8 Video Games That Tackle Incredibly Polarising Subject Matter
Trench warfare isn't supposed to be 'fun'. You know that, right?
The gaming industry is no stranger to political controversy. Scapegoating the medium for 'inspiring' any random acts of violence was very much the norm of the mainstream media for some time - especially the 90s and early 2000s.
This narrative, forever lampooned and discredited by sensible voices on all sides of the political spectrum, is now a thing of the past. But apart from this obvious display of reactionary opinion, are video games now inextricably linked with political subject matter?
There is much to be said, however, of 'accidental politics', and the strive for neutrality when dealing with inherently complex and controversial themes. Indeed, Ed Smith's enlightening contribution to this discussion and its relationship to Battlefield: Hardline is essential reading for anyone interested by the problematic nature of games with potentially volatile contexts.
As Smith notes, Hardline epitomises the idea of a game that uncomfortably avoids discussion surrounding its context, one that becomes "not just highly political but politically dubious". As the drug-fuelled Ghost Recon: Wildlands also approaches, it is certainly an argument to bear in mind.
After all, what is a truly great story without social commentary? Inherently political or otherwise, we are now seeing many video games find themselves bound in external and internal political meta-narratives.
Indeed, as Hardline has shown already, shying away just simply isn't an option...
8. GTA V: Government Use Of Torture
Grand Theft Auto has never been a bastion of satire in the industry. Honestly, contrary to many who believe so, the franchise's incongruous methods of parody have never really managed to stoke discussion, indeed, even going as so far as to completely chastise debate in the first place. It offers a poor imitation of the denigrative approach pioneered by South Park co-creators Trey Parker and Matt Stone, but in a manner that barely manages to provoke discussion. Quite simply, there is no 'hoo-ha' to get with GTA.
Fun free-roamer it is, iconoclastic satire, it is not.
There is one mission, however, that bucks the trends of the series' past; one that garnered controversy, again, due to the preeminence of controversial voices in the media.
For those who have played 'By the Book', they should know that the violence portrayed is anything but gratuitous. Rather, it offers a forceful examination of the use of Government-sanctioned torture, particularly in relation to the United States' War on Terror following the attacks on the World Trade Centre and Pentagon in September 2001. It's an immensely uncomfortable experience to sit through, but Rockstar knew this, and I'd be beyond surprise if it wasn't their intention.
Trevor is a character we're already well accustomed to by the time this mission approaches. One who, in an ironic parody of the chaotic nature of GTA itself, thrives off violence. He is, however, completely repulsed by his acts here, and even goes as far as to offer a scathing monologue on torture itself before giving his victim the chance to escape, after being instructed by the FIB to murder him.
We're also shown just how useless torture is as a method to extract information, as Michael struggles to discern who his target is based on the vague and nondescript intel gained from Trevor's acts.
For a medium so often lampooned for its almost repetitive use of violence as a solution to threats, this was a welcomed discussion to be had, no matter how obtuse it might have been.
7. Ghost Recon Wildlands: The War On Drugs
Of all the United States' costly military ventures, not many are as controversial as the War on Drugs. Sure, there is the War on Terror, but I'm saving that for later.
As far as military shooters go, Ghost Recon was never one to tackle conventional warfare. Always the subject of near-future settings, the tactical shooter always aimed to replicate the late Tom Clancy's high-octane yet fictitious style of story-telling, taking place in completely untenable scenarios to the tune of the the author's international post-Cold War narratives.
Wildlands thus sets itself apart from its predecessors, sending the U.S Army's fictional special-forces unit into the heart of Bolivia itself to tackle the also non-existent Santa Blanca Drug Cartel. In a time where the U.S's policy on drug warfare has come under heavy scrutiny, Ubisoft's choice to set their latest title in such a manner is an interesting one, to say the least.
Current estimates place annual US spending on the War on Drugs at around $51 billion annually, with the nations primary focus of aid and combatants being in, you guessed it, South America. There is a danger here that Ubisoft repeat the mistakes of EA and completely forego any discussion there is to be had with U.S policy in South America, but here's hoping their Paris studio at least attempt to offer some examination of the War's contentious nature.
If not, Wildlands could be remembered for all the wrong reasons.
6. Mafia III: The Legacy Of Jim Crow And Vietnam In The American South
For a game revolving around revenge, mobsters and violence, Mafia III is looking incredibly progressive. Set in a fictionalised version of New Orleans during the late '60s, Hangar 13's addition to the Mafia franchise is promising not just layered gameplay and a compelling narrative, but also a nuanced portrayal of the United States during a period of irrevocable change.
There is, however, much to be said based on what 2K have released thus far, with its most recent E3 demo being particularly telling, regarding some of the narrative elements at play during Lincoln Clay's tale of revenge.
Of course, Clay himself is a veteran of the Vietnam war, a conflict still firmly etched into the American psyche (for better or for worse), and one that has been characterised not just for its unparalleled brutality, but also because of the disproportionate impact the draft had on the young, poor and people of colour.
Clearly, these are elements that will propel Clay towards a life of crime, and it's already obvious that his military background will also hold some impact on the way gameplay and story progresses over the course of the game.
At its core, Mafia III is endeavouring to tell a tale of the Black Mob in the American South during one of the most violent periods in American history. Jim Crow, rather than having been eradicated, still held a painful legacy across Louisiana and beyond.
As the player will don the role of an African American (itself a progressive move) during this period, Clay's experiences will all be impacted by systemic racism, demagoguery and bigotry. It was the reality of the time, and anything other than a erudite examination of it could firmly halt Mafia in its tracks.
5. Metal Gear Solid V: Quiet's Character Model
Love him or hate him, there's no denying that Hideo Kojima is the king of bat-sh*t crazy in videogames. He's the creator of Metal Gear, and also happens to be one of the most prominent figures in the industry. He is, however, not really the best at conveying commentary.
Take Quiet for instance; she's pretty much the best example to give whenever someone mentions the utterly attrocious treatment of women in videogames. She's scantily clad because of a terribly contrived gimmick, silent for the vast majority of the story, and has a primary role in, well, providing the ever-so necessary female eye-candy the medium so clearly relies upon in far too many instances.
Regardless of whatever intention Kojima had in conveying a tale that placed language as the sole reason behind fundamental problems of racism and intolerance (in my view, a whitewashing of the many contributive factors that have given rise to inequality over the years), Quiet's character is nothing more than - as Aoife Wilson puts it - "an appendix to her t*ts".
No, the gimmicky reason behind her scantily clad demeanour does not negate criticism and no, this isn't an issue that exemplifies the very language barriers The Phantom Pain charged with giving rise to the apparent divisions that reside within the world today. It could be argued they are contributive, but not to the extent Kojima would wish to infer.
As far as gender is concerned, video games (and by extent the community) still have a long way to go; Metal Gear only represents the tip of the iceberg.
4. Battlefield I: The Taboo Surrounding The First World War
Apart from The Second World War, you'd be hard-pressed to find a conflict with such a long-lasting cultural or political legacy than The Great War.
In the immediate aftermath of the armistice, governments across Europe, though heavily intent on further legitimising their duplicitous imperial ambitions, sought reflection. This was, after all, the most destructive conflict in history (up until that point). Millions perished, and for that reason the war is etched firmly into the collective consciousness of Europe's nations.
In Britain, for instance, the 11th November is marked as a day of national remembrance; primarily in regards to the First World War, but also for military lives lost long after as well. Each year, school children venture to the battlefields and war graves of France and Belgium to primarily study, but also to reflect.
Point being: There's barely a citizen in the UK that doesn't have an ancestor touched by the conflict.
DICE have taken massive liberties in attempting to retain their staple franchise's style of gameplay in this early 20th century setting, but it's still a title rooted in history. Indeed, there's nothing inherently controversial about that - other wars have long been the setting of military shooters, even Vietnam which is a conflict far more contentious than this one - but the Great War is always discussed in solemn, even idiosyncratic tones.
It was still a war, one that started over 100 years ago now, but even then there's a general hesitance to associate such a conflict with 'fun'.
This probably speaks more for the rampant hysteria of the British press (God, can't someone please save us from Rupert Murdoch?) in regards to the act of remembrance itself, but there is certainly a unique level of significance attributed to the Great War, even if some would argue there shouldn't be.
3. Medal Of Honor: Military Intervention And The War On Terror
When EA and Danger Close brought Medal of Honor to a modern setting to contest the genre with the rival that had dethroned it, no one expected the controversy it would bring.
Indeed, whereas Call of Duty had elected to depict a fictitious version of modern warfare, EA ventured in the opposite direction; showcasing the actual War on Terror from the perspective of a Tier-1 special forces operator. Some would say bold. Others would probably say insensitive.
As a reboot of a franchise centred squarely on the European and Pacific theatres of the Second World War, Medal of Honor was a critical success, but the fact it placed such heavy emphasis on actual combat encounters fought during the early days of the War in Afghanistan didn't sit well with many. The fact the multiplayer too let players take on the role of the Taliban also caused controversy, with the game subsequently being banned from sale at US military bases after it released as a result.
You do have to admire Danger Close for at least attempting to examine the impacts behind the War on Terror, and its authentic nature is a testament to the rigour the studio put in behind the title's design.
Far from glorifying war or the conflict itself, the story told within was character-driven and human in its essence, and whilst it stops short from making a political statement regarding NATO's presence in the nation, portraying actual experiences of soldiers in combat - though not comparable in realism to actual military engagements - is certainly commendable.
In a decade where titles like Six Days in Fallujah are ultimately cancelled because of their setting, it remains intriguing how 2010's Medal of Honor managed to resonate with such a wide audience.
2. Surgeon Simulator: The 2016 American Presidential Election
For commentators stood on the opposite side of the Atlantic watching the American Presidential Race has been a bit like watching a relative's racist uncle start a house fire, all whilst the emergency services attempt to put it out by hosing it down with gasoline and calling it an effective fire retardant.
It's not, and it's not fooling anyone, but still they persist - as does the fire.
Personifying said uncle is Donald Trump, a man who by all accounts embodies the demagogic legacy of George Wallace (albeit in a wotsit-tinged manner) and who - given the ever repulsive polarised nature of American politics - could by all means walk into the White House come January 2017. It's a terrifying prospect to say the least, but at least we have Bossa Studios to laugh us all into denial with their free add-on to 2013's cult hit, Surgeon Simulator.
That's right, now you can operate on the presumptive Republican presidential nominee, in a theatre emblazoned with all his most treasured possessions; ranging from Trump Steaks to Trump Vodka. Just don't expect to find a Trump University degree on there though, since, well, they never got around to actually printing any.
For a game like this to venture into political satire is pretty much unheard of, and it's already stirring controversy within what I imagine is the expansive Surgeon Simulator community. Still though, what's not to love about some well-timed political satire?
1. Far Cry 3: The 'White Saviour' Narrative
To some, Far Cry 3 is a tale firmly rooted in discussions of sanity and savagery. Questions regarding poor portrayal of mental health in video games aside (reducing mental illness to a mere video game mechanic is an example of sanism plain and simple), Far Cry's evocation of tribalistic imagery, callbacks to classic imperialist tropes of the 'Noble Savage' as well as the 'White Saviour' does render its tale problematic by definition.
Indeed, its flippant usage of these caricatures, plot-devices and archetypes is most definitely troubling, and was quite rightly critiqued upon its release for its over reliance - let alone embracement of - these long-derided tropes.
Gameplay wise, Far Cry 3 is still an exemplary release. Its abject embrace of colonial storytelling, however, merely embodies the 'Cultural Imperialism' Edward Said so eloquently attacked in his monograph of the same name. Its ignorance alone is massively offensive, but defences mounted in its name only further exacerbate such disconcerting politics.
Rather, if you were offended by the title, it was only because you didn't understand it. Not because it perpetuated imperialistic narratives. Nah. Your feelings are irrelevant, you were just too dumb to not get it. That's basically what the writer's defence amounts to.
If we are to believe it, the entire point of the script was to tackle these tropes... tropes that the game perpetuated in the first place? Doesn't that just make it a really ineffective satire?
For a series that has formed one of the key cornerstones of Ubisoft's gaming lineup however, Far Cry 3 remains a troubling experience.
- A Conclusion -
While I'm obviously pleased that the various writers of the medium are steadily improving upon the banal naivety of storylines gone-by, it must be said there is a danger of alienation and division. In a community already polarised by external discourse and critique, these moves certainly have the potential to further entrench the long-documented vitriol and angst the community has been characterised by in recent years.
Regardless of the potential consequences of social-commentary forming the basis of many storylines to come, it is paramount that the industry's writers remain uncompromising in their commitment to mature storytelling.
--
Where do you stand on where game's 'can' and 'can't' go? Let us know in the comments!