10 Times The Games Industry Had No Idea WTF It Was Doing

Wow, you really nailed that one, IGN...

Video Game Consoles IGN
IGN/Sony

For as much as we love the gaming industry, there's no denying that it has a penchant for bad ideas. Even back in the golden days of the NES it was clear that publishers and developers could be out of touch with what people wanted, resulting in half-baked ideas like the Power Glove and the Virtual Boy - which tend to only be remembered as memes today.

Unfortunately, it seems that even in 2017 the industry doesn't have much more of a grasp on what it's doing. The divide between companies and players is not only evident in the disastrous release of the Wii U, the 180 U-turns of the Xbox One or the arrogant pricing of the PS3, but also in various ideas that at the very core of what we're playing today.

Thankfully, these WTF decisions the industry likes to implement are usually quietly canned when they don't take off, but that moment of relief only comes after hearing studios insist they're on the right track with 'revolutionary' ideas.

Oftentimes the industry just doesn't know when to quit, resulting in all manner of doomed ideas that should have never made it off the whiteboard...

10. Chasing The Wii With The Kinect And Move

Kinect Fail Gif
Spike TV

It's easy to forget how huge of a deal the Nintendo Wii was. Far eclipsing both the Xbox 360 and the PS3 in terms of sales and appeal, it didn't take long for Microsoft and Sony to attempt to get in on the peripheral-driven success of Nintendo's family-friendly console.

Unfortunately, both companies realised the appeal of motion controls way too late in the game, long after pretty much every family on the planet had already picked up a Wii to bust out at Christmas.

But not only was nobody who owned a Wii interested in Sony's Move motion controllers or Microsoft's full body-scanning Kinect, but this need to catch up to the Wii shifted the focus of Xbox and PlayStation away from the core players they appealed to.

Alienating the majority of your existing audience to attract one that was already happy with the machines they owned was a mistake, but it might not have been so disastrous if the peripherals were actually, you know, any good.

The Move revolution was dropped by Sony faster than the Vita, and while Microsoft gave the Kinect another go with the release of the Xbox One, they quietly killed support for it once again, just a year later.


9. Preparing (Poorly) For The Digital Future

psn wishlist
Sony

Before the launch of the PS4 and Xbox One, the video game industry was convinced that an all-digital future was coming sooner rather than later.

As a result there was a huge push by the big three console makers to revolutionise their online storefront to make it easier than ever for customers to buy their games straight from the source.

Of course the biggest publishers still had a rather intimate relationship with your average brick-and-mortar game stores, meaning that the online storefront wasn't able to undercut the prices of shops like Game and Gamestop.

Not only that, but the big publishers seemingly didn't understand the main appeal of these stores in the first place: the fact that you could buy titles secondhand or share them with your friends.

So the online storefront was not only much more expensive than your average real life store, but the restrictions that came with buying digital (not to mention the huge download files that came with it) meant that players weren't eager to follow publishers into the all-digital future like they were expecting.


8. Assuming There Was No Market For Horror

SILENT HILLS pt
Konami

Sometime in the late 2000s, video game publishers decided that horror games were dead.

Without seemingly any evidence pointing towards the genre's unpopularity - or, you know, without ever trying to sell players a good title to check whether they were right or not - publishers pulled the plug on new AAA horror games and started turning their biggest horror franchises into bombastic action titles.

For years, the biggest companies insisted that there was no market for horror experiences, all the while a little platform called Steam was seeing a huge boom in independent genre releases that were completely tearing up the charts.

Even then, publishers were still slow to accept that there was any demand for scares, and it's only been in the past few years with releases like Alien: Isolation and Resident Evil 7 that they've realised, despite what they thought, the market for good horror games never went away.


7. Phasing Out Split-Screen

Borderlands Handsome Collection split screen
2K Games

Before the days of online gaming, one of the only ways that people could play together (that didn't involve a bunch of extra consoles, TVs and a hell of a lot of wires) was through split-screen.

But it wouldn't be right to say that split-screen was popular just because players couldn't play online yet. Having someone physically in the room with you while you were blasting through Halo always felt great, and it meant that families weren't forced to buy more than one copy of a game just so siblings could play together.

As the years have gone on however developers have focused less and less on implementing this once-standard feature.

Every company has a different excuse as to why, but it's easy to see the cynical reason many players have landed on: why would publishers only sell one copy to one family member, when it could sell multiple copies to all of them?


6. Charging Ahead With Online-Only Ideas

Xbox One X
Microsoft

Just like they did with their idea of an all-digital future, in the early days of the 2010s the video game industry was charging full steam ahead with the thinking that consoles and games should require a connection to the internet to work.

While it's not a terrible idea in itself, all goodwill was squandered with the announcement of the Xbox One, which then needed an internet connection to work and restricted players from sharing their games or playing them offline.

The final nail in the coffin though was the arrogant way Microsoft went about defending their approach, going so far as to tell players who could only play offline to stick with the Xbox 360, as the new console wasn't for them.

Of course the company eventually went back on their online-only design, but only after Sony showed them that the world wasn't ready for their vision of the future following the raucous response to the more accessible PS4.


5. Messing Up Remasters Of Old Games

Marvel Ultimate Alliance
Activision

Even though the idea of remasters in general has taken a kicking over the past couple of years, when they're done right these games can offer players new and improved versions of titles they love that can sometimes surpass the originals in terms of quality.

Some publishers however, seem to view these re-releases as quick cash-grabs; easy opportunities to milk fans for all they're worth while putting in as little effort as possible.

But it's the overpricing of these games that's proven to be the real sticking point. There was no reason why the bundled re-release of Marvel Ultimate Alliance 1 and 2 needed to be £50 when quality remakes like Ratchet and Clank were being sold for £30, and this inflated pricing model has only hindered re-releases that could have otherwise been huge successes.

Sometimes it goes further than just pricing however, and occasionally it becomes evident that publishers have absolutely no respect for either the games they're remastering or the fans who are clamouring for them.

Modern Warfare Remastered is probably the worst example of this, only being available if you bought the special edition of Infinite Warfare, lacking core maps, having microtransactions crow-barred in, and having the game's nine-year old DLC being sold separately, and for an increased price, months later.


4. Thinking Nobody Buys Single-Player Games Anymore

Witcher 3
CD Projekt RED

Just like it did with horror games, at some point the video game industry decided that single-player games were dead. Perhaps down to the massive success of certain multiplayer releases, publishers scrambled to get their own piece of the pie, jamming online suites into story-driven games like Bioshock 2 and Dead Space 2 that didn't need them.

However this idea quickly evolved into something more insidious after the release of the Xbox One and PS4, with some of the biggest releases for the consoles like Titanfall and Star Wars: Battlefront shipping without a single-player campaign at all.

The companies defended the decision by saying that only a fraction of the fanbase actually ever played these campaigns to begin with, and it wasn't worth the effort to continue to implement them. The problem was however, that not only did people love the stories of these first-person shooters, but cutting off support for the single-player didn't result in more content for the multiplayer side of things.

Thanks to the backlash these games received and the likes of The Witcher 3 and Doom being smash-hit single player-only titles, the industry has shifted its thinking a little, and more and more multiplayer-only games have received sequels that put the focus back onto story campaigns.


3. Online Passes

Batman: Arkham City
Rocksteady

Back when the popularity of secondhand game sales were seen as killing the industry, publishers decided that the best way to entice players to buy titles new was to lock off content and punish the people who wouldn't (or couldn't) pony up for a new copy.

For a while new games came with an 'online pass', a one-time code that gave players access to all the content the title had to offer.

In the case of certain games like Arkham City this meant unlocking new levels and new playable characters, but for the most part it was used as an access code for the online portion of multiplayer games.

It turned out that restricting your customers' access to important content and the ability to play online wasn't the best idea however, and a huge player backlash meant that this practice was dropped a few short years after it was implemented.


2. Trying To Push Paid Mods

fallout 4 paladin danse
Bethesda

One of the most pressing problems with the big-wig gaming companies and publishers is that they have a habit of suddenly trying to monetise things that have been free for years.

We saw it with the implementation of online passes, where developers suddenly decided that you needed to pay them for the luxury of online multiplayer (even though most people were already shelling out for subscriptions to Microsoft and Sony to do the same thing), but by far the worst example is the recent push by publishers to charge players for mods.

The modding community has been huge for years, and part of the appeal of certain games comes entirely from the player-created add-ons that keep fans returning to the title for years after its initial release.

Obviously publishers can't fathom the idea of anyone continuing to play a game without also continuing to pay money for it, and so recently companies like Bethesda have attempted to capitalise on these communities by charging for this fan-made content that had until now, always been free.


1. Thinking Consoles Were Dead

Nintendo Switch Ps4 Xbox One
Nintendo/Sony/Microsoft

Believe it or not there was a time, in the twilight of the Xbox 360 generation, where everybody thought that games consoles were dead. With the popularity of Steam and the decline in console sales, you couldn't move for think-pieces and op-eds about the imminent death of console gaming.

More of a problem was that it seemed as though the people who made the consoles themselves thought the same thing. Perhaps believing that the time of dedicated gaming machines was up, Microsoft attempted to appeal to everyone by creating an all-in-one entertainment system that focused on TV, film and streaming as much as it did video games.

For some reason nobody seemed to realise that the decline in console and game sales might have been more to do with a stagnant market than anything else.

With one of the longest gaming generations ever and nothing but a sea of sequels hitting shelves, players weren't buying anything because they were clamouring for something new.

Obviously the 'death of consoles' fear-mongering was silenced when Microsoft and Sony dropped new machines in 2013, with the PS4 being a ridiculous success and even the much-maligned Xbox One outpacing the sales of the 360.

Since then both companies have returned to a games-centric approach, and it's clear that consoles are here to stay.


Watch Next


In this post: 
PS4
 
Posted On: 
Contributor

Josh has over 11 years of experience as a published writer, having worked nine of those years as a full-time content producer at WhatCulture. In that period he has created hundreds of articles, videos and podcast episodes for multiple WhatCulture channels, specialising in gaming, horror and film & TV. He now primarily works as a senior content producer and presenter on WhatCulture Gaming where he co-hosts the WhatCulture Gaming Podcast, a top 3 UK most listened to gaming podcast that he co-created in 2018. Over the years he has reviewed several high-profile gaming releases, covered industry events with on-site reporting, opined on breaking news, and even kicked off his interviewing career by chatting to childhood hero, Tommy Wiseau.