9 Video Game Heroes Who Turned Evil In The Sequel

The best heel turns from your favourite video game characters.

Metal Gear Solid Snake.jpg
Konami

One of the advantages of a long-running video game series is the player can grow attached to the characters over time; after all, fans are still buying Sonic games despite the series producing nothing but junk for at least a decade.

So while a series will likely stick to a familiar formula for both story and gameplay, some of them still like to break the rules and toy with players emotions now and again. Beloved characters can be killed off (RIP Eli Vance) and the heroes can really be put through the emotional wringer; and if the game’s creators really want to mess with you, they’ll turn a hero into a villain too.

If this switch is done right it can be unexpectedly emotional, having to deal with a character you’ve grown to like suddenly turning to the dark side. In a couple of instances, they weren’t all that well defined to start with, so the twist doesn’t have the impact it was supposed to; when it works, though, it can hit you right in the feels.

9. Jill Valentine - Resident Evil 5

Resident Evil 5 jill-valentine
Capcom

Jill Valentine is a beloved character in the Resident Evil universe, having been the lead character in many cases and being an all around cool lady. When Resident Evil 5 tries to convince players she’d died during a mission nobody was buying it, but they didn’t expect her to be involved with Wesker’s evil schemes either.

The twist is pretty shocking, but Capcom quickly undoes any lasting damage by revealing she’s been brainwashed and is under the control of a mechanical spider attached to her chest; because of course. After it’s ripped off she returns to normal and redeems herself by helping put an end to Wesker once and for all.

Sure, she’ll still have to live with the guilt of helping kill thousands of innocent people and suffer post traumatic stress for the rest of her life, but she can just blame it on the spider thingy.


8. Salem - Army Of Two: The Devil's Cartel

Salem Army Of Two.jpg
EA

Army Of Two was a bro-tastic series of co-op games that never really took off the way EA would like (the way that makes them boatloads of money), though the games can be a blast with a willing co-op partner in tow.

The series seems to have stalled completely because of the last game The Devil’s Cartel, an unpolished and flat shooter that made the baffling decision to sideline franchise stars Rios and Salem, and then turned the latter into the main villain.

Part of the charm of the first two games was the meatheaded chemistry between the pair, and while it could have been an interesting twist to have one turn bad – they are mercenaries motivated solely by money after all – Salem's leap to head bad dude feels like cheap shock value, and fans of the series were less than impressed.

True, he does have severe abandonment issues after his partner was forced to leave him behind during a mission, but it’s a twist that never quite gels. Too bad there (probably) won't be another game to redeem his character.


7. Kazuya - Tekken 6

kazuya mishima Tekken.jpg
Namco

Kazuya was introduced as the hero in the original game, having entered the tournament to defeat his evil father Heihachi. Heihachi also ran a powerful corporation involved in various nasty deeds, so Kazuya appears totally justified in wanting to beat the tar out of him, which he succeeds in doing.

It turns out in the sequel he made a deal with the devil to help secure his victory, and when he took over the corporation he was even more ruthless than his father. Heihachi returns to get revenge on his son, eventually tossing his body into a volcano. That should be the end of that, but Kazuya’s body is retrieved in the fourth game and then the storyline becomes hopelessly tangled.

It was a bit of a shock for series fans to realise the hero of the original was really a bad egg the whole time, and while he’s jumped from anti-hero to villain a few times he’s ultimately just as evil as his dad.


6. Robert Baxter - Time Crisis 5

Robert Baxter Time Crisis.jpg
Namco

Nobody plays Time Crisis for the story or character development – at least they shouldn’t – but there’s a certain goofy charm to them. Richard Miller will forever be the protagonist fans love the most, but Robert Baxter and Keith Martin from Time Crisis 2 got some love too; until the fifth game.

The game initially makes you believe Keith has turned bad, only to learn Baxter has been the real traitor all along. It’s a pretty surprising twist to have a former hero go full on evil. He’s also responsible for the death of Christy Ryan, Keith’s girlfriend and the agent they were sent to rescue in the second game.

He even got a douchey makeover for the fifth entry, in contrast to his clean cut appearance in Time Crisis 2. It’s not the most logical of twists and the Baxter in the fifth game feels like a completely different character, but Namco deserves some tiny credit for trying to spice up the storyline a little.


5. Liu Kang - Mortal Kombat X

Liu Kang Mortal Kombat X.jpg
NetheRealm Studios

The storyline of the original Mortal Kombat series became hopelessly tangled with each passing game, so a reboot was inevitable. This new version retold the story of the first three games in one fell swoop and ended with Earthrealm being merged with Netherrealm, most of the heroes dying and Liu Kang cursing Raiden with his dying breath about much he screwed everything up. So yeah, grim business.

It was still a surprise to see Liu come back for the next game as an enemy, but given his grievances with how things panned out we should cut him some slack. He becomes Quan Chi minion and causes the heroes considerable grief, fighting Jax and Raiden during the story mode.

After Quan Chi meets his demise Liu becomes the new ruler of Netherrealm, setting him up as the villain of any future games. Liu was never the coolest character (Sub-Zero is literally that) but it’s a bit bittersweet to see the moral compass of the series fall so far.


4. Gabriel - Castlevania: Lords Of Shadow 2

Castlevania: Lords of Shadow
Konami

Castlevania: Lords Of Shadow positioned itself as a reboot of the classic franchise, where players took on the role of Gabriel Belmont while he took down some evil forces; this includes Satan, so you know he’s really badass.

The twist the developers managed to hide throughout the game’s development is that Gabriel eventually turns into Dracula, the antagonist of the series. Gabriel has a crisis of faith throughout the story, eventually cursing god and becoming the ultimate evil after one heartbreak too many, and he's a full-fledged vampire in the sequel.

It’s a clever subversion of series formula, and some purists were upset with the changes the Lords Of Shadow saga made to the series; nobody wants Quick Time Events infecting their Castlevania games. With Gabriel, the developers managed to craft a likeable hero who’s tragic downfall actually feels organic, and the twist feels more than earned.

Symphony Of The Night and Super Castlevania IV remain the best games in the series, though.


3. Alex Mercer - Prototype 2

Prototype Alex Mercer.jpg
Activision

It would be a mistake to label Mercer as a good guy since he was ultimately the one responsible for unleashing the virus that all but destroyed New York in the first place; plus he does eat random people to heal himself. He does struggle with his monstrous nature, though, and he ultimately stopped Manhattan from getting nuked, so he’s not all bad.

Somewhere between the first and second game he gave up on mankind, though, and unleashed another outbreak in New York. There’s no redemption for Alex this time around, and the new hero James Heller spends the whole game tracking him down to seek revenge for the death of his family. Heller grows to be just as powerful as Mercer and finally kills - and consumes - him in the final battle.

It’s doubtful anyone will feel too sorry for Mercer’ ultimate fate, with the whole attempting to wipe out humanity thing, but he did make for a compelling anti-hero throughout both games.


2. Big Boss - The Metal Gear Solid Series

Naked Snake Metal Gear Solid 3
Konami

Anybody with a half decent knowledge of the knotted mythology of Metal Gear Solid knew Naked Snake would eventually become Big Boss, but the prequel games Snake Eater, Peace Walker and Ground Zeroes let fans see how he changed from idealistic soldier to the ultimate villain of the series.

Kojima doesn’t get much credit for his writing abilities – and to be fair, he does come up with a lot of nonsense – but he does create a real sense of progression in the character through the games, especially after the events of part three. There’s a palpable sense of loss as he gradually loses his faith in the government and becomes a gun for hire.

In a lot of ways Big Boss is a more interesting character than Solid Snake, and even when he makes the leap to the villain he remains sympathetic. The final scene between him and Snake in Guns Of The Patriots should have been way better, however; a CQC man hug was not the way to end things for the character.


1. Kain - Legacy Of Kain: Soul Reaver

Legacy of Kain.jpg
Crystal Dynamics

Kain is the anti-hero to end all anti-heroes; he began life as a nobleman who was viciously murdered by assassins, before coming back as a vampire to seek his revenge, slaying anybody who stood in his way. When searching for a cure he gradually adapts to his new existence, and when he learns there isn’t a cure he decides being an evil vampire will do nicely.

He’s the main villain in the sequel Soul Reaver, where new hero Raziel seeks revenge on Kain for ripping off his wings and generally being a terrible boss. The rest of the series switches control between the two protagonists, but even at his most despicable Kain remains insanely cool and somewhat understandable.

He does find some redemption towards the end of the last game Defiance, which sadly ended the series on an epic cliffhanger that has yet to be resolved.

Can you think of any other video game heroes who turned to the dark side for the sequel? Share them in the comments below.


Watch Next


Contributor
Contributor

Handsome. Charismatic. Intelligent. Noble. Witty. I'm none of these things, but I'm a half decent writer, I guess.