E3 2018: 3 Ups & 6 Downs From Square Enix's Conference

What the hell was that?

Kingdom Hearts III
Square Enix

Well, that was an E3 showcase...apparently. That's right, Square Enix delivered their first E3 presentation to fans in three years, and as a result, excitement was high that they'd provide some enticing updates on upcoming titles, reveal a new game or two and maybe even shock the world with a megaton announcement.

Oh, how naive we were.

Square Enix's hilariously brief E3 livestream - in their minor defence, they avoided using the word "conference" when promoting it - was pretty much the opposite of what most fans both wanted and expected.

Low on interest and high on lukewarm, middle-of-the-road trailers, it's the sort of low-effort presentation that could've easily just been released on a random Wednesday a few months from now.

There were a few intermittently intriguing moments, but mostly the show was just a monument to failed promise and by far the most disappointing of the four major shows so far. EA seemed like they had last place pegged, but it looks like they just got beat at their own mediocre game.

Fingers crossed that Sony's upcoming E3 conference could feature a little more from Square Enix, but you'd definitely be smart to keep your expectations firmly low...


Downs...

6. The Avengers Project Pulls A No-Show

Avengers Project Captain America Shield
Marvel

Square Enix's "The Avengers Project" was first announced back at the start of 2017, and one of the bigger certainties of the company's E3 showcase was that the game would finally be unveiled.

Well, that didn't happen.

The game, rumoured to be a reboot of the Marvel: Ultimate Alliance franchise, was nowhere to be seen in Square Enix's fleeting presser, to the crushing disappointment of many.

While at the time of press it's entirely possible the game will instead make its debut in Sony's E3 conference, this would've unquestionably been a neat announcement for Square Enix's own show.


5. The Near-Total Lack Of (Good) Surprises

Final Fantasy XVI
Quinzelnade.deviantart.com

Alright, it was always incredibly optimistic to even consider the possibility that Final Fantasy XVI could get its first teaser trailer during this show, but there's no denying it would've broken the Internet and sent fans into a frenzy. After all, look at how nuts everybody went over Bethesda's generic logo tease for The Elder Scrolls VI.

As it turned out, Square Enix's show as a whole was almost entirely lacking in crowd-pleasing announcements, save for the reveal of one new IP (but more on that in a moment). There were surprising moments, sure, but they were largely negative ones, sadly.

Of course, showcasing quality content is always going to be more important than surprising the audience just for the sake of it, but with EA shadow-dropping Unravel, Microsoft debuting teasers for new Halo and Gears games and Bethesda introducing Starfield and The Elder Scrolls VI (albeit hilariously early), Square Enix's show just felt incredibly tepid by comparison.

That's right, it was somehow even less whelming than EA's show, which is saying quite a bit.


4. That Vague, Weird Teaser For The Quiet Man

The Quiet Man
Square Enix

Square Enix did introduce a mysterious new title called The Quiet Man by way of a brief teaser trailer. The clip began with a live-action intro, where a deaf young man wanders the city streets and finds himself facing off against a gang of thugs.

As they confront the lad, the action shifts from video to in-engine graphics, and the presumed protagonist of the game beats the snot out of the gangsters while the game's slogan, "Silence rings loudest", is displayed.

Beyond the briefest of glimpses at the game's engine, we know almost nothing about it. The closing title card confirmed it's releasing for PS4 and PC and will be developed by Human Head Studios (2006's original Prey, Dungeon Defenders II), while adding that more will be coming in August (presumably at GamesCom).

This one just didn't really hit the mark, sadly. It's not entirely fair to judge a game based off a 75-second teaser, but the cheesy live-action footage and rather generic-looking action gameplay don't leave much of a first impression. It was probably better to just save this for a full reveal in August, honestly.


3. The Awful Sound Mixing In The Kingdom Hearts III Trailer

Kingdom Hearts III
Square Enix

Square Enix dropped a new trailer for Kingdom Hearts III - which we learned this week has been delayed to a "final" release date of January 29, 2019 - except the term "new" has to be used pretty liberally here.

The three-minute trailer was basically just a scarcely re-edited version of the one that appeared in Microsoft's E3 conference the day before, but to make matters worse, it was still rife with the terrible sound mixing that so many fans noted the first time around.

For some reason, a number of the scenes in the trailer didn't have any environmental sound effects at all, leaving the dialogue to sound jarringly crisp and out-of-place, drawing attention to the fact that, yes, it was recorded in a cushy sound booth.

Hell, there's even a moment in the trailer where Sora clearly speaks but we hear nothing come out of his mouth. Is this really a good look for one of the company's most important upcoming projects?

And considering that the technical problems with the trailer were abundant the day before it aired, Square Enix clearly had time to fix it. How unprofessional.


2. Where The Hell Was Final Fantasy VII Remake?

Final Fantasy 7 Remake
Square Enix

Though recent reports do suggest that Final Fantasy VII Remake is still a long way off from releasing even the first of its three planned episodes, it still would've been reassuring for fans to see a new trailer or brief snippet of gameplay.

After all, with the game apparently being significantly overhauled last year due to a major personnel shift behind the scenes, there's justifiable fan anxiety that the ambitious retelling could become yet another Square Enix game that takes far too long to release and ultimately disappoints.

Well, the company did nothing to quell those fears during their showcase, neither showing any footage from the game nor even mentioning it. Much like The Avengers Project, it could perhaps make an appearance during Sony's E3 show, but it's probably best to expect nothing and maybe, just maybe, get pleasantly surprised.


1. It Was Only 30 Minutes Long

Square Enix E3
Square Enix

The mere fact that Square Enix even had a presentation this year - their first since 2015's 75-minute stage show - suggested they were set to deliver a content-rich showcase worthy of a prime-time E3 slot.

As it turned out, fans were shocked to see the livestream wrap up in just shy of half-an-hour, an hilariously brief time for a heavily hyped-up show that many expected to deliver so, so much more than it actually did.

If Square Enix had so little to offer up, why even do a showcase at all, and not just make their most important reveals in Microsoft and Sony's shows? They knowingly got fans excited and then didn't even take the platform they set for themselves seriously. What a waste.

As hilariously underwhelming as the livestream was, at least there were a few stellar moments that made it not a total waste of everyone's time...


Ups...

3. Babylon's Fall Is PlatniumGames' New IP

Babylon S Fall
PlatinumGames

Easily the most intriguing and unexpected announcement in Square Enix's showcase was the reveal trailer for Babylon's Fall, a new action-adventure game from much-loved Japanese studio PlatinumGames (Bayonetta, Vanquish, Metal Gear Rising: Revengeance, Nier: Automata).

The trailer kept concrete details incredibly vague, though a number of futuristic dates and events were displayed with overt references to a number of literary, mythological concepts.

The text also seemed to suggest that the antagonist of the game is Gaia (the deified personification of Earth), and the heroic "nomads" will attempt to take her on. The trailer closes with a brief in-engine look at two gigantic knight-like warriors battling one another, with the presumed protagonist, a nomad, coming out on top.

PlatinumGames' sheer pedigree is enough to make this an exciting reveal, even if Xbox owners are sadly left in the dust, as the game's currently only confirmed for PS4 and PC. Babylon's Fall releases sometime next year.


2. A Final Fantasy XIV & Monster Hunter World Crossover Is Coming This Summer

Final Fantasy 14 Monster Hunter World
Square Enix

Straight from the school of "f*** it, why not?" video game crossovers, the conference confirmed that a Monster Hunter World-themed crossover event will be taking place within Final Fantasy XIV this summer.

It remains unclear exactly how the two games will intersect, but Square Enix's press release states it will "bring new challenges to players of Final Fantasy XIV Online featuring characters from Monster Hunter World to the world of Hydaelyn."

It's a bit of a shame that Monster Hunter World players don't seem to be getting anything in return in their game, but still, the idea of being able to run around with a Palico in the world of Hydaelyn is undeniably alluring.


1. The Cringe-Free Video Presentation

Shadow Of The Tomb Raider
Crystal Dynamics

Colossally disappointing though the show was overall, the pre-recorded video showcase was a smart choice by Square Enix to cut down on the inherent awkwardness of a live show and keep the cringe-worthy moments at an absolute minimum.

After all, their 2015 live conference was a clumsy mess due to the abundance of live translation that took place - leading to the hilarious gaffe where a translator could be heard snoring over the mic - so keeping things as smoothly controlled as possible made a ton of sense.

It also meant that Square Enix was able to slickly show off a ton of games in that mere half-hour, even if most of the trailers and gameplay reveals weren't all that interesting. After all, everyone knows what Tomb Raider and Just Cause are by this point.

Though the entire conference itself might be considered one big WTF moment, it'll actually avoid being featured much at all in the annual spate of post-E3 cringe compilations.

What did you think of Square Enix's E3 "conference"? Shout it out in the comments!


In this post: 
E3 2018
 
Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

Stay at home dad who spends as much time teaching his kids the merits of Martin Scorsese as possible (against the missus' wishes). General video game, TV and film nut. Occasional sports fan. Full time loon.