10 Ways Rocksteady Should Have Made Batman: Arkham Knight

Lose the Joker, for a start.

Batman arkham knight joker
Rocksteady

In the words of Adele (give me a minute), Batman: Arkham Knight could've had it all. It could've been the final entry in an already illustrious franchise; one that single-handedly proved video games can breathe new life into a timeless character like Batman, and exemplified that when the right developer is at the helm, the lowly superhero genre can birth one of the greatest games of all time.

However, with the need for sequels comes the need for innovation, change and forward movement - no matter how perfect that first instalment may be. As such, Arkham City would take Asylum's mostly linear level structure and stretch it out across a hefty expanse of Gotham, before Origins and Knight mostly did the same. Problem is, the latter added the almost completely unnecessary Batmobile, whilst failing to capitalise on its titular villain in a way that leaves an immortally sour taste behind.

Arkham Knight is the best-playing game in the series on many fundamental levels - and one of the Games of the Year for 2015, I might add - but it's far from perfect, as fans have been more than vocal since launch about what they would've done differently.

Well, it's time to air those grievances...


10. Spread It Out Across More Than One Night

Batman arkham knight
Rocksteady

Like Arkham Origins, Knight took on the timeframe of setting all its events across one evening. From the string of main missions which take hours to complete, to side-missions, collectibles and general exploration in between, we were meant to believe it had all happened in the span of around nine hours, max.

Assumedly it was done to show Batman being pushed to breaking point as all his greatest enemies descended on his city at once, but with all the will in the world, it's a tough sell to conceptualise. This time element is rarely played upon aside from Alfred commenting on it after every three or four missions - or by looking at the wear and tear on his costume - but that's it.

The only way for it to make logical sense was in reducing each side mission to a handful that only take minutes to fulfil, portraying Batman's crusade across Gotham as one that ensnared all his deadliest foes in one fell swoop. That serves Batman being a badass, sure, but it makes all his villains feel like bit-part characters.

They're more of an annoyance, busywork even, rather than part of a larger narrative that could've introduced them over the course of multiple outings.


9. Leave The Joker Dead

Batman Arkham Knight Joker Fire
Rocksteady

Yes, Mark Hamill is brilliant as Joker and yes, he makes for some of the best Batman stories of all time. However, killing him at the close of Arkham City was an immensely brave move that made all of us recoil in pure astonishment. "Did Rocksteady really just do that?!", "What does it mean for the future of the series? Can they even do a game without him? Man, that'll be so interesting to se- oh."

Turns out the answer was no, they didn't even need to think about such things, as thanks to Joker's infected Titan blood getting into Bats' veins, he appeared as a hallucination across the entire game. From ventilation shafts to full-on cutscenes and especially the ending wrap-up, Rocksteady had their "Is he really dead?" cake, and ate it too.

As such, the one-dimensional Arkham Knight and barely-seen Scarecrow played second-fiddle to a climax that saw Batman fighting Joker inside his own mind, and although that made for some cool metaphorical depictions of their clashing ideologies, ultimately felt shoehorned in to appease the masses, rather than capitalising on the fact that Batman had lost his 'other half'.

The loss IS the driving force, and although the tie-in comics explored the idea that Bruce was consistently torn up due to failing to save the Clown Prince, the way it manifested in-game carried none of this weight. It felt far too forced and rushed, like Rocksteady caving in to the pressure of crafting a story without him.


8. Make The Arkham Knight Someone Other Than Jason Todd

Batman arkham knight jason todd
Rocksteady

Todd was always the immediate assumption, the one that gathered the most steam, made the most sense in terms of his backstory and had all of us going "Yup, it's him" from the very first thing he says on-screen. The sad thing is, figuring out - and guessing - the AK's identity in the run-up to release was some of the most fun comic fans have had since DC asked whether or not we wanted Robin to die in the first place.

Could the Knight be Azrael, Damien Wayne, a cyborg - perhaps some Court of Owls assassin? Nope, it was Jason Todd, because at the end of the day, Arkham Knight was being made for the widest audience possible, and no matter how tantalising the fan theories surrounding him (or her) were, Rocksteady had to go with the most easily digestible answer.

Obviously the amount of established characters they could've pulled from would have been solid alternatives (Prometheus, anyone?), but why not have the AK literally be an entirely new character, as was said from the get-go?

Some of the best Batman stories have come from newcomers - such as the aforementioned Court of Owls or Hush - so why not pick someone random who we perhaps failed to save in an older game, only to see that repercussion play out in full?


7. Have Side-Missions That Do Their Characters Justice

batman arkham knight mr freeze
Rocksteady

It comes to something when even Mr. Freeze's mission only lasts a few minutes. Coming off Arkham City and what's easily one of the most influential boss battles of all time, fans were rightly expecting Victor's story segment to be another one for the ages.

Nope, like every other character that had previously been given the appropriate attention to detail, his portrayal was shunted and crammed into a couple of cutscenes and not much else. Hush's appearance - although memorable - was more of a visual where we played as a fake Bruce Wayne, before switching control and slamming him through a table.

Professor Pyg got one of the most dark and twisted inclusions of them all, but others like Firefly, Two-Face and Man-Bat were reconciled to one gameplay mechanic repeated multiple times. Sadly, despite Rocksteady's most impressive character models yet, they felt like busywork, and when you've got characters like these on-hand, not making the most of them was just disappointing.


6. Give Scarecrow A Real Motive And Overall Purpose

Rocksteady

What was Scarecrow's role in AK - what was his purpose? "To envelop Gotham in fear toxin", right? Well, yes, but why? Why does he want to do anything to Batman, other than just for the sake of it?

We never know, as outside of revenge for being bested in Asylum, the only reason he's even in the story is to facilitate one particular level when the bombs go off, and we're treated to a really cool-looking version of Gotham as its engulfed in smog. Then it's over... and things go back to normal. His final act of gassing the hell out of Batman in person is reminiscent of his first appearance from the animated TV series, which is neat as a callback, but ends up not fulfilling the potential of yet another main villain from the game's advertising.

The many aspects of how Joker invades Bruce's psyche would've fit far more comfortably around constant exposure to Fear Toxin, to the point where it then leaves Bruce in a fractured mental state. In fact, there's every possibility this was the original plan, before "More Joker!" was tagged onto all the initial feedback forms. The game's ending is a mix of the two, with Scarecrow's toxin facilitating more appearances by the Joker, only to see Bats thwart the latter in a first-person sequence before stopping Scarecrow in a cutscene.

It's pretty clear that a game focussed entirely on Scarecrow capitalising on Bruce's emotions following the death of Joker would've been much more compelling. Scarecrow would therefore have been Bruce's ultimate mental test, whilst the Knight would've been the physical side of that coin, together providing one hell of a final encounter that would've combined dream sequences with brutal hand-to-hand fights as you alternate fighting them both.


5. Make Fighting The Arkham Knight Epic As Hell

batman arkham knight
Rocksteady

First you blast the Arkham Knight in a helicopter, then an underground maze-chase with an awkwardly ping-ponging Batmobile careening off the walls, a tank fight and finally a weird setup that forces Bats to sneak up on him three times in a row. All of them are terrible, and all serve only to remind you how awesome the Deathstroke fight was in Origins, as that could've been expanded instead.

Considering the Arkham Knight continually bested Batman in everything from cutscenes to PR materials, going toe-to-toe with him should've been a lightning fast exchange of fists, gadgets and ingenuity. Playing up the fact he knows all your moves better than you would be top priority, for example at any point the Knight could've cut the lights to the area you're in, turning the fight into an immediate game of cat and mouse where you had to hunt him down, Grey Fox-in-MGS 1 style.

As it stands, the ideology of the Arkham Knight besting Batman came from the fact he insisted on using guns or machines, rather than anything more learned, visceral or confrontational. We should've deflected every blow from the former Robin, one at a time, proving that we weren't the enemy - as oppose to the weirdly scattershot approach and instant-best-friend-again switch we received instead.


4. Have A Definitive Ending

Rocksteady

What's the ending to Arkham Knight? Is it when Bruce and Gordon take down Scarecrow? When the Knightfall Protocol shows Wayne Manor going sky-high, or when the little addendum scene implies that either Bruce, Azrael or someone else is using Scarecrow's toxin to rule the streets through fear alone?

That's the problem; we don't know. As is the case with the Arkham series being as popular as it is, Rocksteady were likely asked to leave a handful of options wide open for other studios to pick up, as and when they see fit. The problem comes with AK not feeling completely finished, no matter how additional scenes you trigger.

Instead, Rocksteady went down the Dark Knight Rises route of teasing his death and the everlasting peace of Gotham, but didn't nail it to the wall for fear of ending the Arkham series indefinitely. Scott Snyder's Endgame arc had Batman and Joker wipe each other out, only for a final panel to hint in the most subtle way that there could've been a way for Bruce to survive. It worked as the respectful closing of that story's final chapter, whilst nodding to the audience, "But he's out there somewhere... probably."

By contrast, Arkham Knight's various endings had no confidence behind them, emblematic of trying to satisfy everyone and missing the mark entirely. Oh, but it might have had something to do with the fact they had Season Pass content to sell...


3. Ensure Season Pass Content Is Worthwhile

batman and robin arkham knight season pass
Rocksteady

There's a lot to pick apart with the Season Pass offerings. For now, let's go with the idea that they're a good thing (hard to stomach, I know) as for Arkham Knight it allowed Rocksteady to keep making content for a number of months after launch, to - in theory - give fans a little something to chew on long after the base game hit shelves.

Thing is, from start to finish, it was handled poorly. Initially we got only the barest idea of what was being offered, as only vague descriptions of additional missions were released and detailed. Then, the pre-order 'bonuses' of Red Hood and Harley Quinn's mission packs could be completed in 15 minutes max. Following this, the majority of the Season Pass was costume or Batmobile racetrack-related, with the final 'Season of Infamy' pack - the one seeing the return of Mr. Freeze, Ra's Al Ghul and, erm, Mad Hatter - again having incredibly short missions.

It was less that Rocksteady wanted to continue fleshing out Batman's world and delivering fan service, and more that these missions felt siphoned off from the main game, their runtime conducive to a standard side mission, not standalone, purchasable products.


2. Reduce The Riddler's Raceways And Lose The Mech Boss

Batman arkham knight riddler final battle
Rocksteady

In striving to evolve the base idea of The Riddler filling out the game environment with tons upon tons of puzzles to solve, Arkham Knight saw him somehow develop the super-powered ability to single-handedly build entire raceways underground; ones that were complete with moving parts, death-dealing traps and huge moving platforms.

Even if you could get on board with this idea (which I and many others couldn't), the gameplay behind them - which amounted to time trials and dodging environmental hazards - was rote at best. Simply put, nobody bought a Batman game to whizz around racetracks in the Batmobile, and it stood out like a sore thumb, especially when Riddler revealed his 'final form' to be a whopping great mech.

Getting through The Riddler's former puzzles took genuine smarts and an attention to detail that always made you feel like you achieved something, and whilst the majority of the environmental puzzles elsewhere in Gotham retained this feel, facing off against Nigma should've been the apex of this approach. We needed well-written riddles that The Riddler himself would inevitably give away clues to solving through his incessant need to placate his own ego, not a quick-time event beatdown that literally spelt out "Brawn is better than brains."

Where Arkham City rewarded you with a sweet underground takedown (pulling Riddler straight through the floor and calmly turning him over to the authorities) Knight's culmination had him blasting you with massive lasers, before you punched him repeatedly, God of War-style, the entire thing being the most threadbare payoff for hours upon hours of puzzle solving.


1. Lose The Batmobile 'Puzzle Sections' And Tank Battles

Batman Arkham Knight tank battles
Rocksteady

By far and away the lasting negative point surrounding Arkham Knight is the Batmobile. Whilst personally I think its introduction is one of the coolest moments in the entire canon ("Evening the odds"), the forced decision to then have it be the linchpin of certain of missions just felt a bit off-kilter with Batman being the World's Greatest Detective.

As soon as you were using the grapple hook to mantle up the sides of buildings or dangle down inside sewer pipes just to get the appropriate angle on a given target, it instantly made all of me think of similar situations from past games where we would've done these things without the aid of a vehicle. Now, it's not that these sections need to be ditched altogether, just doled out more sporadically, and in-line with Batman's established abilities.

The moment where you get out of a showdown with the Arkham Knight by having the Batmobile take out his guards was spot on - and made you genuinely feel like Bruce; half-improvising, half-always having a backup plan.

As for the tank battles, they to needed to be routed in escalation. The final act of defending the GCPD should've been the first time you really put your skills to the test, facing off against waves of drones in numbers you'd never seen before - not yet another battle that you'd played a handful of times before.

The actual mechanics of the battles themselves were mostly okay - save for watching out for targeting lasers every five seconds - but in far smaller bursts, it would've worked nicely.

What would you change about Arkham Knight? Let us know in the comments!


Gaming Editor
Gaming Editor

WhatCulture's Head of Gaming.