Dark Souls: 6 Heart-Breaking Moments
Its probably safe to say that the main emotion associated with Dark Souls is rage. Or maybe, frustration would be a better way to put it. Frustration, not only because of the countless times we were sent back to those damn bonfires, but also because of the way we were left constantly scratching our heads in a state of ambivalence: Why does that character go there? Whats that item doing here? Why does that big ass wolf have a sword in its mouth? These were among the many questions that used to be asked often. In more recent times, however, the community has excavated its way through the depth of dark secrets that this game hides, and we now have a pretty good idea of what the hell is going on. We may have shot ourselves in the foot.
The phrase ignorance is bliss applies nicely to this game. Dialogue, cut-scenes, item description and item placement offer clues which have been scoured for answers some of which pertain to some of the saddest stories of this genre. What Dark Souls does so well is craft these stories with a subtle elegance that allows the player to piece together the untold parts, until they eventually find a revelation. More often than not, this revelation emits tragedy. If youve put enough hours into the game you should be aware of this, and have perhaps lamented some of the despair as being product of your own un-witting instigation. In other words, this game makes you feel like an a**hole.
(Please note: I do not claim to be the sole discoverer of all this knowledge. This is a collective work of discovery and interpretation by the committed Dark Souls community, and whilst most of the info here is based on in-game given facts, some factors are down to personal opinion.)
Lets take a look back at some of the moments in Dark Souls that are iconically heart-breaking, beginning with
6. Solaire, Knight of the Sun
-->
-->
We first encounter Sun Bro in the Undead Burg after killing the Taurus Demon. From his first few chunks of dialogue he is immediately likeable, and gifts himself to you as an invaluable ally throughout the game. He is a kind, gentle-hearted man in an otherwise grim, forbidding world. But the most striking thing about him, and the core of his story, is his longing to find his own sun.
His mission logically leads to Anor Londo, and when we speak to him there he doesnt have a whole lot to say, other than a joke(?) which hints at a certain sexual preference of his. But the important thing to take note is that he still has not found his own sun.
Next, we can speak to him at the Sunlight Alter just outside the Undead Parish. One piece of dialogue reveals that he is pondering about (his) misfortune. He has thus far failed to find his sun in numerous places, and is beginning to grow doubtful. Where will he possibly find it?
The latter stages of his story lead him to the Demon Ruins and Lost Izalith. When we find him at the last bonfire in the Demon Ruins, he seems to neglect his friendship with the player, as he is so weary of his currently fruitless quest. His desire to find the sun is so strong that it now becomes his madness. But the brave, strong, and diligent knight that Solaire of Astora is does not give up, and he fights on into the fires of Lost Izalith, where
-->
-->
He finds his sun. Or so, he thinks he has. In his warped and desperate state of mind, he decides that the sunlight maggot is fit for his designs, and he dons it as his helm, claiming he is the sun. In doing so, he loses all touch with reality. Corrupted by a wanton bug, he attacks you on sight, and you are left with no real choice but to cut him down. He who was a steadfast friend and ally, an embodiment of hope, a ray of light dead, by your hand. And he dies in a place which, really, could not be further away from the sun. *sigh*
Of course, there is a way to avoid this heartbreak. Just unlock the shortcut to Lost Izalith, kill and collect the sunlight maggot, and Knight Solaire will be saved from his looming insanity. He will survive, and you can summon him to help you fight Lord Gwyn. Praise the sun!
5. Ceaseless Discharge
-->
-->
When I first died to the Ceaseless Discharge, I thought something along the lines of F**k you, you flaming piece of s**t! Blissfully unaware was I of the true nature and story of this demon.
Ceaseless discharge is the only son of the Witch of Izalith. He was born with sores all over his body which ceaselessly discharge lava, meaning he lives in constant pain. His sisters did manage to fashion him a ring which eased his suffering (the Orange Charred Ring), but the clumsy clogs went and dropped it, which created the Centipede Demon (thanks a bunch). Aside from this already tough luck, Ceaseless Discharges family is overwhelmed by tragedy as a result of his mother attempting to duplicate the first flame, but more on that later.
Remember the dead body containing the gold-hemmed black set? Up to a point, we guessed at the identity of those remains. It was generally assumed that it was the Witch of Izalith herself, or something similar. A developer interview then revealed that this body was in fact the remains of a daughter of chaos; it is one of Ceaseless Discharges sisters, who is, so far as we know, nameless. In all his pain and suffering, he gets one small comfort out of life: watching over the remains of his sister.
Enter the heroic Chosen Undead.
Excited by the sight of shiny treasure, you run up to the body and strip it of its dignity. Bad move. Thanks to you, Ceaseless Discharge now gets no comfort out of life whatsoever, and has no hesitation in scorching and crushing you time and time again. The one redeeming quality of this story is that you eventually get to put him out of his misery (probably after dying many, many times).
4. Reah the Accursed
-->
-->

This is a rather long and complicated story with numerous different outcomes. There is tragedy at every turn, as Reah of Thorolund is an innocent victim of banishment, curse, and betrayal.
Reah is known to be a daughter of the House of Thorolund - the most prestigious house connected to the Way of White. The Way of White is a church which seems to be the main governing body of the Dark Souls mythos. Despite her high-birth, Reah is treated as an outcast when the Undead Curse befalls her.
When a member of the church is branded with the Darksign, they are sent in pilgrimage to Lordran, where they must attempt to seek the right of kindling. This leads to two possible outcomes: either the missioned person dies, ridding the church of a cursed member, or the person succeeds in finding the sacred rite, meaning the church is better equipped to serve their leader, Lord Gwyn. Both of these outcomes are beneficial to the Way of White.
So off they send the maiden Reah to Lordran. I wont re-tell the story step by step; it is rather intricate and much of it depends on individual interpretation and opinion. I will, however, list the three possible outcomes. The first is that she is left to rot in the unremitting dark of the Tomb of Giants, where she has been abandoned and betrayed, and her two friends and companions, Vince and Nico, have gone hollow, leaving her all alone and helpless.
However, you can save her from this sombre end, in which case she will escape the darkness and can be found in the Undead Church, praying. At this point you may have learned that Petrus of Thorolund, the cleric who can be found in Firelink Shrine, betrayed her. Whatever his motive may be, he proceeds to finish the job he started by assassinating Reah where she prays. This is the second, tragic outcome of Reahs story.
-->
-->
But this too can be avoided. With the knowledge of Petrus betrayal, you may take it upon yourself to kill him for his wretched behavior. This will save Reah from being assassinated.
For freeing her two escorts Vince and Nico, and simultaneously saving her from the Tomb of Giants, Reah offers to teach you all that she knows. If you then purchase all the miracles and items she has to offer, she considers her debt to you repaid, and thus has nothing left to live for. She has been banished from her home and family, cast away like a piece of trash. She has lost two dear and loyal companions, and been betrayed for reasons which were of no fault of her own. When an Undead has nothing left to live for, they begin to hollow.
For the third outcome you can find Reah in a cell in the Dukes Archives (she has been kidnapped by a channellor, to be a new subject for Seaths experiments). The royal, innocent maiden of Thorolund has fully hollowed, and despite the fact you are her last remaining friend, she attacks you on site. You do her a kindness by slaying her.
3. Siegmeyer Of Catarina
-->
-->
Siegmeyers presence in Lordran can be explained in a few different ways. His circumstance may have been similar to that of Reahs; cast out of his homeland because of his curse. Or perhaps, it something as simple as him wanting to find adventure, for an adventurer is what he is. But the presence of Siegmeyers daughter, Sieglinde, in Lordran reveals that there may be more to this story than meets the eye. She is risking life and limb to find her father, so that she can deliver his wifes final, dying words.
On our own travels through Lordran we save Siegmeyer from jeopardy multiple times. This, of course, was done with good intentions, but it might be possible that in doing so, we were gradually slighting his honour as a knight. This may have been a contributor to his eventual hollowing. Eventually, Sieglinde finds her father, and tells him what she has to say. With the knowledge of his wifes death, Siegmeyers road to hollowing shortens significantly; he is on the verge. Spurred on by his misfortune, our friend Siegmeyer bids us farewell at Firelink Shrine and goes on one final adventure, which leads him down to Ash Lake.
I should note that this characters story can end in multiple ways, but I believe there is only one true ending.
Upon arrival in Ash Lake, Siegmeyer fully hollows, and when his daughter finds him in this state, she is forced to kill him once and for all. She loved him whole-heartedly right till the end. We then arrive helplessly at Ash Lake to see one of the most heart-breaking images of the game: Sieglinde standing morbidly over the body of her fallen father, a brave, noble knight, and a friendly soul who was one of our only friends.
2. The Fair Lady
-->
-->

I made mention earlier about the Witch of Izalith attempting to reduplicate the first flame using her Lord Soul. She did this so that the age of fire could last forever, instead of it eventually burning away into darkness. A nice idea, but it failed, and led to truly horrendous consequences.
It was this action that birthed chaos fire into the world the Bed of Chaos being, well, the bed of it. Izalith and its inhabitants were massacred; no less so where the Witchs daughters (and son). Two such daughters were Quelaag and Quelaan, The Fair Lady. The chaos fire corrupted them, giving them their half-spider forms. They managed to flee Izalith and make residence at the base of Blighttown.
The reason you find The Fair Lady in such a sickly state is that she took sympathy on the sufferings of the denizens of Blighttown; she sucked out their blight-puss, poisoning herself. Quelaag, her sister, takes care of The Fair Lady, feeding her humanity to keep her alive. That is why she attacks those who stray into her lair it is solely in the interest of her dying sister. And then the Chosen Undead kills Quelaag, exterminating the Fair Ladys main supplier of survival. If you equip the Old Witchs Ring, you can understand what The Fair Lady is saying. She is blind, and you are in possession of her sisters soul she believes that you are Quelaag. I dont know about you, but my soul trembled at this point, as I realised what I had done, and just how much of a tragedy this character was. And that voice...
Now, in the words of the many Orange Sign Soapstones seen throughout Lordran, Imminent tears ahead
1. The Legend Of Knight Artorias... And Sif
-->
-->

For me, this particular story embodies all that is great about Dark Souls. It is about bravery, strength, honour, darkness, and above all, failure. The DLC Artorias of the Abyss brought to light the true nature of the characters involved in the attempted vanquishing of the Abyss, and it resulted in us mellowing in our sorrows.
Artorias, one of the four knights of Lord Gwyn, was charged with a mission of venturing into the Abyss, that he may stop it spreading and eventually consuming the world. With his fiercely loyal wolf companion Sif at his side, he set off on behalf of his beloved homeland. But, as was pointed out by Elizabeth of Oolacile, such a hero has nary a murmur of Dark. Without doubt, he will be swallowed by the Abyss, overcome by its utter blackness. This is exactly what happens. Despite what we see of him, Knight Artorias is perhaps the most valiant, noble character of the game. In the abyss, this strength becomes his weakness, and he is consumed by evil. In his final human act, he sacrifices his shield to protect Sif from befalling the same bitter end as himself.
When the Chosen Undead chances upon Artorias in Oolacile, he is no more than a husk. By slaying him, you ensure that he dies with his honour still intact. It is you who then proceeds to kill Manus and cull the Abyss but it is Artorias to whom the legend remains.
If, when you were rifling through the Chasm of the Abyss, you happened to find Sif, and saved him from the surrounding Abyssal fragments, he will recognise you when you approach Artorias grave, hundreds of years in the future
Sif guards the grave and Covenant of Artorias to protect his masters honour and legend, and to protect you. Sif knows what can happen to those who would traverse the abyss; he had to watch as his best friend was overwhelmed by darkness. The Chosen Undead comes seeking the means to traverse the Abyss, and as I said before, Sif recognises you from the past. It is not in his best interest to kill you; he considers you a friend. But he refuses to let you wager your soul in the abyss, so he reluctantly takes up his sword, and fights you out of duty.
To kill Sif at this point is the most heart-breaking thing to do in Dark Souls, so separate yourself from your emotions as you slash away at the Great Grey Wolf that is Sif, and do what must be done for the greater good.
Feel free discuss any of the above, or any other moments which you found particularly sad in the comments below!