22 Biggest Disappointments Of E3 2015

Sadly, Nintendo spent more time on awesome puppets than awesome games.

This year's E3 certainly had its share of Earth-shattering moments, but as ever, it also under-delivered in a number of ways that fans were desperately hopeful for. Sure, you can't please everyone given how entitled some gamers can act, but at the same time, a number of key games and reveals were curiously held back despite reasonable expectations that they would be there this time. That's not all, though: the likes of EA and Ubisoft refused to learn lessons from their previous conferences and kept it pretty much business as usual, while even some games that were revealed showed off some less-than-stellar mechanics and may well have sealed their critical fates already. Then there's those game franchises which sadly refuse to innovate or move with the times, and soon enough risk fatiguing audiences. It sure was an E3 for the ages thanks to Sony, Microsoft and Bethesda, but even so, it's tough not to expect even more from some games and developers, who put in only a minimal level of effort this year, or in one case, basically shouldn't have even bothered showing up at all. Still, there's always next year, right? Without any further ado, here are the 22 biggest disappointments of E3 2015...

22. Dark Souls III Gameplay Was Only Shown Behind Closed Doors

E3 saw the reveal of the first Dark Souls III trailer, even though of course, fans got their first glimpse of the game a few weeks ago when screenshots and key details were leaked. The 2-minute, completely CGI trailer showed off the typical Dark Souls visual style without giving much away plot-wise, but most crucially confirmed that the game is due for release in "early 2016". It was a damn shame, though, that no gameplay footage was shown at any conference or live stream, only behind closed doors to select members of the press. Reports of the footage have already sneaked their way online, though it's still massively frustrating to Souls fans everywhere that they can't see the game in motion. If it's good enough to show to the press, why not everyone else too, especially given the promising nature of most of the spy reports?

21. Nintendo NX Won't Be Revealed Until 2016

If there was anything that could've perked up Nintendo's conference considering the fact they already appear to have lost enthusiasm for the Wii U, it would've been an unveiling of the Nintendo NX platform. However, Nintendo of America boss Reggie Fils-Amie announced during the company's digital event that fans would have to wait a little longer, as it was being held until 2016 for a reveal. It's already known that the platform will deviate significantly from the formula of the previous two Nintendo consoles, with many suspecting they may be turning their attention towards smartphone technology, but it seems that the console's unveiling will likely wait until next year's E3. Will Nintendo return with a proper, fully-fledged conference, or will it be shown off in another digital event? Wait and see.

20. EA Wasted Half Their Conference On Sports & Mobile Gaming (Again)

EA will probably never learn their lesson when it comes to staging an interesting E3 conference, and as soon as the words, "Let's talk about mobile" rang out, many gamers lost hope. Rather than spend more time on their AAA titles, the conference delved into Star Wars and Minions mobile games that likely nobody "hardcore" enough to watch the conferences cared about (except for the shareholders, of course). Then came the glut of annualised sports franchises being shown off, including that awkward chat with Pele to promote FIFA 16 before finally getting back to business with Mirror's Edge: Catalyst. These sports games are going to sell like hotcakes no matter what: did more than half an hour really need to be wasted on all this casual nonsense?

19. Tony Hawk's Pro Skater 5's Shockingly Bad Graphics

Tony Hawk's Pro Skater 5 was first shown off last month complete with screenshots, though a live stream at E3 with Hawk himself saw him reveal the first in-motion footage of the game. The results? Well, they weren't pretty: see it for yourself here. Fans were quick to disparage the game's wildly underwhelming visuals, noting that it didn't look much better than the decline-era titles five years ago, and suffered from trick animations that lacked fluidity. Unsurprisingly, despite being due for release on September 29th, the game wasn't available to be played on the conference floor, only behind closed doors to a select few. When things are already looking so mild, can anyone be surprised? It's a shame, because if there's one game that needs a juicy, big-budget revival, it's this one, but instead it looks like a decidedly cheap cash-grab.

18. The Totally Boring PC Gaming Conference

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kkk6HZ2Kp2w There was plenty of excitement ahead of the very first PC gaming conference at E3, sponsored by PC Gamer of course. Was it going to make a firm stance for PC gamers and add another must-see event to the stacked docket? No, not really. The show, ably hosted by the charismatic Sean "Day9" Plott, was a surprisingly snoozy affair, focusing far too much on expansions and lower-tier titles, and often stopping to give their advertisers a lengthy slot to wax technical about the newest graphics cards (looking at you here, AMD). Even with some cool No Man's Sky footage being shown off, the whole thing felt depressingly low-key and not really part of the proper show. Plus, the 2-and-a-half-hour run-time was absolutely punishing, especially if you live in Europe and stayed up until the wee hours to see if Gabe Newell made an appearance...

17. Assassin's Creed: Syndicate Is Strictly Business As Usual

After Assassin's Creed: Unity suffered immense backlash for its overwhelmingly mediocre release, there was hope that Ubisoft might bring something a little different for the series to E3 as an indication that they're going to put more effort in this time. Instead, fans got more of the same: a glossy, lengthy CGI trailer, and strangely enough, not even any Assassin's Creed: Syndicate gameplay in Ubisoft's conference. Though the footage was posted online instead, it didn't seem to indicate much of an evolution beyond new characters and a Victorian London setting. The formula proves so successful even when Ubisoft put only minimal effort in, so gamers probably shouldn't expect much to change until they're prepared to vote with their wallets and stop buying the annualised action series.

16. Final Fantasy XV No-Shows The Square Enix Conference

Though Final Fantasy XV director Hajime Tabat originally planned for a trailer to play at Square Enix's E3 conference, the Western arm of the company decided against it after they found out it wouldn't contain any new footage. Now, in fairness, Square Enix were perfectly up-front about saying that FFXV wouldn't be appearing at E3, but unless you were trawling gaming news sites every day in the weeks before the conferences, it may have easily slipped through the cracks. Hence the outrage from FF fans the world over when the game no-showed, with the company instead saving it for Gamescom in August. An agonising wait, but hopefully with missing E3, they'll have something very special indeed to show off.

15. Need For Speed's Drifting Camera Looks Totally Awful

Though few will argue with the fact that the new Need for Speed game certainly looks visually pleasing, many had much to say about the game's drifting mechanics, which seem irritating and intrusive to say the least. For starters, whenever the player is shown to launch into a drift, it seems incredibly mechanical, largely because the chain of animations isn't very smooth. Secondly, and more annoyingly, the camera changes perspective and swings down below the car during a drift, which in a game focused on split-second accuracy, can be a potential hindrance and even an extreme annoyance. Hopefully EA will take on-board the vocal social media criticism, as it can't be too hard to fix a camera angle with over 4 months to spare. As for the animation issue? Wait and see on that one...

14. Valve's Absence From The PC Gaming Show

There was one company everyone was hoping would show up at the PC gaming conference, and that's Valve. Even ignoring Half-Life 3, they're one of the most pivotal and integral players in the PC gaming industry today, what with the (mostly) marvelous work they continue to do with Steam. Their appearance in some form or another would have marked a sure stamp of authenticity on the show, but alas, they didn't appear at all throughout the 150-minute show. Perhaps they figured that showing up without Half-Life 3 in tow would just be cruel to the millions of gamers out there. Still, a much-needed injection of pizzazz it would've been in a shockingly snoozy show.

In this post: 
E3 2015
 
Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

Stay at home dad who spends as much time teaching his kids the merits of Martin Scorsese as possible (against the missus' wishes). General video game, TV and film nut. Occasional sports fan. Full time loon.