10 Westerns You Need To Watch After Playing Red Dead Redemption 2
The greatest in fancy hats, facial hair and fabulous horses that cinema has to offer.
Whether or not you've reached the end of Red Dead Redemption 2, you've no doubt fallen in love with the American Old West. Rockstar's sprawling tale of an outlaw gang in decline against the onslaught of ever-encroaching capitalism and corruption is elegiac, heartfelt and nothing short of breathtaking.
That being said, a great deal of people remain under the misconception that the western is an outdated, distasteful institution full of whooping savages and colonial jingoism. They're not entirely wrong, as up until the 1960s the western was (mostly) just that.
During the sixties and seventies, however, things started to change. Opinions on America's history evolved, and the idea of "The Wild West" shifted from glorious conquest to brutal genocide, and the genre began to reflect this - whether directly or figuratively.
The Red Dead Redemption series draws inspiration from the entire spectrum of Western fiction - from the enduring classics to the more complex works of the modern day. So let's have ourselves a little look at some of the films that helped to shape Red Dead into the masterpiece that it is.
10. The Good, The Bad And The Ugly
Whilst hardly a surprising entry, Sergio Leone's three-hour Civil War epic undoubtedly set the tone for westerns for decades to come.
Serving as a prequel to Leone's first two entries in The Dollars Trilogy, We follow Clint Eastwood's now legendary Man With No Name (who is actually named in all three films) on the hunt for a cache of Confederate gold buried somewhere in New Mexico. It's a sprawling masterpiece, taking our (anti)hero(es) over deserts, through volatile border towns and chaotic battlefields on their quest.
Eastwood oozes cool as Blondie (The Good), but it's Eli Wallach's deuteragonist Tuco Ramírez (The Ugly), and Lee Van Cleef as villain Angel Eyes (The Bad, predictably enough), who really shine throughout the film.
Tuco is an uncouth loudmouth with no regard for dignity or personal hygiene - of course, that's what makes him relatable. His swivel-eyed, paranoid energy is a joy to watch. Angel Eyes, on the other hand, is utterly terrifying - he tails the duo like a gathering stormcloud, dispatching everyone who stands between him and them. He feels like some nightmarish 19th century version of a T-800, and it could be argued that if he didn't have such little screen time in comparison to Blondie and Tuco, he'd have stolen the show.
Leone's direction is, as ever, stunning. Huge vistas juxtapose perfectly with his trademark use of extreme close-ups to add a palpable sense of dread to every impending moment of violence.
9. The Wild Bunch
Set at the end of the Old West in an ever-progressing world, Sam Peckinpah's ultra-violent The Wild Bunch is the quintessential tale of the demise of the era.
The film stars a cabal of ageing Hollywood icons as a gang of similarly ageing outlaws being backed into a corner by both the law and the world they now inhabit. The men are walking anachronisms, whose borrowed time is clear from the get-go.
After a botched attempt at a final score, Pike Bishop and the surviving members of his gang flee to the Mexican border to escape a group of now-deputised bounty hunters and happen upon the chance for another final score - which of course couldn't possibly go wrong this time - to steal US Army weapons for a corrupt Mexican Army officer. What follows is a series of betrayals with so many layers that even the Lannisters would recommend toning it down, culminating in one of the bloodiest and most brutal shootouts on film ever seen.
While the overarching theme of a gang coming ever closer to their inevitable doom makes a foregone conclusion seem obvious, The Wild Bunch contains just enough moments of hope and near-success to continually subvert that expectation. The ending is especially powerful, however, in suggesting that while this violent era may be coming to an end, another is about to begin, and the cycle is ever-continuing.
8. Open Range
An unusually reserved effort from Kevin Costner, Open Range is much less of a vanity project than the likes of Dances With Wolves or Wyatt Earp. Granted, he plays a morally upstanding gunslinger who's better at shootin' and doin' what's right than anyone else is, but baby steps everyone. There's actually some nuance at play this time round.
What makes Open Range such a worthwhile watch is not necessarily its plot, as at heart it's a pretty cut-and-dry classic western with well-defined and sometimes simplistic views on morality. What makes it such a worthwhile watch is how it grounds that simplicity in palpable historical authenticity and a well realised world. The frontier town of Harmonville (a clear inspiration for RDRII's Valentine) is populated with lively, if slightly clichéd, characters.
When free-grazers Charlie Waite and Boss Spearman are attacked by a local land baron, leaving one of their companions gravely wounded and another dead, they take it upon themselves to endear themselves to the townsfolk, aiming to turn them against the corrupt local law enforcement and setting the stage for a deadly showdown of their own design. The build-up of tension is almost unbearable, with a sense of foreboding that borders on apocalyptic.
And then they start shooting at each other.
The shootout is almost unparalleled in every way. It's slow, deliberate, and at times awkward. It's such a departure from the usual montage-of-people-getting-shot fare that if nothing else, you need to watch Open Range purely to learn how a showdown is done.
7. Jeremiah Johnson
If you're at all familiar with Jeremiah Johnson, you probably know it from one of the most recognisable reaction gifs out there rather than the film itself.
But look past that admittedly hilarious clip and there's a film well worth your time. Presented as a feature (which includes an overture and an intermission), the dusty plains and tough talkin' cowboys are replaced with waist-deep snow and grizzled mountain men. Robert Redford is the eponymous Jeremiah Johnson, a veteran of the Mexican War, who sets off into the Colorado Rockies to put his troubled past behind him and start afresh. It transpires, however, that starting afresh isn't as simple as it may seem.
Johnson's journey takes many twists and turns - he is mentored by the seasoned and eccentric "Bear Claw" Lapp, is seemingly pranked into marrying a young Flathead Native woman by a fellow trapper, and he adopts a mute young boy whose family were killed. This provides him with an idyllic - if unorthodox - family life up in the high country. However this is short lived, as the meddling nature of a group of American settlers causes his relationship with the Crow Tribe to sour, and things take a very dark turn indeed.
Despite the odd goofy, out-of-placed moment and a couple of montages that haven't aged hugely well, Jeremiah Johnson is a nonetheless thoughtful and moving reflection on the natural world, and deserves special praise for its nuanced representation of the Indigenous people of America.
6. McCabe & Mrs Miller
A far cry from, well, just about anything else on this list, McCabe & Mrs Miller is an odd one, to say the least. The 1971 drama goes beyond the subgenre of the revisionist western and into the still-uncharted territory of the anti-western. There are no gunslingers or hookers with hearts of gold. Just opportunists and regular old hookers with regular old hearts of blood and viscera.
The titular McCabe is a shrewd and often cowardly businessman whose sole mysterious quality is the fact that he may have once killed a man, and Mrs Miller is a brothel madam with a keen business strategy and a debilitating addiction to opium. That's some damn fine protagonists we've got there.
Whilst these two may be the film's designated leads, the real star of the show is Robert Altman's directing, and the presentation of the town itself. The oddly named Presbyterian Church (which RDRII players may find notably similar in design to the town of Strawberry) is rich with supporting characters who dip in and out of the story's focus seamlessly. Much of the dialogue is improvised and a lot of scenes were shot from many angles simultaneously, lending an almost documentary-like feel to the film. Never has a regular night in an old west saloon seemed so convincing.
It's an unusual film, but is certainly unique. And speaking of unusual and unique...
5. Slow West
Released in 2015 to very little fanfare and subsequently flying under the radar, Slow West is a stunning feature debut from The Beta Band's John McClean - presumably the love-child of Bruce Willis' Die Hard protagonist and the guy who wrote American Pie.
Kodi Mitt-McPhee, the most whimsically named actor in Hollywood aside from Benedict Cumberbatch, plays Jay Cavendish, a young Scotsman on a quest to find his lost love, Rose, who has become a fugitive on the American Frontier. He employs bounty hunter Silas Selleck to protect him on his journey across the wilderness, but unbeknownst to him, Selleck has embarked on the same journey - however with the intention of capturing or killing Rose and her father and collecting the bounty. What follows is a slow-burning intrigue in which both characters develop from their inherent mistrust of each other and face tougher moral quandaries than ever before.
Whilst the film is most definitely a western, it almost has more in common with road movies of the sixties and seventies, with its two protagonists repeatedly sidetracked from their shared quest as they are wrong-footed by outlaw couples, treacherous shysters and sinister marauders. Its more absurdist elements - odd comedy moments and absinthe-induced hallucinations - are offset perfectly with scenes of intense brutality, and the result is a truly effective coming-of-age drama against a beautiful and deadly backdrop.
4. High Noon
Widely considered to be one of the earliest revisionist westerns, 1952's High Noon was one of the most subversive films of its era. A clear allegory for the ongoing Hollywood Blacklist led by the House Un-American Activities Committee, the film's story of a lawman abandoned by his entire town to face a dangerous gang of outlaws alone draws parallels with the grip of desperate fear and paranoia that America was under.
With the imminent arrival of a gang led by Frank Miller (no, not that Frank Miller), an outlaw bent on retribution against Sheriff Will Kane for having sent him to jail, the action takes place in near real-time. It all points towards the titular High Noon train, which Miller is travelling into town on. Kane fruitlessly attempts to assemble a posse to combat the gang - he is repeatedly met with hostility and non-cooperation, with the townsfolk attempting to gain political favour from their help or simply resentful of Kane that he once prevented them from getting rich from Miller's previous illegal activities.
When High Noon comes, it is Kane, and Kane alone, facing a force of evil having been abandoned by the world he once knew.
John Wayne (deservedly absent from this list) famously called High Noon "...the most Un-American thing I've ever seen in my whole life". That sounds like as good an incentive to watch as any, really.
3. The Assassination Of Jesse James By The Coward Robert Ford
Where to start with The Assassination Of Jesse James By The Coward Robert Ford? Well, the title might be the most apt. Whilst giving away the most vital event of the film's plot, it provides its audience with an opportunity to invest themselves in the characters and their relationships without second-guessing what their fates will ultimately be. The title itself bears the style of a morally simplistic Old West dime novel, but the film's approach to its characters is anything but.
Granted, James is ultimately assassinated in a less-than-heroic fashion by Ford, but it's the two hour build-up to the event that betrays any preconceptions one may have had about these people and their motivations.
The Assassination Of Jesse James is not about James's murder but rather about Ford's gradual disillusionment with the man who was once his hero. The film opens with the James Gang participating in what will be their final robbery (and it will feel strikingly familiar if you've played RDRII's story), and Bob Ford has come along for the ride. Bob, who idolises Jesse and has avidly collected novels and newspaper clippings of his exploits, is shocked to find that his hero is in reality a jaded, cynical man with no interest in honour or heroics. The pedestal Bob has put Jesse on proves to be his undoing.
With breathtaking cinematography and wonderful performances all round, The Assassination Of Jesse James is a lyrical, heartbreaking deconstruction of the one of the west's greatest legends.
2. Unforgiven
Considered by many to be Clint Eastwood's masterpiece, 1992's Unforgiven is so special because of what it represents - a dismantling of everything Eastwood was known for previously.
His tale of William Munny, a weary reformed outlaw trying to make good on his previous deeds feels like a natural conclusion to the story of the aforementioned Man With No Name, stripping away the mystique of that character and providing the viewer with a more human character than Eastwood's earlier protagonists.
Munny's engagement in one final job (the assassination of two cowboys who disfigured a local prostitute) is less an act of greed or heroism but one of desperation. His farm is failing and he feels unable to provide a future for his children. Upon arrival in the town of Big Whiskey, the job turns out to be anything but simple, as Sheriff "Little Bill" Daggett has already resolved the crime without resorting to murder and has vowed to punish anybody who attempts to collect the bounty. Things swiftly go downhill, with Munny losing his old partner and finally gunning down all the lawmen in town. Despite having earned the bounty, his victory feels hollow as he has slid back towards the past life he had tried so hard to leave behind.
He rides away, not gloriously into the sunset but in a downpour, screaming threats of further violence at anyone who dare follow him into the night. A Wild West hero he ain't.
1. The Proposition
Bit of a departure of around 9,000 miles for the top spot. Penned and scored by none other than Nick Cave, The Proposition takes place in the Australian Outback, but is no less a western than any other. The film neatly draws many parallels, between First Peoples and Indigenous Australians, between Bushrangers and Gunslingers, between violence and...well, violence.
Rockstar go so far as to credit it as one of the primary influences on the original Red Dead Redemption's tone, and John Hillcoat - the film's director - was the man behind the RDR machinima short The Man From Blackwater.
The Proposition is punishingly bleak, following Guy Pearce's dishevelled outlaw Charlie Burns as a local police captain hands him an impossible ultimatum: to kill his older brother in exchange for his younger brother's freedom. Against the sweltering heat of the outback, Burns faces corrupt lawmen, territorial tribal fighters and bounty hunters even dirtier and more wicked than himself. The film's surreal, atmospheric soundtrack, gorgeous cinematography and moments of brutal violence punctuating long stretches of quiet reflection lend a feeling of dreamlike detachment from the whole affair - not that it's a dream you'd find especially pleasant.
The film deals with many grim and difficult themes, including loyalty and distrust, bitter resentment and devastating familial loss. Barely a moment passes where the viewer is afforded respite, and every second of The Proposition will have the viewer dreading what horrors its savage world will unleash next.