10 Video Games Where Evil Won
And there was nothing you could do to stop them.
Many writers base their stories off the well-established “Hero’s Journey” structure, seeing their main character go on an adventure, overcome dramatic odds to defeat evil and find themselves a changed person.
But some try to subvert this structure, showing us what happens when the good side loses despite their best efforts and evil triumphs.
It’s not a new idea by any means, but gaming’s interactive nature makes it more personal and instead of watching it unfold like you would in a film, your actions can be instrumental to evil’s success.
This comes in several forms, be it a deliberate effort on the protagonist’s part, a major deception by the big bad or unconsciously assisting them in other means. Prequels often see this occur, finding themselves constrained by established history.
There might be a pre-determined outcome but it doesn’t stop developers choosing to depict a tragic event to expand franchise lore.
Many games provide bad endings, usually as a non-canon game over scenario or alternative ending, but some games see evil winning regardless of your actions and here are some of these titles.
Note: Spoilers within
10. Resistance 2
It’s a common theme amongst trilogies that the second entry is darker, staging the odds for heroes to make a glorious comeback. Star Wars is a prime film example with both The Empire Strikes Back and The Last Jedi, so it’s unsurprising this happens within gaming too.
Resistance 2 is one such game. Developed by Insomniac Games, it’s a series we’ve not seen since the PS3 era and 2 continued the journey of Sgt Nathan Hale, moving away from its original UK setting to the United States, fending off the Chimeran invasion.
You worked as part of elite group “The Sentinels”, soldiers all infected with a Chimeran virus that enhances their strength. As the story progresses, Hale tries to keep succumbs this virus in check, stopping Chimeran leader Daedalus but inadvertently absorbing his abilities afterwards.
Hale leaves with another Sentinel, Corporal Joseph Capelli, but after waking up from their crashed escape vessel, Capelli discovers Hale has now fully succumbed and is forced to shoot him.
Resistance 3 may have provided a happier ending, seeing the Chimera finally eradicated but at the time, players were left on this sombre note that would continue to haunt the Corporal.
9. Shadow Of The Colossus
Shadow of the Colossus is one of gaming’s most expressive
works. Initially released in 2005 before receiving a full PS4 remake 2 years
ago, you play as Wander, a young man attempting to save Mono, a maiden
sacrificed after she was believed to have a cursed destiny.
Entering a forbidden land on horseback, he seeks to make a
deal with the Dormin, a mysterious entity with an alleged power to revive the
dead. In exchange for reviving Mono, the Dormin inform Wander that he must
destroy the 16 Colossi that scatter the land to enable this.
Except that’s not quite the Dormin’s only reason for asking. The Colossi deaths take a great physical toll on Wander as each one is slain but upon killing the last Colossi, it becomes clear that Wander has been deceived.
Each containing individual essence of Dormin, every Colossi
death led to Dormin’s revival and they consume Wander’s body, turning him into
a shadow giant. Though defeated by shaman Lord Emon, Wander’s blind love for
Mono led to their revival and sealed his fate.
8. InFamous
inFamous is well known for its morality system. Playing as cyclist
courier Cole MacGrath, you gain electrical superpowers after surviving an
explosion in Empire City and could choose to either help the city, gaining positive
karma, or act selfishly and build up negative karma.
As you proceed, Cole finds himself at odds with mob boss
Kessler, leader of The First Sons group that seized control of Empire City in
the explosion aftermath. After several incursions, including his murder of your
friend Trish, you’ll eventually fight him.
Regardless of how you played Cole during the game, Kessler reveals he’s actually you from an alternative future, one now lost due to his actions. He also informs you that Trish’s murder was to ensure you never married her, as their eventual family stops Cole addressing the incoming threat of the Beast.
Kessler’s intentions may have been for the overall good but
his twisted methods brought misery to many, causing his plan to eventually
succeed.
7. Halo Reach
Halo’s is one of gaming’s most widely explored universes,
featuring a rich lore that kept players hooked since its inception in 2002. The
Fall Of Reach is undoubtedly one of its most pivotal moments, marking a turning
point in the Human-Covenant war.
It may explain why Bungie chose this setting for their final
Halo game, 2010’s Halo Reach, its a prequel set weeks before Halo: Combat
Evolved. Playing as SPARTAN-B312, better known as Noble Six and Noble Team’s
latest recruit, you discover that Covenant forces have located planet Reach,
birthplace of the Spartan-II program, and have begun a full-scale invasion.
Coming into contact with the Spartan program’s creator, Dr
Halsey, Noble Team become entrusted with taking Cortana to the UNSC’s Pillar of
Autumn ship, containing information about an alien artifact that can end the
war.
Its tagline “From the beginning, you know the end” is apt, as anyone familiar with Halo knows just why it’s called The Fall of Reach. Staying behind to ensure Autumn’s escape, almost every member is slowly taken down one-by-one, ending with Six’s last stand against Covenant forces.
The Covenant may have eventually been defeated but the
legacy of Noble Team was not forgotten, seeing Reach become a rallying cry
amongst human forces.
6. XCOM: Enemy Unknown (2012)
Firaxis Games successfully revived XCOM back in 2012 with
XCOM: Enemy Unknown back in 2012, rebooting the popular franchise that had been
dormant since 2001’s X-Com Enforcer.
Set amidst an alternate Earth, you were tasked with
controlling XCOM, a paramilitary organisation designed to defend Earth from
alien invasion by the Ethereals, a species possessing powerful psionic
abilities.
Discovering that they’ve experimented on humanity in an
attempt to find a species worthy of uplifting, humanity doesn’t take kindly to
this and XCOM successfully kills their leader, the Uber Ethereal and caused
their ship to self-destruct.
Players thought they were successful in fending off the invasion but 2016’s XCOM 2 revealed a different outcome entirely. Set 20 years after Enemy Unknown, it reveals that you actually lost the war after the Council of Nations surrendered, a new puppet regime called ADVENT has been installed and XCOM has become an underground resistance force.
Initially trying to win over people via propaganda, XCOM 2
ends with ADVENT’s crimes being brought to light and its forces become
overwhelmed. It’s clear that the war isn’t over just yet and 2’s expansion, War
of the Chosen, implies a new war is approaching.
5. Kingdom Hearts: Birth By Sleep
Kingdom Hearts may be gaming’s most convoluted franchise but Birth By Sleep was undoubtedly one of its strongest entries. Released back in 2010, it’s the sixth instalment in the franchise but served as a prequel, set 10 years before the first game.
Revealing primary antagonist Master Xehanort’s origins, it moved away from the exploits of Sora and Riku, focusing on new protagonists Terra, Aqua and Ventus across three separate campaigns.
It starts with Terra and Aqua taking the Mark of Mastery exam which would grant them rank of Keyblade Master. Xehanort manipulates this exam to encourage darkness within Terra’s heart, then goes missing right as the Unversed begin attacking worlds.
Culminating in a final battle against Xehanort, it comes at great cost and the three heroes fail their mission. Aqua becomes trapped in the realm of darkness, Terra’s body becomes possessed by Xehanort and Ventus falls into a catatonic state, hidden inside Castle Oblivion to keep him safe.
It wouldn’t be until Kingdom Hearts 3 that these protagonists finally reached a happy ending but Birth By Sleep ended on a bleak note, though its secret ending “Blank Points” set out the path to their rescue.
4. Crisis Core: Final Fantasy VII
It used to be the case that Final Fantasy titles were
self-contained, bringing a new setting and cast each time with a definitive plot
resolution. Final Fantasy X was the first game to go against this rule with it’s
sequel X-2, establishing a new convention of follow-up titles and several years
later, Crisis Core followed suit.
Set seven years before VII, you played as Zack Fair, a
member of Shinra’s paramilitary force SOLDIER and the Buster Sword’s original
wielder. Tasked with finding missing SOLDIER Genesis, his search reveals a
wider conspiracy that leads directly into the events of VII.
Anyone who played VII will be aware Zack was Aerith’s first
love and upon visiting Gongaga in that game, you discovered its Zack’s hometown
after meeting his parents, both of whom remained unaware of his fate.
This is later clarified when Cloud regains his memories, previously confused by Mako poisoning after Shinra experimented on them both. Upon waking up, Zack saves Cloud’s life but is mortally wounded amidst a large confrontation with Shinra troops, telling Cloud to become his living legacy.
By focusing on Zack for this prequel, its another case of a pre-determined
ending but with VII Remake coming out next week, it’s certainly worth
revisiting.
3. Superhot
Superhot proved a smash hit upon release in 2016. Beginning
life in 2013’s 7 Day FPS Challenge, positive reception led to a full release
and a successful Kickstarter campaign in 2014. Featuring a minimalistic art
style, time only moved as you move and this unique premise led to critical
acclaim.
Its plot worked in a metanarrative manner, seeing you play a
fictional version of yourself in front of an MS-DOS. Receiving a friend’s
message recommending a new game called superhot.exe, it becomes quickly
apparent that your actions are being monitored by a presence known only as “the
system”.
Receiving increasing warnings from the system to stop
playing and finding yourself booted out several times, it engineers you to walk
into your own house and knock yourself unconscious.
This apparently wasn’t enough and you continue playing,
causing the system to not only relent but actively encourage your progress
instead.
After breaking into a laboratory housing the system’s core, you assimilate with it but not before receiving one last instruction. Arriving back in your apartment, you become forced to shoot yourself, finishing this assimilation.
Upon watching the credits, you’ll become instructed to
recommend superhot.exe to friends, sending out the same message you received at
the beginning. It’s a bleak affair but considering you defied the system’s many
warnings, it’s a fate you brought upon yourself.
2. Diablo
Blizzard’s iconic series set the trend for hack-and-slash
dungeon crawlers, inspiring a genre of games that included sequels and
expansions. But rarely does the story end well for its protagonists in Diablo
and the original title is no exception.
First released back in 1997, Diablo took place within
Tristam, the Kingdom of Khanduras’ capital as you attempt to free it from
Hell-spawned evil and these adventures culminated in a final battle with Diablo
himself, Lord of Terror.
Killing his mortal form, the protagonist then attempts to contain his essence within a soulstone, placing it into your own head and sacrificing themselves. But as Diablo II reveals, it was all for nothing.
Retold in II as a warrior trying to contain Diablo’s soul
within him, Diablo instead took over this Warrior’s body and ended up providing
him a new vessel instead. So rather than stopping him, it became clear that your
valiant efforts in the first game were completely futile.
1. Red Dead Redemption
Red Dead Redemption 2 may not have reached the lofty sales
of Grand Theft Auto V but it’s undeniably one of the most successful games of
all-time, selling 29 million copies and launching to critical acclaim but it
didn’t forget its roots.
Based around Arthur Morgan amidst the decline of the Wild
West, a member of the Van Der Linde Gang, its ending paid much attention to
original protagonist John Marston and foreshadowed the beginning of RDR1.
Set 12 years after RDR2, Redemption focused on John trying
to get his wife and child back after their kidnapping by federal agents Edgar
Ross and Archer Fordham. who task him with bringing his former gang members to
justice in exchange for their safety.
Despite holding up his end of the bargain. John finds himself betrayed by the government and, after sending your wife Abigail and son Jack to safety, get executed in a hail of bullets.
It’s a grissly end for the former outlaw and whilst Jack
later kills Edgar Ross out of revenge in the epilogue, his death provides
little solace.