8 Video Games That Made You Pay For Essential Features - Commenter Edition

Pay for... fast travel???

Last year, we wrapped up ten video games that made you pay for essential features, and you guys shared our bafflement so sincerely, that many took to the comments to suggest other games that have done the same thing.

And so, we’ve got another pile of name and shame entries that left us wondering why we were being asked to pay for content that really should have been in the game to begin with. Whether it was a content addition or features that were present previously in the series then later taken out, or an extreme level of nickel-and-diming, every instance on this list is nothing less than unacceptable.

--

8. The Culling - More Than One Match

The Culling 2
Xaviant Games

Battle royale actioner The Culling is a perfect example of whatever the opposite of a noble underdog story is. It launched as The Culling 2 on the same day as Fortnite: Battle Royale in 2018, which sucks, but you’ll stop feeling bad for The Culling developer and publisher Xaviant right about now.

After a single week on storefronts the game was pulled due to player criticism over the game being wildly unfinished, it was then rebooted as The Culling: Origins which restored the game to its more complete state from back in 2016. Then in early 2019 the studio said the game hadn’t made enough money so they were shutting down the servers only to announce a year later in 2020 that the game was back from the dead yet again with an absolutely wild pay-per-match model.

Yes, a battle royale game that wanted you to pay for every match you played. Insanity.

You were given a token for one free match per day but after that you’d need to pay up. Obviously, as a Telltale game would put it, everybody disliked that, so they then changed their tune to give you ten free games per day before you had to start paying. It’s genuinely hard to think of a more consumer unfriendly move they could have chosen. It will likely come as no large shock that just six months later the servers were shut again, this time for good.


7. The Legend Of Zelda: Skyward Sword HD - Fast Travel

the legend of zelda skyward sword hd
Nintendo

Now, there’s a general issue with Nintendo titles about certain things being locked behind Amiibo, or Amiibos, I don’t know if anyone settled on a plural there, but for some games it has been more egregious than others.

There’s Metroid: Samus Returns locking its hardest difficulty mode behind an Amiibo and Link’s iconic horse buddy Epona only being accessible in Breath of the Wild via the means of Amiibo. Almost certainly the worst offender, though, was The Legend of Zelda: Skyward Sword HD which locked the most convenient version of its fast travel behind an Amiibo. While the game does feature a fast travel system whereby you can jump between bird statues you’ve located, the Amiibo version lets you shoot yourself up into the sky and fast travel from anywhere which is far breezier.

Obviously this move was a controversial one, especially since the Loftwing Amiibo needed to initiate the feature sold out everywhere. And even if it was available the thing cost $25.

Sure, you can just buy the NFC cards which are cheaper and emulate what the Amiibo does but it’s scummy that it’s paywalled at all.


6. Dragon Age: Inquisition - The Real Ending

DAI Solas Dread Wolf
BioWare

Dragon Age: Inquisition isn’t the first game to put significant narrative endgame content into a DLC and it won’t be the last, but it is the one I’ve decided to put on this list so let’s talk about it.

The Trespasser DLC came out almost a year after Dragon Age: Inquisition launched and while it’s a fantastic add-on, that sort of makes its lack of inclusion in the original game even worse. As does the fact that now we know the narrative setup for the next game in the series, it’s basically essential to play so you know what’s going on in Dragon Age: Dreadwolf.

Trespasser takes place years after the events of the main game but connects several vital narrative dots, gives you a more complete final chapter with the companions you’ve come to know and love, and rounds out Inquisition’s somewhat lacklustre conclusion. The fact that this one cost players $15 on top of the full priced game they’d just finished isn’t great but that’s not even the worst of it.

The DLC only released on PC, PlayStation 4, and Xbox One, so if you were one of those who played Inquisition on PS3 or Xbox 360 you were bizarrely out of luck if you wanted to play the game’s crucial final chapter.


5. Peridot - The Core Gameplay Loop

Peridot game
Niantic

This one is a little left of field but you guys brought it to our attention so we’ve included it for you. Also, it’s a good stand in for any time you’ve been frustratingly shaken down by a mobile game forcing you to pay to play the core experience. Peridot is an AR mobile game by Pokemon Go developer Niantic and it basically mushes together Pokemon Go with Tamagotchi vibes as you’ll be taking care of and breeding pets.

That’s all very well but you need to pay to breed new dots. You see, they each require a nest basket which are available at $5 a pop.

There are a couple of dice roll ways to get nests otherwise but they’re wildly unlikely to happen for you so this is the only sure fire way to get more pets. It’s an insidious little catch no doubt hoping to snag players who have warmed to the game enough that they want to see and raise dots beyond their starter pal, level up, and explore new dot archetypes.

While a mobile game underhandedly trying to scam your dollars is hardly a new concept, that doesn’t make it any less crummy.


4. Tekken 7 - Frame Data

tekken 7 frame data
Namco

Bandai Namco’s fighter Tekken 7 released to arcades in 2015 and home consoles in 2017. While it reviewed and sold well with outlets praising the game for its new mechanics, impressive graphics, tight and exciting gameplay, and compelling characters, it’s on this list so it must have ballsed something up.

What was it that it ballsed up I hear you ask? And why have I decided to say ballsed? I can’t answer that second question to be honest, but to the first it made you pay for frame data.

For the uninitiated or the uninterested in fighting games, frame data is essential to those who take the competitive nature of the genre seriously. It gives you insight as to how many frames every action takes to execute thereby giving you vital knowledge about what attacks, defences, and moves play in your favour and which will leave you at a disadvantage. While dedicated fans have put the time in to create detailed websites that collate this information, the display of frame data in Tekken 7 is gated behind a paid DLC. Sure, it’s only a few dollars but it’s the principle of the thing.

Taking this feature out and then charging you for it is like if Baldur’s Gate 3 ripped out the ability to change to a top down view and charged you to put it back in. Or if The Quarry took out the ability to save scum through Death Rewinding but charged you if you wanted to use it, oh wait they did do that. Anyway, uncool.


3. Dungeons And Almost Everything Else - Destiny 2

destiny 2
Bungie

Bungie’s 2017 shooter Destiny 2 got off to a solid start but it’s been a long road for the live service shooter since its launch in 2017 and things have, well, changed a little, and you guys want it brought to light. The game went free-to-play in October of 2019 which was a cool thing unless you bought it full price, and then it started charging players for a bunch of standard core gameplay features which is a way less cool thing.

Destiny: The Taken King snagged a spot on our last list for locking paying players who didn’t upgrade to the expansion out of the game, but Bungie are nothing if not consistent because they’ve earned a place on this one with their sequel, too.

Dungeons are one of the central activities you’ll be able to tackle to help boost your power level and get your hands on better loot. These were originally free to all players and now you need a pass to access them which can only be obtained with your real world dollars. Bizarrely, though understandably if you’re Bungie and after a cash grab, these aren’t included in the expansions, instead it’ll cost you 2000 silver.

Of course you can’t buy that increment of the in-game currency so you have to get 3000 silver which is 45 Australian dollars. Insane.

They’ve also sunsetted certain content packages like the initial main story and the Forsaken expansion which is a really pretty way of saying, “Remember that thing you paid for? Yeah, you can’t play that any more.” Not to mention how pricey their DLC is. Sure, the game is technically free to play but if you want to play a semi-comprehensive collection of its content you’re going to be paying well over $200.

Unfortunately the studio has learned they can gate content away from players and ask for them to pay for it later and be successful but as we’ve well and truly highlighted, it’s a scummy practice.


2. Fire Emblem Fates - The Extra Storyline

fire emblem fates
Nintendo

Recent Fire Emblem entries have gone all in on offering you faction choices where you can align yourself with different kingdoms, political figures, or houses depending on which game you’re playing. In Fire Emblem Fates you can choose between territories to throw your weight behind, but it’s a little more complicated than that. The game was released in three different versions. Birthright and Conquest each delved into a separate storyline that focussed on the same set of characters.

The extra confusing and relevant part for our list is that you had to buy these separately and the plot thickens because the Revelation DLC is what you need to actually access the true ending of the game no matter which of the first versions you choose.

I’m not playing, there is an enormous thread on the Fire Emblem subreddit trying to help new players understand which of the DLCs they need to pick up to play this thing properly and it is a monster of a post. Boiled down, if you want the full experience you’re going to need to buy all three and even if you’re happy to go with just one initial path, without that final DLC you’re missing a huge chunk of the intended narrative and ending.

There are also more paid DLC packs which include an extra character, new maps, storylines, classes, items, and fights, along with a pile of other things you’ll scratch your head over wondering why they couldn’t have made it into any of the first three versions of the game.

If you didn’t grab it then, well, you can’t now because the eShop shut down last year but honestly it’s so complicated, maybe you’re better off.


1. The Sims 4 - Growing Families & Seasons

the sims 4
EA

Nobody nickel and dimes quite as successfully and somehow without enormous fan outrage than EA with the Sims franchise. Gone are the days when you’d sit down with The Sims 1 and have a gay old time, maybe with the chunky expansions Livin’ Large, House Party, Vacation, or my favourite: Hot Date.

That’s not to say EA weren’t nickel and diming you back in the early 2000s but let me quantify this for you. The Sims had 7 add-on packs. The Sims 4 has 28 full expansions and game packs and 47 stuff packs and kits. One of these is free. One of them. Nobody does it like EA.

This has especially hit home with each new full sequel as you know full well they could have thrown in tried and true features like seasons, pets, university, and get together. A particular pain point, apart from paying for seasons which is a ridiculous exclusion for a life-sim, is that without 2023’s Growing Together expansion parents couldn’t meaningfully influence their toddlers, children, and adolescents. Players were also given infants as a free content update but it kind of baited you into grabbing this expansion because without it there’s not much you can do with them. There’s a reason they can get away with making the base game free now.


Watch Next


Contributor
Contributor

Jess has been a journalist and content creator in the games industry for over 15 years and has been WhatCulture's resident Australian import and sorry cop since 2020, upping the quotient of swearing and apologising in WhatCulture Gaming's annual blooper videos considerably. She previously worked at GameSpot for 10 years, most notably hosting GameSpot News in addition to E3 live shows, and PAX panels. She regularly livestreams a variety of games on her 'jessmcdonell' YouTube and Twitch channels and hosts the 'Do It On The Day' podcast. She has won awards for her news and feature work in gaming as well as an accolade for her comedic writing (likely an admin error). She can be found on X at @jessmcdonell and Instagram at @jessicamcdonell sharing her current videogame fixations, industry insights, and videos of her cat, Karma.