10 Underappreciated Video Games That Deserve A Sequel
Second chances really are hard to come by, especially in the games industry.
In the modern gaming industry it can feel like every other game is a sequel. The umpteenth entry in a franchise that's been trudging on for years, refusing to die, sucking up all the oxygen the little guys need just to get on their feet.
The Final Fantasy series alone has over 90 games to its name including spin-offs and mobile instalments, and it's not even the biggest one. Gaming needs some more variety but we don’t have to rely on fresh faces and new ideas when there are plenty of pretty damn good franchises that fell flat on their faces on their first outing. Releases that may have reviewed well but that failed to live up to their publisher’s lofty sales standards, or just sold terribly overall.
Even games that simply set up solid ground for that sequel to be the breakout hit that the original outing should have been. These games show that just because you missed your overly-optimistic sales expectations doesn’t mean you’re any less of a blast to play, or any less deserving of that big budget sequel.
10. Enslaved: Odyssey To The West
You can have everything you’d think a game would need; star power, gorgeous visuals, fun gameplay, an interesting story and engaging characters, and success is still not guaranteed. On the other side of every sale there’s a decision, and if people don’t feel like your title is the best use of their money at that specific time, then you’re out of luck no matter how wonderful it is.
Take Enslaved for example. Slapped together by the talented team of Ninja Theory, it had everything going for it. With its sharp dialogue and character interactions slap bang in the middle of when those were at their peak popularity thanks to the Uncharted series, it should have been a hit.
The whole world should have been primed to enjoy the adventures of Monkey and Tripitaka but on the horizon, there stirred a beast, a shambling behemoth. Its name was Call of Duty: Black Ops and it released less than a month after Enslaved, meaning it sucked up a lot of the advertising space in the preceding weeks as well as saved up pocket money.
To make matters worse; in the very same month as Enslaved we had both Fallout: New Vegas and Fable 3, so Enslaved wasn’t so much released, as kicked out the door into a firing squad.
And because of this there’s almost no chance we’ll get a pole-swinging, nimbus riding, piggy-back giving sequel out of our two protagonists. Ah well, at least we’ll always have Pigsy’s Perfect 10...
9. Singularity
Starting with a doomed helicopter ride into an abandoned soviet science facility with a beefy soldier voiced by Nolan North, you'd be forgiven for mistaking it for almost any other shooter from an Activision studio. But if you managed to push past all this you'd shortly have found out that while Singularity looks like a by the numbers, grunty, musclebound patriotic shoot-a-thon, it's actually a time travelling, grunty, musclebound, patriotic shoot-a-thon.
During development, deadlines caused a big chunk of story content to be removed due to the technical constraints of having to render the world twice in two different states while swiftly moving from one to the other, a'la The Medium. Many time travelling set pieces and entire chunks of finished product were excised just to get it out on time as opposed to spending the required man-hours to work out the kinks. Leaving Singularity feeling gutted and a little bit rough around the edges, like it never really got to explore its own premise properly.
But with the standardisation of super-fast SSDs and Microsoft's DirectStorage a Singularity sequel could have no problem blasting between 50s Russia and 2010 Russia as smooth as butter. Making for a more complete experience, a more enjoyable game, and who knows maybe even greater franchise potential down the line.
8. Madworld
If there's one thing you couldn't call Madworld it's 'unoriginal'. In a dystopian future hell world where people use death and violence as entertainment, you must take part in the gameshow ‘Deathwatch’ and win yourself a fortune through creative butchery.
On top of that you're not just some schlub, you're a chainsaw wielding slab of meat with a hairy chest and a violent disposition. Madworld then has you tearing through area after area and boss after boss as two seasoned professional killers commentate your every slash and stab. Points are awarded for kills, with extra multipliers for multi-kills, and how unique your kill is. It's all very well upper cutting someone into the air and slicing them in half from balls to brain but wouldn't you rather put a bin over their head and impale them with a road sign first?
Needless to say reviewers loved Madworld, with its campy humour, black and white comic book art style and extreme violence, however being a Wii game that last part was possibly more to its detriment than its advantage.
The Wii was always considered to be more of a kids/family console and so many of quote-unquote hardcore gamers that would be interested in this kind of gore-a-thon just didn't own the console.
It's not really the type of thing you'd buy your gran for Christmas unless you’re looking at picking up your inheritance early.
7. Vanquish
In the distant future the newly installed Russian government uses a giant microwave to destroy San Fransisco. Instead of sending them a 'thank you' card, the USA sends our protagonist Sam, fitted with an experimental battlesuit, to infiltrate the giant microwave take the fight to those damned communists.
Vanquish is a video game about speed and guns, and shooting those guns at high speed, preferably while on your knees and smoking a cigarette while heavy metal blares all around you. Sam vaults over cover to lay down fire, gently feeds enemy rockets back into the orifices they were fired from and drop-kicks crowds of bad guys to death in slow motion.
It's the kind of intentionally over-the-top ridiculousness we really don't see enough of anymore. It's got no illusions about being anything more than a fun, carefully crafted experience about shooting people real good and it nails every aspect of the formula.
Critics said it was a blast but a little bit short, and sadly a lot of people take a sort of ‘pounds per hour’ approach to buying games as opposed to just enjoying FUN.
You could easily see it as an open world title taking full advantage of the battlesuit for fast traversal, or even just a larger scale linear experience where Sam can spearhead a counter invasion against the Russians, complete with hilarious Russian side characters looking to restore the pre-coup government.
6. Neverdead
With the Souls series at its highest point of popularity, allow me to introduce you to its total opposite: Neverdead, the game where it takes real concerted effort to die.
While our protagonist Bryce may be immortal, he's not invincible and, seemingly as part of this immortality curse, his limbs appear to be attached with sticky tape as they'll fly off the moment an enemy brushes lightly up against you. Lose a leg and Bryce will start hopping around moving slightly slower, lose both legs and all you can do is crawl. Lose an arm and you're down to only using one of your dual guns at a time and so on and so forth. Getting Bryce's limbs to re-attach is as easy as dodge rolling over them, making them magnetically zip up and back onto your torso.
It may sound like a liability to be so loosely attached to your own limbs that they constantly drop off but Bryce can use this ability to traverse tight areas by tearing his head of and masterfully rolling it around through vents and the like. And his immortality allows him to use himself as a human torch by lighting himself on fire.
It’s this unique approach to the gameplay and tying every element of that gameplay into Bryce’s condition of immortality that makes Neverdead so unique, and a sequel that expands even further on his abilities and his past would, at the very least, be interesting.
5. Alpha Protocol
It feels like every other game bills itself as open ended, granting the player the ability to play and take the story in many different directions more often than not this is a gross exaggeration.
Alpha Protocol tried to buck the feeling of being fenced in by focussing mostly on the places you can take the story with your choices in dialogue trees by offering as much possible variety as possible, while keeping the gameplay itself fairly fenced-in.
Dropped into the shoes of Michael Thorton the game starts off looking pretty simplistic, with only the choice of two preset classes or a complete blank slate to edit to your heart’s desire. But later on you’ll find that the meat of the experience and the vast majority of the enjoyment people take from alpha protocol is through the wealth of choice you have in story progression.
Depending on the order you take missions and how you interact with characters and at what times you can end up with drastically different playthroughs, and just seeing how Thorton interacts with his cohorts and enemies as you do very professional things like hang up on your boss or pretend to have communications problems so you can execute surrendering bad guys.
The promise of Alpha Protocol is tied into the variability of its story, and a sequel that could deliver a future for every possible end point would genuinely be a step-up in what we expect from narrative driven video games.
4. Dark Void
Sometimes your game just needs a little bit longer to cook. The get those edges sanded down and, at the very least finish inserting all the content.
Dark Void is yet another title that got pushed out of the door before it was ready and into an unforgiving launch window. An ambitious mixture of arcade-style flight simulator and third-person cover shooter, Dark Void absolutely sings once you push past the first hour or so.
In the game you'll take on Nazi-supporting robot lizards alongside a rag tag group of human resistance fighters made up of people who've become stranded in the Bermuda triangle over the years. This includes Nikola Tesla, who introduces you to his latest invention: only a bloody jetpack.
It's from there that it really picks up speed and starts living up to its potential. The inclusion of the jetpack into large open spaces filled with smaller objectives lets you mix it up, swapping between aerial combat and ground combat at will. Dark Void's main issue is that it ends just as it’s starting to reach its peak, as in it literally cuts from what feels like the mid-point of the story to the final boss.
The real tragedy is the possibilities of the continued story. It ends with a return to the real world, jetpack in tow, just in time to get busy introducing the allies to jetpack technology and setting up an alternative WW2 Rocketeer style game that we'll sadly never get to play.
3. Heavenly Sword
Here for the return of both Ninja Theory and Andy Serkis, Heavenly Sword was an early PS3 exclusive that saw players guiding around a red-headed warrior called Nariko and smacking people with the titular Heavenly Sword.
Taking inspiration mostly from God of War, Heavenly Sword bases its combat around changing stances between fast, ranged and strong depending on which kind of enemies you're fighting, and on quick time events as they were very much in vogue back then. It’s competently put together and tons of fun to play, and sometimes you even get a nice motional controlled cross-bow level where you can try your best to fit as many crossbow bolts as possible into one guy's balls before he hits the ground.
Where Heavenly Sword really sets itself apart is in the quality of the writing and acting, with every single character being distinct and well written. They all have their own consistent personalities, motivations and arcs, and motion capture is used to make the cutscenes as believable as possible. With the particular stand out being Serkis in his role as King Bohan, the ultimate bad guy and the means by which we meet most of the colourful (and sometimes terrifying) characters Heavenly Sword has to offer.
The characterisation was so strong that it got both an animated series and a film, as well as a sequel that was, tragically, cancelled due to the game's poor sales and as part of moving the studio on to developing Enslaved: Odyssey to the West.
2. Binary Domain
It’s all very well to talk about crowded release schedules, rushed development, unfinished products and unreached potential but sometimes the problem is the public. Sometimes, gamers, you make me so mad.
Binary Domain has it all: slick third person shooting, tight controls, a unique art style, technical innovation, likeable characters, a future setting where human-like robots have infiltrated society even unbeknownst to themselves. It even has a French robot that does spin kicks and calls you monsieur.
And to make this game even cooler you can give your squad commands, commendations and just generally interact with them via your microphone. Characters will react to what you say and can gain or lose trust in you depending on how you act. Lose enough trust with a character and they’ll start refusing to do what you say like an over-levelled Pokemon.
So, if Binary Domain is so bloody good in every way, why didn’t it sell well? Why aren’t we on to Binary Domain 4: The Robotening?
Well, dear viewer, I blame you. You chose not to buy Binary Domain. You refused to heed all those glowing reviews, and pretty marketing spots SEGA bought to evangelise this masterpiece. Games fail for all sorts of reasons but every now and then a game just because YOU refused to buy it.
Just be glad that the game’s producer, Daisuke Sato expressed interest in bringing it back after Yakuza’s renewed success in the west. And if that ever happens, you’ll know what to do.
1. Sunset Overdrive
It’s been a common complaint of late that the Xbox has no exclusives. Look past Halo and you’d struggle to find a title beyond Gears of War that you can only play on the Microsoft machine.
It wasn’t always this way, there was once a time when third-party studios were very interested in bringing games to the big X. Sunset Overdrive being a stand-out from the previous generation.
A member of the barely populated comedy video game genre, Sunset Overdrive is a colourful, bombastic, violent and almost obnoxiously tongue-in-cheek experience. The kind of parody that does exactly what it’s parodying while winking at the camera.
But underneath all the self-abasement and dick jokes there was genuinely a fun experience based completely around bouncing on the hoods of cars and skating along electrical wiring.
Insomniac brought their A-game here along with their knack for inventive weaponry, giving us guns that fire vinyl records, teddy bears and fireworks among other things. The world is vibrant and colourful and moving through it is so cathartic you could spend entire play sessions just bouncing, skating and wall-running around.
As such Sunset Overdrive sold really well, and everyone really liked it. So why we’ve not seen a sequel yet is a mystery. Interestingly the likelihood is that if we do it’ll be a Playstation exclusive, now that they’ve bought the studio that owns the IP. So let’s look forward to a tense, dour faced sequel where everyone communicates in either grunting or crying.