10 Most MADDENING Bosses In SoulsBorne Games
Elden Ring, Bloodborne, Dark Souls - FromSoftware you CAN play with madness.
Now this is a surprise.
As you likely noticed, the much-anticipated Shadow of the Erdtree finally dropped on June 21st. Yet rather than the unanimous praise many expected for FromSoftware's latest, the reaction from gamers has been surprisingly mixed (literally, in the case of the game's overall Steam rating). Many of the complaints stem from Shadow of the Erdtree's punishingly high difficulty as, despite coming out two years after the base game, the DLC brooks no quarter for those whose skills have grown rusty in the intervening period. Erdtree starts out hard, and finishes with the stiffest challenge in SoulBorne history.
To be fair, we should probably have seen this coming. After all, FromSoftware have a long and storied history of casting their customers into the pits of madness.
This list will take a look at ten bosses from the delightfully portmanteaued SoulsBorne series (so no Armored Core 6 - sorry, CEL 240 lovers/haters). Each boss has been chosen specifically for its ability to drive the player into a frenzy that would have the average C'thulu cultist say "Dude, chill", whether it be from a ludicrously high level of challenge, bad design, or unfair mechanics.
And to start us off, let's take a look at the man of the hour...
10. Blackgaol Knight (Elden Ring: Shadow of the Erdtree)
Picture the scene:
You've just paid £35/$40 for Shadow of the Erdtree. You've gone through dozens of hours of high-stress combat in the base game just to reach the area where the DLC begins. You've jumped through every hoop and are ready to explore the Lands of Shadow. You take your first tentative, trembling steps into a whole new world...
And then a homocidal knight charges in and one-shots you into oblivion.
"You buffoon. You dolt. You blundering, oafish poltroon of a human. You dare - you dare - think that just because you paid money, just because you passed every test we set you, you can simply wander in to the Lands of Shadow and enjoy yourself? You scum. You worm. You snivelling little excrement. Get down on your knees, lick our armored boots, and PRAY FOR MERCY THAT SHALL NEVER BE GRANTED!"
Now, obviously there's no way of knowing if this meme-inspired rant was actually going through the mind of whoever designed the Blackgaol Knight. But that's the impression given by Shadow of the Erdtree's brutal introduction into its world. Simply even reaching the DLC's start point is a feat in itself, yet having done so your first experience in the Lands of Shadow will likely be a chastening, knight-assisted annihilation.
It's enough to make you feel like developers FromSoftware made a concerted attempt to break their fanbase as quickly as possible. And given how many negative Steam reviews mention the Blackgaol Knight by name, it's safe to say they succeeded.
9. Old King Allant (Demon's Souls)
Demon's Souls - the game that kicked off the SoulsBorne series - is impressively creative in the number of ways its boss fights frustrate the player. From the manic, flailing brutality of the Flamelurker to the sheer sh*thousery of the Maneater spawning a second boss halfway through the fight, Demon's Souls made clear FromSoftware's mission to challenge their fanbase to the brink of insanity.
However, the developers saved their most brutal party trick for last - a gimmick so cruel that it's never been used again in any of their other games. Old King Allant may cut a gallant figure, but he utilizes one of the dirtiest tricks possible in an RPG - level-draining.
Yes, Allant won't just kill you, he'll permanently weaken you if you screw up during the fight. When his hand starts glowing, you'd better time your next doge-roll to perfection or the King will grab hold of your character and drain an entire level from their body. And no, you don't get that level back after you beat him.
Years after the fact, even when all other memories of the game have been lost to time, anyone unlucky enough to have been on the receiving end of Old King Allant's signature move will still be able to recall the stomach-lurching, brain-bending outrage felt upon seeing the words "Soul Level Drained" flash across the screen.
8. Capra Demon (Dark Souls)
The above photo shows the Capra Demon doing what he does best - winding up to crush a Dark Souls neophyte under his preposterously large club.
The inclusion of good old Cappy may raise some eyebrows among SoulsBorne veterans - he is by far and away the easiest boss on this list - but for many gamers this boss battle was where Dark Souls' infamous "git gud" mentality first made itself apparent.
Up to this point, Dark Souls' bosses are surprisingly straightforward affairs. The Asylum Demon is a literal tutorial boss, and the Taurus Demon telegraphs its attacks so blatantly it might as well be attacking you with a semaphore flag. The Capra Demon, however, is where things get interesting. Controller-snappingly interesting
This is because Cappy D doesn't fight alone. The undead ovine brings two snarling dogs with him into battle, and its these feral hounds that will give conniptions to Dark Souls novices. Trying to simultaneously dodge a pair of angry canines while their 10-foot master attempts to hit a home run with your skull feels nigh-on impossible at first, and is the first of many boss-based brick walls Dark Souls throws your way.
Subsequent playthroughs reveal that the Capra Demon is actually one of Dark Souls' easier bosses, but for those just starting out the goat-faced demon is the first real indicator of the soul-crushing frustration that typifies the series.
7. Demon Of Hatred (Sekiro: Shadows Die Twice)
The first Sekiro entry on this list, the Demon of Hatred was named after the emotions he generates in the player. (Fun fact*: his original name was Demon of Hatred, Disbelief and You've Got To Be F**ing Sh**ting Me, but the developers couldn't get it to fit in the text box).
But it's not just the Monster of Loathing's sky-high difficulty that earns him a place on this list. What makes this fight doubly mind-breaking is that beating the Fiend of Resentment requires the player to unlearn the tactics that brought them to this point. Sekiro's combat is built on parrying your opponents, but you simply can't do that to the Devil of Hostility (last one, I promise). Instead, you have to dodge around him and whittle away at all three of his health bars until he falls.
And the kicker? He's completely optional. Which means that the hours of misery and frustration spent banging your head against this adamantine wall of difficulty until it crumbles are completely unnecessary.
To quote the UK's patron saints of self-loathing, Radiohead: "You do it to yourself, you do, and that's what really hurts".
*Not a fact
6. The Bed Of Chaos (Dark Souls)
The Bed of Chaos sits at the top of many a "Worst Souls Boss Ever" list, and for good reason.
The monstrous tree/tentacle/fire hybrid may look visually striking, but the awe soon gives way to ennui as you try your luck again and again like a gambler desperate to snap a losing streak. There's no strategy to the fight - you either get knocked into the abyss by a randomly flailing tentacle, or you get lucky and stumble into striking distance of the monstrous entity's weak points.
Far more than any other SoulsBorne boss, defeating the Bed of Chaos relies on a combination of luck and sheer bloody-mindedness. All you do is race across the arena, being buffeted by tentacles like a ball in an Lovecraftian pachinko machine, hoping each time that fortune will favour you and let you hit the jackpot (or weak spot, in this case).
To be fair, the developers themselves clearly knew the fight was broken - that's why Bed of Chaos is one of the few SoulsBorne bosses with built-in checkpoints. Because without that safety net, actually managing to hit all three weak-spots without dying to random tentacle violence would require enough luck to power a national lottery win.
5. Sister Friede (Dark Souls III: Ashes of Ariandel)
Nuns. Why did it have to be nuns?
Quick history lesson: When Dark Souls III came out in 2016, it was initially derided by hardcore fans for a relatively low difficulty (emphasis very much placed on the word 'relatively'). FromSoftware obviously heard those rumblings of discontent, as DS3's first expansion pack was a doozy. Ashes of Ariandel is a monstrously tough chunk of DLC to chew on, and its capped off with one of the most difficult SoulsBorne bosses ever to make a player headbutt their controller in anger.
Whereas most bosses in the third Dark Souls have two distinct phases, Sister Friede has three. So you can imagine the gut-wrenching disbelief felt when, after Friede falls for a second time, she resurrects herself for a third go on the merry-go-round of your rapidly degrading sanity. And if you guessed that this third phase was the toughest of the lot, congratulations! You are now on the same wavelength as the sadists who designed the damn thing. Please report yourself to the nearest government building for registration.
Sister Friede is a three-course serving of utter misery, served up with a wimple and an attitude of withering contempt towards the player. As such, she's the perfect rebuttal to those who wished on their monkey paws for Dark Souls III to provide a stiffer challenge.
4. Elden Beast (Elden Ring)
Before we begin this entry, can everyone take a moment to drink in the Elden Beast's sumptuous appearance? A living, breathing Cosmos in Elder God form, the Elden Beast is a stunning work of creature design. To FromSoftware's artists, we offer a well-deserved round of applause.
To FromSoftware's programmers, we offer a vigourous shake of the lapels and a spittle-flecked scream of "WHY DID YOU WAIT TWO YEARS TO FIX THIS ****ING FIGHT?"
Yes, turns out Elden Ring players have spent the past two years banging their heads on a final boss that launched with a key feature missing - the ability to hop on your mount and gallop around the Elden Beast's gigantic lair.
Given the vast size of the arena the battle takes place in, it's always been obvious that the fight was built around the player being able to summon their steed to chase down their prey - especially as the Elden Beast has a nasty habit of warping from one end of the battlefield to the other.
God knows why FromSoftware left out such a vital aspect of the fight, or why it took them so long to get around to fixing it. But the realization that, due to the developers negligence, gamers have been effectively fighting Elden Ring's final boss with one hand tied behind their backs is enough to make you break down like a Lovecraft character who just realized their life is controlled by the whims of careless, idiot gods.
3. Orphan of Kos (Bloodborne: The Old Hunters)
Given the subject matter of this list, Orphan of Kos was an obvious shoe-in.
Indeed, when it comes to mania-inducing SoulsBorne bosses, few better to fit the bill than Bloodborne's placenta-wielding infant. The final boss of Bloodborne's superlative The Old Hunters expansion pack, Orphan of Kos is described in the game's lore as a life-form created specifically to kill monster hunters, of which the player is one. Suffice it to say, it's a task the eldritch Orphan excels at.
Of all the bosses on this list, it's the Orphan of Kos who most expertly tightropes across the line separating "frustration" and "elation". Make no mistake, the parent-deprived monstrosity's brutal, erratic fighting style will cause more than a few choice words to slip from your tongue. But unlike many other bosses on this list, the thrill of the fight never devolves into weary drudgery.
Whereas defeating many of the other bosses on this list provokes little more than relief (or, in the worst cases, resentment at having so much of your time wasted) beating Orphan of Kos offers a moment of sheer exhilaration that will have you howling in triumph like a wolf that's been anointed leader of the pack - a giddy, triumphant moment of euphoric insanity.
That's not something that can be said about the next entrant...
2. Isshin, The Sword Saint (Sekiro: Shadows Die Twice)
Pray permit a lapse into personal indulgence:
A while back, I wrote a list on the 10 Best Skill-Check Bosses In Gaming History. In the subsequent YouTube video, most of the comments demanded to know why Sekiro's Genichiro Ashina didn't make the list. Put simply, the one-two punch of the Demon of Hatred and Sword Saint Isshin effectively obliterated all my memories of FromSoftware's ninja-em-up, replacing them with only seething rage at the time spent fighting these two colossal bastards - with the vast majority of my loathing being directed at the latter.
Sword Saint Isshin is brutal. An unforgivingly demanding sadist who demands a near-mythical mastery of the game's combat system, Sekiro's final boss is a relentlessly harsh task-master who delights in making you feel small, worthless, and thoroughly demoralized over your own ability. He is essentially JK Simmon's sadistic teacher from Whiplash in video game form.
Sadly, there's no happy ending here. Even after beating him, the energy and time spent on overcoming Sekiro's biggest challenge will leave you drained of all potential for happiness at the result- instead, you will only feel smouldering anger at having had so much of your time wasted. Sword Saint Isshin represents the nadir of the "git gud" ideology espoused by FromSoftware's most zealous fans, and it's hard to see how the developers could create a more singularly aggravating boss figh-
Here Comes A New Challenger!
Warning - the next entry contains spoilers for Shadow of the Erdtree's final boss.
1. Promised Consort Radahn (Elden Ring: Shadow of the Erdtree)
Amazing as it seems to recall now, when Radahn makes his triumphant return as Erdtree's final boss it's initially a feel-good moment. Radahn became one of Elder Ring's breakout characters due to his comical appearance - a very large man on a very small horse - and the epic nature of his boss battle. As such, seeing him look better than ever in Shadow of the Erdtree feels like seeing an old friend who's taken excellent care of himself in the years you've spent apart.
Then the fight begins, and your old friend proceeds to annihilate you like the last time he saw you was in his wife's bed.
Erdtree's Radahn is an absolute nightmare to fight - a colossal, duel-sword wielding god of the battlefield who, in the fight's second phase, is joined by Erdtree's central figure Miquella. This means you now have to contend with magic attacks that can kill you in a single hit, whilst simultaneously dealing with Radahn trying to turn you into a Tarnished shish kebab.
It's a duel-pronged assault on the senses, and one that's taken a legitimate toll on Elden Ring's playerbase - Eurogamer reviewer Alexis Ong said the fight is "...coded to make you start drinking in real life", and streamer KaiCenat literally had a therapist join him mid-stream to give his mental health a much-needed boost after hundreds (yes, hundreds) of failed attempts at felling Radahn.
Frankly, you can hardly blame most players for giving up at this point. Unless Shadow of the Erdtree's ending involves SoulsBorne creator Hidetaka Miyazaki himself coming round to your house, shaking your hand, and filling in your income tax return so you get a disproportionately large refund, it's just not worth the aggravation.