decision, narrative designed Jason L. Blair took to Twitter to condemn the cancellation, describing Bethesda’s decision as politically motivated, and ‘potentially litigable’. He also commented on the progress that the original team had made, and even went as far as to describe Prey 2 as a complete game, a finished product ready to be shipped:
“It was a lot more than a demo. Prey 2 was a full game. And a crazy fun one. The team was small but you wouldn’t have known it”.
4. Mega Man Universe
Announced in 2010, and inspired predominantly by Mega
Man 2, Mega Man Universe would have allowed players to create their own unique stages,
and share those stages with friends over Xbox Live and PSN. The game was being developed
by Mega Man co-creator Keiji Inafune, and would have allowed players to
customise their own characters, unlock special abilities and equipment, and
even redesign existing stages.
Essentially the Mega Man equivalent of Mario Maker, the game was cancelled in 2011 because of ‘various circumstances’. In reality, Capcom has demonstrated little interest in the blue bomber for as long as can be remembered. Following Keiji Inafune’s departure from the company, both Mega Man Legends 3 and Mega Man Universe were cancelled. In all likelihood, Inafune was the one man keeping the franchise, as well as the character alive.
While Mega Man Universe represented a huge departure for the series, and received a fair amount of criticism for its unfamiliar visual style, the game had a huge amount of potential.
Like Mario Maker, MMU might have been infinitely enjoyable, seeing as how it involved players creating their own challenges, and essentially entertaining themselves. It would have been the perfect send-off for the character and the series, but Capcom had other ideas.
3. Conker: Gettin' Medieval
After the release of Conker’s Bad Fur Day in 2001,
Rare began work on a sequel, initially codenamed Conker’s Other Bad Day. In the
game, players would have reassumed the role of the titular squirrel, who after
being crowned king is sentence to execution for spending his kingdom’s entire treasury
on booze. The tone of the game would have been faithful to the original, and several
prominent characters were planned to make reappearances.
In 2002, Rare was purchased in its entirety by Microsoft, who immediately scrapped the game in favour of other projects, including a remake of Conker’s Bad Fur Day for the original Xbox, titled Conker: Live & Reloaded.
Rare had planned to develop a sequel to Live & Reloaded, which would have emphasised co-operative multiplayer, as well as large scale siege warfare. It was called Conker: Getting’ Medieval, and would have featured Death as a playable character, but it too was cancelled for indistinct reasons.
In September 2015, Rare released a video detailing the project, and showcasing several examples of unused concept art. Perhaps hoping to reignite some interest in the game, the video goes into great detail about the premise, as well as the look and feel of the game.
Ultimately, Conker: Gettin’ Medieval might someday happen, but for the time being, it’s just a mausoleum of wasted potential and unrealised possibilities.
2. Star Wars 1313
In October 2012, Disney purchased LucasArts for a whopping $4.05 billion, and proceeded to disembowel the company. At first, LucasArts were permitted to continue working on their own projects, and it seemed as though business would continue as usual.
In March 2013, Disney cancelled a
number of projects, and halted all internal development within the company.
They proceeded to layoff the vast majority of LucasArts employees, and reduce
the company to a small skeleton crew of around ten individuals.
During this time, a number of unfinished projects were abandoned, including Star Wars 1313, a third-person shooter which emphasised exploration and cover-based shooting. In the game, players would have taken on the role of a young Boba Fett, and the plot would have revolved around eliminating various targets through the underworld metropolis of Coruscant. Unlike previous games, Star Wars 1313 would have emphasised fast-paced shooting rather than Force abilities, and would have been significantly darker than previous instalments in the franchise.
Footage of the game looked promising, and development had progressed significantly prior to its eventual cancellation. The game was originally announced in 2012, and was generating a significant degree of excitement. In all likelihood, it would have been a huge success, and while it could still be revived at some point in the future, there are currently no plans to do so.
1. Earthbound 64
Cancelled in 2000, Earthbound 64 began
development in 1994, and was delayed multiple times prior to its eventual
cancellation. In Japan, a version of the game was released in 2006, entitled
Mother 3, and was generally well received by fans and critics alike. Outside of
Japan, Earthbound 64 never materialised, despite being rumoured to be over 50% complete.
Production on Earthbound 64 persisted for years, and was ported from console to console throughout the 90s. The game was originally planned to be released on the Super Nintendo Entertainment System, but was later moved to the N64, and finally the GameCube.
The cancellation itself was the result of several contributing factors, two of which related directly to the game being overly ambitious. Despite his lack of experience, Shigesato Itoi developed Earthbound 64 using 3D technologies, which ultimately exceeded the capabilities of the platform.
Likewise, the game was rumoured to be over sixty hours in length, which would have made it the longest game in the entire series.
In the end, Earthbound 64 couldn’t meet its own unrealistic
expectations, and was left playing catch up for years prior to its eventual
cancellation. In fairness, Nintendo did everything within their power to keep
the project alive, but it was ultimately sunk by its own ambition.
--
Are there any we missed? Let us now in the comments which other in-development games got shafted before release?