9 Perfect Video Game Sequel Ideas (That Were Rejected)

Will the cancellation of Silent Hills ever stop hurting?

Silent Hill
Konami

Creating AAA games is a notoriously hostile, uncertain business, and sometimes even if a game is a smash, it still may not be enough to save a studio from going under.

That’s why the majority of major titles are based on recognisable names; there’s a reason franchises like Halo or Call Of Duty never go out of fashion. These sequels usually follow a strict formula and are content to deliver gamers exactly what they expect - albeit with a few tweaks.

Once in awhile, a studio will take a risk and colour outside the lines, which will either be met with acclaim and success – think of Resident Evil 4 – or the fans will revolt and the title will bomb. Over the years, many promising looking sequels have been announced, tantalising gamers with cool footage and demos... only to get scrapped before hitting store shelves.

There are numerous reasons this happens; maybe the gameplay isn’t working out so they start again, or they decide it’s too far removed from formula and go back to something safer. Let's take a look at some sequels that were loaded with potential, and examine the reasons they were tossed out.

9. Half-Life 2: Episode Four (Return To Ravenholm)

Half Life Episode 4 Ravenholm
Valve

It feels like the announcement of Half-Life 3 will coincide with the apocalypse at this stage, as it’s been nearly a decade since the last episode. Anybody who played Half-Life 2 will no doubt remember Gordon’s trip to Ravenholm, where it suddenly switches to being a gripping survival horror.

This whole section is an intense, creepy ride that was a standout chapter, and if things had gone according to plan a new episode would have revisited the abandoned town. Valve allowed a little studio named Arkane to play in the Half-Life sandbox a little, and while they were impressed by the results they halted it due to creative concerns.

They felt most of the tropes of Ravenholm had been played out (the headcrab zombies, the traps etc) and that it wasn’t innovative enough. They probably had a point, but at this stage any new Half-Life would be a great thing, and exploring more of the eerie town sounds like a fun way to spend a few hours.


8. Fear Effect Inferno

Fear Effect Inferno
Kronos Digital Entertainment

The Fear Effect games for the PS1 were a stylish mix of action and horror, but the awkward control scheme took some of the fun away. Still, they gathered a fanbase that loved the characters, and Eidos initially appeared gung-ho about bringing the series to the PS2.

Development began on a new game subtitled Inferno, which would have found the mercenary team being chased by demons once again. An early trailer hinted at a lot of horror elements, with Hana experiencing nasty hallucinations and being attacked by demonic doctors.

The game would have featured a more user-friendly control scheme, while still retaining the cinematic gloss of the previous two games. Inferno was coming along nicely until Eidos had a sudden change of heart and decided against finishing it, though it took years before it’s cancellation was confirmed.

That looked like the end for the series, until a Kickstarter campaign managed to raise the funds for a spin-off title called Fear Effect Sedna - which released in 2018 to... less than impressive reviews.


7. Prey 2

Prey 2
Bethesda

The original Prey had a messy development, beginning life in 1995 and going through a few cycles before finally being released in 2006. The game became a success and received some nice reviews for its unique portal-based gameplay, and the concept seemed ripe for a franchise.

A sequel was soon put into motion that starred a new hero, who was a bounty hunter on an alien world. The story would have close ties to the original, but would feature an expansive open world to mess around with. The game was announced with a flashy CG trailer that got fans excited, but then the development went quiet and rumours spread about it being scrapped.

Those fears were eventually confirmed in 2014 when the publisher admitted Prey 2 hadn’t lived up to their standards. Thankfully, the Prey reboot that followed was awesome, but it didn't make us entirely forget what a proper sequel could have been like.


6. Stranglehold 2: Gun Runner

Vin Diesel Gun Runner
Midway

John Woo’s Stranglehold was a brief but addictive action game where you played as Chow Yun Fat’s character from Hard Boiled, and you set about shooting and blowing up large waves of enemies in beautiful slow motion. The story was threadbare and it didn’t have much replay value, but for Woo fans it was catnip.

The game was also a decent sized hit, but Midway wanted to broaden the franchise’s appeal by bringing in another actor for a sequel. The new game was subtitled Gun Runner and saw Chow teaming up with Vin Diesel’s character from Wheelman, another Midway game.

Stranglehold 2 would have focused on working together, and environments had gotten so destructible you could level whole buildings if you wanted too; and why wouldn't you?

There were also driving sections where one player drove while another fired at oncoming enemies, and while early prototypes looked impressive Midway eventually folded due to financial pressure in 2008.


5. The Thing 2

The Thing 2
Computer Artworks

The Thing video game for the PS2 was a sequel to John Carpenter’s classic and followed Captain Blake while he blasted twisted aliens and lead NPC’s to safely. The game could be a damn frustrating experience, since it had ambitious features like a trust meter between you and your allies, but the linear story demanded they “thing” out at certain points no matter what you do.

None the less it was a fun game, and more importantly for the developer it sold well. The sequel would have seen Blake join with MacReady from the movie, as fight their way through a snowy town, an oil rig and eventually a huge aircraft carrier. The graphics were overhauled and new creatures would have attacked, like a nasty “Clinger Beast” that crawled along the ceiling and tried to strangle the player with its intestines.

The early footage looked promising and the new monsters were suitably nightmarish, but sadly the game was scrapped when Computer Artworks closed down.


4. Call Of Duty: Roman Wars

Call Of Duty Roman Wars
Activision

Call Of Duty was the coolest thing ever after Modern Warfare, but the brand got watered down after yearly sequels that were basically the same game with some cosmetic twists.

The series needs to cut loose and experiment again, and for a brief period, it flirted with trying something completely different with Call Of Duty: Roman Wars. Like the title implies it followed a Roman Legion through various battles and was viewed from both a first and third-person perspective. The player would be involved in all sorts of major battles including sieges, commanding ships and even fighting one on one in the Coliseum.

The games idea of vehicle sections would let you control an elephant, and rampage around a battlefield stomping the enemy. This pitch was well received within Activision, but it was rejected for the same reason they liked it; it was too different.

The developed Advanced Warfare instead, which is the very definition of playing it safe.


3. Resident Evil 5

resident evil 5
Capcom

Just like Resident Evil 2 and 4 before it, the fifth game in the series underwent a painful birth before release. It started life as a single player experience, where Chris Redfield was dropped into Africa to track down Wesker, and he had to deal with fast moving zombies and all kinds of nasty new creatures.

The plot for this version was different too, with Chris visiting completely different locations like an abandoned tanker and a village crawling with lickers. Sheva was a supporting character who helped him occasionally, Barry Burton showed up during a major set-piece to lend support and The Merchant from Resident Evil 4 returned to sell the player weapons.

It had the makings of another intense solo experience, but apparently, Capcom got cold feet after a backlash to the dodgy racial undertones of the original trailers; a muscly white American machine gunning an African village is a bit of a loaded image. As a result, the story was rewritten and the focus instead shifted to co-op, with Sheva being promoted to co-lead. It's a decent game, but it removed the series even further from its roots, and the co-op element still feels gimmicky to this day.


2. Silent Hills

P.T. Silent Hills
Konami

Silent Hills is maybe the most heartbreaking video game cancellation of all time; it had a groundbreaking demo that fans are raving about to this day, it would have reinvented a flagging series and it paired two geniuses with Guillermo Del Toro and Hideo Kojima. It was practically money in the bank.

The reasons behind its cancellation remain murky - as does the Kojima / Konami breakup – but based on P.T. alone it could have been a landmark game in survival horror. Little is known about the story, other than it would have featured Norman Reedus in the lead, and the teaser drops various hints about a murdered family and a ghost named Lisa chasing the player.

P.T. was still just a teaser, so we have no idea of the treats that awaited us in the main game. The game had so much potential, and the worst thing is the odds of it being resurrected are zero. It doesn’t even matter if the next Silent Hill game is great, since it could never live up to the hype behind P.T.


1. Legacy Of Kain: Dead Sun

Legacy of Kain Dead Sun
Crystal Dynamics

There hasn’t been a new instalment in the Legacy Of Kain series since 2003’s Defiance (let's ignore Nosgoth) which ended on a huge cliffhanger. A direct sequel titled The Dark Prophecy was in the development shortly after, but was quickly canned when Defiance failed to become a bestseller.

For years there was no news on another game, until it was revealed in 2013 a new game had been in development, but it was binned after a chunk of work had been complete. The game – titled Dead Sun – featured a new hero named Gein, whose soul becomes bound with a human he was hired to murder named Asher.

This bickering double act set out to avenge Asher’s murdered wife, and Gein/Asher had lots of new abilities to mess around with, including an Arkham Asylum like fighting system. The game had gotten as far as motion capturing actors and voice recording, but apparently sales projections for Dead Sun weren’t so hot, so the studio pulled the plug.

This is a crying shame, because Legacy Of Kain has such a rich story it’s begging for a new entry, and Dead Son brought a lot of cool ideas to the table.

--

Can you think of any other cool sequel ideas that were scrapped? Share your favourites in the comments below.


Watch Next


In this post: 
Silent Hills
 
First Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

Handsome. Charismatic. Intelligent. Noble. Witty. I'm none of these things, but I'm a half decent writer, I guess.