10 Terrifying Secrets In Open World Games

Nobody expected to find this terrifying Dead Space reference in Starfield.

Assassin's Creed Valhalla Shadow Figure Thumbnail
Ubisoft

Alongside the breathtaking scenery and extensive list of side activities for players to complete, developers also like to fill their open world games with a vast array of secrets and Easter Eggs.

Whether they’re tucked away in hard-to-reach areas that sometimes require breaking free of the game’s boundaries to find or hiding them in plain sight, players can expect to find dozens of small hidden details and references if they look hard enough.

Although many of the secrets that players will find during their time exploring these vast and sprawling worlds are normally light-hearted jokes that pay homage to a piece of pop culture or a small in-joke that has to do with another of the developer’s games, not every Easter Egg that players stumble upon is an especially pleasant discovery.

Sometimes developers will include some genuinely frightening pieces of hidden content into their open worlds that players won’t expect to find. These can range from harrowing pieces of worldbuilding, mysterious encounters that raise chilling questions, or some good old fashioned jump scares.

Whatever form these secrets come in, though, players may wish that they never found them in the first place. 

10. The Colander - Starfield

Colander Starfield
Bethesda

When players get access to their spaceship in Starfield, they’re free to traverse the stars and discover the countless wonders and secrets that this game has in store.

Being a massive RPG from Bethesda, a large chunk of these surprises are Easter Eggs. Whether these are references to some of the developer's other titles or pop culture juggernauts like The Office and The Shawshank Redemption, there are plenty of amusing details that players can come across during their interstellar adventure.

Not all these secrets are light-hearted, though, with one genuinely unnerving homage to Dead Space being tucked away in a far-off star system.

Travel to Schrodinger III within the Schrodinger system and players will find The Colander, an abandoned starship floating lifelessly amongst the stars. With no option to hail the crew, things already seem wrong with this location, with events only getting creepier once players board Starfield’s version of the Ishimura.

Through reading the ship's logs, players can uncover the sinister events that happened onboard. Explore further, and they'll eventually face the monstrous creature responsible for massacring the entire crew.

With a fearsome power level of 85, this Necromorph-like creature is likely to make short work of any unsuspecting adventurers.


9. Scarecrow's Lair - Batman: Arkham City

Batman Arkham City Scarecrow Boat
Warner Bros. Interactive Entertainment

Like the rest of the Batman: Arkham series, Batman: Arkham City oozes with a gritty atmosphere that’s tailor-made for the eponymous brooding hero

As well as being responsible for the chilling morgue sequence in Arkham Asylum, Scarecrow also delivered the creepiest part of this sequel.

Although the character doesn’t appear in the flesh in this game, players can find their secret hideout on a boat in the Industrial District, which teases their return in Batman: Arkham Knight.

Upon finding the vessel and decrypting the lock to the hatch with the foreboding code “City Of Terror”, the camera will switch to a first-person perspective when players venture below deck.

What they’ll find is a grimy room filled with tanks of insects, with one of Joker’s henchmen sitting on a chair at the far end.

While it looks like he’s unconscious, getting up close to Scarecrow’s victim and zooming in on their face triggers a jump scare which sees him spring to life before collapsing lifelessly back on the chair.

Not only did this scare catch everyone by surprise, but the implications of what happened to this person were even more disturbing.


8. The Grafted Scion's Secret - Elden Ring

elden ring grafted scion
Bandai Namco

Much like the worlds in FromSoftware’s other Soulsborne titles, the Lands Between in Elden Ring is a place of decay and ruin. From the swamps of Scarlet Rot, dank underground dungeons, and the monstrous enemies that dwell there, players will discover plenty of unpleasant sights on their quest to become Elden Lord.

No part of this game embodies its world’s grim nature better than the Grafted Scions. Created by Godrick The Grafted, these creatures are grotesque, multi-limbed monsters made of various body parts that have been crudely stuck together.

This is the very first enemy players face in the game, but because of how quickly this fight ends and the fact that this boss wears a cloak, players are unable to get a good look at it.

However, by hacking the camera and removing the garment, fans have discovered a terrifying secret.

Alongside the masses of twisted flesh and malformed limbs, the most unnerving aspect about the Grafted Scion is that it has the youthful face of a child. Given that the child wears a crown and has iconography of the golden lineage on their weapons, the sinister implication is that Godric experimented on his young descendants to turn them into these abominations.

This was a bleak revelation even for Elden Ring.


7. O'Hara's Haunted House - Far Cry 5

Far Cry 5 Haunted House
Ubisoft

Set within the picturesque countryside of Montana, there’s tonnes of weird and wonderful things for players to do and discover in Far Cry 5's fictional Hope County whenever they’re not fighting back against the fanatical religious cult terrorising the area.

However, not everything that can be found within Far Cry 5’s large open world is as colourfully bizarre as collecting bull testes or working on the set of a low-budget action flick.

By journeying to O'Hara's Haunted House, players can find one of this game's more frightening additions.

A barn that's been transformed into a spooky funhouse, this location is full of creepy mannequins and jump scares. The scariest thing about this place, though, is a mysterious man who can be seen looking out of the attic window.

However, when players arrive at the attic the man is nowhere to be seen. Instead, players will find a singular red balloon, a menacing note, and a deranged voice message in what is a spine-chilling reference to Pennywise from Stephen King's IT.

This isn't the only reference to the child-eating clown in this game either. A second red balloon can also be found floating next to a sewer in another nod towards this classic horror villain.


6. Children Of The Ark - Cyberpunk 2077

Cyberpunk 2077 Children of the Ark
CD Projekt RED

Given that Cyberpunk 2077 takes place in a dystopian future where shady corporations vie for power and violent gangs rule the streets, it should come as no surprise that some of the hidden secrets that are scattered throughout Night City serve as a reflection on the grimness of this game's setting.

One of the most disturbing additions can be found in the Badlands south of Pacifica.

Just northeast of the Fuel Station fast travel point, players can spot two satellite dishes in the wasteland. Head there and they’ll discover the grizzly sight of numerous corpses lying on the ground that are wired to a dead netrunner. As horrifying as this sight is, things only get worse when uncovering a data shard on the deceased hacker's body.

Reading this note reveals that these people belonged to a cult known as The Children Of The Ark, with this location being their headquarters. Believing that a rogue AI will escape from beyond Blackwall and bring about the end of humanity, the cultists killed themselves so that they could upload their consciousness to a spaceship to escape this supposed Judgement Day.

There's a lot of unpleasantness in Night City, but nothing is quite as shocking as this discovery.


5. The Shadow Creature - Assassin's Creed Valhalla

Assassin's Creed Valhalla Shadow Figure
Ubisoft

Assassin’s Creed Valhalla’s version of 9th century England is a huge and stunning landscape that’s packed with dozens of hours' worth of side activities. However, England isn’t the only map that players explore in this epic game. In addition to the expansions, the base game also includes Norway and Vinland alongside the more fantastical realms of Asgard and Jotunheim.

While each of these areas is home to their own collection of wonderful secrets, Valhalla's most unsettling secret can be found in Jotunheim.

When arriving in this icy land of giants, players can stumble upon something unexpectedly frightening while exploring the southeast of the map.

By looking carefully it’s possible to spot a shadowy creature peering through the fog. With its large antlers, razor-sharp claws, and glowing eyes, this entity has an imposing presence despite not being hostile towards players.

Although there’s nothing in the game that explains what this figure is, fans have speculated that this may be a reference to a similar looking creature from Over The Garden Wall.

Whatever this creature is supposed to be, players won't forget the terror of meeting it for the first time.


4. Children Of Goldshire - World Of Warcraft

Children of Goldshire World of Warcraft
Blizzard

Since releasing in 2004, Blizard have continued to add to beloved MMORPG World of Warcraft, bringing new secrets for players to discover with every expansion. Now regarded as having some of the most Easter Eggs in a video game, this gigantic fantasy world is overloaded with jokes and references.

One of the spookiest secrets in this game can be found in the town of Goldshire, which is one of the first areas that human characters will encounter.

Amongst the friendly locals, players can spot a group of six children running through the town. They spawn every morning at seven o’clock in server time, and if players follow them for long enough, they’ll eventually lead them into an empty house in Crystal Lake (which is also a nod to Friday The 13th). Once there, the children proceed to stand silently in a pentagram formation on the second floor.

As if this wasn’t eerie enough, the pleasant music changes into a much more sinister ambience before the demonic voice of C’Thun, the ancient god of madness, can be heard telling players that their friends will abandon them and that they’re going to die.

Reinforcing just how frightening demonic children can be, this is one of World of Warcraft's most unexpectedly terrifying secrets.


3. Creepy Radio Broadcast - Metal Gear Solid V: The Phantom Pain

Metal Gear Solid V Snake
Konami

Although P.T. has unfortunately been removed from the PlayStation store, this teaser for the tragically cancelled Silent Hills game has remained firmly in the nightmares of whoever walked through its repeating hallways.

This demo was so petrifying that it's been cited as the inspiration for the likes of Layers Of Fear, Visage, and various other titles. Moreover, references to this demo have also appeared in other games, with cyberpunk horror Observer containing a sequence which pays homage to it.

However, another reference to P.T. can also be found in Metal Gear Solid V: The Phantom Pain.

Within the game's Africa map, near the Ngumba Industrial Zone (the same area as the story mission Voices), players can find a small green tent in an enemy camp. Head inside and listen carefully to hear a menacing radio broadcast that details a horrific news story about a man who brutally murders their family.

Anyone who's played the teaser will recognise this as the same broadcast that's heard at the start of the demo. Although there's no Lisa to be found, hearing this transmission will send a chill down players' spines.

While Silent Hills has been erased from existence, P.T. lives on in another of Hideo Kojima's games.


2. The Ghost Girl - Pokémon X and Y

Pokemon Ghost Girl
The Pokémon Company

Despite its colourful and child-friendly appearance, the Pokémon series can be surprisingly dark at times. In addition to a selection of the titular critters possessing backstories that could have been taken straight out of a horror film, the games likewise contain a collection of spine-tingling secrets. The scariest and most infamous of which is the ghost girl from Pokémon X and Y.

Whilst exploring the bustling Luminose City, players can enter an unassuming office building. After taking the elevator to the second floor, the atmosphere quickly changes when the usual upbeat music abruptly stops. The lights flicker, and a girl appears directly behind the player’s character. Floating towards the bottom of the screen, she says “No, you’re not the one” before vanishing offscreen, never to be heard from again.

As well as coming completely out of nowhere, it’s the lack of information about this spectre which makes her appearance so chilling. With nothing in the game that explains who she is or what her cryptic words could mean, it’s up to players to come to their own conclusions about what happened to her.

Out of all the ghosts that have appeared throughout this series, none have quite grabbed the community's attention like this one.


1. Strange Man's Cabin - Red Dead Redemption 2

Red Dead Redemption 2 Strange Man painting
Rockstar

From a literal ghost train, grizzly ritual site, a serial killer, and a vampire, Red Dead Redemption 2 is bursting with numerous secrets that are terrifying enough to earn a place on this list. However, no inclusion is quite as unsettling as what’s become known as the Strange Man's Cabin.

Northwest of Calgia Hall, players can find a rundown shack in the bayou called Bayall Edge. Though the small building looks unassuming from the outside, stepping inside reveals one of this game’s eeriest sights.

Alongside an assortment of strange writings scrawled across the furniture and walls, the cabin features an unfinished portrait that sits in the centre of the room.

More is gradually added to the painting the next three times players visit the location. It's only when arriving for a fourth time during the epilogue that the portrait will be complete, revealing the Strange Man from the first game. Players will also be able to spot the figure in the mirror, watching them, only for them to vanish when turning around.

Raising more questions than answers about who this seemingly supernatural top-hatted figure is, it's this cabin's unknowable nature which makes it one of the spookiest places in the entire game.


Watch Next


 
Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

Glasgow-based cinephile who earned a Masters degree in film studies to spend their time writing about cinema, video games, and horror.