10 Terrifying Video Game Truths You Never Noticed

NPCs have character arcs too.

fear 2
Monolith Productions

Here at WhatCulture we love digging around video games for hidden secrets and revelations, especially if those tidbits are more than a little bit creepy.

Back in January of 2021 we made a video covering off on 10 horrifying things that could be found in video games by only the most attentive of players.

Turns out the most attentive of players absolutely includes some of you guys who offered up a handful of other spooky hidden truths that would have been right at home on that original list.

So, given our mutual love of tracking down the nastiest easter eggs and secrets waiting to be discovered in our favourite video games, let's dig in to ten more.

--

10. Horrible Consequences - Assassin’s Creed: Odyssey

assassins creed odyssey
Ubisoft

Apart from offering up the opportunity to visit some iconic locations and characters found around ancient Greece, Odyssey also lets you make some genuinely interesting choices.

Some of these have game-changing impacts and some are more contained. Even those that won’t change your protagonists’ ultimate fate, though, can still be more than a little stirring. Early on in the game you encounter a plague-ridden family amidst a burned village. They have been captured and bound by a priest who is trying to destroy the village and everyone in it, so the disease cannot spread to the rest of the island.

Your choice here seems obvious if you’re trying to be a good guy as you can either let the priest kill the family including their young children or insist they be set free.

If you don’t let the sweet young family die you’ll feel pretty chuffed with yourself, unless you revisit the island later on. Then you discover the priest was right and the plague did indeed spread, killing many people.

It’s pretty awful either way and while not letting them infect the whole island is probably the right choice, walking away and letting a family get slaughtered certainly doesn’t feel heroic. You also make your young friend Phoibe sad, which is extra crappy.


9. Black Soul Gems - The Elder Scrolls V: Skyrim

skyrim soul cairn
Bethesda

Anyone who has played Skyrim won’t have any trouble telling you what soul trapping is. Kill off a creature or human with the spell and you can trap their soul in a soul gem which you can use to enchant or charge weapons.

It’s all very useful and given there’s a lot going on in Skyrim, you’d be forgiven for not thinking too much about it beyond the basics. For those that dug a little deeper or sunk time into the Dawnguard expansion, though, it’s hard to look at soul trapping the same way. Especially if you’re roleplaying a good character. In short, it’s very, very not cool.

In Dawnguard you can venture to a place called The Soul Cairn, a plane of Oblivion inhabited by souls that have been trapped in black soul gems. These gems are unique as they can contain the souls of sentient, humanoid beings and said beings are really not having a good time in the horrible prison realm you sent them to.

Not to mention, these poor unfortunate souls are denied the afterlife and doomed to eventually be eaten by the rulers of the Soul Cairn, the Ideal Masters.

As you can imagine this is all pretty unethical and you might start to feel a bit guilty about forcing said souls to endure eternal torture just so you can keep your cool sword charged. Unless it’s Nazeem, then we can all agree you’re good to go.


8. The Fates Of The Missing - Alien Isolation

alien isolation
Creative Assembly

Alien Isolation isn’t a whimsical light-hearted adventure so it stands to reason a lot of things are going to go sideways in your cat-and-mouse game with one of gaming’s scariest big bads. If you haven’t finished this one yet I’m throwing in a spoiler warning and I’ll catch you over on Number 7.

This particular terrifying video game truth concerns the ID cards that can be found around the station.

Resident attentive player and WhatCulture commenter, Black Winter, pointed out that while some of these ID cards can be attached to nearby dead bodies, others are trickier to access, though all have a picture of said MIA person on it.

Toward the end of the game, you find yourself exploring the Alien nest. Here, you come across dozens of victims with their chests burst open. Each of these victims can be matched to an ID card, cementing that each of those missing people met with an especially horrific fate, being dragged down into the nest and infested with an Alien. Yikes.


7. Romani & Cremia - The Legend Of Zelda: Majora’s Mask

legend of zelda majoras mask
Nintendo

While Alien Isolation could not be more different to The Legend of Zelda: Majora’s Mask, the two are both even more sinister under the hood than you initially expect.

At the Romani Ranch you encounter Romani and her older sister Cremia. There’s a couple of weird things going on here, the first of which is an alien attack you’ll need to fend off and if you fail Romani roams around the ranch clutching her head. The implications of what the aliens did to the girl can only be guessed at but I think we can safely go with it being significantly not chill. Perhaps even more disturbing is the case of Chateau Romani.

Now, for the uninitiated, Majora's Mask takes place in Termina and the world is set to end in three days when the moon falls into the world.

Back to the Chateau Romani. This is essentially suggested to be the alcohol of Termina as you can only buy it from the bar by wearing the Romani mask which is basically Link’s fake ID, letting him masquerade as an adult. In all other cases children aren’t allowed to drink it. On the night of the final day before the world ends Cremia lets her kid sister Romani drink the Chateau Romani, which seems to suggest she wants to get her little sister drunk so she isn’t scared when the world ends.

A level of depressing that I think we can all agree Majora’s Mask has certainly mastered.


6. The Real Zombie Fungus - The Last of Us

Last Of Us Joel Bloater
Sony

This is arguably the most terrifying video game truth on this list because it’s the only one where the video game horror in question actually exists in real life.

If you aren’t already across this one, it’s absolutely fascinating. Essentially, the Cordyceps virus which is the basis of the apocalyptic zombie plague from The Last of Us is a real virus. While the parasitic virus doesn’t affect humans, the parasites do make their homes in the bodies of insects and other fungi and some variants are essentially body snatchers, turning the creatures into zombies.

In one particular case the virus zombifies ants and controls their minds in order to survive, wherein the ants’ tissue is eaten alive from the inside and replaced until it’s only a husk overtaken by the fungus.

They call these "fruiting bodies", which sounds much yummier and less disgusting than it is but imagine what happens to the Clickers but to insects and spiders and you got it.


5. Spencer Jankowski’s Body - F.E.A.R. 2

fear 2 Spencer Jankowski
Warner Bros.

Spen was a combat operative in the first F.E.A.R. title whose fate was left undetermined. He initially disappears after scouting Replica forces alongside his Delta escort. After this point he appears to the Point Man as a phantom wandering through the plant, delivering warnings about the game’s antagonist Alma. Though you’re told his remains may have been found, it’s also noted by the F.E.A.R. commissioner that he can’t be dead as his life signs are unusual but present.

Ultimately it’s never made fully clear what happened to Spen, but attentive players could find their answer in the game’s sequel.

Though it’s wildly unlikely a living person could present as a Phantom, thereby essentially confirming Spen’s death, the games never made it entirely clear one way or the other. That is except for a body that can be found during the early moments of F.E.A.R. 2 in an X-ray lab. The body shares several physical characteristics with Spen including his shaved head, uniform, and lack of eyeballs.

Worth noting he did have eyeballs previously, but not post the whole death thing.


4. Save Malik Or Let Her Die - Deus Ex: Human Revolution

deus ex human revolution malik
Eidos

There are plenty of things in games you can’t control, some that you can, and some you assume you have no say in but actually realise you could have done something.

The fate of Faridah Malik in Deus Ex Human Revolution is the latter. Plenty of players carried on through the game assuming her death was out of their hands. Once the helicopter is shut down, you’re told to run. You can kill off some of her attackers but unless you finish the job and don’t run straight for the helipad’s elevator you can find her body later on with the chip in her head dug out. She can be seen lying on an operating table in the Harvesters’ hideout, presumably having been sold by Belltower to the Harvesters. It’s especially nasty but if you save her instead she helps you down the line at the Singapore facility.

On top of that, there is an Easter egg in Adam Jenson’s apartment that suggests the two grew closer so it’s more than a little grim if you assumed she had to die.


3. The Emergency Alert System Broadcasts - Black Mesa

black mesa
Crowbar Collective

For those who may not know, Black Mesa is a third-party remake of Half-Life created by Crowbar Collective. The reimagining includes a good expansion on the shooter and its lore that has been generally really well received.

One thing it takes artistic licence with concerns radios that you can find scattered throughout the research facility. The terror here is developed through what these broadcasts imply. The first chilling alert suggests that the disaster caused by Gordon Freeman at the Black Mesa facility is not contained strictly within the research facility and has affected the surrounding area.

It notes that an evacuation order has been issued for all residents within a 75 mile radius.

The implications of the second broadcast, sent out just a few hours later, worsen further as it is now being sent by the state department and not local authorities. At this point it states that everyone living within a 150 mile radius should evacuate and watch for symptoms of illness. The final broadcast, now disseminated by the United States Department of Defence mere hours later, reveals a state of emergency has been declared due to an unknown hostile force. It adds that airstrikes will begin over the Black Mesa facility, and the entire state of New Mexico should evacuate. People are advised to shelter at militarised zones, and alert authorities if they have military or firearms training.

Finding out just how far the disaster has spread and how quickly is pretty darn terrifying, especially since you’re only able to experience the heart of the incident first-hand.


2. The Truth About Joker’s Sister - Mass Effect 3

mass effect 3 joker sister
Bioware

Much like many of the games on this list you’d be forgiven for missing this one as it involves quite a bit of patience and hanging around to get the full story. In Mass Effect 3 you can have multiple conversations with the Normandy’s pilot Joker about his sister, Hillary. He expresses concerns over her well-being given she is living on a small human colony, Tiptree.

Hang around the Huerta Memorial Hospital on the Citadel enough, though, and you can actually find out what happened to her.

The full conversation between an Asari Commando and psychologist reveals she did in fact meet someone named Hilary.

Things get pretty dark with each returned visit to the hospital as you learn more about what went down. It turns out that after a Reaper ambush of the colony, the commando tells the psychologist Hillary broke her leg and wouldn’t stop crying, so she killed Hillary in order to prevent being discovered by the Reapers. In what is perhaps the saddest part of all this, Joker never finds out what happened to his sister.

The Asari is traumatised too, and learning her full story lets you use your Spectre status to grant her a gun to take her own life. If you don’t do this she becomes a War Asset.


1. The Secret Of The Generator - Control

control game
Remedy

Big spoiler warning here

If you haven’t played through Control and don’t want to know one of its darkest secrets but if you’re still with me, this one is a doozy.

2019 action-adventure Control is a game with many layers, complicated lore, and more than a few secrets to be found by those who are paying attention. If you make a habit of rifling through desks, scanning whiteboards, internalising files, and piecing more than a few things together for yourself then you might have spotted one of the greatest secrets of the NSC Power Plant. The secret being, NSC stands for Northmoor Sarcophagus Container and the Oldest House is actually powered by the body of the FBC Director before the late director Trench. Trench being the guy you replaced at the start of the game.

Essentially this guy is using his paranatural ability to generate heat to voluntarily be a human battery.

A monitor near the top of the reactor slash sarcophagus depicts a human inside, and it seems to display an infrared view indicating body heat, leading clever players to connect the dots. Trench himself says that, quote, “a Director has to keep the lights on.” This one might have passed you by if you weren’t looking for it but it’s a great, albeit terrifying secret worth knowing to flesh out the game’s lore.


Watch Next


In this post: 
Fear 2
 
First Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

Jess has been a journalist and content creator in the games industry for over 15 years and has been WhatCulture's resident Australian import and sorry cop since 2020, upping the quotient of swearing and apologising in WhatCulture Gaming's annual blooper videos considerably. She previously worked at GameSpot for 10 years, most notably hosting GameSpot News in addition to E3 live shows, and PAX panels. She regularly livestreams a variety of games on her 'jessmcdonell' YouTube and Twitch channels and hosts the 'Do It On The Day' podcast. She has won awards for her news and feature work in gaming as well as an accolade for her comedic writing (likely an admin error). She can be found on X at @jessmcdonell and Instagram at @jessicamcdonell sharing her current videogame fixations, industry insights, and videos of her cat, Karma.