Assassin's Creed Origins Review: 6 Ups & 5 Downs
Not without problems, the Black Flag team have saved the series yet again.
For the first time in years (ever since AC II we'd had annual instalments), Ubisoft finally decided to let the Assassin's Creed franchise rest. Granted it was less a "decision" and more a "Oh god please stop, just for a second", after both AC Unity and Syndicate were tire fires and serviceable enough affairs respectively, the notion behind taking time off was assumedly so the return instalment would then be "back, better than ever".
Is that actually the case?
Well... not entirely. The game makes a pretty terrible first impression with stilted, frenetically finicky combat, glitchy animations, tons of clipping and the occasional mid-air boat flying across the horizon. Bayek himself is on a revenge mission, but within seconds you're laboured with handfuls of generic XP-grinding quests so you're at the "right level" to progress with the more immediate story.
Still, Ubisoft have gone back to the drawing board with a number of aspects ranging from designing a Dark Souls-lite combat system to overhauling the way stealth is approached using your pet eagle, Senu.
What works and what doesn't? Well...
Ups
6. Literally Ubisoft's Version Of The Witcher III
Speaking of going back to the drawing board, Origins' development started back in 2014 with the Black Flag team taking their turn - though clearly The Witcher III became a MAJOR influence.
Everything from the base setup of "guardian mercenary force watching over the people"-style protagonist to the very way your tiled inventory collates items is beat for beat Wild Hunt. You'll investigate side quests by interacting with evidence prompts before revealing the big picture, have missions regularly see some sort of "plot twist" or moral ambiguity you couldn't have seen coming, and even Bayek's stature as an Egyptian Medjay makes him the nearest thing to a real-world Witcher Ubisoft could find.
All of these things work in the game's favour providing your can accept just how much the design is aping CD Projekt RED's 2015 masterpiece, but it is almost parodic noting that the devs have gone, "What works? Oh, that? Okay then."
5. Art Design & Historical Accuracy Is Second To None
From the shimmer of the pyramids to the various types of cloth making up any NPCs attire, the photo-real hieroglyphics adorning sides of temples or the whipping wind cascading red sand all around, Origins is not only one of the best-looking games this generation, but one of the most educational.
Ubisoft have always prided themselves on having a team comprised of "various religious faiths and beliefs"; a veritable band of researchers who assemble their windows into historical time periods like no one else. AC games routinely come with optional codex entries on specific landmarks, cultural traits or insights into trade and ways of life, but here you've literally got explorable communities where different religious beliefs are excised through the populaces literally following different Gods.
It gives Origins a sense of place and passion from the developers that cements the design team as wanting to really transport you back in time. Despite all its flaws, AC Unity was an immaculate recreation of French Revolution-era France, and here it's no different.
Chances are you'll learn much more about what it was like to live in Ancient Egypt than any high school history class, and that's a major plus.
4. A MAMMOTH Skill Tree & Streamlined Animation Set
I can't stress how refreshing it is to have a skill tree in an action game that actually gives you new abilities and worthwhile unlocks. So many games - especially in 2017 - have fallen back on "+0.5% damage" or "+2% XP with each kill" that really don't make any demonstrable difference to gameplay.
Not the case in Origins, as from beginning to end you'll make Bayek into a far more formidable and accomplished fighter. Everything from chaining stealth and combat kills to slow motion in-air arrow firing, stun-kicks, shield-charges, fatality finishers, sleep darts, poison arrows, charged precision shots and MUCH more - there is a ton of stuff to rank up and unlock.
This coming from a game that once made us "acquire" the ability to stab a wounded enemy on the ground in AC Unity, is a ginormous and welcome step up.
Also worth noting is how much traversal animations and the general connective tissue of climbing sequences have been streamlined. No longer are you holding the right trigger and A/X to get a character into the right "mode" for climbing - instead this is pure Uncharted/Horizon: Just hit X when you want to leap anywhere and keep tapping it to mantle or climb. The animation system will do the rest.
3. Impactful Ranged & Melee Combat
Combat control is one of the biggest issues with the game (which I'll get to in the Downs) but the actual impact of weapons and arrows is remarkably satisfying.
Mostly down to the weighty and bass-fuelled sound design, if you cut a wide arc through the air with some hefty blade or spear and it catches a handful of enemies, the requisite controller vibration, squelchy sound effects and multiple health bars all depleting at once is a mighty fine feeling indeed.
This extends to ranged combat where nailing a headshot (with a powered-up bow otherwise it won't work... urgh) jolts a target's head back as you're rewarding with an XP pop and a massive golden set of numbers denoting how much damage was done.
It's very easy to look at these things as essentially the satisfaction of pulling the level on a gambling machine or pushing the buttons to operate the claw down the arcade i.e. the meat of the thing is still lacking, but Ubisoft at least nailed the payoff component of combat pretty damn well.
2. TONS Of Loot & Equipment
Origins' loot grind was the focus of some early gameplay demos, only to be forgotten about once all the hooplah surrounding Battlefront 2 being pay to win started emerging.
The reality is twofold, and outside of some cosmetic items being pay-to-unlock only, you'll pick the majority of gear up from enemy corpses, nab it through story missions or purchase from traders. There's even a "daily mission" vendor who drops an increasingly rare or valuable item depending on how fast you can complete the task at hand.
Thankfully, Ubi didn't go overboard with how fast these items are doled out either, as something like Destiny or Diablo tend to give you a new gun at such a steady clip you're forever switching your entire loadout, never playing to any specific playstyle.
Having a year off and providing the AC team with such a hefty budget has resulted in not a single costume or weapon appearing twice. There are seemingly endless amounts of items to unlock, ranging from mounts to bows, weapons and skins, and as they're touting this as a standout new feature, it's one of the best.
1. A Ludicrous Amount Of Content W/ Multi-Step Mission Design
Onto the general sense of what you'll be doing, and Origins is by far the most feature-complete, varied and just plain stuffed full of stuff an Assassin's Creed has ever been.
There are the standard up-high vantage points to synchronise with, multi-step side missions, dailies, encampments to raid, tombs to plunder, puzzle rooms to solve and randomly dynamic missions that pop up alongside you. A full day/night cycle governs everything from creature appearances to where NPCs will be at any given time - even if a target might head to sleep, letting you sneak in for the kill.
Ubisoft have designed this to be something that gets played for a LONG time, and though you could mainline the story it'll still take you a solid 30+ hours.
Assassin's Creed Origins is an epic - or at least, it is until the following points come into play - but the scope here is to design something that rivals the likes of The Witcher III.
For the most part, they've succeeded.
Downs
5. Combat Is Unrefined And You Will Die, A Lot
For as much as Ubi have prioritised a "hit box-governed" combat model a la Dark Souls, Bloodborne, Nioh etc., through most likely not having enough time to perfect it, Origins' execution feels spotty, to say the least.
Attacks and general movement have a sense of awkward speed to them that makes enemy attacks very hard to read or take the time to analyse. They want you to have these "intense" one on one or group encounters where all combatants are waiting for their time to strike, factoring in the arc of a blade, parries, dodges and which weapons are being used, but the reality is A.I. that rushes you every time, with a mess of unreliable lock-on and movement nigh-on ruining what should be otherwise enjoyable encounters.
As mentioned earlier the actual connections of metal and flesh are impactful and satisfying, but in the moment the control of Bayek falls very short - especially when there are so many examples of how to do this sort of thing right.
4. Using Senu To Tag Enemies Is Unreliable And Gets Old Fast
We've gone from Eagle Vision to an eagle's vision, but never has Assassin's Creed ever mastered - in a reliable and seamless fashion - the ability to tag a 3D environment's worth of enemies.
MGS V had multiple solutions like punching the ground to send out a shockwave that auto-marked foes, aiming the camera at them or just having companion D-Dog around also did the trick. Here we've got Senu, who every time you get close to an objective the game insists you pilot around, arbitrarily tagging enemies from above using a focusing reticule to make sure you're aiming in the right way.
Thing is, although this vision/sound "thing" can penetrate walls and caves, there's no way to know you've marked everyone, and simply because there's no unlockable "Just show me everyone nearby" perk, forces Senu's vision mode into the game in a way that breaks immersion and gets you spotted constantly.
3. It Takes FOREVER To Really Get Going
Again, part of the faux-"epic" feel comes from having a preamble that does eventually click into gear and works towards establishing the assassin order, but can easily go on for many hours depending on how much you indulge in the never-ending side missions, tombs and hidden world elements.
Such things are mandatory to some degree too, as the main missions you actually want to take on are regularly distributed at 3-5 levels above where you are, forcing you to take on such arbitrary side missions to stand a chance.
If you DO decide to tackle a mission far above your recommended level and succeed, then the next batch that unlocks will be even more out of your supposed reach. At some point you just have to leave the main thread for sizeable chunks of time, and being that for fans like myself who were dying to get stuck into the assassin creed's origin part of Assassin's Creed Origins, it's pretty deflating.
2. Some Notable Problems With Loot & Loot Grind
This is one hell of a hair to split, but whilst I said weapon variety and the sheer amount of things you're getting is welcome and rewarding, the actual utilisation of them wears thin over time.
Specifically, you might get 10 different-looking types of spear, but across the board chances are they'll only amount to different damage boosts, bleed damage or perhaps poisoning an enemy. There aren't any standout weapon buffs or traits resigned to the Rare or Legendary groups, and as you can get these things very fast from beginning to end, almost makes you question the 'tiers' of loot at all.
Being Ubi are making this entry in the series as an "appeal to all" demographic-slaying multi-million dollar behemoth, perhaps such loot labels are only in there because "that's what's 'in' right now"? A Legendary weapon certainly doesn't feel all that "legendary", put it that way.
Lastly, although they are completely optional and ultimately pointless, scores of cosmetic items can only purchased with the Helix currency, which you can ONLY get through microtransactions
Props (I guess?) to Ubisoft for not making any of the main progression pay-more-to-play, but it's worth pointing out as amidst this tumultuous loot-dependant time, Origins doesn't emerge unscathed.
1. Bugs, Animation Glitches, Frame Rate Hiccups - Lack Of Polish All Round
By far the most immediate negative comes from Origins still falls short of being a quality product through and through, despite being in development for three years, and taking one year away from the public eye to focus on precisely how to return in style.
Sound effects will miss their cue during attack animations, conversations sometimes have notable pauses between characters talking to one another, faces barely animate or convey the wrong emotion at key times, text will get frozen on-screen, and that's before you get to the wider world stuff.
Floating NPCs, flying boats, frame rate stutters, gliding camels, hovering market stalls and other pedestrians locked to treading the same square of turf over and over - it's immediately noticeable, and once again indicative of Ubisoft's corporate mentality not allowing the requisite time to polish everything before launch.
Of course these things will be patched out as the coding department continues to work tirelessly to fix the issues thousands of us will be yelling about, but just know that if you're buying AC Origins now, expect a pretty bumpy ride.